Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

It's been a while since the last poll, so here's one I've been thinking about for a while now. I'm guessing this one might be pretty divisive but we'll see.

One of the things that most distinguishes the Backloggery from other collection sites is the among of personalization users can have on their pages. When you visit someone's page, you can instantly get a feel for at least one aspect of their personality. And custom banners are probably the largest factor in that.  They're also frequently huge, take up a lot of screen space, and as the site becomes more mobile-friendly they could also needlessly use up people's data. 

There are various ways I could address this issue (enforce a height and file size limits, which will probably happen regardless of poll results) but the one I've thought about most is removing the banner altogether for a smaller, less-obtrusive "card" image instead.

I've whipped up a sample image showing each as they would be seen when viewing a user's list of games.

Banner



Card

The banner gives more room to express yourself, but the card is less obtrusive resulting in less needless scrolling. 

What say you, Backloggery?

About Polls:  

Assume your vote is deciding the default setting.  Everyone likes options, but making alternatives for every aspect of the site just isn't practical. That said, some options will happen. I just want to focus on getting the remake finished first.

Poll results are not binding. Things change. Not all ideas pan out. Technical limitations happen. That said, I'll do my best to let poll results guide my decisions, especially when they show a strong consensus. I make them when I'm not sure what to do after all. 

Files

Previews only

Comments

axemtitanium

Not feeling the card at all. I like the current banners. Are people visiting Backloggery on mobile so much that loading a banner will eat up all their data? Feels like a solution in search of a problem.

Camm

While those voting "banner" are the minority, they seem to feel a lot more strongly about it. I get the sense that those voting "card" simply see the banner as a minor inconvenience, whereas those voting "banner" see the card as losing a not insignificant part of the site. I worry that those voting "card" don't realize that 1) the banner would likely only appear on the main page, and 2) its size will be limited (I assume). I've been hearing "People post huge banners which annoys me". Okay, does that require their complete removal? The card feels more like a second avatar, rather than the theme of the page. 'Loggers have done some creative things with the banner, like those fun "games to beat" visual maps, linking them to the small community events here and there, which they can't do with the card. There's also usability. With the banners, all you need to do is resize an image to ~776 x ~300 (current size, subject to change obviously) and drop it in, without giving much thought to how it might appear in a small space. I know that a lot of images I've used would look strange plopped into the "card" space as-is without at least some cropping. All of that said, I wouldn't mind seeing an example of the card on the main page. Perhaps a compromise: Banner on the main page, card everywhere else? If it must be one or the other, a limited banner (particularly on verticality) would likely satisfy most.