Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This week's suggestion comes from uberdrops with "why is the rum gone?" the quick answer is "because the captain and first mate got in a fight". The long answer is below. Hope you enjoy!

There'll be no drabble suggestion thread this week due to the holidays, but there'll be a new one up next Sunday as usual.

~

One for Many:

“This is mutiny, Kolpers.”

“No, captain. It’s survival.”

The sun shone down harshly on the un-named island. It was a small land mass, part of a volcanic island chain and slowly being reclaimed by the sea. In less than a century, it would be gone entirely.  Right now, it was home to a scattering of small trees, fields of long grasses and little else. The larger main island was reachable by raft or small boat. There would be water there, as well as food, shelter and the possibility of rescue.

At least if any of the sailors on the island survived the next few minutes.

There were two different camps of survivors, sun-parched, hungry and dehyrdrated. Two days ago they had managed to get to this island, dragging themselves out of the waves or throwing themselves off the few boats that managed to make it here. Their vessel, a small rum-running sloop called the Belladon, wallowed offshore, tantalizingly close, still half-out of the water. It was salvageable, provided any man lived long enough to reach it, let alone try to raise it.

Janine Kolpers, former first mate of the Belladon, stood at the head of half the remaining men. Just over ten sailors, out of nearly two dozen survivors from a crew twice that size. Their blades were drawn and several held pistols, a pair with rifles. They’d had little time to gather provisions for their escape, but each man had been armed, even with a simple sword or axe.

Standing on the top of a small hillock with a coterie of loyalists around him, Captain Andos Sankoskan planted his fists on his wide hips, glaring down at his traitorous second in command and the mutineers she’d rallied to her cause. She was more silver-tongued than he’d imagined, or her pack of misfits were more desperate than he thought. “You’re putting your faith in honeyed words,” he told the crew standing behind her. “You know that, do you? Listening to this,” he gestured dismissively towards Kolpers, “woman’s false assurances. Our only chance for survival lies in sticking together, not turning on each other. We can get through this, but only if you trust me.”

“Now those are sweet words, too,” Janine growled. “Almost enough to make us forget that you took us here. You brought us through the Sea of Songs,” there was a rustle of agreement from the mutineers. “You told us it would be safe. You didn’t tell us the price of that safety.” The agreement this time sounded louder and angrier.

“If you want someone to blame for your predicament,” Andos announced, again ignoring Kolpers to talk directly to her men. “You should look to the person who caused this to happen. Had you all listened to me, we would be on our merry way, with a hold full of Rinsian spiced rum and a fat payout waiting for us. But you listened to her,” he pointed at Janine. “You ignored your captain’s orders once and this is where we are now! Don’t let her turn us against one another again.”

“Turn us against you?” Kolpers demanded. “You were sacrificing crew members!”

“Only one,” Sankoskan protested. “And only if we were caught. A man goes over the rails during a storm – do you turn about and look for him and risk the ship getting wrecked, or do you mourn his loss and carry on? A man throws himself on a grenade. Do you pull him off it and have everyone die, or do you respect his bravery?”

“It’s not a tragic accident to cut a man’s throat and wrists and drop him over the side,” Kolpers pointed out. “It’s not bravery to feed someone else to the singers all so you can get your ship back to port a little sooner.”

“Oh and your way was so much better!” Andos snapped. He waved at the half-sunken Belladon. There were figures on it and in the water nearby, watching the drama on the beach play out. “We lost the ship, more than half the crew and we’re all stuck on this island, with provisions running low. Yes, clearly your method has worked so well.”

“There wouldn’t have been a need for any of this is you hadn’t brought us through these waters,” Kolpers said quietly. “You can dress it up with talk about trading one life for many, but the truth is simple.”

“And what’s that?”

“You didn’t have to come here at all. You knew we’d probably get caught. You knew it would mean the death of one of your men. Those standing with you are there because they don’t think it would ever be them. Until the next time you decided to rush your way through this route and sooner or later, they’d go over the rails, too. Everyone but the captain. Everyone but the man who decided to take his ship through mermaid waters.” 

The first mate raised her voice. “Their offer still stands. If we give them the captain, they’ll let us off this island.” She pointed to the larger landmass to the northeast, with its tree-covered slopes. “There’s food there. Water. We can wait there for rescue. They’ll let us go. All they want is the man who kept taking his ship through their waters.” There were a few uncertain glances between them. Kolpers was new to the Belladon. She’d only been brought aboard on their last rum-run. Many of them had served with Sankoskan before, bemoaning the ill fortune they suffered every time the tariff-dodging rum-runner snuck by Rinsian patrol by taking the Sea of Songs. But it was always the newest sailors, or the men nobody liked. That their captain had been sending them to the singers hadn’t sat well… but he was the captain and Kolpers’s naiveté had led to the sinking of their ship and the loss of half the crew.

Line had been drawn, with the survivors either gravitating towards Kolpers or Sankoskan, but what had started as grumbling, angry comments and veiled threats had escalated. Kolpers received a visitor last night, a visitor who’d whispered a promise to the woman. Freedom and survival for just one more life. 

“You said it yourself,” Kolpers pressed. “One life for many. A noble sacrifice for the good of everyone else. Only this time, it’s your life. Still willing to stand by those words, captain?” She raised her voice. “We don’t have to die here. Not for him. Not for a man who put his purse above the lives of his crew. Is a hold of rum worth having your throat cut and sent over the railing? Side with him and sooner or later, it will happen to you.”

There were a few more glances and some mutters from Sankoskan’s men. “What can he promise you?” Kolpers demanded. “Can you make it back to the Belladon for supplies? Do you think they’ll let you row your way out of here? They’ll wait until you’re too far from land to swim back and then sink you, or come onto the island in the night and slit your throats in your sleep. Are you going to fight them with a few swords and pistols? What is the plan for ‘working together’, captain? Do you even have one?”

Andos felt the mood of his men start to shift. “This is mutiny,” he repeated.

“No, captain,” Kolpers answered. “It’s survival.” She nodded at someone behind him. A pair of sailors grabbed Andos’s arms, twisting his cutlass out of his grasp. He squawked in pain, looking to his men for help, but his allies had turned on him, or remained silent.

As he was marched down to the beach, he saw what was waiting for him. From the water, he saw them watching, following as he was dragged out onto an outcropping that protruded into the bay. Sankoskan was sobbing and weeping as he was pushed to the edge. There were a dozen of them there, treading water, watching with curious anticipation. “This is mutiny!” he screamed over and over. “You’ll hang, you’ll all hang! This is mutiny! Mutiny!”

Kolpers came up behind him. “We’ll remember your bravery and your sacrifice,” she told him.

Then with a push, Belladon’s captain was hurled from the rocks into the water below.