Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello wonderful folk,We're about to release a video that is very near and dear to us. I think it's good, I think it's important, and it's also a heavy topic to cover. Here's a link to a draft -- it's missing a few things but it's pretty close to the final version. https://www.dropbox.com/s/be7w0ucskkbup1l/VERITASIUM_LEAD_v4.mp4?dl=0If you have feedback, thoughts, opinions, ideas, please leave a comment.Thank you so much,Petr, on behalf of whole Veritasium team.

Comments

Henner Zeller

The map towards the end showing outlawing leaded fuel is color coded, which is almost impossible to distinguish for people even with a mild color blindness. I could only tell from context that there is probably some color coding going on. There are probably good recommendations for what colors make sense to distinguish for a wider audience, in particular if they have to convey information. From my experience make one of the colors saturated and the other less saturated also with sufficient perceived brightness difference. Other than that, this was an excellent video!

Sam Bebbington

Super interesting! I feel like the first few stories whip past very quickly before the story settles on the leaded fuel section, but going back it makes complete sense. It’s refreshing to know why lead was added to fuel, I always thought it was just acting like a lubricant protecting the valve heads in the engine. Some classic cars still require the additive to protect the engine, while the video shouldn’t be extended to explain the new additives it could be worth a mention that classic car enthusiasts today now use alternative additives.

Felix Petersen

I like the video. I assume you will remove the placeholder and watermarks for getty images. To me, the organization of "age of earth/radioacitivy/Patterson" and "harm through ethyl/lead/HCFCs" repeatedly switching is quite confusing. Especially, the expectation on what the video is about changes repeatedly, which I don't like too much. I think it would be better to separate them and make the connection clearer or arrange it differently. Best Felix

OG

There’s a little “silent” part at 8:16

Benedikt Heinen

Henner - would it help if one of the colors was patterned? ( "solid" green vs red in vertical parallel lines?) That would allow the "normal" colors be used for those with normal color vision - but still also have a visible marker for those with color blindness...?

Shawn Van Ness

At 24:24 .. re "accidental strangulation" .. your sidelong glance seems to suggest maybe they should reopen a homicide investigation. :P

Veritasium

Dear Henner -- this is an important comment. Thank you. I've darkened and saturated the green colour, and desaturated the yellow. We'll be more careful with color information in the future -- Best, Petr

Bahman Engheta

Enjoyed the video very much. Many in the audience may be left wondering about the effects of Midgley pouring Ethyl onto his hand and inhaling in for a full minute.

Robert

I enjoyed the video, but for a long time, it felt a little unfocused. After the intro, I expected to hear about that scientist and something called "Ethyl" (Ethyl-alcohol?, I thought). But then we meet a very different scientist and the video talks about the Manhattan project and Uranium, so I suspected the terrible consequences teasered at the start might be Chernobyl & Fukushima. Finally, we arrive at lead, and then the video skips in time and place to someone cranking a car on a bridge. It takes a while longer before fuels and fuel additives become relevant, and then the a-hah moment (leaded fuel!) arrives, followed by an eventual return to the scientist with his lead-problem. And then CFCs, the ozone layer, etc. come up. This does not feel like one story. It feels a bit like there's a book's worth of stuff in here, perhaps an entire biography. There are asides and little stories which are all interesting in their own right, but which diffuse the main gist. Perhaps this is an attempt to capture the complexity of system dynamics (one little car breakdown on a bridge led, like the proverbial chaos butterfly, to millions of people being more stupid and aggressive and dying... and to an unscrupulous scientist pursuing wealth and willingly accepting others' suffering and deaths to achieve it) but I have some doubts whether the average Youtuber will notice / stick with it. I would recommend producing a highly trimmed version (as well as this "director's cut"). I'd suggest cutting out the Manhattan project, Lord Kelvin, the car breakdown, and anything that distracts from the main two intertwined stories, which are "one scientist, trying to measure earth's age, stumbled across lead contamination, and another scientist, trying to make higher performance fuels, caused terrible problems for humanity." The Franklin Quote is essential, but the dead-ends (different fuel additives that were disregarded) are not. (I guess you mention alcohol because it turned out to be the solution for unleaded fuels? I don't know about cars, so this is just a guess - it's not explicit in the video). I would be tempted to put the Franklin quote at the start and at the end, rather than the middle and the end. The video is a very good parable for climate change, but I feel it is a little too overloaded with anecdotes and asides at the moment. One has to remember things from several minutes ago, which, with my brain being full of lead these days, is a little challenging ;-) If there is a novelisation, I would definitely buy it.

