Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey folks,

Here's a preview of our next video release! We had some great discussions with some fascinating people for this topic, so we hope you enjoy it. As always, any suggestions or corrections are eagerly encouraged. We'd also love to know what kind of thumbnail would really capture your attention on this topic! All ideas welcome.

Thanks again for all your input and support!

Team Veritasium

Files

Science Hype

Comments

Kyle Nishioka

Suggested title "All the (science) hype that's fit to print".

meg noah

Nature articles aren't always peer-reviewed. And they have click-bait titles. Yikes!

Marco Currin

I’m gonna let you SHIZA cabecas HAVE IT You GOT 2 DNA STRANDS… you know of…. as it hints how it works thru EVERYTHING AT ONCE….so the same way a YOLK CANT BE REMOVED FROM A GROWN chicken..:.god can never be removed, from ANYTHING IT IS AND IT IS EVERYTHING AT ONCE …human ego made you DOUBT god is in everything as OTHERS ACT LIKE THE DUMbsusses THEY ARE ALL DAY….I just wanna do what I wanna do all day now I can’t feel god In every around me since words? Or like shock you feel so alive? Maybe I should ACCEPT THE WAY THE WORLD IS BECAUSE GOD ALMIGHTY CONTROLS BALANCING THE Entire THING WITH MY FREE will in the middle of half a body?, I ever see in the past, reflecting light I must be on both sides of to understand. We tricked ourselves our body is WHOLE the same as world flat and center of universe.....same way EYES closed its always dark in the future b4 light , open eyes, time and space form PERIPHERAL VISION as light is FINALLY created outside this thought but part of this thought…wow… ok now the light reflects off a body slower than light but I am? IN? THAT BODY?—-well1/2 way at least …so that’s how our soul gets in and out… we are 1/2 way here and half way with god in the future before the BINDI….as every human is DARK B4 light created eyes….closed…..dark——no walls forever that’s infinity in the future folks…. Cause you never see but 1/2 your body….. you made a lot of physics and boogie man bunny rabbit god devil crap up too…you lied to yourself and your HALF GOD ALMIGHTY…get it now :(

Chris Mullin

I think your division into "established science" and "speculation" is too simplistic. Science makes progress by finding evidence to move things from speculation to established, but it never happens with one experiment. These hyped experiements are kind of claiming they do.

Chris Mullin

I would also think that the real funding mechanism for science (outside the Dept of Defense), where researchers in your field compare proposals and rank them, would usually be a good brake on over-hyping results. Your expert peers get pretty annoyed with people who overhype, or produce unreproducible results, which should tank your funding. It may be those fifteen minutes of fame that tempt scientists to do it anyway.

C.J. Smith

2:48 audio has weird cutoff at end of Geraint's bit (I presume he's continuing to talk, but... you know, quick fade out or whatever) If you want to go full-on clickbait, you could do something like, "Science is a LIE", or something more accurate like "Breaking Science News is a LIE"

Edith Dubiner

1. The comparison of worm-hole found via quantum computers to a drawing of rocket as an actual rocket to the moon, as nice as it is, is not satisfactory. If you could spend a couple more minutes to express in layman terms what it is they actually observed with quantum computers that was inflated to a worm-hole, it would be better. You did specify faults in the room-temperature superconductor "result". That was better. 2. Around 14:00 the camera angles and stability are not ideal. If you have alternative footage, consider using it instead.

John Cox

Really appreciate addressing this issue, especially since it is at at risk of making an unpopular video. @7:52 "...but that saying may need to be updated in the age of social media, when lies now have an even greater advantage." Phrasing: Suggest "excitable headlines" rather than "lie". Are you sure that "lie" is the best term here? Some of these excitable headlines may very well be lies (that is, known falsehoods with intent to deceive), but others are mistakes (ex: a loose cable), and while it was irresponsible not to perform due diligence in double-checking the dubiously fantastic result, there was no intent to deceive and therefore it should not be put into the same category as a lie. @8:10 "Overhyping science discoveries can give people a false sense of how science works." Comment: Is this because most people don't understand the concept of variable certainty and instead only grasp the extremes of certainty? Comment: I heard a suggestion today by a scientist who struggled for years to get published, and she brought up the idea of the "failure CV", that is, having highly successful people in their field try to compile and make available a list of exams that they remember failing, experiments that failed, grants requests that were denied, and in general describing how the science world is difficult and requires struggling through failure. Source: Freakonomics radio ep. 563 " How to Succeed at Failing, Part 3: Grit vs. Quit", @36:05 @13:19 "...but the way certain topics are discussed in the media, it may be impossible to tell if they're part of the established body of knowledge or just very fanciful speculation." Comment: I once read an article (can't remember exactly when or where) talking about an old philosophical debate in news coverage about whether it was more important to present "the facts" or to present "the truth" (that is, an interpretation of the facts and filling in the blanks in an attempt to create a coherent story that fits the facts but that itself may not be entirely factual). Perhaps this debate is behind the way that dubiously fantastic results are discussed in the media. @14:22 "...I'm curious whether a solution _is_ possible." "Yeah, I think there is one, and it's exactly what you're doing." Suggest: Move this little clip to the front of the video. It's a great snippet of the conversation and an excellent preview of the topics. Related grey area (very dark grey): Having generative AI write large portions of a paper. It may get a lot of the material correct by sheer probability based on how much existing published literature got vacuumed up by the training set, but that doesn't make it ok. Source: "ChatGPT and the Future of Medical Writing" https://pubs.rsna.org/doi/abs/10.1148/radiol.223312?journalCode=radiology Commentary: https://www.medpagetoday.com/special-reports/exclusives/102960

Veritasium

Thanks for the detailed feedback, suggestions and additional references. This is very much appreciated.

Bartosz Błaszkiewicz

The audio laudness is sometimes uncomfortably fluctuating. Like in 13:28 when you transit from Derrick to the italian guy the latter is hard to hear

Mike Milne

Many thanks for such a worthwhile (and timely) video! I'd like to add to the previous comments about the audio track. I have age-related hearing loss, so I use hearing aids to restore the upper frequencies. My hearing is adequate for most normal situations, but I have trouble when audio recordings are muffled. For me, this is really a problem with Geraint's sections, as his microphone is clearly not good enough for purpose - it sound's like he's talking through pea soup! In cases like this I would normally use closed captions, but those available on this video are the annoying sort that appear word-by-word, which means you have to watch them the whole time rather than looking at the video. CCs need to appear as a whole phrase at a time - preferably synced to the start of the relevant audio - so that they can be read instantly. I realise that this is only a preview, but I'd like to make a plea that the audio on Geraint's sections could be cleaned up and normalised, and/or that proper CCs might be introduced throughout.

Keith Arnold

You have avoided the elephant in the room - carbon/CO2 & global warming. There are are few things more exciting, and thus prone to hype, than “the world is going to end”. In the 70s scientist swore a new ice age was imminent. Leonard Nimoy fell for that one.

Moritz Latuske

Really appreciate you taking on that topic. It's a really tough nut and one that's very much tied to your work no less... One note for the future: Would please consider keeping your hands off the zoom during interviews? It *really* distracts from the interviewee. You don't do that during your own segments to camera either and they are better for it :)