Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This week, in Belgrade, Montana, a man disappears, seemingly into thin air, but a friend of his says he doesn't want to be found. This friend says the man ran away to start a new life, with a blonde, in a small red car. This is a major surprise to the missing man's wife, who doesn't belive the disappearing story, for a second. Will some lies, and a piece of brain found in a curtain tell a different story???

Along the way, we find out that you need to have a major television deal to afford to live in a lot of Montana, that you never want to be a "forest bride", and that people normally don't have chunks of brain in their curtains!!

New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!

Check us out on VIDEO Wednesday and Friday evenings on Netflix! www.netflix.com/smalltownmurder

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!

Follow us on...

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

facebook.com/smalltownpod

Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!

Comments

Zach Harris

Being a forensic files nut this episode is one of my favorites

PadrePaul Ballin

In the movie "Short Cuts", While on a fishing trip in the wilderness, the three fishermen (Huey Lewis, Fred Ward and Buck Owens) discover the corpse of a young woman floating in the water. Instead of immediately stopping their trip to report the death, they tie the body to a rock so it won't float away and continue fishing for the rest of the weekend and plan to report it on the way home.

Heather

James is right! Biathlon is skiing and shooting. Keri Swenson tells her story on 30 for 30. They shot her and left her for dead but her biathlon training helped her survive.

Sarah Patton

Born in 92 and here to confirm the gray hair and arthritis. Just trying to fall asleep and called out, damn.

Madelyn Bryant

The earth took Buzz made me laugh so hard my tampon flew out

Vanessa Healy

They made that kidnapping mountain story into one on the best TV movies of the 80’s called The kidnapping of Kari Swensen starring Tracy Pollan who is married to Michael J Fox. It was awesome I’ve seen it a bunch.🙃

Rose Logan-Surgeon

I was aware of her story when it happened. I love running trails and her story has lived rent free in my head for over 40 years. Why women will always choose the bear 🐻

The Camo

That's an Australian story! Paul Kelly wrote the song Everything's Turning to White & then they made the movie Jindabyne (awesome fishing 🎣) about this .. .. Edit - based on a Raymond Carver story, my mistake, he's American.

The Camo

...who says I have no brain matter in my camper?!! That's where I keep it all ...

Jill Royson

Where there's muck there's brass

Don Nelson

Name a place on the East Coast that gets tons of snow? How about Syracuse with 117.3 inches per year, average (that's 9.75 feet). Or Buffalo, over 92 inches.

Natey Bag o Donuts

Syracuse has gotten close to ten feet of snow in a season.

Ginger Thomas

Shirley, Ashley, Carol, Francis, Cary, Alison—we’re all men’s names originally

D Coen

Fairbanks, Alaska had a country bar called the silver spur back in the day.

Dorothyann

I’ve heard that mountain man story before. It’s definitely funnier when James and Jimmie tell it. 😆

Wala Kitu

How do you know you’re old? You quote the plot of a Matlock episode but can’t remember where it’s from. For the record me knowing the episode James was talking about probably means I’m even older and own the DVDs rather than catching an episode 30 years ago on a rerun.

Shelly Roberts

I wonder if Savvy is the same band that played in Ft. Worth back in the 80’s with Ricky Lynn Gregg.

Jessica Schafer

Laughing at how jimmie assumes you get land outside of Bozeman for 500k hahaha also only people are moving to the west side of the state. That's why normal people try to avoid that side (corner actually). Billionaires playground. And i assume the normal residents of this area are similar to the people from the outskirts of Denver lol

Sarah Patton

Buffalo is Great Lakes, practically midwestern, more than East Coast. Truly coastal places that have the sea impacting their weather year round just don’t get as cold. I feel like James is more referring to that type of “coastal.”

Carey Turner

I live in NE Montana and we did indeed get snow 2 days ago, and it’s so damn cold here. -30 and-40 degrees in Winter. It’s about 150° difference between seasons. We do have a lot of celebrities living in our state but that’s usually more in the western half. They are right tho, it’s exploding over there which really sucks for a lot of obvious reasons.

Carey Turner

That was a good movie. I had forgotten that it was Tracy.

Zach Harris

It’s honestly my “go to sleep” show since I’ve watched it so much

Heather

Can we get lasanga party merch?!

Scott Brady

Lol I played that version of dodgeball in elementary school, but we called it wall ball (because you were standing up against the opposite wall while you were out) rather than prisoner dodgeball 🤣

Marie Yamanaka Lazzara

Literally just finished a book called “Gray After Dark”. Not until just right now while listening to this episode did I realize that it was based on this true story about the mountain men abducting an Olympic level athlete. That is insane!

Sahar Arafat-Ray

Time to wrap myself in the warm embrace of another shithouse rat crazy murder.

Lucifer Jones

Buffalo came to my mind, I think they average around 8ft each year.

Shayne Bartlett

And I am officially using “what is this a public fish fry!???”

Carey Turner

Don’t have to watch, just listen and shut your eyes and see it on your eyelids. I do that with movies I’ve seen an embarrassing amount of times, you can just listen.

