Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

The most ambitious Veritasium project needs your help

  • A 158
  • B 274
  • C 98
  • D 75
  • E 56
  • 2021-05-19
  • 661 votes
{'title': 'The most ambitious Veritasium project needs your help', 'choices': [{'text': 'A', 'votes': 158}, {'text': 'B', 'votes': 274}, {'text': 'C', 'votes': 98}, {'text': 'D', 'votes': 75}, {'text': 'E', 'votes': 56}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2021, 5, 19, 4, 32, 12, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 661}

Content

All going to plan, I will be posting a video this Friday that is over half an hour long and I think could have been made into three or more separate videos. BUT seeing it all together I hope encourages connections that wouldn't otherwise have been made.

I need your help with the title and thumbnail. I'll put the leading contenders below. Pleas pick your favorite, the one you would most like to see and click on (not what you think others would like). But please also leave that feedback in the comments. And let me know if you have better ideas! I rarely get it right the first time.

Files

Comments

Some Dork

Love the simplicity in C, it’ll immediately stand out among other thumbnails and peak my interest

Abhijit Chanda

I like the thumbnail of A with the title of E

OldManLink

Thumbnail B really makes me want to watch the video. Looking forward to it already!

SkaveRat

I'm torn between A and B. I really like the design of A, but it would probably blur into the noise of my subscription feed too easily. Seeing your face from B would make me click fast (same as if your logo would be visible)

Ethan Abegglen

I'd click B first because I'm the kind of youtube viewer who watches everything that specific creators make, and seeing your face draws me in sooner

Михаил

C will really stand out among other thumbnails, and its minimalistic design is something i am personally fond of

Arnau

B because I immediately recognise it's Veritasium. Seeing a new Veritasium video always makes me click. But this might be different for non-patrons

Brandon Kester

I voted for D because the image caught my attention and the title is very intriguing. I feel like A is very good and may appeal to a more people, but D was the most appealing for me.

Max Bruckner

It's like you read my mind. I've been reading "The Information: A History, a Theory, a Flood" by James Gleick recently and Gödel's incompleteness was a big part in that. I prefer B because it is not that cluttered and human faces draw the eyes in. Interestingly the actual video title didn't play any role whatsoever.

Joshua Axford

D's title is like "What... What? Click" for me. It doesn't give anything away, you have to click on it to satisfy your curiosity. While the other titles give you more information to decide if this is something you want to watch.

Koen Van den Wijngaert

Definitely B, just make sure the trademark owner of that little icon doesn't shut you down 😅

David Johnston

The thumbnail for E (my vote) but the title of B. Having the theorem name in the image is appealing but the title is more tautological than B’s. The image for B, though detracts from the title by being a bit too clever, using a symbol unknown to me, and half an image dedicated to the messenger as opposed to the message.

Luke

I voted B. as it's what I'd most likely stop scrolling for. As a fan of the channel I know if I see your face (or the name Veritasium), it's something worth stopping and watching. That said, C is more of a pattern interrupter, generally speaking.

Stefan Grunspan

You can’t prove everything and I can prove it.

Patrick Timmons

I vote B. I read twice the part about incompleteness in "Gödel, Escher, Bach: an Eternal Golden Braid". As far as I can remember, it says there are statements you can prove are true, some you can prove are false and some you can't decide. It is the mathematical equivalent of the uncertainty principle of Heisenberg. The thing is it says nothing about the probability that a statement would be undecidable which could be for all intent and purposes extremely small.

Quasitling

I like the title for D, and the image isn't bad, either. I think having "Incompleteness" or "Gödel" in the title or thumbnail is a turn-off. "Incompleteness" is too long and a clunky word. "Gödel" mostly appeals to those who recognize the name, which is not many. The image for C is too simple; the whitespace makes it fade into the background. But a tweaked version might be good. I find everything about B bland and the "I can prove it" I find off-putting. I seem to be in the minority, here. I don't think it's the best picture of you. (Maybe it's the expression?) Image-wise, I find D the most striking, although it doesn't connect very well with the subject. The E thumbnail seems out-of-place.

