Cool Hand Luke (1967, Stuart Rosenberg) (Patreon)
Content
58/100
Second viewing, last seen on laserdisc in 1992. Might not be kosher to equate a work camp with a mental hospital—some key distinctions there, to be sure—but I nonetheless think this grim tale of an imprisoned-rebel-turned-martyr wound up being surpassed by One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, which actually predates Cool Hand Luke (Kesey's novel was published in 1962, Pearce's in 1965) despite arriving onscreen eight years later. Strengths are broadly similar: hugely charismatic lead performance (albeit in very different registers); hissable antagonist who hides sadism underneath a thin veneer of politesse; first-rate ensemble of future stars (here including Dennis Hopper, Wayne Rogers, Harry Dean Stanton, and an uncredited Joe Don Baker); clear-eyed acknowledgement that when you fight authority, authority always wins. But there are crucial differences, too, all of which to my mind favor Cuckoo's Nest. Randall P. McMurphy was a true gadfly who didn't initially realize how much power Nurse Ratched wielded over his future. Lucas Jackson's a more conventional Strong Silent Type, mostly keeping to himself, watchful and wary, under no illusions about his circumstances. Which I gotta say makes his repeated escapes less than credible—as Newman plays Luke, he just doesn't come across like someone who'd risk incurring additional time (unless drunk), given that he, unlike McMurphy, will otherwise be released fairly soon. Mostly, though, it's this film's much more blatant religious "subtext" that irks me. Not just risible imagery like Luke posed crucifixion-style after the egg-eating wager* (fun fact: Joey Chestnut once ate 141 eggs in eight minutes—nearly three times as many in ⅐ the time!), but the whole trajectory that eventually places Luke in a church for the finale, praying to a God in whom he doesn't believe. I'm also not in love with his mom's visit, laying out backstory, or with Luke reacting to news of her death by silently weeping as he plays "Plastic Jesus" on the banjo. Brutality notwithstanding, it's a sudsier film overall, less than the sum of its most memorable moments.
* In high school, I bet some friends that I could drink a full shot glass of Tabasco sauce. Which I could. I won. But trust me: Do not do that.