Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello folks! I've got a blog post of a rare sort for you today.

Remember in my big Mythic Bastionland review I made some criticisms about combat balance and structure? Afterwards, designer Chris McDowell made an appearance in the Quinns Quest Discord server in which he was replying to my criticisms, saying things that were altogether too intelligent and generally running the risk of making me look like a cloddish simpleton. So I decided to ask if he'd like to join me for a longer, conversational back-and-forth about the whole affair.

My hope is that this will be a valuable resource for folks playing Mythic Bastionland, or just running TTRPG combat in general. Also, because it's only fair that I give Chris the option of sharing this post with his community, too, I've made the decision to make this the first blog post on Quinns Quest that's open to the public.

Let's GO!

Quinns: Hi Chris! Thanks for agreeing to this conversation. You’re the best. 

Let me start by paraphrasing the criticism I made in my review. In the video I explained, at length, that I love the combat system in Mythic Bastionland. You give players so many interesting options regarding how to fight tactically, or riskily, or just express themselves. Also, I didn’t mention this in the review, but I love how you honour dice in the system. Everyone get to roll a lot of dice, but it’s never... self-indulgent? Each roll always has heft and drama.

So on the one hand, you’ve designed the best combat system that I’ve ever encountered on Quinns Quest, and I’d love to hear more about your design process.

But in my review I went on to say that I wished your game’s minimalist ruleset had just one more page on how to design and structure these combats. Because what I found during my campaign is that by itself, a great set of combat rules doesn’t make for great combat. Instead, our fights were only truly fantastic when they had a great context that elevated the fight beyond two sets of stat-blocks lining up against one another.

That context could be the story behind the fight, or the stakes, or the environment, or sub-objectives, or... what else am I forgetting, I wonder?

Chris: Sure, I get that! Because the game leans heavily into high-player-agency sandbox play it can be tricky to anticipate where, when, or even if a fight is going to take place. If the players are dealing with the Wyvern Myth then there’s a good chance they’ll fight “that foul twisted reptile” at some point, but the objective of the fight and the battlefield situation depend on a context that is developed through play. As with other parts of the system, this is going to call for some Referee improvisation! The Combat page in the Spark Tables section can help here, (see pic below) but I also think that the combat itself doesn’t need to carry all the weight of responsibility. 

A motif of Old School Revival-style play is often that combat should be about whether you fight, rather than how you fight.

That might sound obvious, but it’s easy to fall into the trap of thinking all monsters exist to be fought, and are balanced around being an entertaining, but reliably defeatable, challenge. I like to focus on the buildup and aftermath of the fight as much as the turn-by-turn sword swinging. Going back to the Wyvern example, I’m thinking of the knights learning the creature’s weaknesses from a Seer, hunting down its nest with a local guide, and setting up an ambush to kill it while it sleeps. The tactical play of how that fight actually happens sits alongside those elements as equals, to me, so the combat is designed to be resolved pretty swiftly when it happens.

As you pointed out in the review, this can lead to moments where well-prepared knights make short work of a big scary monster, but I’m not really looking for lengthy set-piece boss battles. The slaying of the dragon is only as important as the quest to get there, the decision to fight, and the glory received afterwards.

With that in mind, I touch on the idea of Dynamic Combat a little in the Oddpocrypha section, but for those looking to wallow in the tactical side of things a little more I’d recommend checking out Index Card RPG which has a load of great advice for making interesting combat scenarios. Oh, and watch my blog, because all this has spurred me on to start drafting a post with a few extra combat tricks you can bring in to spice up an otherwise straightforward encounter. [Editor's note: That post has since been published and can be found here.]

Quinns: Yes. I know we’re both fans of the section on combat in comedically avant-garde adventure - and amazing read - Silent Titans, which I’ll post below.

To be clear, this is an inexplicably grounded set of tips published inside the Silent Titans adventure, which outside of this little strip of practical advice is so unhinged as to be almost unplayable.

I feel like I need to print out all of these little sets of combat tips from different games to have nearby when I’m GMing... but also, I know how I GM, and I feel like I’d never take the time to look at them mid-game. Maybe I need to blu-tack them to my bathroom mirror so I read them when I’m cleaning my teeth, or something.

It occurs to me that maybe combat in TTRPGs really benefits from things like “fighting next to objects with stored kinetic energy” or “having sub-objectives like keeping an NPC safe” because fundamentally, the inescapable thing in TTRPG combat is that any given player spends most of their time waiting. You’re waiting for other players to make their decisions, for the GM to make rulings, for numbers to be crunched. So a combat needs to have so many layers for players to think about when it’s not their turn.