Eric Jensen

I see B as: I'm going to explain a complicated topic for you

Jack Hughes

Having your branding on there is really important for me, either your face or Veritasium, as it differentiates from the other click-baity “science” videos like TOP 10 ANIMALS THAT… which YouTube keeps trying to recommend me.

Celepharn

I liked options A and E most of all. They are very interesting. It might be interesting to look at a variant with a thumbnail E and a title A

halyoav

C. although it may look like presenting the title as a circular reasoning- ("why our..". our, we- what it stands for? etc.) this is my favorite. it somehow questioning the question. and answer it.

IcyMidnight

I like the title for B, but the text in the thumbnail doesn't really make sense. Is it supposed to be a response to/continuation of the title below? If so I don't think that works because most people will read the thumbnail first.

Ludovic Robillard

C picture is the best but D title definitely fit Gôdel incompleteness. Very eager to hear what you will say about it.

Sander Blok

C is very nice and elegant. But I don't think it's very clickbaity though.

Michiel Stikkel

With C I would have done it the other way around. The whole puzzle with one piece missing. if that was the intent here, I think slight outline of the rest of the pieces would have helped.

Roman Rodak

C would stand out perfectly among all the other flashy thumbnails

Ulrich Wisser

I voted B, mainly because I trust you to do good science videos. So having you in the thumbnail lets me click on it directly, otherwise I would have to check the author. I you want something that not just talks to fanboys (or fangirls), I would vote for A or E.

Daniel M. Bensen

I like A's picture most, but B and D have better titles

lesto

I am torn between B and C, voted for B as seeing your face is immediate happiness and a watch, but i like the minimalist aesthetic of C. The others feels like watching a generic stock image, very meh :/

Martijn Coppoolse

A's picture is generic enough, but I really like the word "INCOMPLETENESS" across it.

Ivan Ribakov

Image from C stands out from all typical youtube thumbnails and would make me what to see what it is about. I would slightly modify the title though to make it more... down to earth - "Why our knowledge will never be complete"

Tony Charlton

I will add to the fact that I will always click on your videos so seeing you in the thumb will make me click but this may not help you widen your audience. I selected B as instructed as this is the one I would click first. Beyond that i really like C as it would really stand out against the usual youtube thumbs. looking forward to it.

Christian Leichsenring

Really surprised the to me rather boring thumbnail B has such a sizeable lead.

Richard Pelletier

A, D, and E did not make sense to me, so it was between B and C. B looked better to me than C. C was too simple.

Mario Battaglia

"You can't prove everything that's true" is really interesting to me, but seeing "I can prove it" in the thumbnail is kind of misleading. And also I feel confused about the meaning of the g

Sava Kovalenko

I voted E, because it looked like science is going to be involved. All others look click bait-ish, that most YTers use to grab attention and then talk about the power of believing in yourself for straight 10 minutes :D Not bad on it's own, but usually not actual knowledge involved

Thales Martins

A- It's the one. The Title is good and the image is bright and the one that most grab my attention

Michael Krugman

B has the personal touch, but how about “Why there will NEVER be a ‘KnowItAll’…”

Joel Menken

B’s thumbnail is simple but most eye catching. E’s title is the best of the four options.

Jay Shaffer

"hole at the bottom of math" is specific and intriguing

Virgile Andreani

I chose A because it is the prettiest to me. I like the contrast between the white and black halves of the image. However, A, D: I don't really understand why there is a city. I am surprised that B is leading the poll, because I don't find the thumbnail intriguing. E is the most explicit but maybe the less exciting. C is original but I think a bit too empty. Also, a hole in the shape of a puzzle piece gives the idea that it can be completed. I think I would rather draw a whole puzzle (or knowledge graph) scarred by a hole with a very weird shape that definitely cannot be filled with a normal piece.

Espen Ekelund

I kinda like C, since the emptiness of the picture tells the same story as the title!

Zeus

I only watch videos I'm specifically interested in - I don't "follow" anyone. Hence, the topic should be identifiable as clearly and specifically as possible, ideally right from the pic rather than the description. Only E satisfies these criteria. It's a bit cluttered and not the prettiest, but I probably wouldn't click any others at all. More than anything I despise cheap intrigue and clickbaits, and D leans that way. Meanwhile, I AM interested in the Goedel's theorem, and without this keyword the video has every chance of being lost (for me) or put off.

