Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I have been working on this video (very slowly) for over two years. There are no masks in it because all the interviews were filmed before Covid. It is a different kind of video for me - it deals with issues related to violent crime, law enforcement and privacy. Of course there is a lot of science involved as well, but it alone can't provide answers to some of the central questions that are raised.

My plan is to go live with this video on Thursday morning. So I would appreciate any feedback or suggestions you have. Title and thumbnail ideas would be great too!

Best,

Derek

Files

Your DNA is already in a database

Comments

James Hoopes

Wow! Terrific video! My constructive criticism is that I think you underplayed the massive shift this will be in our right to privacy. You brushed against it when someone you interviewed said this was going to be decided by SCOTUS. But if they allow this, it’s going to involve us completely rethinking the unwritten concept of a right to privacy. This isn’t just about the right to privacy of our DNA, but our whole right to privacy as individuals. We will cease being legal individuals and we become shared legal identities based on our family. That’s why I’d use a title like, the coming privacy earthquake. Just amazing and thought-provoking, as always. Well done!

Paul Looyen

Great video and I like the swapping of interviews to tell the story. Certainly a different video but as a biology major at university I appreciated it. Also raises a lot of ethical issues and thus diverse opinions, and I can see your comments exploding. Two little things (very minor) When you talk about the odds of theSNP maybe have the value enlarge instead of leaving it small in the corner. At 20:41 your interviewee raises his hand to say something and it cuts. Maybe shave a few frames off it it seemed like you “cut him off” All in all another complex topic video well done

Benedikt Heinen

It will be interesting to see how this will also pan out on an international stage -- say my cousin moves from Germany to the US and registers on a site there. Would my cousin's DNA _there_ possibly be usable by law enforcement _here_? And - which country's privacy rules should apply?

Andrew Dean

The title "You have the DNA of a Killer" Sub "Would you share your DNA to Catch a Killer? Thumb Nail: Mirror/mugshot with parts of a face revealed in blocks but not enough to recognize the person. (Great Video)

Markus Appel

Very good and interesting video. The scene with the model 3D family tree seems to have a lot of second degree incest doesn't it?

Christian Leichsenring

The "parent" graphic has no crossovers. This is not only highly unlikely but probably also confusing as a viewer might then wonder where the shorter segments for more distant relatives come from if chromosomes stay intact between parent and children.

Martijn Coppoolse

The "no consent required" in the thumbnail definitely caught my attention: do keep that in! Very informative video! (I wasn't able to watch it past 20:00, though. YouTube wouldn't load the remainder for some reason, but that's probably due to a spotty connection at my end; will retry later.)

Christian Leichsenring

One thing that might be worth implicitly hinting at is: right now we're using this information to find criminals. There is nothing to stop any regime from using the same tools to suppress political opposition. That's a truly dystopian thought.

Dariel Barroso

Great video I think it's very interesting! I personally don't like longer videos, it feels like a longer commitment and I never end up watching them but I watched through this one and it kept my attention the whole way. I liked someone else's idea in the comments that said to name the video "Would you share your DNA to catch a killer?" It seems way more engaging

Klimbo93

Huge quality content, making me happy I'm supporting you here. I agree I had some questions along the video regarding for instance, international borders limitations, but I believe its unreasonable to ask for all the answers in one video that doest go for 3 hours. For me, the content is perfectly scoped and presented.

Matthias Konigorski

I like the "no consent required" in the current tumbnail. How about the title "They/We already have your DNA" Or "Which crimes strike privacy?" / "Giving up your privacy to catch a murderer?" Impressive video on a controversy topic! I only would have wished for digging a little deeper into possible impacts when those data gets abused. But i guess there will be enough of that into the comments - Maybe you want to disable them on youtube ;)

Klimbo93

The one thing I do kinda disagree about, is actually your recent approach to thumbnails. "no consent required" is a typical case of a title that hits a anger/outrage trigger on the audience. This has a double edge. It is extremely effective to make you click, but also serves as this huge source of stress online that leads to growing toxicity of the audience. It looks unavoidable, since other content creators have figured it out and are going to use it anyways, but, if it was me, I wouldn't stay in clean conscience, if I was being a part of it.

