Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Please choose

  • Keep going 426
  • Stop at the third movie 602
  • 2026-05-09
  • 1028 votes
{'title': 'Please choose', 'choices': [{'text': 'Keep going', 'votes': 426}, {'text': 'Stop at the third movie', 'votes': 602}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 5, 9, 1, 10, 4, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1028}

Content

Hey guys, for Pirates of the Caribbean, do you think I should stop after the third movie and move on to a new franchise, or keep going and watch the rest of the series?

Comments

DantesInfernoTv

Definitely keep going girl , this franchise is definitely worth all 5 the movies❤️ especially with a little surprise in the 5th and it’s about a old sea myth which also is quite fun I think !

Calbert

I would say at least watch the 4th one. It’s still a pretty decent movie I think. The 5th one decreases in quality quite a bit.

Rafael

My suggestion would be stop after 4 if you wanna watch more pirates

Mahdi Hasan

Definitely stop at the 3rd movie...because after that this franchise died... Its not worth watching & waste your times.. There are so many other great movies to watch.. Like : Back To The Future Blade Runner Parasite Memories of murder Seven The Shawshank Redemption The Shinning

Chris B

The first 3 are a contained story (as you already see after seeing the first two). 4 and 5 are standalones. I think 4th is the weakest, 5th is a bit better. Although the story is worse than the first three, I mean, it's still a vibe and awesome Johnny Depp, so you might still enjoy them.

Julian David

What are you guys talking about 4th is really a fun movie and 5th while not the best has one of the best character moments in the franchise.

Mike Arnold

Can't wait for you to start legend of Korra

Mike Arnold

Deffs resubbing patreon when you start legend of Korra

The Rog

How sad that you guys are voting that she'd stop after the 3rd, knowing full well that she'll enjoy the rest. Just look at her reactions & how much she's enjoying the characters & lore. The rest are not as good but still good enough to be enjoyed, specially by someone who clearly likes the world & the characters. Unbelievable. 😑

Thomas

Ready to move on. Might I suggest Dune next?

Maurice

I didn’t vote for the Pirates franchise, but I think you should keep going for the people who did vote for it. I’m still hoping for the last season of Once Upon A Time. So I know how some of the people who voted for this franchise might feel if you don’t finish it.

Emmanuel Paquette

4th yes 5th never its terrible (not the actors fault fyi) bad script

Seelia

Stop after 3rd movie. 😂

Seelia

Can we recommend some Cdramas? 😂 Pursuit of Jade please! Best romance I've seen in a drama in yrs!

Nick

Stop! I’m still shocked it beat The Dark Knight Trilogy in that poll

Valentini

The 4 has a different style and the 5 brings in Jack’s origins. But if you could get started on the Fantastic Beasts, The Hobbit and Avatar franchises ( both of which exist in long versions ), that would be great 😃 And these are must-sees.

Nick

Dark Knight trilogy after Pirates🙏

Sanya Arif

Its sad that we have votes against watching after 3. For me, I loved and enjoyed all the movies, even went to the cinemas to watch all of them.

Kevin Karst

It's the Star Wars episodes 7-9 fiasco all over again. Gatekeepers gonna gatekeep, unfortunately. She would have loved those movies.

Psicólogo Felipe Romero

Imo, there SHOULD be an option for skipping the third one. It's Messy and bloated with uninteresting subplots). The fourth is much more entertaining. Never watched the fifth 😮

Donni Lloyd

Keep going. The series is good enough to go past the original trilogy. IMO

Donni Lloyd

it was a Poll, not a YOUR OPINION thing

Stellar

You should start lost girl!

Anna Hellstrom

YES, LOST is such a great serie and great for reaction videos

borntrouble

4th movie is better than 2nd and 3rd imo

Nick

Exactly! The Dark Knight trilogy is widely regarded as one of the greatest and most popular movie trilogy of all time (on par with Lotr). That’s according to IMDB, RT, LetterboxD, etc… so yeah Pirates of the Caribbean beating it in a poll is quite shocking.

Bxb

Stop after 4. On Stranger Tides is worth it just for Penelope Cruz alone 😂

Boaty Zooka

Keep going dont listen to them! 😭😭😭

Jack

KEEP GOING! The people who voted (like me) for Pirates of the Caribbean didn’t vote for three movies, they voted for five! If you could ask only the people who voted for Pirates all five would win easily. You will miss out on so much fun to satisfy the people who just want you to watch something else to begin with.

