Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

A.O.T replacement

  • Death Note 479
  • Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood 273
  • Vinland Saga 206
  • 2026-07-24
  • —2026-08-14
  • 958 votes
{'title': 'A.O.T replacement ', 'choices': [{'text': 'Death Note', 'votes': 479}, {'text': ' Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood', 'votes': 273}, {'text': ' Vinland Saga', 'votes': 206}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 8, 14, 3, 49, 19, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 7, 24, 2, 14, 50, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 958}

Content

Comments

Elisabeth Hutchinson

Do Death Note and FMAB both eventually? They're both must watches.

archit vyas

well whatever you watch from these three Sofie..watch it in originally intended voice acting i.e. sub ....do not be fooled by essay speaking dub listeners

Kelsey

I'm glad it came down to these 3 - glad you other subs have some taste. But praying now for FMAB 🙏🙏🙏 the storytelling and soundtrack is so peak 🤌🤌

Mina E.D

Hoping Death Note wins. Classic + vibe change + not so long If Fmab wins I gotta get cracking on it from now tho

Mina E.D

I agree but if death note wins, the dub people will freak out especially on youtube

Jarron Taylor

There’s a reason death note’s dub is more iconic than the sub

archit vyas

@Jarom Taylor....anyone can make a dub...and can be iconic or not it doesn't matter....because its NOT ORIGINAL

Faraam Knight

Nooo, es para cuando AOT se termine

Swisheroo

FULL METAL CMON 😭😭

Swisheroo

To all that voted Vinland, choose FULL METAL 🙏 yall aint winning at that rate. PLEASE FULL METAL 🙏😭🫡

b jan

For 99% of animes, yes. FMAB dub is superior, however.

archit vyas

you can't be superior against original

Ristaroth

I'm sorry , but anything except FMA so I'm both fine with Death note and Vinland saga even tho I think she will probably watch all of them in the future.

darkchaos125

Oof...this is what people wanted as a replacement for AoT? Yikes.......there are much better choices than these....

Opticblasting3

It's always the sub freaks that are gatekeeping

PBnJ

Not really. Sure there are better shows in general but these are great picks. Especially for a newer viewer.

darkchaos125

I've spoken too soon then. My concern is when reactors only have so much time, I overworry about them finding the best but a variety is good too.

Magdalena

Death note please 🙏

melkamu avrham

Please watch Black Clover the new season is going to be fire

Lau’

Death not is the most popular, but Vinland really is the best

darya

Everyone around me watched it with sub, never heard anyone saying dub is iconic. Nothing will ever beat the original voices

PBnJ

Lowkey you might be right 😂. I didn’t think about it that way. But yeah maybe we should’ve recommend peak first then go for variety or iconic. These shows are fine but, there certainly are better. Except FMA that’s was my first manga/anime so it holds a special place in my heart compared to the others. But I don’t think they’ll win many polls. The iconic shows tend to beat ones less popular regardless of which one is generally better.

mangakiet

Just wondering outside of action has Fruits Basket ever been mentioned in her polls? Not seen many reactors do it but its definitely one of the many series that makes me enjoy anime growing up !

Jon

I personally liked DN back in the day but Idk I feel this might not be suitable for a reaction series. Doesn't have the insane plot depth of AoT or other Animes for that matter.

Allison

I just finished fruits basket. The build of character development would be amazing for this channel. Please don’t vote Death Note. It goes NOWHERE. It’s the same episode across the series. There’s no plot movement or character development. Sofie needs something she can sink her teeth into.

Allison

Anything but Death Note. Come on, guys. Think of Sofie and her channel. Name one thing about death note that she’ll be able to analyze. Can’t? There’s no character development and the plot is basically the same episode over and over again.

mangakiet

Did u watch the "newer" completed one 2019? And I totally agree! i feel Sofie will understand and get all emotional. I just wanna see reactors cry lol I love action but everyone is doing FMA / JJK / AOT / S.Levelling And I understand they are all amazing! However we need a range that isn't just epic fights

Chlo

please please please fmab! it would be such a good change in pace from aot. and it's such a well done complete story

Loki

I don't know any of these shows at all. Is this anime?

Eslam Bouafif

Whatever happens please watch anime in it's original language, no matter how many people push for the dub version

I Love AOC

Not bad strat tbh. Team Death Note all the way, tho.

I Love AOC

Dubs always sound like parody versions of the real ones, bro.

Adriano D.

