Home
Creators
Search Recent Missing Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Charmed replacement (Patreon)

Published:
2026-10-30 13:20:41
Edited:
2026-11-05 01:28:32
Imported:

Poll

Charmed replacement

  • The Good Place 343
  • Gilmore Girls 375
  • Gossip Girl 135
  • 2026-10-30
  • —2026-11-05
  • 853 votes
{'title': 'Charmed replacement ', 'choices': [{'text': 'The Good Place', 'votes': 343}, {'text': 'Gilmore Girls ', 'votes': 375}, {'text': 'Gossip Girl ', 'votes': 135}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 5, 1, 28, 29, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 10, 30, 13, 19, 17, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 853}

Content

Comments

Helen Nesbitt

Ohh I need more Gilmore Girls reactions 🤩

Nine3x

Honorable mentions for future reference - how to get away with murder Killing Eve Wynonna Earp

PhantomLuna

Ah well, none of these are for me. Was hoping with something a bit more magical as a replacement for Charmed.

Elsa Millie

Oh I hope Gilmore Girls wins so much!

GomezAddams

Please consider Severance someday. I'm 💯 you'll love it. Thanks for all you do, and have a Very Happy Halloween!! 🎃👻🧛‍♂️🦇🧙‍♀️🐈‍⬛️🐺🕷🧟‍♂️💀

Roni

I hope for Gilmore Girls, there are way too few reactions for the monumental series it is! :0)

juliet

Can we have all 3 please? 😭

janeelmonae

Honorable mention: Grey’s Anatomy!

juliet

omg my favorite show ever! i would be so happy

Neil Writes Things

You should consider Silo and/or Severance for future reactions 😊

Scarlet.66

Okay, I may have jumped the gun by predicting that we’d get The Good Place after seeing the results in the first round. I thought we had it in the bag, but now I’m actually kind of worried. 😭 Sorry to those I wrote to in the first-round comment section for being an annoyingly optimistic and hopeful person. 😭 I hope The Good Place wins! 🔥💪

Darkpoole

I hope you'll consider Pushing Daisies someday.

Mizzqueenie

" I feel like people are just voting for their favorite popular shows without reading what Sophie actually asked for! Gilmore girls and The Good place are fun, but they aren't 'Charmed replacements. ' Merlin actually has the magic, high-stakes, humor and deep character bonds that fit the charmed vibe so much better. Good luck 👍!

Mina E.D

Good place gng im gonna need yall to lock in 🤞

Devon

Sad to see Gossip Girl so far behind. I really hope you'll consider it again at some point.

Raquel

Pleaaaase, my girls (Gilmore) have to win!! They tick every single box on Sofie's list... "I want a show that brings me the same comfort and fun I get from Charmed, with lovable characters, humor, friendships, romance, and a little drama." Plus, they have that special ingredient that makes you feel like you're part of their world. The Good Place is still a show I absolutely love, but I just can't put it ahead of one of my all-time favorites. ❤️

martatiny

THE GOOD PLACE PLSSSSS❤️❤️❤️

Gigi

GILMORE GIRLS ❤️ one of the most iconic tv shows ever

amy 💕

praying gilmore girls winsssss

Alyssa Dyson

Anything but the Gilmore girls lol 😂

Bruce K

Yesterday I was losing hope. Today is a new day! re: Gossip Girls, maybe we could warm up for it with The OC by the same writers? Sure Gossip Girl has the backstabbing, fashion and melodrama; but The OC's got the found-family, fun dialogue, and genuine heart.

Polina

The good place is a shorter show than the others -just a suggestion if you would like , to maybe watch it together with another one.-especially if they are close in this poll too. I hope eventually later you will react to all 3 of these.

Asaunte

I knew it was too good to be true😭

Scarlet.66

@ Asaunte This community poll system is so unpredictable. 😭 A show can lead in the first round, then lose in the second? I now get what you meant when you wrote in the other comment section that you knew The Good Place wouldn’t win. Tbh, I’ve kind of lost hope for this one too.😭

eric knight

The good place is gold. Gilmore girls is ok if you are into more drama.

Shannon

But only for the first 5-6 seasons 😅

Mina E.D

The good place is my pick cause its writing is very clearly well planned out and well executed. Theres lots to discuss in terms of themes and the subject matter can be heavy at times, and yet they manage to add a lot of levity. I wouldn't mind gilmore girls, but it'll take forever to finish, and imo its a victim of "they start to lose the plot as the seasons progress".

Maurice

If Gossip Girl remains low. I hope we get a third round for a Charmed replacement . If it came down to The Good Place and Gilmore Girls, I’m sure most people who are voting for Gossip Girl like myself would vote for Gilmore Girls as their second choice. I really don’t think a sitcom should replace Charmed.

Gabriela Popescu

Please not gossip girl, it’s so melodramatic and kind of geared towards teens. It’s a fun watch but overly dramatic. Just my opinion!

KelseyAnn

GILMORE GIRLS I BEG YOU😭

juliet

10* (at least)

juliet

I had already changed my vote to *Gilmore Girls* when I realized that *Gossip Girl* didn't stand a chance of winning. It's good that there's an option to cancel your vote and vote again.

Jelani

This is us ? 👀

PBnJ

Dang Gilmore Girls and the Good place are fighting for that spot 😂

Raquel

Oohh, this vote is getting really close! 😅 Just a thought... what about Gilmore Girls after Charmed, and The Good Place after Friends? The Good Place is much shorter than GG, so once it finishes, there's still time to start another show while GG is still running! Plus, they even make references to a few things that happen in Friends in some episodes! Just an idea... 😅

Stellar

There’s a tie. We should do pretty little liars 🥰 or Bones

Mina E.D

That's also true. I forgot about the references

Nanners

If the Good Place doesn’t win, I hope it will be a contender for a Friends replacement.

SB

For the next round you should add That 70’s Show, Abbott Elementary and Boy Meets World if you want more lighter shows

Joey Tribbiani

I'm a huge Gilmore Girls and The Good Place fan so whichever one that wins, I'm happy. That said, The Good Place is probably a better follow-up for Friends.

Eric Church

boy meets world would be interesting because it would be the first show sofie reacts to where the main kid characters actually grow up i mean don't me wrong one tree hill they all got older age wise but they were full grown from the start nathan's actor was already 18 and the rest were early 20s playing high school kids in boy meets world she'll get to see actual kids grow into young adults.

PBnJ

It’s mainly because other shows get voted out and so those voters have to flock to other shows. That’s what I think

Scarlet.66

Yeah, I kinda came to that conclusion when I read the comments.😭 But it’s fine. I like Gilmore Girls too. I’m just patiently waiting for the next opportunity for The Good Place to be in the poll again.🔥

Tia

Rooting for the Good Place!

Alexis Vorian

There's only one correct answer, The Good Place.

Alexis Vorian

The good place is just 50 eps long, Gilmore Girls is 173, you could watch TGP and the Gilmore Girls, everybody happy.

Faulty

If those were all her requirements then Gilmore Girls really should win 👍

Elsa Millie

After the poll results I'm suddenly so excited for Charmed to end. No offense Charmed 😁