Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

And thusly, after delivering something like 8 hours of content(!), our Nobilis season of Play to Find Out draws to a close. Please enjoy this extra-long talkback that is something like our review of Nobilis, I suppose! A game that is fascinating, awe-inspiring, most definitely a bit broken, and will remain in my heart for some time.

I've gotta say, it's such a relief to record an Actual Play show where Emily, Rob and I don't have to hold back on how we really feel! It makes me love this project so much more, because it can be honest about - among other things - how roleplaying is hard, but making a great game is even harder. But both are also magical acts that are nonetheless well worth doing.

Thank you all so much for listening, everybody. We'll be back with another old game in a little while.

Files

Comments

Jacob Haras

After being so obsessed with this series, the ending seemed so abrupt. I wish we could have gotten to the minimum viable sessions Rob describes but I understand it's taxing and also literally costs money. I just thought Rob's Roads was the most interesting fucking character ever and I love you three playing together. It's sort of like mythic bastionland though (running my 3rd session tomorrow btw!), this game has to die so we can get another roll on the 72 fucked up RPGs table. Hope we won't have to wait too long, fantastic work everyone involved

Neon

I thought Rob and Emily did fantastically in this story. Both so sharp and creative. Truly among my favourite Actual Play players in relatively no time at all. I realise that blocking the roads, and withholding rest was a sacrifice play, but does the game take account of the wave of worship that returns after withholding your domain from the people? It feels like a fun gamble.

Andrew Keen

It's interesting to hear how exhausting you found playing / running Nobilis, as I found much of it quite calming to listen to! This was especially true of the earlier episodes where the discussions on the nature of godhood had an almost meditative quality to them. It's an interesting companion piece to the Jorune PTFO which, although a lot of fun, I found bloody exhausting to listen to!

Julien Blic

It's interesting that some of the issues raised bout the game have been addressed on the 3rd edition of the game: you can get your MP back when your bond (things you always want to do) and affliction (things you always do regardless of if you want to) get you into trouble, which is exactly what Emily suggests. And there is a Persona stats which is about imbuing yourself/others with characteristics of your domain, and could easily get you anywhere you want.

Nicholas Bielik

I was a regular player of the Amber Diceless Roleplaying game, a game where you also play godlike beings in an RPG which also uses a diceless system although one very different than the one from Nobilis. One reason I think I never played Nobilis, though I owned the game, was probably because I sort of felt like Amber had already cracked that egg for us. I mean Amber was the game I played more than other in the 1990s (with Mike Pondsmith's Mekton coming a close second). I would be interested to see you all approach Amber at some point in order to see how it connects up with your experience of playing Nobilis. It's a very different game though despite having a lot of overlap. This was a fascinating trip through what sounds like a flawed masterpiece of a game.

Nicholas Bielik

One significant difference between the two games is that the Amber rulebook is stuffed full of advice and examples of play for all sorts of situations!

Nicholas Bielik

Also, Amber was a far more popular game as it was much more playable. The Amber fan community was one of the communities that helped birth what would eventually become story games. Fred Hicks and Rob Donahue of Evil Hat, the designers of Fate, came out of that scene.

Karol Marcjan

Given how much Quinn expresses his strong instinct to heave to rules-as-written/intended, it'd be interesting to hear what he has to say about books like Blades in the Dark: Deep Cuts which is AFAIU a collection of mostly independent rule modifications to the base game to mix and match differently at each table.

Declan Murphy

I loved this, I would love for you lot to sit down and talk about some of your other non PTFO campaigns, sort of like the player interview for delta green

Tuneable

Rob, as an art student who had to take a handful of art history classes surrounding the 19th and 20th century, I appreciate that gesamtkunstnerd joke. I see you lol

Lojaan

This was such a great AP to listen to but yeah. Hot damn I would never want to run this. It seems like if they reduced the power of the gods so they we're like "local gods", gods of town and country, like the god of this road, or this river, or rest as interpreted in this region then it would be more playable. Tho you would need a reality enforcer or something to keep everyone in line. Tho I guess then you are playing Mage the Ascension

Karol Marcjan

Oh, also: the way Quinn pauses many times during this campaign to figure out what to do next? More APs need to show GMs doing that.

