Weekly Drabble #38: What Lies Beneath (Patreon)
Content
In this story, a young man, wracked by guilt, is driven to find out the truth of a terrible situation. Hope you all enjoy and thanks for your patience!
Author's note: I chose the wife's name as a nod to the (very old) nature of the name. A lot of people think Tiffany is a 'modern' name, but it has roots that go back hundreds of years, if not longer.
~
What Lies Beneath:
It hadn’t rained yet, and for that I was grateful. The shovel turned the sod easily. More easily, I felt, than it should have. Almost as if the soil was loose. I tried to put that thought out my head as I continued to dig, unearthing my wife’s grave.
~
Her name was Tiffany and I thought I’d loved her. Her family name was Vanderhorst, a proud old name from a family fallen on hard times. They were still wealthy, but not as much as they had once been. There’s a saying from the east – how far east I couldn’t tell you – that wealth does not survive three generations. Tiffany’s family had been clutching onto it for five. They’d once had lands, servants and titles but squandered most of it in feuds with other nobles and the wastages of successive generations. Their power had diminished, but they were still wealthy.
I hadn’t cared about that. My own family had money of their own. We were the town’s bankers. My father, his father before him and my older brother Carl. I was the ne’er do well, a natural historian spending more time with his books about anatomy and sketches of insects and voles than with ledgers and banksheets. I had dreams not of accruing interest or calling in loans, but of crossing the ocean and penning my own studies and observations about creatures no one else had ever seen.
Now, I was in a cemetery, turning the earth over where my wife’s body lay.
~
It started five months ago. That was two years after we were married. Starry-eyed dreamer or not, the son of a banker was still a good match for a Vanderhorst, especially since we weren’t some of ‘those people’. The wedding was a nice enough affair and we were happy. At least, I thought we were. Daughter of an aging dynasty or not, Tiffany was still used to more wealth than I had. We never wanted for money, but she seemed put out that I didn’t have more. When we visited my brother, she always complimented him on his taste and his possessions – and he always had something new to show off. In our home, she would look at what we had and sigh. Whenever I asked, she would smile and say it was nothing, or just that she was tired.
Maybe I should have been more attentive. I should have spent more time at home, but my work was consuming. I spent days collecting specimens, making notes and doing my studies. I attended lectures with fellow natural historians, amateur and acclaimed alike. I published a field guide to the plant life in our region and received some attention from the academic community for it. Whenever I tried to talk to my wife about it, she would put that same polite smile on her face and nod. ‘That’s nice, dear.’
She didn’t appreciate my work, but at least she didn’t complain too much over it. I thought that was simply a husband and wife with separate interests. Her paintings didn’t interest me, but I encouraged her, though I had to miss more than a few showings due to my work. Carl was good enough to put in an appearance and escort Tiffany to and from her shows. I didn’t think anything of it when he hung the first painting in his foyer. I thought he was simply being a good brother.
I started to suspect otherwise. We began spending more time at my brother’s and he would more frequently pop in to our home. I would come back from a day’s studies to find him chatting with Tiffany, or sitting at the dinner table. I’d ask him if business was so slow at the bank that he could afford so much time away, but he’d wave the question the off, saying father wanted him to get out and socialize more, so I thought little more of it. At first.
There would be whispers, the two of them laughing at some private joke and when I inquired, be told it was nothing. Tiffany’s mood changed. Instead of sulking whenever I left for a conference, she seemed almost eager. And my brother was always around. Perhaps I was being paranoid. That was what I told myself. But even I started to recognize the way they looked at each other. Standing a little too close, touching a little too often or too long. A familiarity beyond simple friendship.
I knew I was losing her. I had to do something. In desperation, I convinced Tiffany to accompany me out of the house on one of my exploratory walks. I had invited her before, but she wasn’t a fan of nature’s grit and grime and had never accepted my offer. Perhaps she felt guilty. I tried not to think on that, but the thought refused to leave. I had spotted some strange tracks, of a type neither I nor my colleagues had ever seen before, deeper in the woods, though I had never caught sight of what had left them. I hoped such a mystery would catch Tiffany’s attention and show her the value of my work and why it was I spent so much time away from her. I talked as we headed into the forest, telling her about the various plants and animals, but she was largely silent, almost sullenly so. As if she resented having to come out here and regretted her decision.