Anyway, okay, I agree with you- the lead up to the fight in Mythic Bastionland should be considered part of the fight itself. The way you designed the Myths mean that players catch all of these ominous glimpses of the being threatening the realm before they draw their swords, and my players and I definitely had fun with that.

On the subject, while I was running Mythic Bastionland I was also fetishistic about how, in real life, it was a serious effort for medieval warriors to get into their armour, string their bows, keep their blades sharp and so on, so I made sure to have plenty of roleplaying and tactical complications whenever my players did the busywork of transforming themselves into killing machines in a hurry. Just as you, Chris, designed a game where unwieldy weapons are terrible in corridors, I had lots of fun attacking my players in the middle of the night when they were in their tents with only a dagger to hand, or creating complications after my players told me that their larger weapons were being carried by their squires.

But I do want to talk about combat balance a little bit. Sure, the build up to a fight can be just as exciting as the fight itself, and I’m certainly not saying that fights have to be long. Also, I remember one of my players telling me about a year ago that because danger mostly exists in the players’ imagination, a fight where the players steamroll their opponents might feel like a failure to the GM and at the same time feel like a glorious victory to the players.

All the same, the fights in my campaign of Mythic which felt truly amazing did all have some real jeopardy to them, with players triumphing over an enemy after first fearing for their lives. And as I say in my review, Mythic Bastionland simply doesn’t seem interested in balancing the strength of enemies to the strength of players.

Do you have any advice for GMs trying to balance combat? Do you truly not think it’s particularly interesting? Or are you so practiced as a GM that on some instinctive level you can do it without thinking?

Chris: The type of combat that gets me excited doesn’t really focus on balance in terms of creating an even fight that’s nudged generously in favour of the players. Of course a matched contest can be fun, and they do exist in this game, but I like playing in a world that embraces the mismatched fights in the same way.

You’re right about Mythic, though, a well-rested group of Knights can make short work of many of their opponents when push comes to shove.

For my previous games, Into the Odd and Electric Bastionland (see below), the characters are generally a bunch of losers who get in over their heads, and you can easily run into situations where some monstrosity eats half of the group in a single combat.

In those games it’s meant to encourage outside-the-box strategies or finding a way to avoid the fight altogether. For Mythic it’s a different proposition. Of course I want the Knights to face adversity, but it also felt like an opportunity to gift players that feeling of power, where the Knights can be at times like an unstoppable force (see below, again).

There’s a passage that describes how Knights live between two worlds: one of rank, oath, and rule of the worthy, the other of chaos, brutality, and rule of the strong. Giving the Knights a lot of raw martial prowess really lets the players explore that and hopefully begin to consider their place in the world. 

A nice side-effect of all this is that as the Knights grow in Glory they’re going to get more involved in court and inter-realm politics, where crises aren’t so easily solved just by spilling enough blood. Make them long for the days when their biggest problem was riding out to stab an Ogre!

For those looking to increase the deadliness of enemies, creating a world with even more bite, I think there are a few options. The most straightforward would be to allow more of the strange creatures found in Myths to use Feats as if they were a Knight. 

Quinns: Okay then, last question. It’s a bit more philosophical, I’m afraid, but I’m sure you can hack it.

Combat obviously plays a large role in the TTRPG community because roleplaying grew (and still grows to this day) out of the popularity of D&D, which was originally a wargame and today that’s still a big part of the brand.

In 2008 we even saw D&D 4th edition try and return to these roots, with grid-based combat and an rigid framework for balancing encounters, as if this was a videogame. But then alongside this, in the last forty years we’ve seen generations of RPG designers who have successfully uncoupled their TTRPGs from any combat of any kind.

Alongside this, I can’t help but see you, Chris - alongside large parts of the old-school revival community - as a bit of enigma? Mythic Bastionland has this profoundly intelligent and well-thought through combat system... but you also just told me that you’d take joy in a table full of players becoming regents and transitioning away from even using it.

What is combat in TTRPGs, to you? It’s like you couldn’t imagine designing a game that doesn’t have fighting at the heart of the rulebook, while at the same time you don’t want it front and centre of the stories you tell. It feels like you’re excited by it and bored by it at the same time!

Chris: It’s interesting to look at that connection to wargames. In those very first experimental wargames that pushed into what we’d recognise as an RPG, such as Braunstein, players immediately began to explore the space outside of combat. You had players who were civilians, but reports note just how much players wanted to talk things through with other characters, all while pursuing their own objectives. It’s like RPGs grew out of wargames, but couldn’t wait to explore the non-war elements of play!

I don’t for a minute expect anybody to pick up Mythic Bastionland and then avoid the combat system entirely, but I like the idea of a campaign that changes over its course. Zero-to-hero isn’t that interesting to me but warrior-knight to general-knight to monarch-knight to dead-knight feels much more exciting, while still giving the players plenty of other paths they could follow. It nudges things in a certain way so that session 5 of your campaign feels different to session 15 and session 50. 