Jack

Exactly! I voted for five Pirates movies, not three.

Jack

Seriously. Wait six months for Hunger Games to end and get the poll result I wanted in Pirates and she could be out after three.

Jack

The Dark Knight is a perfect 10/10 movie. The whole trilogy is remarkable. I love it. I’m voting for it in the next poll. Doesn’t change the fact I voted for Pirates of the Caribbean in the last poll and want her to watch all five. I find Pirates to just be a good fun time. I love the characters and the world and would happily watch more of them. I implore people who voted not to keep going to change their votes to keep going because who knows? Maybe it’s your pick that’s getting cut in half next on some poll like this and you need votes to convince her to keep going because some people who didn’t even vote for your series just want her to move on. It’s two more movies. That’s it.

Ashley

Definitely stop after the 3rd film imo

Kal

LOST would be so good

Jack

28% of people voted Pirates to win the poll. 38% are saying in this poll to keep going. That means the Pirates voters and a chunk of people who didn’t vote for it all want you to continue. Everyone else didn’t vote for it in the first place. That 28% voted for five movies.

OutlawStar

Stop. It was made as a trilogy and anything after is Disney milking it

The Rog

Absolutely! She would have positively loved those movies! People forget how much she genuinely enjoyed those worlds or just don't care. It's the same for The Hobbit trilogy, based on her reactions, I believe she would absolute love those movies! Just look back at how she felt & the joy it brought her, watching LOTR. I sincerely hope she decides to watch them & Star Wars episodes 7-9, without having to rely on the polls. The gatekeepers make me almost want to leave Patreon but then I remember I'm here to support her, above anything else. I sincerely do hope she gets around all these movies mentioned & reacts to them for us, she would so love to step into those beautiful worlds again, I just know it.

Ricardo B,

Can't vote on this one. Never watched 4 or 5. I'll watch if you end up watching them.

Kevin B.

the gate keeping on reaction channels annoys me greatly even when its something I dislike for example I really didnt like the star wars Episodes 7-9 but I would never vote against it sofie deserved to make her own decisions on what she likes and dislikes once she starts on a path I think she should continue it unless shes not having fun on that path just my two cents so yes I voted yes to continue.

DaniJay

The first 3 movies are one contained story arc and I think the third one is a perfect conclusion to this story. The next two are more standalone (cash grabs by Disney if we’re honest lol)

The Rog

I couldn't agree more! If she enjoyed the content, then she should make her own decision on whether or not to continue on with it. 👍

Big Preston

I would watch them since they are likely making another one soon and it’s just good to complete things

Kevin B.

I have to be honest when I read this I thought you ment the show Lost Girl not till I read the replies did I say oh they ment Lost hahha

silverarrow06

I'd say the whole poll wasn't a good idea. There was no chance a majority would vote for continuing since so many people initially voted for other franchises and will vote with the "stoppers" for sure. The vast majority of the people who voted for "pirates" wanted to see you react to all five movies, but will be the minority overall. This outcome was predictable. If you made poll at all then only for those who wanted you to see the movies initially, because they're the only ones really interested in this reactions. I know it's impossible to do, so I think it would have been better if you would've just followed your guts wether to continue or not. Just my two cents...🤔🙂

Jack

I hope she reads comments like this one and realizes the poll was a bad idea for all the reasons you stated. The people who voted, voted for five movies. Will future Series polls say how many movies in each series are a guarantee and the rest rely on a poll?

Maria Hiendl

Please keep going. Yes they are not as good as the first three but still quite enjoyable. And I kind of have a guilty pleasure love for the fifth on

AyaMoon

People who votes for stop just want you to go to another franchise, those who voted for the movie to beginning with wants to see the franchise covered ! I really would like to see you react to all 5, I think you would enjoy them all honestly !

Luisa Izzicupo

Yessss! Lost please! It's the best serie ever!

Alexander M

I would just add more friends episodes instead , just saying

Helly R

You mean Lost or Lost Girl

David

Dont look at the vote. Keep going.

Razzer95

Personally I'd prefer you start a new movie series like The Dark Knight trilogy, Indiana jones, The Bourne trilogy and maybe even the Godfather series but I wouldn't have a problem if you wanted to finish Pirates of the Caribbean first

Nina

That's just ridiculous. No matter how bloated or messy is it...it's the culmination and ending to several great characters of the franchise and therefore absolutely necessary. These characters need a finished arc.

