Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This week's prompt is 'failed egalitarianism' from Stephen Branham. Stop me if you've heard this one. A con man, a sex slave and a political professor sit in an office...

When you have to unify the galaxy and twenty thousand different systems of governance, how do you rule them? You just say everyone is equal, right? Well... maybe not. How equal is equal? And if equality isn't the answer, then what is?

~

Kings of Men:

“Equality,” Erasmus Ermine, the Black Fleet’s Emeritus and chairman of the civilian governance council, said to his audience, “is not equal. Such was the rallying cry of the Movement for Restorative Justice, which became the Party for Restorative Social Balance in Governance and then the infamous Restorative Government. As odd as it sounds, that motto was not paradoxical.”

“It sounds like it,” Killian pointed out. She and Erasmus were in the Warlord’s private offices. She was sitting on the corner of the large dark wooden desk, half-lounging in a manner partway between insouciant seduction and insubordinate surety, but the Warlord didn’t chastise her. Since birth, she’d been trained to present herself ‘appropriately’. A pleasure slave from the Allonis Guild was more than a mere bed-pet; they were living works of art. At any moment of the day, they should be admired and desired like a master scultpor’s work. Helfer could slip between personas at a moment’s notice, going from a dedicated and domineering commander of armies to a submissive, eager slave girl and back again. Sometimes when she was with those she trusted and her defences were lowered, she would lapse into her old training unconsciously.

Despite of the incongruity of his most trusted military commander sitting on his desk as if she were about to peel her uniform off bit by bit, the Warlord remained in his seat, hands steepled, the unmasked side of his face attentive as he listened to Ermine’s words. He did, however, discreetly tap Killian’s hand. Her eyes darted to him briefly before she realized how she was sitting and she straightened. She did not, he noticed, remove herself entirely from his desk. For his part, Erasmus diplomatically pretended not to notice the general’s brief lapse. Though they clashed frequently in matters of doctrine and procedure, he respected Helfer.

The Emeritus hadn’t gotten his position at random; he was highly educated and well-versed in many different political and philosophical schools of thought and ideologies. Killian was an ex-slave, who’d only been taught what her trainers and master had wanted her to know. The Warlord himself was a man of singular determination and keen intellect, but also lacked a formal education. Both of them had become something greater than what they had begun as. Part of that was the reason Erasmus had accepted the Warlord’s offer: the young man with the mutilated face wasn’t another petty king or would-be tyrant. He knew what he lacked and turned to others to help him with those missing pieces.

It wasn’t enough for the Ascendancy to conquer; it had to rule and rule well enough that its dominion would not fragment the instant its fleets were no longer present to enforce its will. It not only had to endure, but survive and grow to face the Serpents. They might come in a day, or a century. There was no way to tell, and if humanity once again fractured into countless warring nations before that time, extinction was their fate.

Thus, the Warlord not only listened to the advice of his advisors but would seek it out. Erasmus often had points of view to consider or matters of philosophy that made conversion and rule of conquered territories easier. He could even bring nations to heel through words instead of fleets.

“It does, does it not?” Erasmus asked with a schoolteacher’s smile, given the perfect lead-in to the rest of his lecture. “But not in the minds of those who spoke it. The Restorians argued that treating all people equally was itself an expression of bias and prejudice, as it ignored the history of those involved. Those who had faced oppression could not – and should not, it was claimed – be held to the same standards as privileged members of society, a perspective that is common among our ranks of freed slaves.” He held up a hand to forestall the general’s next comment. “I only describe, Lady Virago. I neither support nor condemn. Our Warlord,” he nodded deferentially to the younger man, “advocates for equality among all. A vassal king and a former slave have the same rights within the Ascendancy. A noble intent, but we have all heard the rumblings of those who believe that their position, whether perceived as higher or lower, entitles them to certain treatment. The king believes his crown entitles him to more. The slave believes his suffering does. Which of them is correct?”

“The slave,” Killian answered without hesitation.

Erasmus pushed his glasses up his nose. “But why should a man, who was merely fortunate enough not to suffer in life, be denied for the sake of someone he’s done no wrong to? It is well to say compassion, but even compassion has its limits. Moreover, not every king is resplendent in power and privilege. Joaquin III of Telent’s Ground, on pain of death, had to marry his sister to preserve the bloodline. Wilmet XIV of Briar’s World was kept alive for three decades in constant pain until one of the offspring he was forced to sire was deemed a suitable heir.” He tilted his head back to the Warlord. “Even our liege is not free of burden.” Erasmus, like Killian, was one of the few members of court to know what was beneath the Warlord’s half-mask, and the agony that the slowly ever-changing flesh hidden beneath it caused him.

“Nor is a slave’s life always painful,” the Emeritus continued. “Consider my own circumstances. Though a court jester for a cruel, sadistic tyrant, I was never beaten, never assaulted nor violated. Because of this privilege, should I be entitled to less than those that were? Such a question is asked in many quarters, that I do not and cannot speak for other slaves as what I endured was less than their own. So to be equal, we must divide those that suffered into classes of their own.

“Then we come to another division, between those kept in brutal conditions as expendable workers or those given treasured status as house pets. How equal is it that a pleasure slave who is only required to service their master or mistress and otherwise resides in luxury be granted the same as a man or woman who was forced to toil day in and day out?” There was a slightly apologetic note in his voice as he referenced Killian’s own heritage. But although she’d been bred as a pleasure slave and all the conditioning and training, there had been an inextinguishable part of her, as in every human, that had wanted freedom. A part that she’d believed dead but had sprung into vibrant, terrifying life with the touch of a stranger’s hand and a question he’d put to her, one no one else ever had.

“Thus,” Ermine continued, “we can see the folly in the dictum. No one is equal to another... so all must be, lest you risk creating an oligarchy of one form or another.

“The downfall of the Restorian government was, in the end, its cannibalistic rule. Victimization became power, so even as the party gathered more support and more influence, its insistence of oppression and prejudices within society became stronger. It widened rifts for its own ends, creating classes of perpetual victims and eternal victimizers. The latter benefited from the Restorian rule, the former... did not. Eventually the polarization that the Restorians stoked led to civil war, a conflict that, generations later, the system has yet to recover from.” He paused to catch his breath, though his lesson was not yet finished.

“But on the flip side of the equation, how many societies have suffered or even collapsed because they did not balance the needs or expectations of their citizens? The powerful few and the masses alike can both topple governments that they believe do not serve their interests or no longer represent them. How do you define equality for those you rule?”

“What’s the answer, then?” Killian asked. “How do you do that?”

“Ah, my dear Lady,” Ermine said with a smile, looking from her to the Warlord. “That is the question, is it not?”