c'mon

First off, besides any commendation - very interesting content BTW -, these times make sure to not forget to add a short statement at the beginning of the video's description that the interviews where taken before Covid-19. However, the much more important point, and I mean really important, is that I initially did not understand the difference between 23andme, ancestry and gedmatch, when gedmatch was first mentioned. Even after watching the whole video I am still not 100% sure. And then there is also familytreedna at the end. I think this is the actual main pivoting point of the whole video and it is by far not clearly enough explained. The main question that I still have is: Why were the law-enforcers able or allowed to use gedmatch and not 23andme or ancestry? Did I understand it correctly that today they cannot use gedmatch anymore? And in general, which databases are they allowed to use today, which are they not allowed to use, and why in both cases? Maybe that is something that a U.S. resident would understand more easily, but I am from Europe. Maybe it also has something to do with not being a native speaker, because it seemed that parts of the answer were in some of what the interviewees said and they sometimes were at the brink of mumbling or speaking way too fast. I did not always understand what they said. So, since you for sure have an international audience, maybe you should make these things a bit clearer. For the thumbnail / title: "DNA can find you without your sample!" or similar.

c'mon

BTW, if the title was "No consent required" then I would not even click on it. Boooooring.

Mike 1.0

I like the thumbnail tagline, but the image is difficult to see. FANTASTIC video and interviews. I work with computer security and although there is nothing groundbreaking in this video, it raised many red flags in terms of security and privacy. I work with computer security protecting personally-identifiable information and so forth, and see a collision between DNA warehousing and splicing. With these tools, it is entirely possible to manufacture a false positive DNA match. I guarantee this is already been considered and acted upon. Tin foil hat aside, The security of DNA profiles is of the most importance. Just one infiltration into the genome database will be disastrous before generations to come. If you're looking for a related topic, I suggest looking into security, from safes and vaults used to transport payrolls into old western territories, to modern computing systems guarding secrets that must never be revealed. They all have one, massive security flaw: a human holds the key. The only thing retaining these secrets and preventing these DNA warehouses from the black market is one or two humans not being able to be fooled into performing some unrelated action. Cyber security is terrifying. A great resource is Troy Hunt, who started the trend of documenting stolen email addresses to alert people their computer login has been stolen, through HaveIBeenPwned.com which currently tracks an unbelievable 11,469,997,183 stolen accounts.

Hermien Pellissier

Excellent content as always! I did find that the audio levels are not quite consistent throughout the video though. Especially when Paul Holes is talking the levels sounded lower to me. I was listening to the video at a fairly low volume, and it was noticeable that parts were less audible.

Kimberly Green

The advisory at the beginning ("disturbing for some viewers") could also benefit from mentioning that the video was made over the span of years, including pre-COVID. A simple written blurb would suffice.

Hugh Arthur

Great video. While using DNA like this to find criminals is great. I feel like DNA could be used for nefarious purposes. A bit of a slippery slope.

C.J. Smith

A couple of the interviews (the interview with the people at 0:59 and the interview with the person at 3:09) seem a bit quieter than the other talking. 4:43 "these are called... STR" based on the grammar of this particular sentence, maybe it should be STRs (you do say STRs later when talking about them in a plural sense) So my GF does genetics, and something she kinda questioned is when you say at 7:29 that the human genome is 3 billion bases - it's 3 billion base pairs from one parent and 3 billion base pairs from the other parent. So in length it's 3 billion long, but you have 2 pairs, so in a sense if you were to get the entire DNA for an individual you would need to measure 6 billion bases (the other half of the pair doesn't need to be measured, but the other copy from your other parent would be measured). She's unsure on the details of how the percentage that are different is calculated, so not sure if that means there are 6 million differences or if that's determined differently.

Anthony May

nice one. there's two key points in this, which you hit well. 1) how DNA doesn't require ME to submit my DNA to be part of a sharing of my genetic identity, merely those family members around me who've done it, inadvertently involves me too. This is one aspect of the 'thin edge of the wedge' privacy concern surrounding this tech. and as the cops pointed out, that 1000 distant family members what whittled down to about 5 candidates who couldn've been the Golden State Killer. Presumably the other 4 were also investigated, possibly to the point of 'spying' or search and seizure, and that's where this can go horribly wrong for people, because it's no longer the certainty of the DNA driving the case, but the competence of the policy who are now on 'my' case, and I know I'm innocent, when they never would've been on my case without the DNA database option. You might think that's not a concern, but for those who are already *systematically* marginalised and deliberately mistreated by law enforcement, especially in the USA, tha'ts a real problem! 2) Near the end of the video, I was thinking what I was about to write here, and then one of the cops said it expliicitly: that the tech is progressing beyond the readiness of our society to deal with its implications (a familiar story!). We all (or at least, almost all? lol) want our law enforcement to be able to solve cases accurately and quickly and bring justice to offenders. The problem is, Law Enforement, and governments in general, are ALSO one of the biggest abusers or mis-users of tech and detailed databases, from telecommunications metadata, to DNA matching, and many others, commencing their use of these new techniques with noble intentions, but far too often we know these technologies and databases can be used by more and more government and even non-government entities, not just for criminal cases, but civil cases too. And this is where the "tech is ahead of our society's readiness for it", in that our governmental and legal institutions have been demonstrated, many times, to not be as robust as we might've first thought, sometimes to also not be as honourable as we would hope them to be.

