Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This is a horrific headline. There are three other people on this podcast, Dr. Emily Friedman, Elliot Davis and Play to Find Out editor Brian Flaherty. Unfortunately, none of them are Dropout star, Madison Square Garden Dungeon Master and personal hero of mine Brennan Lee Mulligan. So he gets the headline and my three other podcasters get, uh, an apology, I guess. Sorry!

I'm just doing a quick Patreon post to let you folks know this episode of excellent TTRPG podcast Talk of the Table was just released. It's actually the second time I've been on the show, with me making an appearance last year to talk about games criticism.

This year they invited me back to talk about whether Actual Play is a good way to teach games, but the conversation quickly spirals outwards to all sorts of strange and interesting places, especially if you chuck the Many Sided Media Patreon a few extra bucks to hear the entire second hour of this discussion. Holy crap!

Enjoy, folks.

Quinns

Files

Roundtable: Teaching Games Through Actual Play (ft. Brennan Lee Mulligan, Quinns, and Dr. Emily Friedman)

Listen to this episode from Talk of the Table on Spotify. In this Talk of the Table Roundtable special, Brian & Elliot sit down with Dr. Emily Friedman, Quintin Smith aka 'Quinns', and Brennan Lee Mulligan for a discussion on pedagogic actual play.

Comments

Randall

Called it! Woohoo looking forward to this!

Robert Hanton

Tracked down the podcast and downloaded the episode (since I'm also a big Droput/BLM fan), and then scrolled down the episode list and ended up downloading 3 more that sounded really interesting from just the most recent half-dozen. I barely have time to listen to the podcasts I'm already subscribed to, and yet...

Quinns Quest

It's at the top! The embed! I'll chuck in another link for good measure

DuneArchitect

Ah on mobile wasn’t clear that was a link, thanks!

Kris Green

It was very good! You were very good. You were all very good. The whole episode is just $5. And just like Robert, I ended up downloading some of their older eps to listen to on the go.

Eustace Lu

Listening to the podcast rn and just want to say this: Of course actual-play isn’t the best way to get people to play games, like how the designer of Lancer said in the interview, releasing your rulebook for free is the best way to get people to play your game.

backup_bokoblin

Quinns I don’t have infinite money you can’t keep getting away with exposing me to content that’s worth paying for!!!

Michael R. Underwood

An excellent discussion! Very fun to hear from these folks all talking with one another.

Mike Chapman

This episode was great. Was it really the first time you've ever spoken with Brennan, or just the first time it was recorded? I'm not sure if I've heard your previous appearance, so I downloaded that one too.

Josh

Hi Quinns, this was a FANTASTIC discussion! The idea of high-level roleplaying is something I’ve been chasing for a while (I’ve been DMing for 5 years) but one of the roadblocks I’ve really run into is *finding* the players to make an in-person play group who actually want to take it as seriously as me. There was a moment when Dr Friedman mentioned that you “have an incredible talent to have a playgroup of 12 people” to play with, I would love to see a video or patreon post describing your process of how you pull together a group you want to play a campaign with that you feel would match your same level of love and care you have for the story you’re trying to make. Love all the care and thought you put into your discussions/reviews and excited for the next one!

Lojaan

Hell yeah. There is so much spotlight on the GMs, but a big part of what makes D20, CR and PTFO so great is the *players*. I'm so interested in if players that good need to be found, or can they be cultivated?

Lojaan

This was so good. Definitely worth the $5. How great was that BLeeM line "why do you deserve to be great at this straight away?" As someone who has suffered from perfectionism and fear of failure that hit hard (in a good way)!

Francois

I think the scary part of not being good straightaway at ttrpgs is that as a DM you're not practicing your craft in isolation, you are by definition doing it for people, and if these people aren't having a good time, it's easy to blame yourself. No amount of watching videos about the game will replace the experience of being in the trenches both keeping the plates spinning and making sure you have enough of a grip on the rules to keep everything running smoothly. Oh damn I guess I joined the therapy session too

Erin Jungjohann

Holy shit, what an incredible thing to hear if you're struggling with imposter syndrome. I want this conversation to rewire my entire brain.

DuneArchitect

Fantastic discussion! Thanks for sharing

Benj

100%! In acting, you can workshop and you can rehearse and you can re-block and re-choreograph, and when the rubber truly hits the road is when the audience shuffle in, but in roleplaying, the audience ARE the other actors, so you go right to opening night NOW.

Benj

Great chat! And blimey I wish I could go out for tacos with you all to catch that later conversation too!

