How to balance encounters?
- Level Based 9
- Character Level Responsive 13
- Some other option, please comment below! 1
Hello, everyone! I'm in the middle of writing the combat encounters for my next game, Ker Nethalas: Into the Midnight Throne, and I'm faced with the same, usual problems that pop up each time I make a game: how do I balance this thing? Right now I'm contemplating two options:
- Level based: The classical way to balance enemies. You are level X, and will only fight enemies found in the encounter tables specifically tailored to that level. We all know how this goes: a level 1 character will face a lot of kobolds and that sort of easy opponents, and a level 20 will see a lot of dragons and planar monstrosities (these are not examples taken from my game, there are no kobolds or dragons). The higher the level, the more complex enemies become.
- Character level-responsive: What I mean by this is that you have a large list of enemies (I'm thinking Ker Nethalas will have about 50 different types of monsters at launch), and each one of them has a basic stat block. This basic stat block is modified by some parameters that are tied to your character's level. So when you face a kobold at level 1 it will be theoretically balanced to your level, but facing it at level 15 would mean that it's been buffed to your level, becoming as much of a threat as it was when you first encountered. Anyone familiar with Skyrim knows how this goes.
Each method has its advantages and disadvantages: with level based, you can get a bit tired of facing the same monsters all the time until you level up, but it's really easy to use because you just grab the monster's stat block and start rolling. With the responsive method, you never really know what you're going to face, but it can be annoying to have to adapt each encounter to your current level. It's not like there's a lot of math involved (it would be just adding more HP, better attacks and/or armor, and that sort of stuff), but it does slow down gameplay a bit.
My first inclination has been to go classic and make a table of enemies for each level. Later on you can find Elite versions of easier enemies, with their stats increased to match your higher level. But you're still just facing a smaller range of monsters each level.
So what do you guys think, what's the best option?
EDIT: Just in case it's not clear, in both cases I'm planning on combat to be always somewhat balanced, your character's level is always taken into account. My question is not if I should add balanced combat or not, it's HOW to do so. Ker Nethalas is a survival dungeon crawling game closer to a tabletop, not truly a real RPG with all the freedom that RPGs have. At least, not mechanically, speaking.