Zach Harris

I have that issue with The Dark Knight and Dark Knight Rises recently…I’ll be going to sleep and subconsciously quoting the whole movie

Stephanie Burt

Love these guys! Sarah Patton, 72 here, not a gray hair! But wishing I did!

Shana Colbert

Talking about a rat in your car, yes I have but only because my 13 year old niece let it escape out of the cage it was in. It took a week to get that fucking thing out of my car!

Hvquay

As a Montanan, I always enjoy your roasts. I think my favorite was the Butte episode that took place between drunk miners in the 60's. Or, IDK, the one in Ft. Benton where a wife trolled and killed her husband was wild, too. Weird shit happens out here. I remember the Kari Swenson case, I was a little kid then, and I think there was a TV movie made about it. I'm just waiting for you guys to do a case close to home, there are several to choose from! (I'm from the Unabomber town...) I love how you guys really capture the small town culture, your observations are spot on and hilarious. Thanks for the shout out about our winters, we're weirdly proud of our suffering in that regard. I will just keep my pedantic observations about the pronunciation of Helena and the wolf population in MT in 1990 to myself, as I know you and everyone else here don't care. 🤣🤣🤣

70Boss302

Born in 1971...hush now little bebe 😆

Amy Sousa

I absolutely remember this case as well. It was huge national news. So weird that these stories this intersected in this elliptical way.

Laurie Katherine

I’m willing to bet that the band, The Waiting, is a Tom Petty cover band

Felix Mallott

I have a funny story about a friend who lost a snake and a mouse in her car.

Bianca

🤣🤣🤣

Hvquay

I meant to say also, as an aside, the guy who was being guided on a hunting trip by the two psychos in the Kari Swenson case probably waited until the trip was over because he was no doubt in the back country/wilderness areas with them, on foot or horseback, and to leave after being told that would be very suspicious and they, being the experienced wooden and guides, would have definitely been able to catch/stop him. He probably waited out of concern for his own safety.

Mgncapri

We hosted a lasagna party. Everyone brought their own recipe and winner won a certificate and a bottle of booze. Way more fun than a pot luck. Bonus Episode suggestion: Wardens/Guards who behave badly. Always fascinating to stumble upon those stories. I bet there's some good ones out there.

Shinea I

James, I adore you, but you need to come to Buffalo in the winter. You'll change your opinion real quick 😆 I have spent several Christmas holidays snowed into my apartment because I literally can't see my car under the snow

70Boss302

Sigh.....Always a forest bridesmaid, never a forest bride

Zachary Leatherwood

Whats up Turkeys🦃? Jealousy is a mother fucker. Pick up a hobby like painting 🖼️if you feel yourself being pulled down the jealousy hole. 🖕🏾🧊

Shayla Sadorf

Yes! I came to the comments to say this!

Carey Turner

Right?! It is a crazy proudness we have about our damn cold weather!

Savannah Malloy

One time I found a baby possum in my kitchen drawer once. I can’t even express exactly just how much it’s scared the shit out of me, while I was looking for a god damn zester. but it was cute. We found their Mama outside trying to get under the house the next night, so they were reunited, oddly enough.

Carey Turner

Also, I thought the same thing about the mispronunciation of Helena and also Placerville in California. It’s actually not too far down the road from the Donner party’s last party.

Carey Turner

Omg I can’t even imagine the fucking stink it had to get between the pee and shit! 🤢

Carey Turner

Want some of mine? I’ve got plenty! 😆

Shana Colbert

It was awful, thank god it didn't eat the wiring

TaphWithNoLastName

1:23:15 reminds me of a quote from Elastigirl talking about Mr. Incredible in The Incredibles lmao "Either he's in trouble, or he's going to be."

Jennifer S.

Prisoner Dodge Ball is the second most New York game I’ve ever fucking heard of, second only to stick ball. Count on NYC Italian kids to come up with a game that includes a prison stint. 😂

Jennifer S.

Buffalo and Syracuse are basically Canada. Definitely more like Canada than the east coast weather wise… and in pretty much every other sense. It’s like the rural south with more farms and without the accent and mosquitos.

Phildo

Wood forest bride. Get ‘er to the campsite she’s yours, hilarious. Montana, ‘Merika.

Jebediah Marquis Wu

I said this ain’t no public fish fry! Also James still having to say “Zamazing” pleases me.

Erika Fultz

'76 and I don't have gray hair, I've got some white... it's not even growing in in a cool way so I will continue to color my hair.

Erika Fultz

Nailed the pronunciation of the Purkinje!

Ryan

Did he say curtain tissue?

Rainee Courtnage

Belgrade has inherited Bozeman's inflated prices without the benefit of businesses to support the economy. They lie. There are Jews, Muslims, Hindus living there among the Dutch who established farming and dairy in Belgrade, Manhattan and Churchill, all in 5 miles apart. You did a Smalltown Murder a few years ago about a serial killer /frozen body parts collection. Manhattan, I think.

Tierra Porter

'93 and it all hit me at once. Now my back and feet hurt all the tine and I take great pride in telling the younger ppl to get their shit together. Yes, there is a grey streak that goes right down the middle of my hair too.