MineHack

I so very much would love a sequel! Probely won't get one but it would be so hype!! My favorite PTFO jet. <3

Alex Aitken

Sorry if you've already touched on it, but Necronautilus (in the one campaign I've played of it) I think does a very similar idea to Nobilis in a way that addresses some of your complaints. It has a similar "go to planets as godlike beings with mortal pasts and solve problems/have adventures" narrative, and the powers are biiig and sweeping (and revolve around gathering/using words as your characters don't have corporeal bodies and is SUPER fun) and there's just a bit more cohesion to the economy and usage of powers that I think makes it a bit more fun (or at least doesn't clash as much w the fun storytelling aspect). The theming and art and everything about it absolutely rules, too!!

Quinns Quest

This is perfect timing. I've wanted to read Necronautilus for ages and I just now brought a copy home from PAX Unplugged!

Quinns Quest

Hahaha, it's very much the pain at the core of this series! But I think everyone working on PTFO is up for a longer series next time we record. But we have to release season 4 next, which is the live show

Wakelyn

Oh man, I'm really, really tempted to try to run this over Discord.

ThymeBonus

Oh this was fantastic! When you were you all discussing how to play this as a PVP style game the first thought I had was actually of the board game Diplomacy. If you've never played it it's a bit like Risk except you don't get lots of troops and more often than not you need to coordinate your moves with other players to take territory (massive over simplification). Where it gets really interesting, and where it relates here, is that each turn is simultaneous. Every player writes down their orders (e.g. troop move to France, Support into British Channel) and then they are revealed and resolved all at once.

Paxcow

As someone who is always in, and prefers to be, the GM seat for my group, I just don't care anymore for games that are all, "You can BE anything and DO anything because you're so UNIQUE and POWERFUL! *And*, we've got this *wild* and *detailed* resolution system that allows for really free-form, improvisational approaches to the mechanics!" They just feel like such headaches to run, and the payoff is often not that demonstrably Greater(tm) an experience than other tighter, more focused games provide, I feel like. If everyone at the table is an accomplished theatre-kid who can generate plot and drama from nothing, and riff unprompted until the cows come home, then sure, having that kind of "wide-open playspace" is great. And, the GM really will just be facilitating, and probably won't get as burned out. Kind of like when Rob was talking about what a group would need to do a really effective short-run session of Nobilis though, there's just this huge pile of "ifs".

Dan Svensson

Amber is much easier to grasp in both setting and rules and it doesnt get in the way of itself. Also it made me read some Zelazny books and they are great. The only bad thing are the magic rules but magic was never really more than alluded to in the books.

Kolton Kulis

This was fantastic, Quinns! The ending was a little abrupt, but I like leaving the question "What does a world of home offices look like?" open for the audience to explore and ponder. I am not generally a narrativist GM and prefer more trad or simulationist play, but this let's play of Nobilis has left me very inspired. I agree with your sentiment that a high powered god focused system needs to be more open ended and less specific/simulationist. I have cracked open my dusty Apocalypse World, Blades in the Dark, and Ironsworn books as reference, have been throwing ideas at the wall, and working on a prototype BitD/PbtA god system. The WIP idea is your god never needs to roll for mundane and mortal tasks or even lower powered miracles. You only roll against mortals when it reaches a certain scale threshold like you razing a city alone or you vs. an entire army. I've been using tweaked BitD Deep Cuts action resolution, so even at that scale you succeed all the time but generate narrative consequences or threat clocks. With a system like this, it would generate stories about players making sweeping changes to the world but watching as all sorts of unintended consequences pop up in response to their changes. Still working out how to handle direct god vs. god interactions.

Alastair

Something I found really interesting, which got a bit alluded to here and there but I don't think really came to the forefront, was the implicit horror in this story and setting. I know becoming a Nobilis is presented as deeply fulfilling and joyful but there's a sense in which the original person is somewhat erased, replaced by this new being that has far more depth in some aspects, but in other ways seems almost flattened to their domain. If you could somehow describe to Josie and Derek what was about to happen to them would they be excited or terrified? And that's not to mention what this world is like from the human perspective - constantly reshaped in bizarre and horrifying ways to the petty whims of creatures that you can't even bear to look at, and half the time you don't even know that they're doing it. I almost think that you *could* run an asynchronous PvP game using Nobilis, but only one group would be Nobles and using the Nobilis system. The other group would be humans and they'd be playing something like Delta Green.

