Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • The Night Before Larry Was Stretched - Fiddle Full Speed.mp3
  • The Night Before Larry Was Stretched - Fiddle Steady.mp3
  • The Night Before Larry Was Stretched - Guitar Full Speed.mp3
  • The Night Before Larry Was Stretched - Guitar Steady.mp3

Missing 1 full-res photo, 4 files, as this post has not yet been imported.

Files

Previews only

Comments

JB

So, I've a question. Why key of Bflat? Matin Hayes plays it in Gm, is that right? I'm not musical enough to understand why a particular key would be chosen. I'm certainly not talented enough to smoothly hit that fourth finger Eflat....so educate me. Why the key choice? It sounds better? The accompaniment chords work better? Or is that just the way you learnt it? So beautiful....thanks as always.

The Good Tune

Good question JB. Actually, just like Martin Hayes we are also playing this one in Gm. Gm has two flats in its key signature, just like Bb (they are relative major and minors), so you are right to have picked up on that two flats can be Bb, but in this case we're in the relative minor of Gm. Why certain tunes are written in certain keys - that's often to do with the sound and range you want. Have you ever played a tune in A major and noticed how bright and ringing it can sound on the fiddle? Try playing another one in Bb and you'll notice how the sound changes to a more closed, mellow tone. Each key will have a certain timbre, and each instrument will have a range. So composers will find what sound they want for particular instruments and compose from there. Keep practicing that 4th finger E flat! Remember, it's right next door to your 3rd finger D. You could always transpose and play in E minor for example, see how that sounds compared to Gm.

JB

I see, I see. Right...basic chord theory has always perplexed me. And a quick search of the Circle of 5ths showing Gm with the 2 flats would have sorted it for me. Thanks for taking the time. And yes...the Eflat on fourth finger has forced me to improve that. It is coming along. Thanks again! Super helpful