Home
Creators
Search Recent Missing Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Charmed replacement Round 1 (Patreon)

Published:
2026-10-27 23:13:15
Imported:
2026-11

Poll

Charmed replacement Round 1

  • Gossip girl 193
  • The good place 289
  • Gilmore girls 203
  • Bridgerton 179
  • Merlin 187
  • 2026-10-27
  • 1051 votes
{'title': 'Charmed replacement Round 1 ', 'choices': [{'text': 'Gossip girl ', 'votes': 193}, {'text': 'The good place', 'votes': 289}, {'text': 'Gilmore girls', 'votes': 203}, {'text': 'Bridgerton', 'votes': 179}, {'text': 'Merlin ', 'votes': 187}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 10, 27, 22, 34, 59, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1051}

Content

Hey guys! ❤️

With Charmed almost coming to an end though we still have the last season, it's time to choose our next show!

I decided to stick with these because my current lineup is already pretty heavy and honestly, your girl needs something a little lighter! 😂

I want a show that brings the same comfort and fun I get from Charmed, with lovable characters, humor, friendships, romance, and a little drama.

So, which one should we watch next? Vote below! ❤️

Comments

Asaunte

The Good Place would be such an amazing watch for Sofie but I already know it's not winning lol

jamielee

omg merlin 💕💕

JDM

Im curious for in the future where we get to suggest shows that get put in these polls, I used to think it was here on the patreon page or is it somewhere else like in the discord chat....with that being said my vote would either go to the good place or gossip girl

JC Whittaker

Grimm, if you are looking for something along the lines of Charmed.

G

sofie watching gossip girl would literally be a dream come true omg

Enzo Reis

Gossip Girl or The Good Place 😍🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

Rainbow

Merlin is great - but have you already watched Doctor Who (from Rose/2004 reboot?)

Loki

Bridgerton!!!

PhantomLuna

Merlin! Not enough people react to it. That show will forever have a special place in my heart 💜

Kai

Gilmore Girls PLEASE, you would LOVE it 💕 Also I’d like to recommend ‘Orphan Black’ and ‘Bones’ for future shows/polls!

Frankie

Both the good place and merlin are two of my favorite shows (buffy is the other)

Chris

Good shows to replace Charmed - Supernatural or Grimm

Miloš 🇷🇸

MERLIN!! Perfect charmed replacement! This post also makes me sad man 😔

DaniJay

You reacting to Gilmore Girls would be AMAZING! I feel like you’d love the characters and the feel of the show

Ricardo B,

First place for Good Place!

Hala

OH MY GOD GILMORE GIRLS HAS TO WIN

Asaunte

And i hope it stays that way but I'm not getting my hopes up

Joey Tribbiani

the good place and gilmore girls are two of my favorite shows, but honestly anything in that list would make me happy

Allison

Orphan black would be a great replacement for dark

Inés Soriano

Like for the forgotten anime tribe :( We want Fruits Basket reactions! For a wholesome series with one of the best endings in the world <3

Melanie S2A

Seeing you react to Gossip Girl is a VITAL necessity 🙏🙏

Nanners

The Good Place!!

Nanners

There is a place to make show suggestions on the discord.

Kelsey

Gilmore Girls would be so good!! Checks all the boxes of what you mentioned you’d like in a show.

martatiny

The good place is an underrated masterpiece❤️

Mina E.D

The Good Place or Bridgerton would be FIRE!!

86lantash

I know where my vote goes. Let’s forking go.

Halima

Bridgerton omg

GomezAddams

Please consider Severance someday. 🙏 And have a Very Happy Halloween!! 🎃👻🧛‍♂️🦇🧙‍♀️🐈‍⬛️🧟‍♂️🐺💀

Polina

'lovable characters, humor, friendships, romance, and a little drama."-Gilmore Girls really matches what you said here in my opinion. The good place would be great too though. I would not in my opinion call the gossip girl characters 'lovable''-they are entertaining and interesting though.

Nick

Agree

Maurice

Even though my vote is for Gossip Girl. Gilmore Girls will check off all the boxes you said you were looking for more than any other show on this list.

Mizzqueenie

''I'M SCREAMING MERLIN!!! 😍 💖 But man , we can already see the writing on the wall. 😅 Best of luck to Merlin, because the rest of these shows are some absolute heavy hitters!"

Alile

I loved the first few seasons of Gilmore Girls, so if it wins I’d definitely watch reactions for seasons 1-3 and then select episodes from then on. 😂 But I vote The Good Place because I remember enjoying it, but never rewatching it after the first watch. 🙂

Alile

Orphan Black!!! I wish that was on the poll! 😩

Eric Church

that don't anything anymore scarlet. remember the back and fourth war between the sixth sense and obsession ? obsession was leading originally but look at the result. lol it don't matter whats in the lead right now.

amy 💕

i neeeed you to watch gilmore girls ugh

Roni

Gilmore Girls is quality-wise simply one of the best-written series of all time, its witty dialogue and characters keeps it constantly entertaining. I like all the others, watched Merlin and Gossip Girl as it aired. But these are mostly guilty pleasure with quite a few cringy and childish moments. If it‘s a once in a lifetime watch, Gilmore Girls is the first choice :0)

juliet

FINALLY THE SHOWS I KNOW AND LOVE OMG

juliet

YEEEEES

Monika

Ah, it's a pity Shadowhunters isn't more popular to make the list. Out of here, Merlin is one I rarely see reactions to, so rooting for it.

