Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello, everyone! Today I wanted to explain some of my design decisions regarding Broken Shores 2e. Some people seem to be bothered by the fact that the second edition of the game isn't backwards compatible. To be blunt, I think doing so would be a scam. Releasing a second edition with so few changes that keeps the game compatible with previous editions is something that I honestly think is just a cash grab. For example, the new Warhammer Fantasy edition, or the new GURPS edition. The changes are so few that they should have been free updates. I understand why big companies such as Cubicle 7 and Steve Jackson games can't do that, though, but me? I can do whatever I want.

And that's exactly what I did with Ker Nethalas Gravebound Edition. According to what most other companies do, I should have labeled it as a second edition and charge everyone for it. But I honestly thought that wasn't fair, and offered free upgrades to everyone. So when I say that Broken Shores 2e is a new edition, that means it truly is a new game. It still uses a D100 ruleset, the setting is the same, the lore is the same, so lots of things will be familiar to those that own 1e. But the changes and additions are so vast that I can't just offer this as a free update; 2e has about 2.5 times the amount of content 1e had, and uses all-original art, as opposed to the mix of commissioned art and stock art from 1e.

Why the big departure from 1e rules, I hear you ask? Well, the 1e rules were essentially my interpretation of Chaosium's BRP engine, and as such it dragged many of the issues I have with that ruleset (mainly combat being boring as hell). It also introduced ideas and mechanics that didn't work very well with that existing foundation. And over the years since I first worked on 1e, I've developed and refined my own system, what I am now calling the Momentum Engine, and have decided to use it with as many of my new games as possible. This is a game engine that has been tried and tested for years now, and even though I always make tweaks and changes to the core formula, it will be familiar to anyone who has played other of my more recent games, such as Ker Nethalas Gravebound, or Warlord Ascendant 2e.

Using the old 1e rules would have resulted in a worse game, plain and simple. The reason why I decided to work on a second edition was precisely because those old rules really don't represent what I am capable of doing now, they are extremely dated and I don't think they have aged well. They are confusing and clumsy, and if people enjoyed the game it was purely thanks to the interesting setting and the sandbox nature of it. Those two core elements have been preserved and expanded in 2e, and they are now being supported by a solid ruleset that I understand and am comfortable working with, so I can guarantee everyone that 2e is a far superior game to 1e.

So all I ask is: give it a chance. Take a look at the gameplay videos that are starting to appear, listen to my interviews discussing it, and see it for yourself. If you enjoyed 1e I can guarantee you will love 2e. And no, I will not release a third edition in a couple of years, because I've made sure 2e has a solid foundation to work with for years to come.

Don't forget to follow the Kickstarter campaign, which will launch the 5th of October!

Files

Comments

MightyK

I think backwards compatibility only makes sense if there is tons of content from the first edition you would like to play with the new edition. But as that's not really the case, what exactly would 2e compatible with? I think it's perfectly fine to release a 2e that's really a second, completely new edition. Like pathfinder 2e for example.

Carlos Jimenez

I don't understand the need for backwards compatibility, unless I'm wrong, except Egrestea content, all the content of the first edition is already in the new second edition book.

Carlos Jimenez

Maybe they use house rules and/or custom monsters or NPCs, but it shouldn't be difficult to convert to the new edition, right?