Zeus

Yes! that would be better than any of the suggestions. E has the best title, but B is the best (or rather, "right") picture (yet the worst title).

Ardais

B for me, because you ask a question in the title and give an apparent "answer" in the thumbnail. My attention was immediately drawn to that one when I opened the picture in a new tab.

Vincent R. Turgeon

I voted C because it's eye catching and the image of a missing piece in a puzzle speaks loudly and it's intriguing. The completely white thumbnail is very different to anything else and attracted my eye right away and it's mysterious enough to push me to read the title.

Vincent R. Turgeon

I also like B because it doesn't make sense but then you think about it and want to know how you can prove it. So i would get drawn to it too. But the picture doesn't catch the eye like C.

Jay Iyengar

Have you heard the expression, "you don't know your ass from a hole in the ground"? I heard it in a personal development seminar, many years ago, a few times.. it woke me up, every time! The seminar leader would then follow that up with a "how do you know THAT?", a few times with a participant who challenged that notion and soon it becomes clear we really do not! Might sound extreme or harsh, but was certainly catchy and did the trick every time... especially when trying to get across a paradigm-shifting idea!

Myron Dietz

Godel’s name catchs my eye. Plus this looks like something you would see on Nebula.

Josh Campbell

The text in the thumbnail of option B along with the somewhat cryptic photo tugs at my curiosity and the title triggers my defense mechanisms. Internal dialog: {{ Prove WHAT, how, and what is the g for, Google? I don't like Google, what did they do now. Probably not Google, that's to mainstream and shallow for Derek. A proof that proving truths 100% of the time is false, I must watch this before doing that thing I really need to get done! }} IMO option B also hacks YouTube algorithm the most. Some might consider this to be slightly negative but I feel it's a bit "click bait-ish". However, I as a subscriber know that it is not click bait and I would watch it anyway. It's probably a totally unrelated subject but all these titles gave me a similar feeling I had while watching a video about the question "How Many Holes Does A Straw Have?" by MindYourDecisions. Maybe it's just key words triggering that memory.

Tricia Midgley

I chose D because the black hole metaphor sucks me in :)

Dan Skibo

I feel like while the hole pictures are catchy, they are misleading in terms of the content. The missing puzzle piece feels the most accurate, but it isn't catchy as it is. Perhaps a puzzle of the city missing pieces around the boundary?

Andrew Newhouse

Looking forward to the video! I generally like "B", but the lower-case g is confusing - is this about Google? If that g were replaced with something with fewer connotations, I think B would be my choice. As it stands, I voted D - the slightly retro picture isn't my favorite, but D's title is the most intriguing to me.

Kimberly Green

My eye is drawn to A, because I'm trying to see the details of the city. But my preference is along the lines of a modified C. I would change the background of C to a chalkboard or light blue field filled with equations and turn the missing puzzle piece white.

Benjamin Tabb

Option A seems to be more succinct; the visual ties into its title clearly marked below. It’s such a difficult concept and it really needs to be accompanied by a title such as you have an example A

Pamela Wissenbach

I liked A best. It seems more mathematical, given the graph paper like design drawing your eye down in a drain like way toward the INCOMPLETENESS. I want to know what is incomplete and how it effects life.

Man Danley

I dislike immediately A and D, as a husband of a Trypophobia wife. She would hate to see those graphics. Too many holes and would make it hard for her to even consider watching it. B is good , it shows your face and a succinct title.

Clifford Scarborough

B above is the only positively assertive advertisement, and it hosts your lovely mug to boot.

Bruce Goren

“A” was my immediate choice, followed by “E,” but it was all subconscious and I cannot for the life of me explain why.

Roberto De Lucchi

I believe that incompleted knowledge it is unavoidable, we can never end of learning, undertand or interpret the teaching of the life. There is infinite matters that are far away of our undersanding, such are the secrets of the universe, the nature, the human being and the human brain. Also, I am personally convinced that physic laws we have, are only the limited capacity of the humans about the facts that are part of our dimension, only that. Based on that, there is not way that we can prove everything we consider as true or absolute thruth, basically this is the reason why I choiced the option B.