Eventually, I stopped talking. I don’t know why I kept leading us into the woods. This journey had been a failure. From her comments, she seemed to consider my work even more of a waste of time. Maybe, I thought, maybe if I showed her something strange and unexpected she would change her mind. Maybe that would be the thing to repair our marriage. That was foolish, but I had no other ideas.
Maybe, I think, as I scoop another clod of soil out of the ground, maybe I had another motive, one I didn’t want to admit, even to myself. I would like to imagine myself a better man than that. I would like to think that, but a better man would not be here, doing what I am I doing.
The sun is almost gone. My torch is flickering. I can feel the rain coming. I’m almost deep enough. I’m almost at my beloved Tiffany’s coffin. I feel a sort of madness, an obsession to keep going. I don’t think I could stop even if I wanted to. I have to finish. I have to know.
~
The sun was starting to set when we reached the clearing. This was where I had seen the last tracks, pressed into the bank of the small, gurgling stream and baked there by a hot sun. ‘Almost like a man’s,’ I told Tiffany. ‘But somehow not.’
She was not impressed. The slowly-growing twilight was alarming her and she wanted to go home. I should have listened, but I tarried a little longer, hoping to find some trace of this strange animal. Academic arrogance and marital desperation, I think. I had something to prove. I needed her to see that my work wasn’t just dry pictures in books for bespectacled men and frumpy women to titter and harrumph over.
There were fresh tracks and I followed them, ignoring Tiffany’s protestations. The animal was close, I could feel it! I should have been more attentive. I should noticed that all the birds fell silent, all the frogs ended their chorus. I didn’t. Not until my wife screamed.
I turned and saw… I can’t say what it was. It had emerged from a knot of trees that protruded into the clearing, as if it had been watching and waiting for its chance. It was large and pale, almost a man yet terrifyingly not. It strode on two legs, moving in a fashion I still cannot describe. It was advancing on Tiffany.
There are wolves in the forest. Ever since my old mentor was mauled by one, I have always carried a rifle. I dropped my notebook and pencil and raised my gun as the beast reached for my wife. My finger was on the trigger.
I did not fire.
Perhaps it was shock. That is what I told myself in the days after. Shock and fright forcing me to freeze in that crucial instant. It may even be so, but I know that as I sighted in on the creature’s back, the image foremost in my mind was of my wife and my brother. She, playing with her hair and looking demurely away. Him, smiling and leaning in, their hands entwined… and then they looked up as I entered the room. The silly natural historian who spent his days watching beetles and drawing flowers, who neglected his wife in favour of the applause of strangers.
That thought flashed through me and I did not fire.
Tiffany saw. She looked past the beast to me. I do not know what she saw on my face, but in her eyes I have never seen such despair before or since. She knew. She knew I would not save her. The beast bore her to the ground, slashing and biting. Bits of cloth and sprays of blood went into the air.
Realizing what my hesitation had done, I squeezed the trigger. My bullet took the creature in its back. It reared back and screamed in pain, a sound I wish to never hear again. It whirled towards me, its jaws dripping with my wife’s blood.
I reloaded and with a shaking hand, I fired again. It howled as my shot caught it in the shoulder. It made as if to charge, but my trembling fingers slid a third round into my rifle and it turned, dropping to all fours like an animal and running into the growing shadows, my bullet finding nothing but air.
Tiffany was dead. Her glassy eyes stared at nothing, but I could feel accusation in them. I carried her body back to our horses. I know the beast followed me. Though I never glimpsed it, I could feel its eyes on me every step of the way.
Tiffany had been much beloved by our neighbours and it seemed as if the whole town turned out for the funeral. I told them the story as I’d told it to myself. She wanted to pick some lilies for a bouquet, so she wandered off. I heard her scream. I rushed back to see a wolf of some other animal on her. I shot at the creature, but it fled. Everyone nodded sadly. I was clapped on my shoulders, told I’d done all that I could. Each assurance of sympathy cut deeper than any scorn. I knew what I’d done. Rather, what I’d failed to do.