C.J. Smith

I like somebody's suggestion of "you have the DNA of a killer", but I also like the "no consent required" bit, and unfortunately those don't work at the same time haha

c'mon

Some feedback about the feedback process: To ask the community for "feedback or suggestions" about one day before you want to go live with it, feels a bit like being sold for a fool. Like you are not really taking your audience here on patreon seriously. I mean a week in advance would be ok. Then it would be credible that you are actually planning to listen and incorporate some of the "feedback or suggestions" into the video. But one day? Seriously?

C.J. Smith

As for the picture, the current one seems a bit too monochrome. Could even just make the DNA string from the person to the server some other color to add something eye-catching.

Veritasium

This is a good point and one I’ve been carefully weighing up. Most people use the 3 billion number with the idea that you have the possibility of having two different letters at each spot. When Family tree DNA talks about measuring 710,000 locations they actually mean 710,000 x2 because you have two options at each SNP. So I like to think of it as 3 billion positions, where three million of them can vary but you have the option of having two different letters at each of those spots

c'mon

The current thumbnail, btw, with the server rack and the numbers is misleading IMHO. I have no better idea, though. Sorry.

Mmmmm. Cookies!

First up - nice work. I'll look forward to watching this with my kids this weekend. This is a great topic, as it's the intersection of technology, political science, law & justice, and social impact. Few people seem to realize how those fields are evolving together. This seems like a single piece of the puzzle in a larger picture. Many of these same issues arise in Facial Recognition and other biometric fields. The Facial Recognition is a bigger issue, as "consent" is given simply by walking around a city where thousands+ of cameras are doing this constantly and in real-time. Beyond biometrics, license plate readers and Cell Phone surveillance are two other pieces of that puzzle enabled by data collection and analysis. While I wouldn't change your video, I would add something at the beginning or end alluding to "This is just chapter 1 in a longer series". If you want to bring this back to Math (always a happy place!), then all of this data is a Graph and the analysis of those graphs is a core modern computer science problem. When nodes start popping up in multiple graphs forming connections, patterns emerge...

Bruce Goren

Great video. Thanks for making it.

Alán Orth

Really nice video! But as someone else pointed it out - please do this a few days earlier. If I had the time I'd try to invest some time in detail work. But I lack the available free time to "promptly" - within a day give valuable feedback. In these feedback questions I barely ever see high number of comments. Pretty please give the community a tad bit more time! Also the video is absolutely lovely - I am really blown away by these infos - I hope it will be picked up by mass media as it covers important topics.

Eric Mockensturm

Two things, one minor, one serious... #1: It seems kinda odd to include the small clip of you and the guy from Verogen laughing as you enter the building. Just seems out of place and a bit too light-hearted for the video. #2: Do some research on DNA contamination, e.g. https://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2013/06/28/south-bay-paramedics-likely-brought-innocent-mans-dna-to-crime-scene/. As a former mechanical engineering professor and someone who had been harassed by law enforcement for years about something he did not do, this is a SERIOUS issue. DNA evidence is great, but when there's an issue with it, there can be very serious consequences for innocent people. I hope no one ever has to experience what I did, which is why I'm writing a book about my experience.

Corey Gemme

Sorry to have to mention this in these feedback sections but I really wish you just once and for all acknowledge and take care of this shade ball thing. Even though you may think of this as silly, on principle I feel like I’m being ignored and that’s kind of what bothers me. I’ve lived my whole life without a shade ball so the lack of the item itself isn’t really the issue anymore. It’s bothering me that the shake ball episode was why I eventually signed up as a supporter. Now it’s making me feel taken advantage of to keep supporting each month as I feel like I’m being blown off! And I’m not getting any response to my direct emails so that leaves me to have to mention the stuff here.

