Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Wich logo do you think is better?

  • A 29
  • B 31
  • C 51
  • D 161
  • None of them. 2
  • 2017-07-23
  • —2017-07-24
  • 274 votes
{'title': 'Wich logo do you think is better?', 'choices': [{'text': 'A', 'votes': 29}, {'text': 'B', 'votes': 31}, {'text': 'C', 'votes': 51}, {'text': 'D', 'votes': 161}, {'text': 'None of them.', 'votes': 2}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2017, 7, 24, 23, 1, 8, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2017, 7, 23, 17, 58, 49, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 274}

Content

I hired a graphic designer to change the logo of "Pact with a Witch".I drove him crazy with so many arguments and twiching here and there... (I know, I´ m that kind of clients... but I like things how I have in mind or if possible even better... ^^).So... 

A is the orignal.

B is the one graphic designer did.

C Is my retouching without sparkles.

D Is my retouching with sparkles.

Wich one do you like most and you think would fit better with the game atmosphere you´ ve played so far?Thanks!

Files

Comments

David Swain

I like the existing one as, well its the one which I associate with the project. as the same time it has a amateur feel to me. B looks nice but I also like your increase of the contrast for C and D, between the last 2 I think the sparkles is what finishes it for me

Vashi

I actually like A and D the most ... A for its simplicity and a bit cartoonish but D is fancy and strict

Zuripai Games

B looks great from a color and design point of view, but it's not very readable compared to the original A. D is great, it's readable at a glance and very well designed. Although I do feel the bottom half of "Pact" could be "brightened" just a tiny bit to make it clear for total readability sake. Other then that D is very nice!

jonnymelabo

Well... probably that was what I didn´t like from it at all... the "amateur" look... even if it´s an amateur project (after all is my first project :P). Thanks for your comment! ;)

jonnymelabo

I´ m susrprised on the quantity of people who liked the A design, when it was done just to have something fast thought to be changed in the future... ^^ Probably is more readable or is just nostalgic or for simple long association... Thanks for your comment! ;)

jonnymelabo

My idea was change a little bit the B logo, but I get feeling up and I changed it quite a lot after all... ^^ I already added a little bit bright on the sides at the very close bottom of the word PACT to enhance better its visibility... Humm... Probabaly I could add a little bit more. Thanks for your detailed comment! ;)

Dr. TeaRex

I'm torn between C and D. I think the sparkles are a bit excessive, but at the same time, the colour of D seems slightly more vibrant than C. Either way, both C and D are very nice.

Desudro

I love D. I love the retouching you did to it. Very well done :3

DrunkenOwl

Selected D. Your own work is nice too but every brand needs a change time to time :)

John (Doe)

I voted for B, but it is missing the brightness of D (which would be my second choice). Maybe combine the two?

Fitzs35

i love C, it looks so neat, would be my preferred one. ~keep up the good work~

Discontinued (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-13 12:00 If you have to use it in small format I would use C. And for the bigger formats I would use D. I finally voted for D, even if C is clean, the last one looks more "magic" and "erotic" with the sparkles. Keep working. You're doing an amazing job!
2017-07-24 08:05

CLevGo

I would say Keep A but alter the shading with a slightly lighter version of C.

jonnymelabo

In theory they have exactly the same color... ^^ But nice to know your opinion! ;)

jonnymelabo

It´s what I tried to do in the D and it ended up looking quite different... ^^

jonnymelabo

Thanks! Yeah... sparkles in B looks nice, but when image is small it disturbs a little, that´ s why I made sparkles in D not so big... Things can change but I prefer spend my time advancing the game... ^^ Thanks for your comment!

jonnymelabo

When I did A it was in a very rush at the beginning of this project... Don´t probably in future I will try something new... but for now I prefer dedicate my time entererly on advacing the game. Thanks for your comment! ;)

Bree

I would say A is better if only because it is much more easily readable. The first priority of logos is readability. The other logos are way better, but much harder to read. If you tone down the colors in the other logos, they should easily surpass the original. But as is, they are worse.

Tron (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-13 12:00 D! (☞゚∀゚)☞
2017-07-24 20:05

Dr. TeaRex

Interesting. Then it seems that the thing I don't like about D is also the thing I DO like about D. Because the sparkles must be giving the illusion that it is more vibrant than C.

mike

its hard to choose between B and D...

Ynreh

yeah! so cool!