Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

PROGRAMMING NOTE: Our immediate post-midterms coverage will be during the live show on Friday (then some more after that.) Your electionslop is coming! But to give us time to prep for the show we banked an episode with Derek Davison and Eleanor Janega, talking their new podcast season on the Second Crusades. We once again look at the idea of the crusades as it exists in the right’s memory versus what actually happened, how crusading was LARPing even at the time, and how a millennium’s worth of valorizing defeat led us to Pete Hegseth.

Find Welcome to the Crusades from American Prestige at: welcometothecrusades.com

Files

Comments

Bide

Been refreshing all day for this one 🙌

Nick

was just playing ck2 lmao

Tommy U

excited for the mp let’s play but it seems mean to exclude mr. ettingermentum

Kyle B

Sixth and I’m gay

Ben H

CK2 goated game

jaytaiko

- Haley Stevens

A Kayyy

the episode has nothing to do what that lol

Pete Bondurant

Lmao not quite. Wouldn’t be Chapo if they didn’t keep us waiting for the slop.

Adam Nir

DR ELEANOR IS BACK FUCK YES

Kapjak

This is slop of unparalleled quality

Swagmoder

I never learned how to play ck2 but ck3 is goated

chubbs941

I was literally just listening ezra klein's post election coverage and feeling my blood pressure exploding. I NEED MY SLOP FELLAS

mdog

youre joking

Reece Coren

Love all the new podcasts you guys are introducing us to 💙

Kirk Lazarus

CK2 with the Game Of Thrones mod is elite. Probably my most played game ever.

Mickey Quinn (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-08 00:00 Pete Hegseth’s currently doing leg lifts while trapped inside the head of a 50ft wicker effigy that’s about to be set ablaze…
2026-11-05 23:11 Pete Hegseth’s currently doing leg lifts while trapped inside a 50ft wicker effigy that’s about to be set ablaze…

Pete Hegseth’s currently doing leg lifts while trapped inside a 50ft wicker effigy that’s about to be set ablaze…

ploob

Hi I'm gay actor Jeff Goldblum!

Horse Badorties

The most fascinating thing about the bogus right-wing medieval history is that the IRGC is the modern-day equivalent of the Templars.

Blank

Perfectly timed for my commute, fuck yes god is good

myminisinavice

DR. JANEGA MY FUCKING QUEEN LET’S GOOOOOOO

RanRan Bobandy

This new season of The Player's Club seems a little light on video games. I mean, I never played Crusader Kings II but I still want to listen to what the game is about.

Trevor Brandt

Any valorization of the crusades can be immediately laughed at as soon as you read about the 4th crusade lol.

jer

Post election but no post election coverage. K

Alex

Eleanor keeps calling crusaders “white boys”. This seems to me like she can’t stop bringing in her culture wars into the topic.

More Human than Human

Literal politics podcast can’t do podcasts about politics when the politics happen

Juno Kraköwski

Chapo taking the election loss real hard. So sad to see.

John

*Squeezes balls*

Slumbertron

Love CK2 but Victoria 3 is the best.

Plarp

PEE ON ME.

OleKyShark

Bruh. My slop. Please.

Kamran Husain

she blew on my wave til i was like heil heila

The Real Spiro Agnew

Crusades coverage? On my Chapo? What is this, Radio War Nerd?

Tvvvv

What were midterm policies for the democrats? What was their platform? It seemed like accusing people of rape and of being pedophiles. I wasn’t really able to discern the vision.

Harry P. Ness

Dr. Eleanor S tier guest on any show

Greasy_Jones

Predator handshake meme and it's Islam and Reformed Norse Pagans beating on Christians together

Shuff Head

Uhm, actually, St Bernards were named after St Bernard of Menthon, not St Bernard of Clairvaux!!