My brother simply stared. He knew that Tiffany wouldn’t have gone anywhere in the forest by herself. He didn’t say anything then or later, but we talk little these days. Neither of us can bear to ask the questions that weigh down the air between us.
Some of the hunters went into the forest to look for the animal I’d described. One went missing. Another group went out and brought back the body of a large, grizzled wolf. I lied and said that it looked like the beast that had killed my wife. The matter was closed.
But it wasn’t. I started to see Tiffany. At first, I believe it was my own guilt. Out of the corner of my eye, in a busy street. I’d see her face, hear her voice or smell her perfume. I’d turn and then… she’d be gone. A flash, a flicker and nothing.
I began to drink. I started seeing her other places. Outside the window of our home. Standing in the street at dusk. I woke up one morning to find her clothes laid out, just as she would do every night when she’d been alive. I felt as if I was going mad. I’d hear her voice whispering to me, telling me I’d let her die. Saying what a failure I’d been. It was all my fault. Other times, she would be contrite. She was sorry, she missed me. She should have been a better wife. Accusing one moment, apologetic the next. I don’t know which was worse.
I didn’t just feel like I was going mad, I was certain that I was. My friends and family looked on me with pity. My priest told me to put my trust in the Lord. I prayed, I tried to put her from my mind but none of it worked.
Everything felt so real. I’d wake up with the smell of her still in my nostrils. When her apparition moved something, I’d find it the next day in its new place. When she lay next to me, she was so cold. Sometimes I felt her hands creep towards my throat. I thought those were dreams.
Sometimes, she would just stare from a darkened corner, across a street or from a copse of trees. Stare silently. I would look away and she would be gone. Or she would have moved. I would follow her around a corner and see nothing, or catch a glimpse of her. I would chase after her stumbling, cursing, pleading but I could never seem to catch her.
I didn’t know what was real and what was hallucination. Maybe it all was. Or maybe my Tiffany had come back, drawn by her anger and guilt. Or maybe she was something else and I was being toyed with. Or all of them together. None of it made any sense.
One night, I was resolute. I tried to follow her, chasing her into the forest, crashing through brambles, cutting and bruising myself as I ran after her. She led me to the clearing. Her body lay on the ground, just as it had that awful day. I approached her bloodied form and I felt something behind me. Strong, thin hands grasped my neck. “You let this happen,” my wife hissed in my ear. I awoke in my own bed, but found myself covered in scratches.
Another time I followed her to a small cliff. We’d gone there while I was courting her, watching the moon rise. She was sitting as she had been then. I sat next to her, and she lay her head on my shoulder. The morning, one of her long golden hairs was on my clothes.
I couldn’t bear it any longer. My own guilt was eating at me as surely as these visions. I never knew whether she could come to me in scorn or sympathy. I didn’t know what the truth was. I’d told so many lies. Those I told of these visitations – avoiding the full truth of the matter – sympathized, but they assured me Tiffany was dead and buried. I’d carried her body from the woods myself.
This had to end. I had to prove that my wife was dead. She wasn’t haunting me. It was my own mind tormenting me like this. It was all me. Moving things and telling myself it was her. Stumbling drunkenly in the dark and convincing myself I’d gone into the forest. Finding one of her hairs and deluding myself she’d been there. No, no I had to prove to myself that my Tiffany, the woman I thought I loved, was truly gone.
I brought a shovel, a lantern and wood for my torches with me. It was a cloudless night and rain was in the air. I started to dig with the frenzy of a madman, piling the loose sod higher and higher as I excavated Tiffany’s grave. I was almost there. In my rush, I must have struck the coffin with my shovel’s blade, as the lid was cracked and broken.
I fell to my knees, pawing away the dirt like an animal. It had gone silent around me, the owls and ravens quieting, but I didn’t notice. I had to know. I had to know. This had to end. I swept and clawed at the dirt, my hands stabbed with splinters from the shattered wood. I was almost there.
I pulled away the broken coffin lid and finally, I had my answer.