Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Archaeologist Dr Helen Geake answers questions from Time Team members in this special question and answer episode of the podcast.
You've been wondering how much archaeology there is still to discover in the world, what's lost when a site is backfilled, why long barrows are seeing a resurgence in popularity and which historical fiction writers know their stuff.

There's also Helen's Find where Helen takes an object discovered through archaeology and explains its unique story. You can find the object mentioned in today's episode here.

To get your question featured on a future episode head to the 'chats' section here on Patreon and join the discussion.

Files

Comments

Michael Crouch

I have had a few short stories published although not historical, but if they were I would opt for a kind of window dressing. For example, Victorian London just needs some dark cobbled passageways, a bit of fog, a tavern or two, street urchins, etc. it may not be detailed or even totally accurate but it sets the scene. It is fiction and the story would always come before the historical detail, I think. Non-fiction provides good resource sometimes. I read Katherine Swynford by Alison Weir and it really brought Medieval England to life for me.

Lee Broderick

Fiction - one of my lecturers at undergraduate, Derek Gore, published some novels when he retired. I've never read them, so can't speak to the quality of the writing, but you'd hope the archaeology, at least, is accurate. I have always enjoyed Candace Robb's writing. She's not an archaeologist but does spend a lot of time with archaeologists when researching her fiction, including the York Archaeological Trust for her Owen Archer series.

steve

Despite the probability of things being preserved being low, they do. Waterlogged deposits hold incredible remains. Vindolanda is a treasure trove of Roman military history and so much more. In the right conditions even biological materials can be preserved and have been. You don't know what may be still surviving until you find it.

Cheryl

Thank you for a thoroughly enjoyable podcast. The idea of personal lockers in medieval hospitals has taken my fancy. The lockers of my youth have apparently become history to prevent bombs and drug stashes. Historical anachronisms in today's books and movies can make me howl inside (in laughter or pain). Helen's suggestions are well made. Writers in earlier centuries did not dwell clothing details or how the meals were served. But knowing the historical context which those writers took for granted in their contemporary readers can enrich my understanding of the books. So hooray for the historians writing fiction and available history nonfiction to literally put us in their place in time! And the lovely rabbit holes I can fall into finding authentic research. And thank you to my university for giving alums free access to proper research books and documents.

Gareth Tovey

Patrick O’Brian’s Aubrey/Maturin naval fiction series is highly regarded for its accuracy as well as its characters.

Fiona D

These Q&A episodes are just brilliant. Please go for as many bonus episodes as you can manage. The answers/discussions go off in such unexpected and fascinating directions.

Peter Farrington

Regarding authors writing about the past you mentioned Bernard Cornwall, one of his books was called 'Stonehenge' which covered a possible reason and process of the construction of the monument on Salisbury plain, it is a very interesting read and his story is very plausible.

Elisabeth

Thoroughly enjoyable! Thank you!

Janette Menhennet

I do write historical fiction and for me, at least, the story never comes first. it is a delicate balance. I fictionalise the locations, so for instance, the town may be remarkably like a real town but the people, businesses, and small historical details differ. What to me is important to get right is the nature of the town and society. I once spent a night (or two) trawling through photos to confirm that a cheap bedsit in London in the 50s would probably not have central heating. that character then goes off to live in a country that does not exist. Again however it has the characteristics of the general location.

Michael Crouch

That’s interesting to know. If I were writing something in recent history or living memory then I would aim to be more historically accurate than say, the Anglo-Saxon era, where so many unknowns allow for a bit more invention. For me it would generally be about getting the feel and atmosphere of the era right. It raises some complicated ideas. I shall probably stick to reading history and writing contemporary stories.

Kerie Receveur

Lindsey Davis, George MacDonald Fraser and Dorothy Dunnett.

Kerie Receveur

I find the sneering tone in which Christianity is mentioned upsetting.

Elaine P

Dorothy Dunnett is brilliant, thrilled to see another person who knows her work.

Elaine P

Adding to the great authors others have listed, Ellis Peters/Edith Pargeter brings Medieval England and Wales to life for me, and her prose is almost poetry. And Georgette Heyer, though unfortunately known as just a romance novelist, was a serious and skilled historian, and wrote several historical novels, dying before she could finish her opus on the Duke of Bedford - she evokes the Medieval world as skillfully as she does the Regency.

Pauline

Luckily for me my local library had her full works some 60 years ago when I was in my teens.