Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey folks! Got a surprise between-season video for you today.

Last month I got invited to the charming, sun-drenched Spanish games event Guadalindie in Málaga to give a talk of my choice. Did I primarily say yes because I've never been to Spain? Yes. Between cups of sangria and morsels of Iberico ham, was I gonna do my best with the talk? Also yes.

The whole 45 minute thing is now on YouTube, and the recording is excellent. It's like you're there in the room with me! I hope you guys enjoy this, I put a lot of heart into it.

I wanted to give a talk about why on People Make Games I do so many videos about the weird fringes of what can be considered a "game". This constant reaching for something new and unexplored is also why I left the video game industry to co-found Shut Up & Sit Down, or why I then left board games to found Quinns Quest.

But when I sat down to write this talk... I guess I found myself getting pretty polemical. In the above video you'll see me being very enthusiastic but also more than a little angry that the rest of the games industry is still so siloed, and mostly I just list example after example of ways in which the games industry is failing not just designers and players, but also failing ethical challenges by keeping its culture inside this cramped little box of what a "game" is.

That sounds hi-falutin but it's a fun talk! Hit play, you'll see.

Peace! 🕊️✌️

Files

Why We're Doing Journalism Differently: The Future isn't Games, it's Play - PMG | Guadalindie 2026

Quinns (Quintin Smith) has dedicated his career to giving visibility to great games that deserve more attention. After working for ten years in video games, ten years in board games, and creating a new channel about role-playing games (as well as making some documentaries for People Make Games), there came a point when he decided that genres are for losers and should disappear. More information on previous and upcoming editions: https://guadalindie.com/en/ Follow Guadalindie: Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/guadalindie.bsky.social Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/guadalindie/

Comments

Fable

Im a librarian who has to do a lot of work to get backing for what our field calls "games-based programming and servies", and i think this play rephrase could help us a lot too! Thank you for sharing!!

Quinns Quest

Ohhhhhh this is cool as fuck! Thanks for the link

Dennis Cenholt Andersen

What an awesome talk, thanks Quinns. I know it's maybe not the same, but I just got into solo roleplaying, which I never thought of even as a possibility for gaming. But It's fucking awesome!

Colin Beerens

I'd just like to support/second the recommendation of the first person you offered the microphone to afterwards, 17776 and its sequel 20020 are absolute heart-wrenchingly beautiful and hilarious examinations of why humans play.

Samuel Sarjant

Cripes this is inspiring. I gotta find my nearest Nordic LARP and see if I can set up some immersive stuff with my local improv group.

Thomas Richard

Really interesting talk, now I have to figure out why I missed all these things and find a way to get there!

Quinns Quest

Yes!! I caught up with that guy after the talk. Turns out I have heard of it, I'm a huge Jon Bois fan in fact

daniel schmitt

I know you mentioned it on SD&SU a while back and have a written article, but i would love to see you cover Blades in the Dark in this Quinns Quest format because it was such a shift in TTRPGs since it came out and started a whole new branch of game types.

Shaun

"Michelangelo, Leonardo, Da Vinci, they're all dead. I REMAIN... as a performance artist"

Matt Kimmich

While I enjoyed most of the talk and agree with a lot of it, there's also something about it that rubs me the wrong way. I agree that the games press (and industry) should be more curious, and that especially the biggest sites are often the least curious. But there's also an extent to which I think you don't seem aware of your privilege, Quinns. I love watching videos on PMG about Wasteland Weekend or about Jerry Gretzinger - but you get to visit those because PMG can cater to a specific audience that is willing to pay for these things, and because of additional sponsoring. These are not experiences that the vast majority of people who play games will be able to have. That doesn't mean they can't be interested - as I said, I think it's fantastic that PMG can make these videos, and I enjoyed them greatly -, but there is also an argument for gaming sites that focus on what is accessible to their audience. There's also an argument for a gaming press that in no small part focuses on video games, especially at a time when small developers who do wildly original things are finding it more and more difficult to be discovered due to the sheer amount (and, these days, more and more slop made quickly with AI) that comes out. The more broadly gaming sites interpret their remit, the less they can contribute to making such video games discoverable. And while you allude to the realities of the marketplace once or twice, I do think you downplay it to an extent in order to come down hard on the press. Again, there's a privilege to PMG being able to do what you do, and there's a lot of nuance that I think would benefit your point here. None of the above invalidates your arguments, but I think they would be strengthened by a bit of a reality check with respect to the conditions that make it possible for PMG to do its work and that make it difficult, and perhaps not as universally important, for others to do the same. The press and the industry can and should improve, in many of the ways you mention, but I believe there is more nuance there than you acknowledge in your talk.

Quinns Quest

Hi Matt! Thanks for the thoughtful comment, as well as the kind words. If I didn't rub at least some people the wrong way I would have felt that I hadn't gone hard enough in the talk, so all of this is fine. 😅 I am /deeply/ aware of my privilege. For as long as I've been working for People Make Games I've been describing it as an unreal amount of freedom for a journalist to have. I'm not so far away from my jobs working for the editors (and to a lesser extent, the advertisers) of websites and magazines to have forgotten how taxing it is to get an editor to commission anything new. But! Just because PMG uses its funding to do the maximalist version of the coverage of these spaces doesn't mean that's the only way that coverage can exist. Sure, we went to Wasteland Weekend, but some of my favourite larps ever have been chamber larps you can play at home for free. Our stories on Roblox, VRChat and Second Life didn't involve us paying a cent. And sure, I went to Singapore to cover Jubensha, but another site could have commissioned local journalists to write about it and got a story that was even richer. That said, you are for /sure/ correct that the economic realities of gaming sites mean that many of them are struggling to make ends meet /without/ taking risks. I'm not ignorant of that, nor am I blaming them, I'm just... despairing at the situation of the entire games industry. If I came down hard on the games press in the talk, it's because that's the only corner I have permission to come down harder on- I'm part of the press.