It’s the same as how travelling in Winter is really bad in this game, so players will often use that season to hunker down and deal with in-house problems, rather than wandering the wilderness like normal. I like those changes of pace to occur in a way that feels true to the world. 

But am I bored by combat? In many games, yes! I often joke that 99% of my game design comes out being impatient. Rolling a character? Make it faster. Rolling to hit? Get outta here! Monster stat blocks? Arghh just give me the gist of it. I think we’ve all been in those sessions where you notice that two hours have passed and you haven’t really done anything. That’s what I’m always trying to avoid. 

I’m also not precious about my little subsystems. I love how combat turned out but there’s so much more to the game than that.

It’s a cliche, but I think of it like a toolbox. Perhaps those older knights use the mass combat system more, perhaps they get really involved with managing crises in their domain and building great projects, or perhaps the group reaches a point where they’re hardly using the rules at all, and just resolving things with conversation and the odd luck roll. Each table’s game of Mythic Bastionland is going to be different, which is why I think tone-setting and referee guidance are just as important as getting all the mechanical cogs to spin a certain way.

Quinns: Amazing. Thanks so much, Chris.

Chris: No worries, thanks for the chat!

Files

Comments

Roger Leroux

Definitely an interesting take on the necessity (or lack thereof) of combat in an RPG. I personally agree with Chris that I lack patience with how long a fight can take place. A recent D&D style session was only a partial battle as we got through thirteen (!!) rounds of a fight and will be resuming next session.

Jethro

When I read the book I took all the specifics like "here's how a shield wall works" as a menu of options to choose from when PCs did something unexpected and strange.

Ethan Cordray

So much great advice in this! What a useful perspective for me, to consider what combat actually *does* in a game narratively, and how the form of that combat can express the thematic and character-development aspects of a game's story. Thank you so much for sharing this interview!

Todd Christiansen

I just knew Silent Titans would come up in this discussion. I finally got to run the first dungeon as a one-shot. Still want to run the whole campaign sometime. Thanks Quinns and Chris!

Spencer St. James

Chris talking about players wanting to deviate from the war game roots just makes me think of exalted, an RPG I generally love, that is extremely focused on physical combat to the detriment of most of its non-combat abilities. I get his point where some of the best drama and character-centric moments don't happen when you're waiting for a bunch of numbers to coalesce on someone else's turn, so I've put a lot of value into games who take everything besides combat just as seriously as the rules for stabbing each other

Ads

I'm going to say this out loud: it's weird that there is so much focus on combat. Yeah, sure, arguably, like Sean McCoy says, it's the things that you don't construct elaborate rules for that are the most interesting, but.... if you establish elaborate rules, especially in a game about walking tanks, then ofc people will think those rules are what the game is about. I've been grappling with exactly this issue in the discord wrt Electric Bastionland. Rules as written, combat seems like a key structural element, but looking at the art and reading between the lines it feels like a game about angst and failure and absurdity and wonder. I wish its rules supported those things instead of pointing me towards a fight.

Ads

I should add that I deeply understand the OSR impulse. I played that way for many years. I also think that the rules these games have are brilliant, and wonderfully flexible. I'm only questioning why we start with fighting in a game like EBL which feels like it wants to do lots of other things before it goes anywhere near violence

Patrick Clemer Alfarth

Chris’ blogposts are so insightful and helpful for running a game of Mythic Bastionland that I question if they shouldn’t have been part of the book to begin with. Of course hindsight is 20/20, but I feel like it would’ve been great to have those tips and ideas, or a version of them, in the core material.

The Abstract Gas of Abscess Pass

I love Chris's sentiment that the balance isn't the the fully load-bearing part of combat. Its the narrative around it. And its hard to make balanced combat while allowing the lead up and fallout of the combat to shine.

Nicholas Caldwell

Agreed. I bought the game based on this review, but I have the same feeling as when I bought In Nomine ages ago - it's beautiful and thought provoking but how do I run it? At least Quinns pointed this out in the review so I was prepared for it.

Echo Tango

This is why I really liked reading through Wildsea's rules, the player species and roles, and monsters. Sure, there's combat, but your skills are also your HP, and you could damage them in non-combat too. Plus all of the monsters' body-parts which get used for...crafting, magic and trading? Heart similarly seems to take its non-combat seriously. I don't think I'll ever get enough pals' calendars to align for Wildsea or Heart - they seem complex enough to take at least 2-5 sessions to get comfortable with the rules *and* finish a story. But I've got my rules-light game system for one-shots, which will be enough for now. ^^;

Echo Tango

:) I'm a fan of rules-light combat nowadays. Even with players who decide what they'll do while waiting for their turns, DnD-style combat always ends up with too many dice, math, or looking up rules for it to flow smoothly and quickly. I still like maps because I'm a visual person, and struggle with theatre-of-the-mind, but it's so nice to just say "my guy continues running from last turn, so he should make it to this wall before hitting the dirt" or "I think I can only get to this tree instead of that farther wall, because my leg's injured".

