Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

39/100

Hope: nope. Na: nah.

Look, if slick, ultra-digital mayhem appeals to you—and I'm not saying it shouldn't, though "slick" admittedly rings pejorative—you're gonna have a blast with this. (Though I find it hard to imagine anyone not thinking Hope's 156 minutes a tad excessive.) Certainly it ain't boring. Gets wearisome, for those not delighted, but the nearly nonstop frenetic stimuli keep you alert. Probably helps if you play a lot of contemporary video games, as opposed to not having touched a joystick (are they still called that? how did the phallic connotation escape me as a kid?) since like 1986. Na takes everything I dug about Bong's The Host and does the opposite, starting with a cutesy game of visual keep-away—we repeatedly see the carnage wreaked by something massive and violent, corpses strewn everywhere, concrete walls shattered and cars hurled a full city block, but not the creature itself—that goes on for close to an hour. (By contrast, I will never forget the glorious cognitive dissonance of seeing that mutant fish-thing merrily gallumph down the riverside in broad daylight, out of nowhere.) What finally shows up onscreen could only be more blatantly computer-generated if it kept stopping to tell our heroes (such as they are) "It's not destruction, it's reconfiguration." Pace is breathless for remarkably long stretches but Na's too enamored for my taste of that cool-the-first-time-you-see-it shot in which someone tears ass toward the camera while the thing pursuing him slams into both frame and something solid from a parallel direction, sending (actual physical) objects flying in the background. Then the movie's structure gets very wonky, with the apparent threat neutralized but there's still 90 minutes of movie left so now we're just waiting for the damn shoe(s) to drop, which takes a small eternity of cross-cutting among three equally blah narrative threads. Excepting the plucky outraged female cop (played by Jung Ho-yeon from season one of Squid Game), I found the human characters uniformly repellent...which I think is intentional, Na attempts something kinda provocative (though hardly unprecedented) here w/r/t viewer identification, but the way that aspect unfolds/coalesces/concludes just seemed like an incoherent mess to me, possibly setting up as many as four sequels. So Hope—did I mention that the title's reminiscent of Clinton's '92 campaign? it's the damn town name—mostly just exhausted me. I love the idea of high-octane fun with an unexpected sting in the tail (pretend it's a gas-fueled scorpion if you don't care for mixed metaphors), but something about Na's approach scuttles even strong ideas. That's why The Wailing turned into The Bailing*.

* Though actually I should have stuck with that film, as I'd previously seen both The Chaser and The Yellow Sea. Neither of which I particularly liked (56 and 47, respectively), but I only "allow" myself to W/O if the director's work is unknown to me. Hence my staying to the end of, say, The Wizard of the Kremlin, despite its clear mediocrity. Anyway, I must have failed to recognize Na's name and neglected to double-check. The Wailing's been a Patreon request for a while now so odds are I'll be returning to it at some point. Wouldn't count on a change of heart, though.)

Files

Comments

Devan Suber

It really feels like a movie that was somehow cut in half. The ending was so abrupt.

boardsofcinema

I remember hearing that the version of this film that screened at Cannes apparently had horrendous creature CG, with David Ehrlich even calling it "some of the worst [he'd seen] since The Mummy Returns". In response, the director subsequently "fine-tuned" the film for the sole purpose of improving that (source: https://www.dreadcentral.com/news/582736/it-sounds-like-director-na-hong-jins-re-edit-of-hope-is-a-winner/). Assuming you didn't watch the Cannes cut, did the CG still look bad to you in the re-edited version you did see?

Mike D'Angelo

No idea which version they’re screening for press but it’s about to open so I assume it’s the revised one. The F/X didn’t seem “bad” to me, exactly. I’m just hostile to digital stuff that looks and moves like it’s computer-generated. I felt and still feel that way about much of Jurassic Park, which was revolutionary at the time. This looked video-game-ish to me in a way that for example Jackson’s Kong did not. But a lot of that’s how things move more than how they’re rendered.

Tiger Inn

Speaking for only myself (I liked the film a lot more than Mike) the CG still looks pretty bad, though some of the creatures look much more convincing (by dint of their designs) than others.

Cameron Watson

Does Fury Road not apply to that opening sentence?

Enrico Truffi

Rope - 45 Nope - 38 Hope - 39 If you want your movie to be liked by Mike, maybe don't call it with a four letter word that ends with -ope. (although there are at least three more "Hope"s that seem to be generally well regarded, so who knows)

Nick Vass

Rare exception: Dope (2015), which Mike liked! Otherwise, yeah, the -ope ain't doing any favors.