Wes

Where the heck is Frawns

Eamon Short (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-07 03:00 34:09 I mean, there's a pretty good reason if you put yourself in their heads pace at their time. It's to avoid a whole Seljuk / Ottoman situation where if the second son is better liked or more adapt, its just gonna start a huge civil war and permanently prune the dynastic tree. Better to have a bunch of sons, take your bet the education will work, and the 1st well be at least competent, send 1 to the church, and depending on the time 1 to the law, and marry the rest off for alliances. The people might have been working in a stupid system, but I loathe this idea that people of the past were inheritly, on a genetic level, preternaturally somehow so much stupider than us.
2026-11-06 00:43 34:09 I mean, there's a pretty good reason if you put yourself in their head-space, at their time. It's to avoid a whole Seljuk / Ottoman situation where if the second son is better liked or more adept, its just gonna start a huge civil war and permanently prune the dynastic tree. Better to have a bunch of sons, take your bet the education will work, and the 1st will be at least competent, send 1 to the church, and depending on the time 1 to the law (or keep around, as an advisor), and marry the rest off for alliances. The people might have been working in a stupid system, but I loathe this idea that people of the past were inheritly, on a genetic level, preternaturally somehow so much stupider than us.

34:09 I mean, there's a pretty good reason if you put yourself in their head-space, at their time. It's to avoid a whole Seljuk / Ottoman situation where if the second son is better liked or more adept, its just gonna start a huge civil war and permanently prune the dynastic tree. Better to have a bunch of sons, take your bet the education will work, and the 1st will be at least competent, send 1 to the church, and depending on the time 1 to the law (or keep around, as an advisor), and marry the rest off for alliances. The people might have been working in a stupid system, but I loathe this idea that people of the past were inheritly, on a genetic level, preternaturally somehow so much stupider than us.

Squeet Deedle (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-09 09:00 Only thing worse than the delayed post election ep is also finding out it's gonna be audio of a live show
2026-11-06 00:46 Only thing worse than the delayed post election ep is also finding out it's gonna be audio of a live show [Edit; I did not expect this comment to get much motion, I am lightly ribbing the boys, I'm also gonna probably make another joke when they invite Ettingermentum on to tell me that Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries are Elite Ball Knowers who I have to respect now or whatever, it's all fine]

Only thing worse than the delayed post election ep is also finding out it's gonna be audio of a live show [Edit; I did not expect this comment to get much motion, I am lightly ribbing the boys, I'm also gonna probably make another joke when they invite Ettingermentum on to tell me that Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries are Elite Ball Knowers who I have to respect now or whatever, it's all fine]

Eamon Short

That's how most academic, educated people, in anglo places not in America say it.

Jim Chapman

If my grandpa could have saved money on his taxes by converting to Islam, I’d be praying to Mecca five times a day.

Richard Cochnar

I speak Burger-English not the Queen’s English.

Ben Kelley

I like when you think there will be no Felix, but then one hour and eight minutes passes and you're like: "Oh. There he is."

Esteé Dee

All slop is good slop my dear Mr chapo

Casserolboi

Am i going insane or did we get an epic Felix jump scare at an hour and 7 minutes and 40 seconds? Killed me lol. I love these guests, brought me back to binging hell on earth with matt.. 2000% better than more fucking midterm coverage

ADIFT

Gonna assume the real crusades are somewhere between the 'Pete Hegseth deus vult' version and the 'honey babe messy bitch it's as simple as that' version

Casserolboi

I loved ck2 but it's pretty sandboxy...

Quaritch

Felix begins speaking

Bob

Babe

Robert E LGBT

Why does the woman keep talking about Frahnts?

Nathaniel Weiner

Can't remember the last time a host pushed back against something a guest said. Not complaining but I didn't even know he was in the room.

Troy Mesman

Are you stupid? She's literally contrasting the white European invaders to the non-white west Asian people they were invading. She is just using modern lingo to accurately describe the scenario. It was also in service of the grander parallels between the crusades and modern Christian nationalist ideology. You didn't listen to the episode there's no way, you're just a Strasserist who listens to chapo ironically and it's the first time you realized they're on the left of the political spectrum. Culture war? Get out of here with that shit. Any reference to race as a distinguishing, or explanatory factor in any historical context does not a culture war make. I know Chapo favors a material analysis, but all of them also acknowledge the underlying white supremacy that undergirds the ideology of both European and American hegemony.