Mmmmm. Cookies!

The history of technology and law enforcement is - at best - a bit sketchy. The strongest example of this is the FBI and Hair Matching scandal. From the FBI: https://www.fbi.gov/news/pressrel/press-releases/fbi-testimony-on-microscopic-hair-analysis-contained-errors-in-at-least-90-percent-of-cases-in-ongoing-review Also, this history of Lie Detector tests, which are not admissible as legal evidence. Recently Gunshot Detection has gone through the same thing, with ShotSpotter being found to be - at best - deceptive about the science it's using and the racial impact that it's having. https://www.aclu.org/news/privacy-technology/four-problems-with-the-shotspotter-gunshot-detection-system/ As the DNA story (and Facial Recognition) seem poised to go down the same path. Thank you for shining a spotlight on some of these issues, and I'm hoping you continue to delve deeper into the intersection of science and tech and law enforcement.

Eric Jensen

Very interesting video! I did not know this was possible. Very clever. For For thumbnail: maybe show a family tree with a person icon at each point, but faded except for two or three in orange with a green DNA string above our below. The path from the highlighted ones dashed to you.

Elizabeth Schneider

I knew the Golden State Killer was caught using a DNA database, but I thought his identity was confirmed using his daughters DNA taken from her university health center. I must be thinking of some other case. I have no issue opening up my DNA to law enforcement, but the reason I will never voluntarily give a DNA sample was briefly touched upon by one of the two guys doing an interview about the Golden State Killer. I’m not sure if it will happen in my lifetime, but I definitely see DNA being used at some point to determine eligibility for healthcare and possibly other nefarious (eugenics) activities.

maydreamer

Thank you for such a clear and concise doc of the issues involved. I agree with the retired officer who brought up having corporations taking control of where your dna is distributed. There is no doubt in my mind that businesses like insurance companies would jump at the chance to use customer dna to accept or reject customers.

Veritasium

Corey! You're not being ignored. One shade ball was mailed to you. I believe it was lost. I requested a replacement be sent to you. I think this request was ignored by the warehouse. I will keep trying with them.

Andreas Fink

Good video, pointing at an issue that is very relevant though not widely known. I learned a lot from the video about a technique that I had marked off in my mind as known and understood, and, I am a physician. Wrong I was, this "proximity search" is a whole new world. Good informationen, well presented and, very important, also pointing at the resulting privacy issues. And yes, DuckDuckGo is a more private search engine! I have been using it for years now. :-)

Lionel Pöffel

I learnt a lot through the video, thanks for at least pointing to the potential issues involved in using this relative DNA search technique. I fear though that the most important misuse is not insurance companies jumping at the data, but law enforcement itself for much more than major crimes. Sorry to say that, but they have a history... I would have loved to see a voice mentioning that.

Alexandra Wallman

I loved this video! You could call it something like- YOUR SISTER MIGHT HELP PUT YOU IN JAIL

Bob Vogel

Great. Thanks for this.

Michael R Wilson

I thought the content was great. The cover image is not as good. The computer on the right is dark and hard to read. The monotone gray scale is dull. If the base letters between the human shape and the computer bank could be a double helix then the DNA connection would be more recognizable at a glance. The base letters could be different color to give the image more snap.

Michael R Wilson

Title idea: "You Are Here (whether you know it or not)" with arrow to the computer bank.

Michael Aichlmayr

Pig-pen from peanuts walking across the scene (I know, copyright issues), and the caption, "Your DNA is everywhere" (but not where you think)

Daniel M. Bensen

I liked the way you edited their story-telling together

Kimberly Green

I have to disagree somewhat. The video "The Universe is Hostile to Computers" includes a snippet about genetics and evolution. That snippet was a direct result (confirmed to me by Derek) of feedback I gave on a video. So, while I do agree that more time for feedback would be beneficial, I don't agree that the feedback process lacks credibility.

John R

Thought-provoking video. It would have benefited from an interview with an advocate of privacy rights. The video certainly acknowledged that privacy concerns exist, but no one advocated that side of the question. The focus was more on catching criminals. This viewer was left wondering about the Brave New World we are careening into. Perhaps the genie is already out of the bottle, and society never really made an informed decision?

Cristiano Toncelli

Very good topic and very good video. I would shorten a little the first 4' 30'', removing some gruesome details about the crimes of the killer that I think are unnecessary.