Andres Rosales

B's thumb, A's title and I'm confused why the card has a G on it. A card with the missing puzzle piece from C would be cool.

C.J. Smith

If I'm just looking quickly, B because I know it's your video. I like the titles of B and D better than the others - the others almost seem obvious and wouldn't draw me in. A thought on thumbnail C - I wonder if it would be better if the white was outlined as though it was made up of puzzle pieces, thus making the black piece look more like the hole in the puzzle of knowledge. As is I thought it was just a single black puzzle piece.

JDG

1. your face is branding. i see you and will very likely click -> B's image 2. unprovable axioms disturb me -> B's text 3. i view this as a hole at the bottom of math too! -> D's text to improve C, i you could in light gray fill the test of the screen with puzzle piece outlines. at first, i wasn't entirely sure what i was looking at.

JDG

di you mean B then? B is the thumbnail with his face. (i also generally watch by specific creator.)

Ethan Abegglen

Yes you're right, my bad. It has been edited

JDG

thanks for the summary of the incompleteness theorems.

C.J. Smith

My GF also says B, she says it's more click-bait-y "You can prove what?"

Paul Peijzel

B. The title is clear and I like the apparent contradiction between the title of the video and the title in the video. Plus, it shows your face, which links it to you as well.

Adrian Byram

I pick E mostly because it contains Gödel’s name – I expect a lot more people are aware of his name than the word "incompleteness". But Image B is probably more effective

Rick Fleischer

D is the only title to which I didn't think, "Obviously: we'll never know everything."

R. Eric Reuss

I like the visuals on (A). If you'd asked me to vote for what I thought other people would like, it'd have been (B), but it's more clickbaity than I personally prefer. (Which I realize may be necessary.) The lowercase "g" in (B) is strongly reminiscent of Google - if that's not an intended association perhaps choose a different font? Love the look-feel of (D), but it's a touch too mysterious / cryptic for me.

Puppy Dog Dad

I’d prefer C with inverted colors. The rest are too busy or I don’t get them.

Clayton Greenwell

I'm choosing B. To me at least, it seems to have the broadest appeal to someone scrolling whom isn't currently aware of your channel.

CharlieVictor

In my opinion, B is really the only viable option here. All of the others require too much study to decipher what they're about.

InvestorMainiac

I really like "You can't prove everything that's true" it's intriguing. I've got no idea what "I can prove it 'g' " means and if I wasn't a follower of yours I'd probably ignore it.

Patrick Kennedy

I like B for the semi-paradoxical and complementary title and thumbnail. No matter the thumbnail "you can't prove everything" is an extremely compelling statement to make. The thumbnail seems a bit... unfinished though, it's not clear what "g" is supposed to be in the context, if it were like a capital T to represent capital T Truth it might make more sense, but beyond the interplay with the title it wouldn't make me click C is a solid runner up, it's a more compelling title without the jargon of "incompleteness" and I like the thumbnail idea of a missing puzzle piece a lot. That said, it's very unclear that the puzzle piece is a void; on the contrary, it looks like a puzzle piece in a white void. C differes from A in that idk what the heck the thumbnail is supposed to convey

RayLast

I didn't vote for any because although I think I would visually more likely click on B, what it says and the little g card Aren't very attracting or compelling, IMO. Maybe change the words to something like "THE UNFILLABLE HOLE IN KNOWLEDGE!" or "THE UNFILLABLE HOLE IN MATH."

Mik Scheper

Meh—they're all too small for me to provide a realistic opinion, and the ship's sailed anyhow. Thumbnail polls normally show up at a reasonable size in the Patreon app in my phone; I think I normally tap on them to see them full-size, but that's not working for me today. Has anyone else experienced this problem?

Bernard Gisin

B would be la last choice. A or E my first choice. I already read a lot about Godel's incompleteness.

Stan Hol Horeman

| like Gödel and I like the word Incompleteness, but I am dutch, :-). So please use E.