Science Bitch

Is it not at least slightly odd to take such a triumphally reductive view on a topic you notionally specialise in. If all you really need to know is that the crusades were just white boys bein white, what actually is the point of the scholarship

etienne

went to the Museum of Inquisition at Carcassonne because I thought it would be a pretty ironic death metal thing but I got out of it kinda shook

JD Nonce

I watched that and when he said ‘democrats won because they picked up candidates that fit their states and districts’ my jaw hit the floor. Like yes this is so fucking obvious how are you getting paid to say this. And then he said something how democrats should allow for ideological diversity (within reason) along the central axis of affordability and they should be tailored for the community they are representing. Again, that’s so fucking obvious!!! He was saying these things as if he was a man seeing clearly after coming out of cataract surgery

BROKEN JAR

dead ass i think felix starts speaking at 1 hour and 8 minutes

etienne

idk how you come to that conclusion when the guest is trying to lay down the exact power struggles on both sides of the equation that made the crusades happen, maybe you're just literally disregarding what she says because some reason that I can only theorize on

JD Nonce

Oh he also said ‘voters don’t like it when their lives get worse.’ WOW THANKS FOR THE INSIGHT

Tim O'

That's more desperate than smoking resin. Be strong, brother 🫂

Ghordo

lol Will had no idea what was coming at the start of this recording

Keith

Haley Stevens is hot, and her boyfriend fucks. These are the lessons of the midterms.

JP

It’s the crusades, babe

Punished Smooth Shrek

If you want a politics podcast go listen to Pod Save America. This is Chapo

Alex

Wow, i hope you are young and with time you will become a bit less angry-for-no-particular-reason. Anyhow, “white”, as it is used by American culture warriors today, is certainly a much later (historically) invention than Crudades. Eleanor is surely aware of this, yet chooses to pander to other semi-educated Americans for some reason.

Christopher Price

it ended better than when he pushed back against David Cross

Tvvvv

Eleanor has an amazing voice.

Alex

I don't think she is a scholar, rather a precarious grifter in the gig economy of attention who happens to have a PhD in medieval history.

Richard Cochnar

Never heard of her before but she’s an instant favorite. Extremely fun to listen to

Scott Gunsaullus

Yup, more slop pls. I already subscribe to the Davisonverse.

W

Fuck yeah, Dr. J

roland00

the second crusade is important due to eleanor / portrayed by Katharine Hepburn

Amer Naik

I hate you all, I want my $5 back

Shiv

DR J!!

EVIL PLANET

Oh great, the post-election episode is a fucking live episode. Lovely

Mikey

Post midterms go back to the episode where they have DJ Byrnes on. It has all the signs of things to come.

Mikey

Yet somehow he barely clears Matt Yglesias

Mikey

Brandonization, if it happened to Trump what made you think it wouldn’t happen to Chapo?

Yander Fawf (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-06 23:00 Are they posting the live show? Don’t they tend not tot to typically?
2026-11-06 04:41 Are they posting the live show? Don’t they tend not to typically?

Are they posting the live show? Don’t they tend not to typically?

Will

Dr. Janega is brilliant, but the way she says "France" makes me want to scream. YOU ARE FROM TACOMA, ELEANOR

ObsBlk

Excellent display of antipathy for your audience, Mr. Chapo.

Rastopop

Sorry Dr J's so impossible to listen to. Way too much editorializing in her historical descriptions that leave everything even less clear as to what was going on. So sad.

Carter Kriss

lived my entire life in Texas and can confirm no one wants to go to Odessa

EZ

An element of excommunication that really needs to be considered (maybe it will be; I’m only 23 minutes in) is how psychologically terrifying it would have been to have been designated as such. It’s hard for modern minds, but these dudes believed in literal god and heaven and hell. Excommunication meant you were going to fucking hell. Perhaps some monarchs etc were “atheists” as we would refer to them today, but the idea of such a belief was so far outside the realm of possible belief. I’m so curious about how we understand history when populated by people who were literally afraid of going to hell. It’s a material concern that we don’t necessarily have today in modern times.

EZ

It’s modern lingo that doesn’t map onto the historical period she’s discussing. Religious difference was FAR more important than “racial” difference, a concept that itself didn’t exist at the time. The concept of “white boys” would have been inscrutable at the time. It was all a matter of Christendom versus everyone else, ie Turks and Mohammedans and all of the other idiosyncratic ways they had of defining groups at the time. Eleanor reeks of being a try-hard “cool professor.” Too bad she is trading in modern shibboleths rather than historical accuracy.

EZ

Ahem

EZ

Is Eleanor not in America? Don’t care, but she sure sounds like that’s where she was educated, at least.