Full Metal is nice, a little too childish at times. Vinland is great the way it's written, its characters, but i truly dislike its take on the main philosophical aspect. Death Note, go for it, best of the three.

Skrajny

I voted, but what does it mean 'replacement'? There is no replacement for AoT.

Sami

Death note is the best replacement for AOT and I would encourage you to watch the Dub version.

Flawless

Deathnote is Amazin, one of my favorite animes. The mindgames and plots are real in this anime.

Kelsey

it just means the new show that will take up the time slot that is currently held by AoT once she finishes watching it

RisePhx

AOT Rewatch?

Marina

Whichever is selected, simply do another poll for dub vs sub. People are going to get heating about this. A poll will make the majority opinion clear.

Frosty

The second half of Death note is terrible idk why people want it so bad

userdel

will 4x1-2 of aot be up today?

Julian David

Full metal is so Good come on Death Note is overrated

WellkotS m

where is the aot 4x1 4x2?

Pablo JOBERT

vinland is objectivly the best for her, fmab is too goofy sometime and death note is not that great in the second part

Are-eem

Sad....Vinland saga in 3rd place

Daniel

I'm so happy Death Note won. Sofie will love it. But in all honesty, any one of those three shows would be great, and maybe she'll get to watch them all someday.

Daniel

Yep. AOT (Attack On Titan) is an anime and the first Sofie ever watched/reacted to. And now I guess she wants to keep that weekly "slot" by following up with another anime.

Daniel

Couldn't disagree more. Have you even fully watched Death Note? Or dropped it after three episodes?

Daniel

I agree! Besides, I assume people pushing for dub are expecting the English version. But, at least to me, that only makes sense if your native language is English and you're more comfortable that way... which is not Sofie's case. We are used to reading subtitles even when the show's original language is English anyway, because sometimes it's hard to understand the audio. Take Friends for example, Sofie's been watching it with English subtitles. Anyway sorry for the wall of text lol

Daniel

Exactly. It will be refreshing to see something not focused on fighting all the time.

Никита Климов

They were originally supposed to come out on Friday. It's already Sunday, and there's still no video. If she's having some kind of delay, why didn't she write about it?

Allison

Obviously, lots of people are disagreeing because they love death note. I did watch until the very end and I did so begrudgingly because I thought surely it would be an amazing ending because everybody speaks so highly of it. I was sorely disappointed.

Ricardo B,

I overwhelmingly prefer the subbed version, but if there's a vote I'd rather go for the dub. I never made a comment as I voted for sub for AoT, but Sofie seems to have way too much trouble keeping up with the subs. The dub of death note is perfectly good, and if it makes for a smoother reaction, then it's better.

archit vyas

if she is putting a poll on sub or dub..then she wants people to choose what they "OVERWHELMINGLY PREFER" ......just because you want dub you are saying like this be honest with your thoughts.

Daniel

Oh. First of all, I'm sorry for my previous comment. Second, I'm sorry to hear you didn't enjoy watching it. I guess it's one of those shows where the ending doesn't provide straightforward answers, and that's kind of the whole point. Anticlimactic endings aren't for everyone. But if it makes you feel any better, I actually can't stand AOT... and apparently everyone loves it. I feel very misunderstood lol They're just different types of shows with different target audiences, I guess. And hey, if anything Sofie's reactions and analyses might make you see Death Note differently and appreciate it more heheh

Allison

That’s true! I might end up hate watching it, along for the ride. Who knows… I didn’t think it was anticlimactic and I understood what the show was trying to do. I was just waiting to like it more the whole time lol. There were things about it that I liked and were fun to watch, but eventually, it felt monotonous and I wanted more from it. I guess I need my characters to learn and grow and my plot to feel earned. I do love AOT and my first anime I ever watched was FMAB - so I guess that set the bar. Also - where is dandandandan on this list!!?

Terry C

Death Note was good until a certain point, then it was terrible tbh. So overall, I'd rank the anime mediocre. Had it ended at a certain point, then it would be pretty good, but since you have to judge the anime on it's entirety, it equals out to mediocre.

Terry C

Yeah no dubovers please. Should be watched how it was created to be, the real version has far superior voice acting too compared to the terrible dubovers.

Allison

Yes. This. I didn’t hate it completely and I don’t knock anyone who enjoyed it, but due to the fact that there’s no character development, I think it’s a bad fit for the channel. She’ll probably like it at first though, so I guess that’s something 😕

Freethinker Ang

Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood (English Dub)