Roger Leroux

Same. The constant micro-arithmetic finally made me snap and stop playing D&D/Pathfinder.

Barnaby McArthur

This conversation has really made me think about the amount of focus (at least in my D&D YouTube sphere) that is put on balancing combat and in turn the pressure it puts on the GM/myself to have perfect combats. Pressure to balance or pressure to add second objectives or both/more. There is a glee that I see in players when they one shot a big bad but unfortunately because I have spent a decent chunk of prep time creating the combat my glee for them is through gritted teeth. I am happy for them, but I feel that I have waisted time that could of been spent creating something else for them to play with. That flip side however is a 13 round combat slog where things are “too balanced”? Where now I’m frustrated that the players aren’t seeing the cool other stuff I’ve made for them. Reading this and writing this comment has reminded me to have a chat with my players to see how they are liking the combats we play at the moment, and ask them what they want to see from them. Anyway! Starting a Bastionland campaign next week. Quinn’s, you”re coverage on all these games is insightful and inspiring and Chris it is a treat to hear about your game and it’s design. Can’t wait to start playing!

Ads

Definitely head to Chris's blog and YouTube channel if you haven't already. They're heaving with instructional advice

Baulderstone

Balancing combat eats away at player agency. Any game where the combat arose out of the players' actions is going to sometimes result in fights that are either a walkover or highly dangerous to them. When the GM worries about balancing every fight, it doesn't really matter how reckless or cautious the players were. They always get a "fair" fight. Rather than worrying about balance, the GM should concern themselves with whether the opposition makes sense based on what led to the fight. Keep in mind too that the wargaming scene D&D grew out of wasn't always concerned with chess-like balance in games. Often you played out mis-matched historical battles simply to see how it could have happened differently.

woahdomino

This was a really neat read! Out of curiosity, what do others really enjoy about a combat system? I'm increasingly finding I don't enjoy a lot of the mechanics surrounding that part of ttrpgs.

Ads

Is the question of balancing the combat or not missing the point here? Isn't the concern more that sometimes - when you're playing a game with knights and monsters - you want the fight to be the thing? I mean, *why wouldn't you want that*? Why should the stuff that happens around the fight - the decision to fight and the subsequent glory or whatever - matter more? Sure, it can be interesting from an emergent storytelling point of view to let the cards fall where they may, but if you've built up a head of dramatic steam and you're all playing dudes with swords and everyone's in the mood for a scrap... as a GM I want to facilitate that. This isn't a philosophical question underpinned by the thought that player agency or storytelling or whatever should be at the heart of a game, it's about having a good time for two hours on a Friday night. I'm not saying gaming philosophies are unimportant, and MBL clearly leans into OSR principles, but I do think that much of the discussion here and elsewhere when this sort of thing comes up has a tendency to lean into the theoretical rather than acknowledging that its good to give the people what they want from time to time, and earned, epic battles are part of that for many, many groups. Whether advice about how to do that needs to be in the rulebook in a day and age of blogs and social media, I dunno, but it can't hurt, especially given that you want the advice to address the specifics of the ruleset under discussion.

Christopher derhodes

I mostly agree. But the issue here isn’t lack balance either way, it’s that the lack of balance is almost always in the players’ favor, often times wildly so. It makes it feel like violence is just such an easy solution without risk or interesting decisions.

Christopher derhodes

I think perhaps the issue is that yeah, there are certainly non-combat solutions to many of the myths, and they may or may not work well depending on what’s tried and if there’s a dice roll involved. When combat is too way easy though, it’s just a very reliable way to address many of the myths, with a high degree of success. A near-certainty. So having combat be too easy actually steers many players towards lots of combat, which it sounds like is the opposite of what Chris wants in the game. I’m with Quinn on this combat could have been better. Part of that is the combat system’s fault and part is the myths’ fault where many epic enemies just can’t stand up to the knights. The Lich for instance is just a guy with a 1d10 weapon that a party of knights can impair. Even if they don’t, 1d10 minus armor (or just plain deny) means the lich is just going to be humiliated by 2-3 knights. And there might be 5 or 6 knights. The book is great but myths feel like they were written for maybe games with only two players in them. Some guidance on playing games with more players would have been really helpful. This game looks great and I might run it this fall. But it does feel like McDowell made a great combat system and then sort of lost interest in it, implying that GMs and players should too.