Sexual Harry Potter

I thought Will was saying hegseth was literally a crusader kings 2 fan 😭 I didn’t realize “deus vult” became well known today because of ck2. it’s hilarious to imagine him trying to play a Paradox strategy game, id give it no more than 5 minutes before he’s smashing a whiskey bottle through the screen in rage because he lacks the baseline literacy and cognitive ability to complete the tutorial

EZ

Really insulting historical interpretation happening here. I totally get having a useless PhD. Welcome to the club. Don’t make history stupid to make it marketable, babes

EZ

I agree with half of this statement

taejo-pom

Boooooooo feed me election slop fuck this

John Lisowy

*Felix part of the ep begins at the last 25mins

Michael S. Judge

I sympathize, cos on the one hand, "Frontz," but on another, it's really hard to study something in great detail and not feel like a fuckin' dickhead when you say it wrong

Zachary J Rodell

Is there a podcast anyone can recommend where i can get the election slope now before its too old

Jesse R

I thought this was going to be a video games episode

Sexual Harry Potter

Absolutely enraging. How long did he spend smugly telling leftists that overwhelmingly popular economic policies like universal healthcare or not funding genocide were just not “pragmatic” and that Kamala lost because they didn’t have enough data analysts and she was sabotaged by “the groups” ? I hope someone reminds this clown every day of his life that his suggested policy platform was zoning laws, cutting red tape to make way for technological development, and ass backwards ideas of reindustrialization and building state capacity that always seemed to end in deregulation. I truly could have never imagined just how poorly abundance YIMBYism would age considering the trump admin’s signature economic policies are a failed reindustrialization via tariffs and cutting red tape to put data centers in everyone’s backyard in service of religious devotion to AI development.

Sexual Harry Potter

Go listen to Ezra Klein buddy this ain’t that type of show

Sexual Harry Potter

I don’t think it’s fair for them to say only the first one succeeded when the 4th one successfully sacked Constantinople and undermined the primary Christian stronghold in the east, something Muslims took centuries to accomplish

zach

Timely

RFK'S BRAINWORM

What is this fucking shit!? I pay money for this shit!?

SM

She’s a frequent guest on TrashFuture if you’ve heard of that podcast. Her writing is very good as well (not a shock)

Sexual Harry Potter

Please demand all future guests do not pronounce France like that or I will be forced to unsubscribe and find a more proletarian podcast

Aria

felix is Lion

Rastopop

Interdiction of a kingdom was also quite bad, meant no sacraments could be performed; no marriages, baptisms, no last rites, the dead couldn't be buried in consecrated ground, plus church bells couldn't be run. Of course some kings didn't mind because they could collect the rents from the church's lands.

Hot Rod

He was preparing voters for accepting the failures of this coming Congress to pass any kind of universal programming, or to prep voters to defend the next Manchin, Baucus or Sinema who will inevitably come out of this midterm and dilute any M4A proposals. “Ope the parliamentarian says we can’t; sorry comrades” - some new rep in Mississippi in 2029

Billy Gray

They’re dabbing on us folks 🪩

Brent

Hilarious and sad, but this stuff actually is relevant to our politics today

Brent

we can Frawnce if we want to we can leave your friends behind ‘cause your friends don’t Frawnce and if they don’t Frawnce well they’re no friends of mine

Rastopop

Agreed, it's one thing to use contemporary language to clarify the past to a modern audience. But Dr J seems to go way too far in this direction that it completely obscures what she is trying to convey. Rather than illuminating the past or demonstrating the unique complexity of a different time she ends up flattening everything into an uninteresting mass.

Bi War Criminal

Why the fuck did they do this episode with the midterms happening this week? Lmao

Glo-Lo

Are we saying Fronce now?

JD Peery

Between Two Fires MENTIONED

Jackson

First time he speaks is to tell the female guest she’s wrong

Miguel-swanson

between two fires mentioned! that's crazy, I just finished reading it this morning. the descent into hell particularly disturbed me in part due to my christian upbringing

Jessica

Politics delayed is politics denied

Jessica

Coverage delayed is coverage denied

Shoals

I thought this was gonna be a Felix episode 😭

C. Andrew

There's a blue wave and you're laughing

Richard Cochnar

Was probably playing counter strike and forgot to show up. A well-deserved “Welcome to work, diva 💅” to him.