John Cox

A well researched video. I appreciate the "Placeholder" text when there's a blank background. The quote by Benjamin Franklin is quite sobering and reminds me of how long it took for the medical world to adopt hand washing. Suggested title: "Poisoning the world"

John Cox

I got the impression that it was being told as if the events were happening, like two plot lines colliding and intertwining. This would justify going back and forth. Neither Patterson's nor Midgley's careers could be properly explained in isolation from each other.

Pavlo Pravdiukov

On 2:35 you said "convection slows the rate of cooling", but the opposite is true! Convection transfers heat from the core closer to the surface, increasing its temperature. And the higher the temperature - the higher the rate of cooling. I think, he estimated the rate of cooling near the surface based on the temperature gradient and it was pretty high, which lead him to believe the Earth was recently formed. If it would have formed long ago, it would be cooler and the heat transfer rate would be slower. Here it's described better https://www.americanscientist.org/article/kelvin-perry-and-the-age-of-the-earth

Felix Petersen

I agree, but the way that it was combined just feels off to me.

Dumky

Small nit: when you argue that "the world is less intelligent today because of gasoline" (19m50s), it sounds like you're making a statement about net effect (ie. a net harm). But to do so you'd have to account for any positive effects (such as gasoline enabling greater productivity and population) which increased the total IQ of the world. Maybe a reduction in average IQ would be better? Or maybe the estimates mentioned at the end fo the video (estimates of net deaths and net costs)?

Danielle Church

You've got a chart late in the video of the CDC's recommendations on lead levels in blood; the VO says ug/dL but the visual reads mg/dL

Tricia Midgley

My name is Tricia Midgley and Thomas Midgley is my ancestor. My husband's family has told this story many times to our children. I also tell it in science class since I'm related. I can't believe you have now made it into a video! I will definitely be showing this to my students when it is done! Thank you, thank you!

Gordon Garmaise

Minor confusion at about 8:50 - while talking about diesel being low octane, you gesture toward the container of octane. I think your intention was to indicate the cylinder used for compression. It gave me a moment's confusion. Perhaps a text overlay for clarity.

Adrian Byram

Wow -- what an appalling story, but so well told. Thank you! While I knew about lead and about CFCs, I did not realize the underlying connections until this. This raises the question, if there had not been a Thomas Midgley would the economic-industrial complex have invented and deployed these molecules anyway? Or was Midgley, given his personal desire for wealth, critical to their development? Would a larger team realized the safety implications and found a different solution to anti-knocking?

Dave Muth

I had the same thought at the same point in the video. That convection should increase the systemic rate of cooling.

Dave Muth

Kudos! Wren, and you getting them as a sponsor: BRILLIANT!

Matthew Gambrell

I had the same problem too at this point in the video. It jarred me from the vibe of the video and I had to pause to think about it. Could it perhaps be corrected as follows (I'm not sure about the physics, it's just my best guess): "...he didn't take into account convection in the earth's mantle, and that dramatically slows the rate of cooling." + "since it can continually drag up more heat up from the core than anyone suspected was there". You could also have Veritasi-chan pop in with a placard: "Wow, so much heat from the core!"

Matthew Gambrell

Benjamin Franklin's quote has "recieved" instead of "received". I don't know if the spelling of that is some holy wars subject but if you google the actual quote it's 432 results for received and 2 tweets for recieved.

Matthew Gambrell

He actually argues the world is less intelligent today because of _leaded_ gasoline which is subject to the same criticism but probably much more likely to be true in the end...