Paxcow

*Hard* agree, here! Like, ttrpgs are essentially an entire universe of particular niches operating in the shadow of the one IP everyone is familiar with. The best books I've read lean into that, and don't automatically assume whoever is picking it up is already firmly ensconced in the ideology and tropes of whatever particular niche that book is a part of. I feel like a lot of OSR stuff that I've read at least implicitly assumes you're already steeped in at least some OSR, or the particular principles OSR seems to vibe with. Or, the book just assumes by virtue of how cleverly and dynamically it's arranged, simply coming into contact with its mechanics in play at all will cause spontaneous moments of satori which will cause everyone to get it without the book needing to explain anything to them. That's a bummer, because there's some really neat stuff out there that I think would really take off if there was just a pinch more scaffolding in there for new people(especially GMs!). I got *super* excited about GUN when I first read it, but then just found myself feeling compelled to do all of this extra work on the back-end to be able to get it to a form to where my players(who don't obsessively read ttrpg books as much as their GM does XD ) could get *why* this game is so neat.

Ads

It's funny, my sister initially found the OSR quite off putting as a result of all the tacit assumptions about rules and principles of play. In addition, iirc she experienced the ubiquitous minimalist style as exclusive and a little macho. Incidentally, I've just read and great blog post over on the Indie Game Reading Club about the ways in which story game culture is exclusive. Frankly, I don't think the writer went far enough, but their overall point that the foregrounding of excellence across all domains is stressful and exhausting struck a chord with me. Anyway, my substantive point is that the quirks of our play cultures and philosophies should be highlighted when we're in their presence because, while there are many great things about said cultures and philosophies, they sometimes get in the way of fun. To me that's what the discussion above boils down to: Chris tacitly expressing a desire to cleave to high player agency, emergent storytelling and, in relation to combat's place in MBL, a view that rules should not dictate the kind of game you play. A kind of poststructrual approach. And Quinns just wanting some help making the cool bit be cool. Assuming I've read that correctly, I have an awful lot of interest in and respect for Chris's position - I genuinely think he's one of the great game designers, and I'm excited to buy everything he makes - but there's a sense in which it feels more ideological than pragmatic.

Randall

Does anyone have a higher-res version of the page from Silent Titans? The bits that I can make out look like incredible advice, but it's quite difficult to parse with the resolution of the photo.

Garrison Gondek

Chris's paragraph about impatience explains a lot about his games, and also a lot about why I'm really enamored with how his games are designed these days. I especially love not rolling to hit--everything about that just sings to me. I can definitely sympathize with people wanting more structure and direction in terms of combat balance or how Myths might be resolved, but I also think that the open space is something really fun. I also love the idea that what the campaign is about will shift over time, reaching a point where the days of solving everything with a fight are a nostalgic memory (this also feels very Arthurian!). To me, the presence of a combat system, even a well-designed one, doesn't necessarily mean that a game is *about* combat, or that combat is its main thing. I like to think of a lot of the content in the Bastionland books as nucleation points for imagination, and they really do get my imagination going.

Josh Rodell

I remember Brennan Lee Mulligan talking at some point about the idea that the reason he needs to be able to rely on good solid combat rules in an RPG isn't because combat is the most important part of the story, its because its the part of the narrative that he can't satisfyingly provide himself. I've not played Mythic Bastionland, so I don't want to come off like I'm commenting on anything specific, and I also don't want to seem like I'm trying to argue with Chris, but to me, a "combat encounter", or any other part of a story that's got fighting in it, is more interesting if more interesting things happen in the fight. A fight that's operating in only one dimension (hit each other until one of you dies) has a lower ceiling on how interesting it is, regardless of what narrative flavour is attached to it.

Josh Rodell

At this point, I find myself judging any system that has Rolling to Hit. Its an anti-fun mechanic with no reason to exist other than legacy.

Garrison Gondek

I don't even think Chris would disagree, really. I think the idea of having a shifting battlefield, other objectives and things going on, etc. is really harmonious with OSR-style combat design, which also emphasizes players thinking outside of the box to get an advantage. There's another TTRPG called Strike! (which is not OSR, it's heavily inspired by D&D 4e) that actually codifies this in the rules: in Strike!, a combat encounter MUST have a specific objective or goal, and that goal cannot be "defeat all the enemies" or "defeat the boss." I always really liked that about it. (Incidentally I have some real problems with that Brennan Lee Mulligan quote, because I think he really discounts the way rules in a well-designed TTRPG can *build* narrative rather than either forcing you down a path or getting in the way of a story. And not just in the PbtA/"storygame" sense which is I think is probably what he's imagining when he talks about "narrative rules.")