Joseph

We’re so back. Awesome episode with great guests

Twall

MAPPP GAMEEEEEEEEE

Michael

HistoryHit heads eating good

DMac94

@EZ No, pretty sure she currently lives and works in the UK and has been there a while

Plarp

It's cool that it's not really a bit anymore. You just sincerely hate your audience.

Ryan Humphrey

Anybody need a ticket for the show tonight? Can't make it.

jordan

Great episode. libbed up losers in the comments need to know their place!

Reece Coren

But I still don’t understand why you guys chose to fumble this moment so bad

Jessica Rios

Unacceptable. You guys call it in all the time since Matt left and it sucks.

johnwaynesmom

Lol y'all are actually crazy for this one

Zack Burke

Between Two Fires is so fuckin' good!

K H

That explanation of the Pope makes so much sense. They needed a third neutral party to modulate killing each other. Otherwise it would be too fraught. I feel like the feudal system also makes training more than one possible successor a dangerous prospect to dynastic cohesion.

Punished Smooth Shrek

Look, I don’t want to be “that guy” but this is not the episode for the times. I mean, where the hell is the new Landman coverage?!!!

Peter

Even by Felix standards, this was a late entry.

J L

hey guys great ep sendwomen love to see derrick and eleanor back on the pod sendwomen they’re always such great guests

J L (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-10 01:00 i thought you were joking, but no, felix jumpscare
2026-11-06 17:04 i thought you were joking, but no, felix is silent for an hour and 7 minutes

i thought you were joking, but no, felix is silent for an hour and 7 minutes

Kmicky

That shit got me so hyped!!! One of my favorite books I’ve read in the past few years I can’t recommend it enough for fans of horror or medieval stuff. I picked it up in passing and finished the entire thing in one reading session, it’s impossible to put down!

Dan McLain

Grossly oversimplified Roman (Byzantine) POV in this one - First Crusade called for to get Anatolian land back, Levant was not on Byzantine radar whatsoever. Also emperor Manuel gave the 2nd crusade leaders good advice re: the Turks which they completely ignored and led to the destruction of the German army

absoluteboi

damn it's rough when you're the only person laughing at your jokes. stop trying to make every sentence into some whimsical millennial post and people wont get tired of your personality as quickly.

Michael Adams

You're only getting away with this Chapo because I love Derek and Eleanor so much

NarsilsBane

She's not bad, but she applies a very heavy post-modern interpretation to historical figures & events. She reminds me of people who watched Kingdom of Heaven and think that's how history actually looks.

Phyction

real felix jumpscare on this one

EnKaff

Using racial terms to describe people from the Middle Ages is an anachronism. Professional historians definitely shouldn't be using those terms.

Thomas Côté

I for one am happy to be not hearing more elections coverage lmao squeel amerifats

chubbs941

The thing that really drove me insane was that while he was making all of these bog standard observations about the best candidate fit, he totally downplayed the fact that every single last one of them, from Talafreako, to AES, and even Roy fucking Cooper ran on a populist message against billionaires and corruption. I wouldn't even say that "candidate quality" didn't matter, but come the fuck on ezra

Timothy Buttons

I can't help but feel bad for Derek and Eleanor, it's not their fault that the episode they recorded last week ended up being the Chapo midterms followup

Jack Ross

Jumpscare from Felix not saying anything until over an hour into the show

Carlo Reyna

beach resorts and endless cruises are the modern day peasant pilgrimage

Hank

It's almost like she's making a joke or something.

Hank

Fart sound

Mia

and his mic sounds like it was dipped in the bath

Shabd

Eleanor rules but I can’t stand how she says France 😭 great ep

Justin Friedman

Idk what would be worse, this medieval historical bullshit no one cares about or an electionslop ep with Ettingermentum

Keenan Fitzgerald

Where’d all these MSNOW viewers come from begging for the same election takes we’ve read 1000 times on twitter for the last two days. Eat your History Slop and like it.

Valentino

Comment section is gay

ridiculouspump

Legit when Felix spoke that was like seeing a ghost

Jacobo

I personally really am happy with a Derek Davison episode

gumb0

Felix is point shaving what time he starts speaking

Boochie Seriouss

That memey, colloquialized way of describing history (i.e. calling a medieval queen a baddie for context) is bad form. It plays like a high school history teacher trying to win over a class of bored kids, and makes it hard to take this seriously.

D

They're dabbing on us.

Emir Stukov

What the fuck is this bullshit. Post midterm coverage. Seriously, you have ONE job.

