Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello wonderful people,

After a short break, we're back! We've got a new video coming out early next week -- if you want to have a sneak peek and give some suggestions, we'd really appreciate that.

Thank you!

Casper on behalf of the Veritasium team.

Comments

Jaimy van Weiden

Cool video man! Crazy to see how little the average knows about the universe. We should learn more about how the universe works. Here in the Netherlands you won't learn anything about the universe nor science at school. You are really doing a great job telling people about how the universe works! Keep the work up! About the video, I kinda missed a short introduction about what the video was about. You jumped right into the video and I got a bit distracted by the many cut scenes in the beginning. Maybe you can do a short intro with one scene to know what you are watching. And at the end of the video there was a white pixel to the right of your face. It was a bit distracting because my mind was trying to figure out if it was a dead pixel on my tv or just a speck of dust on your lens. All and all a nice video to watch. Maybe not the deep dive in science we normally get. Still it was amusing to watch.

Noelle Smiley

With 2 000 000 000 000 (+) galaxies, each with 100 000 000 000 stars we are approaching Avagadros number sort of scale for # stars in Universe ... similar to the number of molecules in a Tablespoon of water. Extra level of wonder!

Joseph Gill

Nice to see a return to your person-on-the-streets roots. Low information density: 15 minutes to say "college students are pretty clueless about the size of moons, planets, stars, galaxies and the universe, and the number of galaxies (hundred billion) and the number of stars in each (also about a hundred billion)." As a marketing tactic, the low information density seems brilliant: my brain was going slow enough at the end to check out and buy a basic subscription to Ground News. I have always liked your curious and kind approach to things like this. Well played, sir! I appreciate how you simply spur curiosity and leave bemoaning to others. I wouldn't want all your videos to be this information sparse, any more than I would want a Japanese dinner to consist entirely of miso soup, so I will look forward to something more hearty and filling in your next video.

Bruce Goren

I have to say that I was dismayed by the apparent lack of knowledge of this subject. A failure (or maybe feature in the minds of some) of our educational system. In a world that is becoming increasingly dependent upon science and technology, a lack of knowledge on something that I consider to be so basic is not encouraging. Maybe a follow-up on how our school systems teach science and what can be done to improve it. And thanks for really cranking out the content lately. Love your work.

meg noah

I do this in my first tutorial for astronomy I teach at community college. It's all powers of 10 from nano to the farthest quasar. I make an analogy to "Hitchhiker's Guide" quote: ""Space," it says, "is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mindbogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist, but that's just peanuts to space." Here, the walk to the chemist (pharmacist in UK) is the 9 steps of powers of 10 from a baseball bat (1 m) to the size of glucose, etc. and there are many many steps of powers of 10 to even the nearest star.

meg noah

I wonder if they were thinking that by 'size' you meant the projected angular span in the celestial sky angle space.

meg noah

And then the next thing we discuss is Voyager missions (Voyager 1 is not communicating since Dec. 2023) and how they will out live the Sun. Map all this distance to light years. Then we talk about Olbert's paradox and how just observing the night sky is evidence that the Universe is not both infinitely old and infinitely big.

John Cox

@7:28 possible typo: "So the galaxy is a huge collection of stellar systems" Is this expected to be known as a synonym for for "solar system"? It's not a commonly used term. Other than that, great video.

FatalXception

This is one of the only Veritasium video's I've been unable to watch. It was actually painful to see people with such little understanding and care about the world they live on, let alone it's place in the galaxy.

Alissa

The astrology comment about sent me through the roof.

Bartosz Błaszkiewicz

Are you sure it's an average? I'd say those are cherry-picked worst for the drama.

Bartosz Błaszkiewicz

I wouldn't say that there's nothing between galaxies. Sure the intergalactic matter is incredibly sparse but considering the sheer volume of it I guess there's still a lot of matter. Also, what about the wandering stars and dark planets that were slingshot out into "the void"?

Bartosz Błaszkiewicz

After watching the video I don't understand what was it's premise. It's like one of those "Americans are stupid" and their clones. I never liked them. (I mean I never liked those formats. Most Americans are OK and at least few of them I know to be smart).

Gregor Shapiro

Is the galaxy rotation at 7:34 in the correct direction? There are 'stars' (neutron stars etc.) that are considerably smaller than the Earth or any Moons of planets that we know of. Explain that there are several places for the 'Stars' label. Are there not electromagnetic fields and the other fields of physics between the stars and galaxies?

Gregor Shapiro

The wandering rogues mostly will not have gotten far from their galaxies.

Bartosz Błaszkiewicz

Good point. I failed to notice that some things we call stars are smaller than planets. A good, in depth, explainer of the scale of the universe should include such details. Of course it is Dereks prerogative to produce a shallow, elementary school video whenever he wants. Its just not what we are used to getting from him.

Gregor Shapiro

The (low) depth of the astronomical knowledge displayed by the interview subjects astounded me. We can just hope that this was not a representative sampling and perhaps Derek or his crew could make that clear.

Gregor Shapiro

I am fairly sure I knew the answers to the order of those things when still in high school but of course back then there were 9 planets!

RaiMoed

Sorry, not so convincing to me. Whatching people, why they try to make guesses is not so interesting to me. Yes, science communication is important, but this video is actually not catching me.

Mr. Hunter Jones

I see some comments here that are critical of the "man on the street" format. I understand that. But I see the connection to some older veritasium vids that used this format. What I saw were people being open to conversation about a topic that they were not well informed about. To be fair, Derek had a target rich environment. He was at a school. In the end it all came together as he spoke of where we are in the Universe and how we can use our knowledge to help us be humble and work together, not descend into chaos.

Christian Leichsenring

A good reminder that outside one's personal bubble, people have a very... different knowledge base.

Mike Milne

Kids say the darndest things... OK for a TV show I guess, but a bit dumbed-down for a Vertasium video, in my opinion.

Chris Mullin

I would like to know how much you selected the interviewees who guessed furthest off, to get a better sense of the range of understanding out there. What percentage got the ordering right? Did anyone answer "several thousand planets" to your question from the start? Did anyone know 100 B stars/galaxy? I would also suggest including the Hubble or JWST Ultra deep field photo as an actual picture of the large scale of the universe. They clearly illustrate the vast distances between galaxies.

Donald J Arndt

So very very painful for me too - I could not finish it.

Nathan Warkentin

Good video, but am I the only one annoyed at the dead pixel on the camera used on Derek at the middle and end of the video?

Donald J Arndt

I remember all of this being discussed and tested in high school in general science! Nothing is special here. Go to Canada for example and do the same on the street - you'll see much better results.