Quinns Quest

Yeah, I agree with Garrison here. Brennan is such a phenomenal improviser that I think if he were to run a combat using Powered by the Apocalypse mechanics, he could absolutely put together a satisfying fight. I wonder if he's just spent so long in LARP and D&D communities that... maybe he can't imagine it? Though that seems hard to believe. If I'm putting on my tinfoil hat for a second, I also think that he knows that the lengthy combats you see in Actual Play are what he thinks (or knows) his audiences really respond to. But I don't think he could say that publicly.

Quinns Quest

Personally, I think it's more likely that Chris McDowell is just such a great GM that he'd have no problem instinctively tweaking enemies or situations so that scary enemies aren't humiliated. But that's just my theory to put alongside your theory where they'll make a nice matching set.

Quinns Quest

Ah, how interesting to see the highly-specific shield wall rules as an example for how GMs can or should add custom rules depending on the fight. Yeah, I expect Chris would agree with you there.

Quinns Quest

Oh wow. You actually played it! How did it go?

Quinns Quest

Yes, it's interesting and good how in Wildsea (or something like Slugblaster) the game isn't written with an eye to making combat exciting, but making *action* exciting. It brings the game more in line with how TV and movies work, where someone fleeing a fight or steering a ship is given similar prominence to them fighting with a sword.

Quinns Quest

Personal taste and all that, but I think what I want in a combat system is for players to be simultaneously scared enough of fights that they want to try and avoid them, but excited enough by the rules that when combat finally starts, there's an "O shit it's going down" moment.

woahdomino

(No worries if you're busy and can't respond to this) I definitely agree on both takes here but it doesn't quite answer my question. What mechanically within a rules system helps support that vibe for combat?

Randall

You're the best thanks Quinns! It was my birthday on Monday, and my eyesight must be going... Hey while you're here - thanks very much for the direction to the Mystic Arts hexcrawl video in the Mythic Bastionland review. I've been exploring Daði's other videos, and he's very thoughtful about RPGs with lots of helpful videos. I'm strongly considering backing him on Patreon, but I may not have come across his stuff without your pointer to it. I appreciate how you're highlighting smaller creators in the space.

Michael Jones

I find that "Balance" is a misnomer in rpg discussions - a "well balanced combat system" isn't one where every fight is moderately challenging, it's a fight where a really tough fight is really tough, and a somewhat easy one is somewhat easy but still challenging in ways that make it worth the time, and a perfunctory one probably doesn't happen or can be resolved very swiftly. I think what most people are asking for when they talk about a "balanced" system is one where the GM can calibrate the system to the desired effect, but the players still have agency, and can effect the stakes and outcomes.

Shaun Makes

There is definitely a need to be able to tune the expected difficulty of an encounter. Chris has included a whole host of play examples in this book (better and more plentiful than any other RPG book I've read, and some definitely clarify the intent behind many of MB's rules. Probably one scenario that's missing is exactly this. The Referee realizes that the players are in a situation that they had hoped would be more dramatic, or is too difficult. How do you adjust on the fly to maintain the tone and energy of a climactic encounter, or to avoid (or fail forward from) a TPK. Some of the best advice I've seen around this comes from Sly Flourish's blog. But, maybe that's just not in the design intent of an OSR game!

Shaun Makes

This is a really tough question! I love the tactical board-gaminess of Pathfinder 2E, but it also runs way too long, and during combats with too many or too few enemies I lose steam. There have been many times when I'm tempted to handwave the remaining rounds of a combat once it looks too one-sided. I also really love the high danger of something like Delta Green or Frontier Scum, where you have narrow chance of making a split second decision to forgo your action (DG) or lose your hat (FS) to potentially avoid a killing blow. You want to avoid combat at almost all costs, but when you get into it, you need to take advantage of every part of the scene to survive. These are games where the players are constantly asking questions about what is around them they can take advantage of because their on-paper "Abilities" are limited or non-existant, and it leans way more towards a collaborative improv.

Shaun Makes

I think the overarching thing here isn't balance or "secondary objectives," it becomes about combat being about "something." I don't fight the bear because I came across it on a pathway, I fight it to scare it off or to survive, or because I'm trapped and have no other choice. Unless the bear is very hungry it really just wants to scare me off as well. Fights between two humans are almost always likely to be about something other than killing: intimidation, property, ego, frustration. Any of these things are more likely "main objectives" of a combat, but RPG games, especially the Big One, start from a different conceit: that all fighting is to the death, even if you just met a lost goblin in an alley.