Jason Matthews

Laura Palmer ended up there in the last episode of Twin Peaks: The Return, if memory serves. She was pretty eager to leave.

Aedan

crazy seeing the angry mob here lmao. i was pleasantly surprised for history ep. this is christman pilled

Trevor Brandt

Agreed, hence why I say the 4th crusade makes the whole idea of the crusades so laughable. The crusaders (backed mostly by the Venetians) handed Christianity its biggest L in history, and supercharged the demise of the Byzantines, which never really recovered from the sack.

Russell Elmore

Is it just me or for the last month or so has Felix been straight contrarianism in every thing he says? Like I get the feeling he'd say the sun was blue given the chance sometimes.

Russell Elmore

Just wanted to say I can't wait to bust out Bernard of Clairvaux and Eleanor of Aquitaine for my next Dennis Miller impression. Plenty of "babes" in the chamber too. I wish Dr J would say "Chachi" occasionally!

Juan

The existence of a papal bull implies the existence of a papal cuck

angel

Well this is more than a bit of a let down.

Ted Lavender

Bold seeing as this is an Amerifat politics podcast.

Savannakhet

Bernard of Clairvaux "you can just do things y'know."

jugsdotgov

I got as excited as the crusaders did about having heard of Damascus when I looked up dr Eleanor and learned she’s from Tacoma

Tom

I do disagree with Will, you do need to watch the directors cut of Kingdom of Heaven.

jg

Whose idea was this delay ass bullshit Hakeem Jeffries?

Broadway Joe

She was also on one of the Appendix episodes for the “Hell on Earth” series Matt and Chris did.

GriftOfTheMagi

Just wanted to list pods that I have listened to this week that are in my normal rotation because I was actively seeking election discussion Pod save America (good lord I made it like 25 mins! Majority report (listen often but not every day like this week) Trill billies (Aaron’s laugh is grating but I enjoy this show) Anyway by the time chapo posts anything about the most overwhelming midterm win our lifetime I will prob be seeking out non election related stuff like maybe a history episode or something

glieb

“frahnce”

Fernslinger

Holy shit! Felix was there the whole time!!!

The Steel Harvest

"Preachers were the equivalent of the uncs freestyling on the street." Some of us listened to the HOE appendices

Ted Lavender

It took all of my willpower to keep listening after Eleanor of Aquitaine said “alright, bet.” Mr. Christman would never stoop so low.

Bil

I’m sorry but these guys are not good. Welcome to the crusades is good because D & D keep things moving but We’re Not So Different is unlistenable. Just bad content…

Chas Padunski

I said this on the last crusades ep, but I really don’t think Eleanor and David adequately establish that the crusades are actually connected to our dumb and endless neocon wars. There’s definitely a conceptual similarity. And there’s no doubt the crusaders were dolts. But most of this is just “don’t these two things sound similar!?” I think it’s much more helpful to think of the crusades as a pressure release valve for Christian on Christian violence, which was rampant in this period. That and, as they say, a way for the Church to establish its authority. Along with many other factors of course. None of those have much to do with today’s middle eastern excursions. I don’t think the crusades form anything but the empty conceptual space for the invasion of Iraq, et al. There’s no real relationship between the two.

Chas Padunski

Thank you. I like her. But I’m a trained medievalist too. And it’s a bit annoying to see her takes become Gospel for non-experts.

Ted Lavender

The other thing to think about is if you paid for tickets to the 10 year anniversary show and then they talked about the midterm elections.

Ted Lavender

This guest is just Katherine Krueger doing a Katherine Krueger impression.

Kiel Cone

Yeah but it’s still a less annoying use of the word ‘baddy’ than labeling any random hot girl. Like Atleast she did something BAD.

Kiel Cone

Scapegoating comes with medieval history podcast territory.

