INSPIRATION SUPPORT: THOUGHTS ON EDITING MUSIC (DIGITALLY) (Patreon)
Content
Good morning fam!
Today I'd like to present you some thoughts on the "editing music" process.
For this inspiration support I will elaborate these thoughts in text. This side of music production is more of a "broad topic", so doing a short video about it wouldn't really do it justice.
Digital music production technology massively changed the quality and detail of editing music. Technically speaking, editing music is defined as any process that alters the original recording or audio material, f.e. splicing, comping, sampling, pitch correction, stretching, fading, phase alignment, compressing, cut-copy-pasting, or any other method used to alter the created or recorded material.
The possibilities of digital editing have made things easier than ever and can be over-done quickly. I still find myself in this situation sometimes today. Its process is packed with critical decisions and can be a process to get lost in very easy.
In my view, yes, editing things you initially created, especially within electronic music, can be a help to keep control in your production. If it is left undone it can compromise the track, leaving it to sound a little unfocused, sloppy or not powerful enough... Editing too much though can easily lead to cold, sort of clinical or lifeless productions. It's a thin line to walk so to speak. Over all the years I have been producing I came to the conclusion it’s best to of course make use of editing, but not as a go-to. If what you got sounds good already, then it simply doesn’t need much editing, or none at all.
As you might already feel from this one, as with all other inspiration support posts my aim here is not to present a "one single go-to method" for editing music that will work with every producer, track or every situation. There are always many factors to take into account when making the best decisions while editing things. With this post I do aim to share some learning in the form of 4 more general editing pointers/thoughts which became a help for myself when approaching the editing stages and when trying to optimise the quality of a track (when needed).
1. Ensure the material you have is as good (recorded) it could be.
To put it pretty bluntly, it is very hard to make gold from shit. Always ensure the material you use or record is of the best quality you can go for. Recorded signals from hardware, software or audio parts used shouldn't be clipping or include bad phasing, too much noise or clicks f.e. If the track is all about sounding wrong and if it works within the specific genre its made for, simply forget this pointer :D
2. Do never forget to also look for attitude and feel instead of f.e. perfect timing and perfect pitch when gauging the quality of a recorded signal. For example a little pitch correction on otherwise great material will sound much better than a perfectly pitched average recorded signal. For most dance-floor orientated electronic music, working on the grid, having a controlled timing on things and being in the right pitch became pretty important factors. I do agree to a certain extent, but I believe that following your feeling while listening is as important. So do not over edit things, even in electronic music. But simply try to amend the right amount, so the track feels both controlled but also still transports the vibe you had in your mind when you creatively were working on it.
I think it is always worth to have a fresh listen to the track when coming to this pointer. When you listen, focus on the whole song and not too much on details. Listening to the same part over and over can start to take you into the world of detail and away from what is most important, the overall feeling. Once caught up in the small detail, which of course is important, one can easily tend to forget that the larger picture is also being effected. Remember that part of the music experience are the subtle "imperfections" that make the track authentic and unique. Once you have assessed this situation, you can then turn to the finer details that trim everything out just so.
3. Fine tuning what you got is important and can make a difference. When entering this more detailed side of editing or fine tuning, I use this editing stage to polish elements or section by f.e. ensuring that beginning and end parts of recorded signal are faded properly, so things become more smooth, transitions work well, phases align properly etc etc. To put it short: to get what you have sounding as good as possible, nothing more. When listening to the track in this stage I pay attention to the detail, also look at visual analysers and make notes. I usually start with the most obvious problem areas and work from there. It is important to keep the perspective of the whole song in mind here still. Certain tracks may require this type of bully editing as part of their "core" message of it, especially within electronic music. If you have a track that is all about being the best edited track ever, editing is a necessary part of achieving that effect of course :D
4. Try to edit while the material is fresh in your head! Even if the edits are just rough, they may save you a lot of time later trying to reacquaint yourself with the material. You usually may have a completely different perspective the next day and not feel everything, but at least you finished what you thought was good that day.
For those who disagree with my thoughts above; that is of course absolutely fine. Always do what you do, the way you want to do it. I am not trying to stop you from it at all. If you create something that is super dope, people will listen to it. One just should never really blame technology for lack of success. I found that using what technology suits the type of music you make and taking responsibility for the quality of your music itself is a "healthy" approach to look at on this matter.
I hope you did like these more general thoughts and I hope they might be a source of inspiration for you when you jump back on one of your next productions.
Coming up next; I will be giving out early access to a fresh bootleg I recently finished and am also working on a couple of sounds for you. I will also record the next PHACETIME with The Caracal Project today + working on more cool things for you!
<3
Flo