Scarlet.66

You’re right. I forgot about that. But I truly believe The Good Place will win.💪 You know, false optimism and all.😭 Beside, looking at the result now, the gap has only gotten bigger over the last 9 hours. It would take a miracle for it to lose.💗

cruzinbosco

Gilmore Girls is exactly what you want. All that you listed is right there waiting for you. IMO, it's the #1 comfort show (other than Friends). 🍂🍃🍁☕📚

Raquel

My favourite reactor watching Gilmore Girls would be a dream come true 😭❤️ It’s one of my top comfort shows and honestly, it has EVERYTHING: comedy, drama, love interests, teenage moments and adult problems, complex characters you can both love and hate, character development, iconic moments and BRUTAL dialogue. And just like Friends, it’s one of those shows that makes you feel like you’re part of their lives, like you actually know them and you’re just hanging out with them. 🥹❤️ The Good Place would also be a great choice. It’s hilarious, clever and so refreshingly original. I just feel like Gilmore Girls has that extra something, with its mix of humour, drama, romance, family dynamics and incredibly layered characters. There’s just so much to unpack!

Yen

Not likely, but Bridgerton pls

juliet

YES PLEASE

juliet

*The Good Place* is a sitcom unlike any other. I don’t think it should be on this list. I really love this series, and I’d love for you to watch it one day, but in this case it’s out of place. It would be a good replacement for *Friends*.

Grace

Gilmore girls would defo bring the same joy!

juliet

Okay, what would it take to get you to watch *Off Campus*? It has everything you listed, plus an amazing soundtrack, which I know you appreciate.

Belthazor82

My preference would be Gossip Girl. It's been ages since I watched that and it was really good. It's an iconic show. It's also with someone you already know from The Boys. The Good Place would be my second choice. I loved the first season, but felt like it went downhill quickly after that. But it definitely does check your boxes. Also, I feel like it wouldn't be the worst idea to watch that before Gossip Girl. Then you'll recognize immediately who voices Gossip Girl.

MIAN ABDUR REHMAN ALI

Gossip Girl…the OG. Don’t fall for the higher votes for any other show

Fatima Bah

The good place is soo so fun and really good. Perfect for that light and comfort you’re looking for, so I hope it wins.

cruzinbosco

The pilot of Gossip Girl is still one of the best pilots I have ever watched. And season one is just *chef's kiss*. I do hope she watches it at some point because man, what a ride.

KelseyAnn

I will forever be a Patreon subscriber if she does Gilmore girls OMFG!😭❤️ we neeeed more quality Gilmore girl reactions!😭😭

Razzer95

None of these are my cup of tea but I totally get wanting a more light hearted show. My mum always loved Gilmore Girls so I'll vote for them

Gigi

please please please gossip girl or gilmore girls

Polina

The good place is a shorter show. If it wins, maybe if you would like ,you can watch another one that wins second place at same time as the good place because it is shorter? Just a suggestion. Hope you will eventually sometime react to gilmore girls and gossip girl .

Allison

I have been wanting you to watch The Good Place for forever. I’m so excited!

Who

Ok, so this is what I’m thinking. In my biased opinion Sofie needs to watch Lost. However Lost isn’t light enough for what she wants right now. So while in a vacuum I’d vote for Gossip Girl, GG is 121 episodes and pushes the potential for a Lost reaction too far into the future. The Good Place on the other hand is far shorter. Leaves a larger light on for a much better show nearer in the future.

Randy Giles

I'm surprised Supernatural wasn't on the list, a fantasy show that was on the same network as Charmed and Buffy. Supernatural isn't as light-hearted as Charmed, but has a lot of funny episodes in it, and some of the banter between the brothers is humorous. Out of the ones listed, I've only seen Gilmore Girls, so I will refrain from voting. I never saw The Good Place, but I loved Kristen Bell in Veronica Mars.

Randy Giles

Excellent choice...and excellent avatar.

Randy Giles

I've been binge-watching Bones for the past two weeks, coincidentally. It's a little bit like Lucifer, but without the supernatural elements.

Maurice

Supernatural is the perfect show to replace Charmed and Dark, but Supernatural is a little more dark and heavy, and she’s not looking to replace Charmed with a show like that unfortunately.

userdel

hi when is aot?

Lunki

Loved that show. Waiting for every new season to come out was hell 😂

Marlene

You should watch supernatural

yara

I really do feel like we should have the good place as a replacement for friends as it is a sitcom and replacing charmed with one of the other shows (hopefully gilmore girls) which is honestly the most fair thing to do as the good place is so different from the other shows on the poll

Ashley

I think Gilmore Girls is the vibe you're looking for especially at this time of year, but The Good Place will probably make you laugh more and they're both excellent shows so I think you'll be happy with either. :)

Minstrengest

I’ll subscribe right away if you started doing Merlin reaction videos <3