Chapter 58 - Trial and Error [KoT] (Patreon)
Content
The list of things that might have gone wrong with my first healing draught ran to two full pages.
I wrote it in the Reading Room that first night, at the desk under the green lamp, in neat Japanese. Every possible mistake I could think of. Every step in chapter six I might have done slightly differently from how it should have been done.
The water. I'd used water from the pump. Was it pure enough?
The heat. At the heat of a hand held long in it. I'd tested it with my hand. But how long was long? How hot was too hot?
The herbs. Bruised, not crushed. Too much? Too little?
The glimmerroot. Thin as paper. Thin enough?
The stirring. The pattern. The rune. Had I drawn it correctly?
The binding. The thread of mana. Steady? Strong enough? Too strong?
The straining. Muslin from an old dust sheet. Fine enough?
The settling. A cool, dark place. The storeroom beside the kitchen. Cool enough?
The bottle. Clean glass. Clean enough?
I looked at the list for a long time.
Then I did something I hadn't done since my first life, since a high school chemistry class I'd found tedious and pointless at the time.
I designed an experiment.
Change one thing at a time, my chemistry teacher used to say. Mr. Hayashi, a tired, kind man with chalk dust on his sleeves. If you change two things and the result changes, how will you know which one did it? Change one thing. Keep everything else exactly the same. Then you'll know.
At sixteen, I'd thought it was obvious. Boring.
At seven, kneeling on the floor of the annex kitchen in front of a row of my great-grandmother's bottles, I thought it was the wisest thing anyone had ever told me.
So that's what I did. One thing at a time.
The water first.
I'd suspected the water from the start. The pump in the yard was old, its pipe was iron, and in summer, when the water ran low, it sometimes came out with a faint orange tinge, especially first thing in the morning. Berta used to let it run a while before filling the kettle.
I tested it. I boiled a pot of pump water until it was gone, the way you'd reduce a sauce. When I looked into the bottom of the empty pot, there was a thin, rusty-orange crust, like a ring in a bathtub. When I scraped it with a fingernail it came away gritty.
Iron. And other things too, probably, that I couldn't see.
Pure water, chapter six said. Not water from the pump.
So I tried rainwater. On the next rainy day I set out every clean bowl and pot I owned in the garden, collected it, and poured it carefully into a big clean jar.
Then I remembered something else. From Earth. A summer camp when I was eleven, where a counselor had shown us how to make a water filter out of a plastic bottle, sand, gravel, and charcoal from the campfire. I hadn't thought about it in twenty years.
I made one. Not from a plastic bottle, of course. From a cracked earthenware pot out of the storeroom, with a hole in its base, packed with a layer of clean gravel from the stream, then fine sand, then crushed charcoal from the stove, then more sand. I poured the rainwater through it and caught it in a clean jar beneath.
It came out sparkling.
Attempt Two used filtered rainwater. Everything else exactly as before.
It was less cloudy. Not clear. But definitely less cloudy. And the sediment at the bottom in the morning was thinner.
Water: improved, I wrote that night. Not the whole problem. But part of it.
The heat next.
This was where I ran into trouble.
For Attempt Three, I steeped the herbs a little hotter to see what would happen. The draught boiled over while I was slicing the glimmerroot, and a great gout of pink foam surged out of the pot, over the stove, and onto the floor, hissing and spitting. Some of it hit the ceiling.
There was a pink stain on the kitchen ceiling for the rest of the time I lived in that annex.
For Attempt Four, I steeped them cooler. The draught came out very weak and very green and hardly smelled of anything.
Attempt Five was the explosion.
I'm still not entirely sure what happened. I'd steeped the herbs at what I thought was the right heat, strained them, brought the liquor to a simmer, added the glimmerroot, and put the lid on the pot while I fetched a clean spoon from the drawer. Just for a moment. To keep the heat in.
When I turned around, the lid was trembling. Rattling against the rim. And a thin, high whistle was coming from underneath it, like a kettle, only stranger. Higher. Almost musical.
I took one step toward the stove.
The lid blew off.
It went straight up, spinning, with a bang like a slammed door, hit the ceiling beside the pink stain, and came down again on the far side of the kitchen with a clang that left a dent in the plaster of the wall. Out of the pot rolled a great puff of rosy pink smoke that crossed the kitchen and swallowed me whole.
When it cleared, I was standing in the middle of the kitchen coughing, eyes streaming, face tingling. My eyebrows felt strange. I put my hand up to them. They were crisp. Singed at the ends. The whole kitchen smelled of burnt hair and sweet rot.
The draught was gone. Boiled away entirely, leaving a sticky pink crust welded to the bottom of the pot.
I stood there a moment, coughing, ears ringing.
Then I started to laugh. I couldn't help it. I stood in the middle of the pink, smoky kitchen with my singed eyebrows and laughed until I had to sit down on the floor.
When I finally got up to open the window and let the smoke out, I looked across the lawn, past the thorns on the east wall, toward the main house.
At the second-floor window near the corner there was a small golden head pressed to the glass. And beside it, a tall grey one, with both hands over its mouth.
I could see Isolde laughing, even from that distance. Bouncing on whatever she was standing on, pointing at the pink smoke still drifting from the annex chimney.
Behind her, Berta was slowly shaking her head, the way she used to when I came in from the garden covered in mud.
I waved, a little sheepishly.
Isolde waved back with both hands.
Glimmerroot, I wrote that night in my notes, must not be heated in a closed vessel. It releases mana as it binds, and the mana must have somewhere to go. Never cover the pot.