TJ Kotzé

The concept of a balanced encounter is tricky because I would argue that Dark Souls is balanced yet many would say it is unfair. Those experienced players even say it is too easy. I think as flexible as peoples opinions are so too is the concept of a balanced encounter, balanced for who, when and where? Because I don't think you can or should balance an encounter for every situation. #ravingsofamadman

Josh Rodell

I'm worried I might have misrepresented BLeeM here. For the record, I interpreted what he was saying (which was in the context of Worlds Beyond Number, which has very minimal combat, not Dimension 20, which is 50% combat) as being not that combat rules aren't important to the narrative, but that the importance that combat has to the narrative is better served by having rules than by being looser.

Todd Christiansen

It went pretty well! Not perfect but that's largely due to me being fairly inexperienced as a GM. Siblings and cousins on a camping trip were forgiving of any mistakes, and they seemed to enjoy the bizarre-ass nature of the dungeon, and engaged with all the fun things.

Cole(M, Bonnema);

"A motif of Old School Revival-style play is often that combat should be about whether you fight, rather than how you fight." This statement has radically altered my perspective on several past systems I've GM'd and I'm heartbroken that I've never heard it before.

Johnathan Holstad

Quinns, I think its awesome youre doing the work youre doing to bridge the imaginary gaps in our community. As an OSR-head who LOVES story games as well (its like comparing steak to ice cream, imho) Im happy youre shining the spotlight on both play cultures. For anyone who is hearing "OSR" for the first time, I really recommend you to check out the Old School Renaissance. Its a community and a movement that produced Mythic Bastionland, and the THEORYCRAFTING that has been done in the game design space of OSR games is more impressive in scope than just about anything else in the hobby tbh.

Johnathan Holstad

You can just play a game that is more combat-centric. 4e, Draw Steel, Lancer, etc. MB is an OSR game, and thats fine. Why shouldn't the fight be the thing? Well, go back and read old arthurian legends. Read the odyssey. Read Conan. Read the legends of Hercules. In the fantasy fiction that inspires the OSR, fights are very much NOT centered. In the Hobbit, for example, Bilbo almost never fights anyone. Sure, fights happen, but combat is reserved for narratively impactful moments. He sneaks around Smaug. He tricks the trolls. He escapes from the goblins. He sneaks past Gollum. When Peter Jackson adapted the Hobbit to film, he added a bunch of cinematic fight scenes and pretty much everyone agrees those movies are... controversial at best and a betrayal at worst. The OSR sings when you treat combat as WAR, and not sport. Remember that Achilles died, but Odysseus lived. Maybe in your group you dont find that fun. Thats fine - my group doesnt find long, drawn out, tactical combat enjoyable. We would rather play a miniatures war game, or a video game for that. MBs refusal to center combat is not (certainly not for my group) a mark against it. It merely means it is not for your group.

Ads

Yeah, I mean, I've been invested to some degree or other in the OSR for the last 12+ years. It brought me back to roleplaying games. I understand and am intimately familiar with the ideas underpinning it, but I still come back to my question: what's wrong with occasionally wanting combat to be the thing in a game that clearly centers tactical combat, at least to some extent (that is, not to the extent of DS)? Part of the reason why I think that's worth asking here is because MB clearly isn't straightforwardly OSR, in that most OSR games provide very limited tactical options within the rules. There's a sense in which *they're not that interested in combat*. I don't think that's the case ina game like MB that leans into gambits and feats. The basis for the concept of tactical infinity is the idea that rules matter less than the creativity of players wrt overcoming violent encounters. But in MB the rules cover off rather a lot more. What Quinns' is asking is how to get the most from said rules when a fight is a climax. What Chris is saying in response is that the fight matters less than everything else, which is kinda fine philosophically, but is unsatisfying in the context of a game that seems to provide a framework for fights that are tactically interesting at least some of the time. I didn't say anything about long, drawn out fights, btw. I love those in Eat the Reich, I'd probably enjoy them in DS (were I to play it, which seems doubtful), but I agree that on the whole you wouldn't want that in MB. I should add that the reason MB appeals to me is it's oneiric, weird mythic quality. I absolutely get why you're sceptical about cinematic fights and suchlike. I'm not sure cinematic fights are what's being asked for. I'm definitely not asking for them!

Alexander

What a fantastic conversation. I've been running two Mythic Bastionland campaigns (making one sandbox for two different parties is so much fun, very different campaigns unfolding!) and I've really leaned into Chris' advice on not worrying about balance. It's been fun to throw creatures in that are true to what they'd be in a fantasy setting and let the players decide if they want to find out just what they can do. The lack of balance seemed to really teach them how to approach the game. They discovered "The Wheel" and did the classic "let's just kill that guy guarding it" and quickly turned tail after he lobbed one of the Knight's heads off. They quickly started to think outside of the box and came up with an ingenious solution. They've also been second thinking rushing in. Saw the Iron Hounds running across the fields and we're like "hell no," haha. I think what's been so incredible is the ownership that the players are developing about their world. I think we've all played games where you drop an adventure hook and everyone's like..."well, I guess we should go do that?" Now they have true choice and I genuinely do not care where they go cause it's all filled with adventure. Can't thank you enough for putting this game on my radar!

