Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

On the current site, each user's page can hold about 20 comments before old ones are automatically deleted. This is because when I made the site 12 years ago, I had no idea what I was doing. 😅

Now I'm a lot more experienced and it would be very easy to make comments permanent in the site remake. From a programming perspective, it's actually the default. But is that what we want? In this era of endless data collection, I've grown kinda fond of the Backloggery's more ethereal comment style.  

But it's also rather unexpected behavior for a comment system and I know some people wish comments didn't vanish once they're bumped of the page. Sounds like a good time for a poll! 


A few general words about polls:  

Poll results are not binding. Things change. Not all ideas pan out. Technical limitations happen. That said, I'll do my best to let poll results guide my decisions, especially when they show a strong consensus.  I make them when I'm not sure what to do after all.

Assume your vote is deciding the default setting.  Feedback like "Why not make it an option?" tends to not be very helpful. Everyone likes options, but making alternatives for every aspect of the site just isn't practical. That said, some options will happen. I just want to focus on getting the remake finished first.

Comments

MDarkness

There is certainly valuable community history that has been lost due to the current practices, including in relation to people that are not a part of the site anymore. I think that comments should remain unless manually deleted, but a full wipe should be made easy, in case the person wants it all to go away for one reason or another.

T. J. F.

I’d say default to permanent (man, I wish GameFAQs still had all the threads from 20+ years ago when I was super active), but maybe a setting per profile to purge after certain times.