Matt Kimmich

Cheers for the reply, Quinns. And your replies certainly make sense: I can understand the likes of IGN not broadening their remit to include all kinds of play, but that doesn’t excuse them from ignoring stories that are entirely about video games in a narrow sense because the story isn’t the tired old review-as-customer-service-only thing.

Brett Rolfe

Something that struck me as interesting (depressing?), Quinns can you confirm… at $30B, the US fantasy sports industry is the same size as the global board game industry?!

Steve Hatherley

Thanks for sharing - a very interesting talk. As someone who has always played a wide range of games, I've long been mildly irritated that the "games industry" has come to mean videogames. (I'm still smarting over needing to add "tt" to my beloved rpgs.)

Flare (Nikola)

Can we please have the link to the Chinese culture newsletter referenced in the talk? (I hate myself so much for deciding to not go to Guadalindie now after watching the talk)

Danny Hughes

Hey there! I’m new here, but speaking of finding games in other places: the Upright Citizens Brigade (where Sam Riegel, Brennan Lee Mulligan, and basically all of Drop Out come from) has called their style of teaching improv “game” for over a decade. Lots of the stuff in their comedy manual is really relevant to RPGs. Example: viewing the principle of “yes, and” not as literally every idea actually happens, but moreso that the improvisers are the puppeteers and the characters they’re playing are the puppets. Yes and is for the puppeteers, not the puppets! You can say no when you’ve established the rules of a scene (or a game). A good read for any role play gamer interested in this is Will Hines’ How to Be the Greatest Improviser on Earth.

Quinns Quest

It was called Chaoyang Trap. That collective has disbanded now, sadly. Still looking for a really good replacement, but for now I read Active Faults

Aurelius Noble

Thanks for talk, really great to have a holistic picture like this. I just tried designing a TTRPG for the first-time and immediately experienced this issue (of what is/isn't X type of game). The (poorly conceived) concept was for a game about Vampire Hunters inspired by Alice is Missing focused on having to do terrible things to the community in the pursuit of "the greater good". Almost immediately the feedback was that this wasn't a TTRPG, because it had pre-defined story beats, limited player freedom (i.e. hunters couldn't choose to join the vampire) and board game esque mechanics for balancing the "finding the truth" aspect with narrative consequences (doing terrible things). Maybe this is just semantics, but I found it really limiting. People were either saying I should move towards a "balanced" board game experience, or drop these mechanics from a TTRPG because they incentivised players to make particular narrative choices (namely ones that I hoped would raise some ethical qualms among the players). I think something you touch on here but don't delve into as much, is that it's not just abot the "bounds" of gaming, but the insularity of some communities and the reticience to really experiment. For instance, I think the idea that all TTRPGs should provide players with complete "freedom" is quite limiting (perhaps in similar ways to open-world video games), in that this can prevent players from forming deep connections with their character. Not that there isn't space for both, but not every game needs to provide complete freedom. There are narrative experiences where you want players to embody a character, and it's ok to structurally constrain them, e.g. in Alice you don't want the players to have the "freedom" to join the kidnappers, because this would break the narrative the game is trying to tell.

Phase-out

Wow, super interesting talk Quinns, thanks <3

Echo Tango

🙂 I am astonished at how deep the Nordic LARP scene gets. Fascinating stuff!

Arne Sahlberg

Excellent talk. This is the talk where I first heard about Jubensha and it's been the coolest thing I've done in some time.

disk

Oh, this reminded me of that time I saw people mixing strikeball and LARPs in a multi-day S.T.A.L.K.E.R recreation. Loved watching the guy playing a reporter with his camera So many interesting games...

ChickenDragon

This is an interesting way of looking at things.

Quinns Quest

Improv is absolutely part of this, for sure! And you can see how improv bleeds into TTRPGs and larping, obviously. Within larp there's this whole concept of "playing to lift" which could have come right out of an improv class.

Jan Holan

Heya Quinns! Since your talk about larps mentioned nordic larps (altough we in Czechia prefer the distinction "content larps") and even briefly Disco Elysium I gotta something for you - 97 Poets of Revachol, a 109 person 3 day game in old hospital, about revolution, poverty, poetry, surrealism, despair, taxidermy and all other things connected - including players of Unseen concepts and actuall sweatshop work as a part of the play. I was one of the main writers/designers on that game, you can check it out here https://revachol.rolling.cz/ (or photos https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.562132146323009&type=3). There is a slight possibility of future runs, we just finished 2 of them last week. Hit me up if you would be interested to know more about that one (or even about tradition of Czech larp in general, many European larpers are coming in in our beatiful little country for games from our volunteer-run organization https://rolling.cz/en/about-us/)!