Tyro The Fox

Interesting. I feel it depends on the game and intended tale. Which feels wishy-washy and dull to say but it seems appropriate. 'Mythic Bastionland', like many OSR games I have played, has a very laid-back feel to its crunch. "Eh, it'll work out or it won't. Life isn't fair, and you'll be better able to make stories if the game isn't handing you victories left right and centre". You have to think, combat is nasty and weird and is supposed to be a threat. A fight is rising tension. So, to raise the tension, it has to be a possible threat. I do think Quinn's is fair to ask for more details on what a combat should look like because he doesn't want to make something utterly ruinous but its also fair to say that those rules would be functionality house rules. A page saying 'do it however you feel works' would need to be pretty solid work to make that usable. Appropriately, the book doesn't bother and just strips it out because it can be cut, so is cut. Something like 5e or 5.5e D&D seem the opposite. Terrified you'll look elsewhere, it tries to be all things to all men and grow bloated and strained for it. Shackled to key elements it can't get away from while also trying to cater to more roleplay centric elements. Most of D&Ds most useful abilities are combat and exploration ones, as its dungeon delving roots are deeply held. Buuuut, it doesn't stop people trying to smash it into different genres and make things a little messy as it gets rammed in there. Like, D&D feels best when its an action movie. Get to the next point where you can use your super cool powers because that's where the majority of the mechanics went. Make it do a mystery or politics and it can do it but you need to hammer in extra mechanics to track reputation or favours. And have fun if you rolled a Barbarian and now need to debate philosophy of rights when you're best skills are in running, climbing and hitting people. You can do it, but you'd be lapped by the Bard every time. I twbd to strive for a better balance between the action and drama that can lead into it, while still allowing for non-combat solutions to occur. I often have adventures where fights are avoided because the players said the right thing or offered the right parley. 13th Age and Mausritter being great at this for lots of different angles. I enjoy how 13th Age's Background system allows for both creativity and storytelling while also still being pretty straightforward to play with. Your character can play a coward or a bastard or a lone weirdo that licks toads and they can all be useful both in and out of combat. But I also love Mausritter because all stat blocks simply state what the character wants. Nothing more, and allows for a key manner in their motivation that can be interpreted well. Shig the Skunk, from Honey in the Rafters just wants a good meal. Meaning he is not only likely to eat the players but can be potentially convinced to take a quart of cursed honey instead. Bang, easy route to a moment of possible danger avoided in a game that will kill you at any opportunity. And I run the game where they smash spells over their knee. They need help staying alive. I think that's my answer though: Combat should be a rise in tension and being able to know how to make that tension work within any game is needed. Combat as the centre of an experience is fine but you have to be able to service that goal and support it. Venturing into dangerous places and fighting monsters is one way. But I have honestly found more and more that I have players more than happy to talk their way out of the corner I try to out them in, only drawing weapons when that doesn't work. So, you have fighting as a consequence more than a set peice, most of the time.

MGLL

We've ended up picking up different bits of different games when we play. For this, the "3 and done" rule of the new vampire and werewolf has been great. You can all generally tell how a combat has gone from the first three rounds of it, and talk through the results without having to spend the time to grind every number down.

Aoife

As someone who finds combat tedious in that it is often the default mechanism to push narrative forward Mythic Bastionland is now going on the buy list.

Joshua Jaworski

What Chris is saying entirely makes sense and lines up perfectly with the general operating modes of OSR. This being said, I think there's a difference between "balancing encounters" and the GM _knowing what the balance is_ (e.g. the intention of D&D's CR system). I don't say this as advocating for every fight being a winnable situation (or "good fight") for the PCs, but from the perspective of allowing a GM to accurately telegraph the danger to PCs - which is another often cited facet of OSR play. If the players are about to charge into a situation in which they'll have no chance of surviving, there should be signs that this is the case. The GM needs to know what level of danger they're telegraphing to the players - if that's clear from the information given about a combatant, then all is well, but it sounds like perhaps the issue here is Quinns feeling that isn't particularly conveyed. To be clear, this comes from someone who owns both Into the Odd and Mythic Bastionland and is keen to get both to his table (though is tied up running a long-running 5e game, a Wildsea campaign, and sporadic Shadowdark dungeons)!