Garrett Holladay

What a wonderful discussion. I really connected with it because I have been recently inspired by the QQ channel/patreon to start GMing games of my own after being a player in the hobby for many years. I was always scared to make the jump but after getting my feet wet I am loving it! I've been able to wrangle my brothers in and share a hobby I love. While I am not a master GM yet, the talks in the podcast were emboldening.

Quinns Quest

Yeah, that's the one-liner that's stuck in my head, too

DuneArchitect

For those wondering what's behind the veil for the paid full episode, they go deeper and hit some difficult and more serious topics. For me worth the $5 to listen, plus will go through some of their other episodes this month

Lojaan

Yeah but it doesn't have to be like that. It's just you and your friends. You can totally treat it like a workshop. Nothing wrong with "hi gang, let's all try this out and see how we go?"

SpongeGunderson

Great conversation! But my biggest problem: You’ve sold me on the concept of romance books, but now I don’t know where to start! Got any top recommendations?

NØKKEN_WAITS

thats a really GREAT round table.

Chad

Something I'd love to see made available from Actual Plays (in general) is the unedited version of the material. Certainly clearly marked so other users cannot mistake it for the "intended product", but I think one of the factors that makes Actual Plays intimidating to a GM trying to use them as reference or as a learning tool is how the editing process can cut out a lot of the negotiating between players & GM, rules lookups, and faffing about. As you yourself mentioned Quinns, a lot of that does gets left in in the PTFO podcast (of which I'm very appreciative!), but knowing how much got cut out can be inspirational. Either in the, "Wow, that's how good you can get at rule recall/rulings not rules/lookup" or "Wow, my table at home isn't actually as far off as I had thought it was"

Kris Green

Our group has retconned whole sessions, "I've been thinking, last session was a downer, what do we want to take from it, and if nothing, let's start over from the top."

Dr. Em Friedman

I promise you aren’t missing anything compared to raw!

Mike

I've only listened to the first hour, but another point is that while RPGs have been made more approachable by actual play, it's likely also raised player's (and GMs) expectations. It's one thing to be trying things out for a curious group, it's another thing for folks who have spent countless hours watching professionals who make it look easy, and have editing and sound design on their side.

Lojaan

Quinns - ignore anyone who says “I could never do that”. I bet they were never going to try anyway. Don’t let their decision to play small affect you. As someone annoying but insightful once said “if you dim your light to make others seem brighter, you make the whole world darker”

Dr. Em Friedman

My scholarship is literally around the so-called Mercer (or Mulligan or Quinns) effect, and so far we see it primarily as a GM anxiety rather than as significant reshaping of player expectations. There have always been theatre kids in the hobby — they just haven’t been as visible to folks with other playstyles! It’s also worth noting that “professional” is really tricky — as we talk about, it’s about skills and toolkits from long non-recorded experience, which anyone can get if they want a comparable playstyle. Many don’t!

SuccessfulGeek

Subscribed to them and finally got around to listening to the whole 2 hour episode. Absolutely fantastic! I really need to get my group back together and keep sucking as a new GM and keep growing.

Alexander McConnell

Maybe I'm just extraordinarily arrogant, but I've never watched or listened to any actual play that made me think I COULDN'T do for my friends what you're all doing for your friends. But then, I've been eternally baffled about the constant griping about the Matt Mercer Effect that was going on in the TTRPG space. Maybe my style just dovetails really nicely with what Mercer was doing, but no one has EVER complained my games were just not the same as actual play. EDIT: I did once say I was pleased to see Quinns playing Nobilis because I'd owned it for years and never played it, but that was not because I couldn't have played it if my group at the time had been interested. It's just kind of a hard game to sell people on. We played Changeling: The Lost instead. Which was just Trad enough that they could accept it.

Beau Yarbrough

"no one has EVER complained my games were just not the same as actual play" I don't think most gamemasters have gotten this complaint. I think this is more of an internet myth than an actual issue people routinely encounter at their tables.

Frank Levi

I was just catching up on Quinns Quest backlog and I didn't expect to see NRB over here!

Cameron Jo

My main fear starting TTRPGS was ruining it for my friends. That's why I watched so many videos about how to do this well, how to do that well, how to anticipate this scenario, or that scenario. Stressed so much before ever playing. A chess player doesn't have to worry about ruining the concept of games for their opponent. A musician doesn't have to worry about ruining the audience's opinion on music. But as a GM it's a real fear that if I don't perform well enough then my friends could conclude that TTRPGs aren't for them. Full stop. Fortunately my days are not so stress-filled and I'm relatively confident these days that I can give any player at least one satisfying session of good ol role playin. There's also a huge difference between playing with people who are on the fence about RPGs and those who are down to clown from the start.