Raquel

Sorry if this comes across the wrong way, but most of us who voted for Pirates of the Caribbean did so thinking of the whole franchise, not just the first three movies. Even if the last two are less popular, they are still part of the saga, much more than, for example, the Hunger Games prequel. I understand that the question now is whether to continue the franchise or move on to something else, but personally I lean towards respecting the poll result and seeing it through to the end. I think it’s a bit unfair to dismiss what a lot of people voted for, and I think it would be fairer to let the winning franchise be completed before moving on, since many people voted for it with that idea in mind.

kosia

The fact that this poll exists.... Makes me feel maybe she should move on. If she really wanted to continue would this poll exist. She may be getting burned out with the franchise. If we really want to see it, she will keep going but she seems ready for something new. I want her to watch what she wants I'm here for it either way

Miloš 🇷🇸

I heard the sixth movie is about to have all the original cast :)

DantesInfernoTv

To my knowledge Keira knightley won’t be unfortunately but Orlando bloom and Johnny depp ect will be but I’m more curious about those who will be joining the cast going forward in the franchise ❤️ especially with the news also that the director wants this movie to be a reboot..

Halima

Seconding The Bourne trilogy

Stellar

This is hilarious reading these replies! I actually meant the Canadian show Lost Girl about Bo. But now that people thought I meant the other one that is just LOST, yes that too! How about both. 🤣

Stellar

I actually meant Lost Girl. But both now that people are thinking I meant Lost. 😆 I’ve seen both and now I need her to do both haha

Stellar

I meant the Canadian tv show “Lost Girl” but also now Lost cuz that is a good one 😂

Young Ish Jon

I think the first three are a great trilogy and if you wanted to, it's a good stopping point. However, I think there's enough good in the next two that are worth a look. Keep going and enjoy yaself I reckon!

Kevin B.

hey that was my first thought and for the record I love the show Lost Girl, I guess I should have stuck with my first thought about what you ment but I let myself get convinced that you ment lost since Lost is way more well known and I only met a handful of people that even knew what lost girl was hahah

Alex

Please don’t compare Pirates 4/5 to those horrendous star wars fan-fiction “movies.” That’s really disrespectful

Stellar

Reading through the comments I was actually confused when so many people got excited haha I was like oh a lot of people want Lost Girl! Because like you I’m not familiar with many people knowing what that show is 😅 now it makes sense they thought I meant the other show. But we’re all tv nerds over here so it does appear more people know about it than we would think. I’m def gonna start pushing for her to react to both.

Psicólogo Felipe Romero

I was only taking into consideratión the enjoyment factor watching these movies, the third one was easily the Only one I don't want to watch again and thats it. Its not that serious

Bxb

Agreed

Bora Usta

I loved 4 when I first saw it. Never seen 5 but heard mixed things about it. I'd say definitely go with 4 but I'm not sure about 5.

Lunki

I do like the last movie they did. Its also connected to the trilogy.

Kevin Karst

The only one being disrespectful here is you, refusing to accept that the Star Wars sequels have lots of fans. Your (questionable) opinion doesn‘t make you right, it‘s just an opinion. Also the average imdb rating of the SW sequels is 6.9, whereas PotC 4 & 5 are rated 6.6 and 6.5. So it‘s definitely not an absurd comparison, if anything you‘re the one with the minority opinion. Most importantly: I‘ve seen 3 reactors so far reacting to Episodes 7-9 and they ALL LOVED them.

Conor Murphy

Personally I don’t care for the 5th one, but I quite like the 4th one and think it keeps the spirit well enough.

Mr_ColdRice

nawww the 4th movie was perfectly finee its the 5th one thats kinda iffy

Anonymous

as someone who votes no, (not a fan of the films, think they marginally taint the series and don't want to waste your time), I had no idea people were so passionate about them and I think it's a more valid passion than any haters, at the end of the day it's better to produce content for people to see and some can ignore than to not produce something for the people who want it, there's no real losers if you do watch them all, people who don't like it don't have to watch. So even though I voted no, I think you should watch them all, people clearly want it and it's better to have done it than not. 🩵 Obviously do whatever you want first and foremost but if looking to cater to other people, nice to give the people who want it something to enjoy :)

BlackBeardYT

it's true that the good movies ends with the 3rd one, but that doesn't mean the last two weren't good, it's just that they aren't as good