Caspar Bankert

Quinns, if you ever recover from the last two impossible RPGs you looked at, I would love to see you tackle Continuum. It is a time travel game where player characters can skip around in their own timelines, meet future and past selves and basically treat causality like a to-do list. The whole thing is built on keeping the timeline “stable” while you constantly mess with it on purpose. You owe favors to your future self, you are haunted by promises your past self already made, and every little scene is part of a giant, pre-planned knot of cause and effect. It is also, very honestly, shamelessly unplayable. The bookkeeping is brutal, the rules expect superhuman discipline and the whole thing feels like it was written for a table of time-travel lawyers. But that is exactly why I would love you to look at it. I really want to know if there is a playable core inside that madness, or if it truly collapses under its own weight. If anyone can dig something interesting out of that mess, it is probably you.

Tyro The Fox

I am a bit of an evangelist for Cortex Prime so take this with a grain of salt, but I feel you'd get a more even game if it was couched in some form of those mechanics. Buuut, with trade-offs. Player sheets could be a little simpler, and able to incorporate a dice pool of Relationships and Attributes relating to the main aspects of a deity as described here. Checks would be used to determine both if something is possible, but also if something happens without consequence. Certainly, you could have something just happen; but 'failure' here would be messing up all consequences and having something unexpected happen. Or, rightly, Plot Points become extremely powerful. And the means of acquiring them could be interesting for a bit of push and pull within a narrative, while still allowing for some form of a godly power to exist within the game. If nothing else, abstracted forms of damage being manageable within Cortex would be helpful. However, you lose the immediacy of strength that Nobilis displays. You would lose the diceless system in favour of one that's closer to a gamble on whether you succeed or not. Being diceless does lend the game an ease which suits the premise really well. The prospect that a deity can fail at something would have to be addressed, possibly to make it that dice sizes in particular things are able to auto succeed but in place of spending power points, a Nobilis can instead roll a check to attempt to succeed, at the cost of possible failure and Plot Points. It's not apples to apples but I feel finding ways and means to play these games and keep these pieces of work alive in new forms that a group might benefit from is great. I do appreciate that shoving it into another system is not the best idea, but Cortex Prime does seem flexible to handle a lot of things. And I enjoy the adaptation process. Edit: Cortex Prime practically is a PvP system, it would work quite well for opposing groups of Nobilis meeting.

InkedRaven

The rules on certain points coming back after a “story “ is finished, permanent points, and temporary points —reminds me of the world of darkness 20th anniversary edition. I wonder if Nobilis was taking from those rules and assuming the player understood that system? As those games (werewolf, vampire, and hunter) were extremely popular at the time of nobiliss…I mean in general this system on philosophy reminds me of mage in WoD honestly.

Kieran Ward

"The god of debate asks you 'Are you sure?' and suddenly you are not sure."

Mau

Thank you for closing a 20+ year chapter in my life. I always wanted to play it and after listening to this season it just made me feel like I did it. Indeed, it sounds like it would have been juicy to play it by email in the early 2000’s, just like I did with World of Darkness Thank you orz

Vonn Frey

It really sucked that Quinn's wrote off and ignored the gifts, and flaws rules because it would have fixed a lot of they're issues with the system. Gifts can cheeply give you things like teleportation or mending things (anything you want really) to avoid dealing with mundain things you don't enjoy. Flaws give a way to replenish/farm miracle points when you let something bad happen because of them, very similarly to what they suggested.

GoodOl'CSB

Long out of date and I don’t know if this was mentioned elsewhere, but I wonder if there was an overemphasis on roads as a conveyance for vehicles. Early in the series I think there was a real effort to establish that roads was paths, walkways, trails, highways, etc but it seemed like there was a huge emphasis on ‘traffic’. Still think this was super fun to listen to and I’m gald to have been exposed to it. I don’t think I’m in any rush to go play Nobilis, but it was very interesting to listen to.

Sadghostgirl37

I'm going to be thinking about Gesamtkunstnerd for the rest of my life now. dang it.