And underneath, smaller: Check eyebrows.
I worked out the heat eventually. It came, of all places, from tea.
Japanese tea. Green tea. My grandmother used to make it every afternoon in her little house in the countryside, and she always let the water cool a while after it boiled before pouring it over the leaves. I asked her why once, when I was eight or nine. If the water was too hot, she'd said, it burned the leaves. Made the tea bitter. You had to be gentle with it. Coax out the sweetness. Don't force it.
I sat in the Reading Room with chapter six open in front of me and thought about my grandmother's teapot.
At the heat of a hand held long in it.
Not boiling. Not close. Warm. Warm enough that you could hold your hand in it a long time and it would feel pleasantly hot but not hurt. My grandmother's green-tea temperature. Gentle. Coaxing.
I'd been steeping the herbs much too hot. Pulling out the bitterness along with the virtues. That was the smell, I realized. That terrible, earthy, pond-bottom bitterness. I'd been cooking the silverleaf, not steeping it.
For Attempt Eight, I let the water cool until I could hold my hand in it while I counted to a hundred. Then I steeped the herbs.
The liquor came out a pale, clear green and smelled sharp and clean and bright, like freshly crushed silverleaf on a spring morning. Not bitter at all.
Heat, I wrote. Much lower than I thought. Grandmother's tea.
The stirring took longest.
I'd been following the diagram in chapter six exactly. Round and round, clockwise. Then the sharp turn. Then round the other way. Then the long sweeping curve through the middle. Every time the same. And every time I'd felt that faint honey-thick resistance in the spoon that told me the binding was taking hold.
But it never felt smooth. There was always a moment, right at the sharp turn, where the resistance jerked. Snagged. Like a thread catching on a splinter, and the spoon would twitch in my fingers.
I'd assumed that was simply how it felt. That the turn was meant to be difficult.
Then one night in the Reading Room, holding the page very close to the green lamp and studying the diagram for the hundredth time, I saw something I'd never noticed.
In the margin beside the sharp turn there was a mark. So faint I'd taken it for a smudge, or a flaw in the paper. A tiny pencil arrow pointing the opposite way from the printed one.
And beside it, smaller still, in that quick, sharp, leaning hand:
Arrow three is backwards. In every printed copy I have ever seen. Counter-sunwise at the turn, or the binding fights itself.
—O.
I sat very still.
Then I looked at the diagram again. Not as a stirring pattern. As a rune. The whole woven shape, gather, bind, awaken, hold. And I traced the turn the way O's arrow said. Counter-sunwise.
It made sense. It made perfect sense. With the printed arrow, the line through the turn crossed back over itself in the wrong place, and the rune for bind came out twisted, like a knot tied backwards. It still worked, mostly. It still bound. But it fought itself at that one point, and some of the mana leaked away.
Another copying error. Like the Kindle chant. Like Garrett's fire spell. Someone, somewhere, centuries ago, had drawn arrow three backwards, and every alchemist since had faithfully copied it and stirred their draughts with a twist in them, and never known.
I laughed out loud, alone in the Reading Room. "Thank you, O," I told the margin. "Whoever you are."
For Attempt Eleven, I stirred it O's way.
And the resistance in the spoon was smooth. All the way through. No snag at the turn. Just a steady, even, honey-thick pull, round and round and through, like drawing a pen across good paper. And I felt the binding take hold. Really felt it. Not as instinct, the way a craftsman would, but as understanding. The rune completing itself in the liquid, line by line, as I drew it.
The glimmerroot slices went clear faster than ever. The rosy color spread through the draught in a smooth, even wave.
In the morning, after settling, it was nearly clear.
Nearly. I held it up to the kitchen window, and there was still the faintest haze, like breath on glass just beginning to fade. And at the very bottom, a few tiny grains of sediment.
But the color. The color was right. A faint rosy hue, like watered wine.
I made a small cut on the back of my hand and let one drop of Attempt Eleven fall onto it.
It stung. Then, as I watched, the bleeding stopped almost at once. Over the next hour the edges of the cut drew together, sealed, and faded to a thin pink line.
An hour. Not days. An hour.
That night in the Reading Room, I looked over my notes.
Two weeks. Eleven attempts. A pink stain on the ceiling. A dent in the kitchen wall where the pot lid had hit it. Singed eyebrows only just growing back, the new hairs prickly when I rubbed them. And twenty-two pages of notes in neat Japanese, every change recorded, every result.
Water: filtered rainwater.
Heat: grandmother's tea. Count to a hundred with the hand in it.
Glimmerroot: thin as paper. Thinner. Never cover the pot.
Stirring: O's way. Counter-sunwise at the turn.
Mana: a steady thread. Like inscription. Never let it waver.
Each had made it better. Each had brought it closer.
But it still wasn't clear. Not perfectly. Not the way chapter six described.
And I didn't know why.
I took out the library card and looked at it for what felt like the thousandth time.
Volumes Comprehended: 47 / 48
I put it back.
Then I sat in the armchair by the window, under my Library apple tree with its ripe red apple glowing at the end of its branch, and read chapter six again. Every word. Slowly. Looking for whatever I'd missed.
It was near the end. In the paragraph about the binding. A sentence I'd read a hundred times without really thinking about it.
Stir, in the pattern given below, while holding in the mind the intention of healing.
The intention of healing.
I'd held that intention every time. As clearly as I could. Healing.
But what did that mean?
I sat back and looked out at the apple, glowing in the gold light, and thought about it. And slowly, the way the meaning of the first rune had come to me years ago, after I first felt my own wellspring, I began to understand.