Tyler Race

Also born in '92 and thankfully I don't have arthritis (yet), but the gray hair is real 😭

NonniX2

Did anyone else run to the comments to see "rat + vehicle" stories? Just me? Oh ok!🤣

NonniX2

My life in one sentence!

Jairo

is there a movie about the Warden who took the inmates out to dinner... I NEED THIS MOVIE IN MY LIFEEEEEE

R

James’ characterization of dating: it’s just men proving they’re magnanimous enough to tolerate a woman’s lame escape room interests 😆 The straights are NOT OK

Danielle Doane Montalvo

I grew up in upstate NY and can confirm we played Prisoner Dodge Ball lol

Danielle Doane Montalvo

My husband has misspelled my name on several occasions. To be fair he is an immigrant but I’m not sure it’s a valid excuse 🤣

Gloria D.

Grew up on the East Coast now live in Montana and it does seem to get a lot colder the temperatures go below zero . But it does not have humidity at all so it doesn’t have that feeling of going through your soul like it does on the East Coast.

Ashley W.

*raises hand* we've had rats and mice inside our cars. Like, inside the cab. We live in the country, so they find a way in, but you clean your car and lay down mousetraps, you don't shoot them.

Leslie

Please do a bonus episode on warden Micky

Danielle Hilton

Jimmy you are not a loser LOL. Jimmy is the best!!

Nurse Ratchet

As a matter of fact @dericcahill has had rats chew into the cab of his brand new truck cab. Watch the video on his facebook😅🤣

Farmerbillythehero

Does anyone know why the juror would say that you can't fire a .357 in rapid succession?

Matressa, Countess of Whorington

My grandmother never spelled my brother Michael's name correctly, it was "Michelle", so our mom would call him that to tease him 😉

Matressa, Countess of Whorington

Also my dad had a "nervous breakdown" when I was in high-school. It was a bad year and he punched a coworker in the face.

Maito King

When I heard the color of clothes thing i immediately thought the Lindsay Clancy trial and thr jurors who wore pink

Davey Boy.

WTF is a public Fish Fry..!!?? 😱...lol..

Kyra Richter

Immediate adoption into my lexicon.

Danielle Carter

I had a mouse live in my Mecury Mountaineer for a week. I had to put a peanut butter trap in the back to catch it. It also ate my cigarettes.

Liesl Manone

Oh, yes, they both, oh, yes, they both reached for The gun, the gun, the gun, the gun, oh, yes They both reached for the gun, for the gun

Stephanie Burt

I have 4 years on you,. My mom was going grey at 38. My dad doesn't even have a lot of gray yet! I'm a natural blonde, so when I do, it won't really tell if I am hahah

Stephanie Burt

72 here! Lots of arthritis, fibromyalgia and every other fucking bullshit health problem that I can get lol. It sucks big time

deeznutz

Helen...uh... neither "e" is long. Get it right lol

It Ain't Easy Being Eldritch

James was saying at the beginning that he had never heard of a man named "Allison", so I have a Sahara Fart Fun Fact for you all: Drew Carey of "Whose Line Is it Anyway" and his eponymous sitcom fame, has "Allison" for a middle name. Also he was in the Marines when he was much younger. 😄👍🏼

It Ain't Easy Being Eldritch

I get SO PUMPED when J & J start talking about the forensic STEM stuff from a case!!!! I used to work in biotech labs, and I know how to do, and have done a lot of the assays mentioned in this story (cutting DNA w/ restriction enzymes, PCR, gel electrophoresis, etc.) and I LOVED every second of working in the lab. When James was talking about how the lab that tested the familial DNA "ran the band off the gel", I was basically shouting at my phone how fucking dumb the lab tech that did that is!!!! That's bush-league shit right there! Unfortunately, I was forced to stop working in biotech because of my disabilities, and I miss it terribly. But, c'est la vie!

Stacy Nielsen

Damn! Why is Oregon the unfortunate big house 🤣

neill with 4 last names

Was just getting to the show's climax, and....(patreon is updating. Please come back later) Aargh Patreon, you utter, utter, utter c...(comments are updating. Please come back later). There. That's shown them 🙄 Best episode for a while, inane giggling at 3am can get some odd looks from the neighbours. Anyone else finding the J's are getting even slicker recently?

Kristen Ellis

Just wanted to say Maja is pronounced “maya” 😂 it’s my middle name and it was never pronounced correctly hahaha

G S

Worse thing ever and its 2026 still no cure, just trial injections and pain injections and 3 different meds and still suffering

rylie dehiya

I am actively dealing with a pack rat on the interior of my car. Finally killed it and now have to get it professionally disinfected and my vents cleaned/replaced T.T

Stephanie Burt

I'm so sorry, my aunt had that as well, I seen her In punishment so often, I myself have fibromyalgia, plus many other ailments . It sucks getting older that's for sure .

Melissa Blue

We live an hour from Belgrade, my hubby and I were listening to this while driving through Belgrade to go to the Home Depot in a Bozeman. We were trying to figure out which truck stop this must have been. We think we remember which one was the flying J…

Lisa Adams

“Please tell them you did not destroy a rat in any sort of inside situation.”