The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas (1982, Colin Higgins) (Patreon)
Content
46/100
Kicks off with Jim Narrator Nabors giving us the Chicken Ranch's complete history...and I gotta say, even with all the highly specific details related as exposition, it never once occurred to me that Best Little Whorehouse had been inspired by an actual brothel, shuttered less than a decade prior to this movie's release. That's far more interesting than anything onscreen wound up being, and while I haven't read the Playboy article that is Whorehouse's ur-text, it almost had to focus on broad community reaction. The story here is: How did locals handle the unexpected negative attention drawn by a crusading journalist to largely harmless vice that everyone had tacitly condoned for almost 130 years but that nobody was eager to actively defend? Do I want to know the answer to that question? Definitely. But do I want to see that scenario dramatized? Hmm. Feels like it would only work as some sort of ribald Our Town riff (which is what Nabors is sorta doing). Larry L. King's solution (writing with Peter Masterson) was to have Sheriff Ed Earl Dodd represent/embody town sentiment, a dynamic that the movie version undermines by making Ed Earl and Miss Mona, who onstage had briefly been lovers many years earlier, into a present-tense romantic duo. Ed's strenuous efforts to save the Chicken Ranch hence seem motivated by love, rather than by a wonky mix of affection, tradition and small-c conservatism. Which is a significant problem in that Burt Reynolds never seems, in this movie or his many others, to be in love with anyone but himself (even if he and Sally Field had some mutual horny chemistry at the outset). In any case, I'd argue that there's precious little narrative here and not much in the way of characters, either. The entire project seems founded upon innocuous PG-rated naughtiness, at a time when the -13 designation wasn't yet needed. Dolly Parton was its ideal madam: cartoonishly sexual without ever seeming remotely sexy.
All of which might be of little consequence if I considered Best Little Whorehouse to be a first-rate musical. That had always been my vague impression: acclaimed on Broadway, ruined by the dude who directed Foul Play and Nine to Five. I'd never encountered any of the numbers, though, and maybe that's because...they aren't so hot? Putting that interrogatively because I don't feel confident rendering judgment without having seen a solid stage production (especially given that roughly half of the musical's numbers were cut, in some cases to make room for Parton tunes both new and old; had no idea that "I Will Always Love You" made its movie debut here), but only "The Sidestep" seemed either inventive or catchy, and even that one has major scansion issues imo. (Plus some lyrical clumsiness—"I love to dance a little sidestep" rhymed exclusively/repeatedly with "I love to sweep around the wide step" feels like the songwriter quit early for lunch. Sondheim would've somehow found four different rhymes for that, including "obfuscate-without-having-lied prep"*) I note that Carol Hall had no other success on (or indeed off-)Broadway, which makes me inclined to suspect that folks are making allowances. Though the numbers generally aren't bad. Just, y'know, fine. Likewise the cast, apart from Dom DeLuise doing some weird, ineffective combo of Zero Mostel and Kenneth Mars ca. The Producers; Parton's extremely likeable, as always, and Reynolds tones down his self-regard a little opposite her, so that Miss Mona and Ed Earl do at least seem friendly (as they were originally meant to be). This decidedly did not make me excited to watch him sing in At Long Last Love, however.
Apparently the Chicken Ranch set still exists on the Universal Studios tour (and was reused by Rob Zombie for House of 1000 Corpses, of all things). I missed it by five years, did the tour in '77. Bruce the Shark was already in place, though.
* Requires stressing the wrong syllable of "obfuscate," but I'm not gonna spend the ten hours Sondheim would have to find an alternative that actually scans.