Grubo

Felix realized he was muted an hour in

absoluteboi

yeah its interesting because as a culture we kinda accepted "bad" to be a modern colloquialism for "cool" mostly uncontroversially but then it turned out MJ was actually confessing

Dee Rubes

My favorite dirtbag medievalist on chapo! Weird she kept talking about “white boys” in medieval Europe tho, considering whose historical analysis they are criticizing. 🧐

cornholio

Beyond terrible. For being a doctor it’s insane to me that she boils it down to “everyone involved in the crusades was stupid. They didn’t plan it at all and only went because the first one worked.” That’s beyond inaccurate and intellectually dishonest.

cornholio

Yeah then she pronounced Iran “aye-rawn” lol

cornholio

Please end the millenializing of history it’s so annoying and hard to listen to

cornholio

Yeah it’s intellectually dishonest and also not really funny or informative

cornholio

I couldn’t keep count with all the laughing I wasn’t doing

cornholio

Precisely. The idea that the second crusade wasn’t planned at all is beyond ridiculous. Perhaps planned inadequately, but certainly there was planning. She’s a poor historian and the other guy is irrelevant.

Dank Spilf

they shouldn't let her get away with saying fronce.

Jon Beans

And still no audio released on patreon or the RSS feed, one day later

Eamon Short

We need Matt back for history episodes so desperately. The only one who ever pushes back on this stuff, because he actually understands how history, in the societal concept, works.

Adam Urato

To be fair we only pay them 2.4 million dollars a year and they work almost four hours a week

D

At this point I have to assume they are going to use the Friday live recording for their Monday episode. I'm all for the Chapo guys making their money, but this does seem fuckin lazy.

Scam Rodgers

soooo where's the live show epi??

wavylady

Ok but if there was no racial politics at play at the time why would they be conflicted about marrying Armenians?

Robert E LGBT

There must be some serious audio engineering going on because there is STILL no ep for the midterms

Jeffrey power

Great timing for a fucking CRUSADES EPISODE

Teddie Kelly

most embarrassing comment section of any podcast. hogs, hogs, all of you

More Human than Human

These guys owe Matt 96% of their paychecks. Period. That dude carried the whole damn show for years

Sexual Harry Potter

Idk, significantly more Christians died fighting Christians in Europe during the timeline of the crusades than the equivalent period leading up to them. And one of the biggest losses of credibility for the popes and crusaders that ended this was how frequently they were ordered to go kill other Christians for political purposes or chose to do so for persons gain. I do think it’s valid to say the crusades helped form the blueprint for colonialism, and colonialism definitely was a much needed pressure valve for intra European wars after the unprecedented bloodbath of the end of feudalism. Medieval Europe didn’t really have experience with settling faraway lands, exploiting local conflicts, extracting resources, and Christianizing them to this degree before the crusades, they worked out tactics in the Middle East and applied them in Africa and the new world. So in that way If you consider the war on Iran based out of Israel as a form of neocolonialism then I think it makes sense. But I agree they really did not give a satisfying explanation in the episode other than just saying it as if it’s self evident. And I think that can mislead people into thinking its radical religious beliefs motivating this

Sexual Harry Potter

I mean they’re not wrong but it would also be nice if they were offering something other than “we are not child molesters”

Sexual Harry Potter

@narsilsbane literally all I could think about through the episode was how she is essentially doing a reverse version of the chud narrative of the crusades. I used to be exactly like this so I totally understand being passionate about a subject and finding it incredibly annoying when its biggest fans are largely shitty people and morons. But at a certain point you gotta ask yourself how much of your historical analysis is actually just playing the culture war game by defaulting to the opposing opinion of whatever the people you dislike say. It’s a podcast not a research paper so there’s nothing wrong with communicating in a casual more engaging and relatable way but it gets to a point

Tvvvv

To think that some people may question felix’s value on the show.

EnKaff

Racism isn't the only form of bigotry. I think Americans have a hard time getting their heads around this, particularly when they think about the past, because their country developed in parallel with the birth of racist ideology.

EnKaff

The modern day salience of the crusades is entirely due to the invasion of Iraq. I'm old enough to remember the 90's when they were regarded as a mere historical footnote.

EnKaff

Do tell...

Fernslinger

The episode that finally broke Travis! RIP to a true hero

Chas Padunski

Your comment is actually to my point: yeah, they are the “empty conceptual space” certain warmongers use to interpret their own desires. But there is no actual, meaningful connection outside of that self-justification. Eleanor and Derek seem to suggest the Crusades inaugurated a millennium of white European desire for racialized conquest. And I’m just not sure that holds up. The fact that they disappeared from popular consciousness indicates they aren’t the engine of Americo-European interventionism, in fact.

