Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello wonderful patrons!We have a new video coming out really soon -- here's a sneak peek.https://www.dropbox.com/s/n7h2e5umjiy25vb/SN_Fabio%20V4.1.mp4?dl=0As usual, if you have any notes or suggestions or see something that isn't quite right, please let us know.Thanks,Petr on behalf of the whole Ve Team

Comments

Donald J Arndt

I enjoyed every minute - looked good to me

Charles S. Cook

This is Outstanding! I hope you are able to upgrade from the free images that have credits on them.

Edith Dubiner

The audio and video are not synched at the beginning of the video. Except for that, a nice video.

Naomi Gumpel

Blur phone number at about 17:30

John Cox

Looking good, but there were some rough points for me: @3:06 "A star 20 times the mass of our sun has a lifespan of just 10 million years." The graph could use a little extra clarity to help the viewer understand that it's a logarithmic scale. Most of us plebians are used to linear scales, and tossing in a logarithmic scale for only a few frames may cause a little confusion as we try to figure out where the "20 times" falls on the X axis. It might only need an arrow and a text note that it's a logarithmic scale. @3:24 "And when the hydrogen runs out, fusion slows, gravity compresses the core..." Script disconnects from the animation for a bit. It appears later that you are zooming in, but at the point you say that the core is compressed, the animation appears to do the opposite. 1. You say, "when the hydrogen runs out", but the animation does not show the hydrogen running out. Reduced, yes, but the animation appears to show a fair amount of it left by the time you continue on. 2. You say "compresses the core", but the animation shows the star and its core expanding, not compressing. @5:10 "With the electrons gone, the core collapses, and fast." Explanation? Is this a complex explanation that will take too much time to cover in this video? @6:35 "...and as a result, it traps some of those neutrinos and captures their energy, and this is what makes a star go supernova." But if the energy is captured, how does it get released? The words "traps" and "captures" indicate that the energy is taken and contained, but a supernova is clearly not contained. How did this captured energy get released?

FatalXception

I really enjoyed the whole video, astronomy is always a fascinating subject. One minor suggestion, at the very end, almost in a throwaway, you say but we also have to thank these explosions for causing the solar system and planets to coalesce. This was interesting, and you should explain why a supernova or gamma ray burst nearby would cause this to happen.

Bob Terrell

This is just a rough draft. :)

Bob Terrell

I'm a little curious how we know how many hydrogen atoms per cubic meter there are in interstellar space, but that's outside the scope of this video.

Gregor Shapiro

I object to "A BILLION TIMES LESS" (bright). Use "a billionth" (you can pronounce it I'm sure! Times is a multiplier as I recall from grade school. A billion times id greater than the original. just adding "less" makes it an oxymoron. Same for "million times less" and "thousand times less"!!

Gregor Shapiro

Fix sound sync (neutrinos 05:46... and atmospheric protection form cosmic rays 11:40... etc. I suggest removing (all or some of) the scratches, dust etc. from the animations. I find them distracting.

Gregor Shapiro

It is a publicly available paper... (Becomes visible at 17.18 on my video)

Michael Kali

I think the last claim at 17:56 about how "4.6 billion years ago it was a shockwave from a nearby supernova that triggered the collapse of the cloud of gas and dust that formed our solar system" - is a bit confusing. why does such a shockwave triggers the collapse?

FatalXception

That's the throwaway comment I'm referencing. Earlier he talks about how the explosions in our area of the milky way have led us to being in a very low density area even for a vacuum, why would shockwaves cause planets and stars to coalesce in our solar system instead of just blowing away the matter.

katgod

I enjoyed the video and agree with Gregor S about Billion times less vs billionth and think John Cox also made some good points. There is a

katgod

Started to say that there is a lot in this video and many of the points could use there own video at some future date.

Kimberly Green

Totally off-topic, but one of my paternal 3rd great grandfathers was named Levant Van De Bogart. Considering it's a very uncommon surname, I'm thrilled to see someone with it, especially as another Veritasium supporter.