Chas Padunski

Re: more Christians killing Christians after than before the crusades, you’re over-extending the timeline a bit, I think. It’s true that in the early modern period intra-European war killed an enormous number of people. But the very early Middle Ages were basically one gigantic kill fest among semi-Christianized Germans. The Pax Dei Movement, for example, is an early attempt by the church to rein in just the absolute low-grade slaughter aristocrats were engaged in. Movements like Pax Dei, the Crusades, and the institutionalization of aristocracy (making it a question of blood rather than conquest) did a lot to cut down on Christian on Christian violence, especially in the day to day. Of course, that’s the high Middle Ages. By the 17th century, which I think you’re referencing, that had fallen apart.

Savannakhet

The funniest scenario is that they skip talking about the mid terms and the next episode is a film episode about some shitty Ben Shapiro film.

AllyBat

Praying for this

Cory Gipson

I can’t think of a more pressing topic in the wake of a historic electoral wipeout than the fucking crusades

etienne

it was kind of a schlocky private run thing, they had pretty good info on the French kings who south to finally put the southern coast under proper crown control and stamp out that weird Cathar power base, but then it was just a shit ton of torture instruments and descriptions. 7/10 go if you like death metal

etienne

imagine a french chud being like "we need a crusade unto Toulouse"

billbo

Lol. This is pathetic

SinceIwas16

Almost a literal week since the massive midterm blue balls release & still nada? The emotional neglect is real. You realize we have DSM diagnoses & depend on slop to cope, right? Oh well, crusades it is.

Alex Payne

LFG I live for these American Prestige crossover eps

alec belcher

Ngl it's actually pretty disappointing even though I have minimal if not zero expectations already

Emily Beal

Not to be a hog, but does paying $5 a month just get you video game and movie eps now? If so, that’s fine! You’re prerogative. Just can’t really justify to myself doing it anymore after like 7 years

Leyland

Using Derek as a human shield here. Not cool!

Robert Buxton

Crusading is actually the least fun part of the Crusader Kings franchise.

E

In my mind Chapo is now the Will Menaker show and it's primarily a movie podcast and tbh that is fine.

TugNuggins

Why do you say that? We're the crusades not a series of idiotic blunders?

Baby J

He also said the midterms vindicated the abundance agenda. Lol.

oooeeeooo

I hope someone gets fired for that blunder

Doug Cartel

Crusader Krangs Yeah I don't know who to look up on this but I think the success of the Abrahamic religions is in part because of the low entry fee to get in, although I think I'm probably too lazy to pray five times a day

Doug Cartel

"lost cause" shit is definitey an attractive form of suicide. American Confederacy, Rhodesia, crusades, third Reich etc and on and on and on

Auragami

I heard this Elanor of Acutane had really nice skin.

K H

I quite liked this episode. Wish they expanded more on Sunni Shia division.

K H

I mean it's not that different to now and the various mideast wars we've had. That is an accurate if pithy summation of how we function.

Vodka Grinch

Know your enemy had a really great election recap

ADIFT

No, that's reductive. Sure there were lots of hilarious catastrophe campaigns as there have been forever in every war. But some captured territory for years. They distracted princes from continental politics and forged the careers of others. It's important not to idealize the crusades like the manosphere does, but this episode went so far in the other direction it felt like motivated storytelling. The author was getting buttmad in the middle of trying to descrbe things like a fox news pundit.

wavylady

Of course it isn’t, but to me the doctrine of discovery seems like an obvious development from the crusades’ theological rule bending. It doesn’t seem like a jump to say it was original recipe racist white boys

EnKaff

I think that's a different argument from saying people in the 11th Century didn't think in racial categories though.

Coleman

how about you accept my balls into your forehead

Coleman

Yea. I'd be 100% okay with not talking about midterms at all. It's not that complicated, and all the wikipedia pages have been updated at this point.

Jessica Rios

As soon as they drop the midterm show I’m canceling. They don’t have their hearts in it anymore and this is frankly insulting.

Andy

Babe

JASON

I think the boys snuck Rachel Maddow onto the Pod to talk about the crusades

Thomas Côté

Clearly it is now a euro-lean history podcast now

Henry

I mean they definitely work more than that. I think it's funny that you guys think they just chat on mic with no preparation, or that there aren't secondary tasks associated with having a very popular podcast. Its a very silly perspective

Henry

This was annoying of them though

Henry

lol my bad

newglarus

Where the hell is my election podcast