Free Solo (2018, Elizabeth Chai Vasarhelyi & Jimmy Chin) (Patreon)
Content
62/100
Sometimes you have to get up close to a thing before you can appreciate how truly insane it is. Nothing about climbing a steep granite mountain without ropes or other tools had ever seemed remotely safe to me, but the inherent danger, in my mind, was just gravity-based: After not too long, you're up high enough that if you slip and fall, you die. Doesn't sound appealing, so no thanks. When I'd picture it, though, there was still, to some degree, rather crucially, a grade. A slope. Having climbed rock formations near beaches as a kid, I naïvely imagined climbing Yosemite's El Capitan to be fundamentally a much much grander version of that playful endeavor, riskier only due to the elevation. Free Solo reveals that climbers like Alex Honnold rely on imperfections in the rockface so small that they're barely even visible to the camera. They bet their lives on ridges that wouldn't hold a goddamn pencil. It had never occurred to me that routes are minutely worked out in advance (on ropes), handhold by handhold and footstep by footstep—that the initial challenge lies simply in finding a path that a human being theoretically could navigate (which often requires climbing downward laterally for a while, because continuing up at that point is impossible). Even if you know in advance that he makes it to the top, whether by having seen (as I did) promotion for his Taipei tower climb earlier this year or just by suspecting that nobody would release (at least not right away) a documentary about a dude who plummeted to his death, Honnold's climactic ascent is at once awe-inspiring and nerve-wracking, a feat of athleticism and courage but also a testament to because-it-is-there cussedness.
Or maybe something else. While I can't imagine anyone other than terminal acrophobes not enjoying (or "enjoying," for marginal acrophobes) Free Solo's final 15-20 minutes, much of the film functions as a character study of Honnold, who I found...interesting. Curious. On the one hand, he's friendly, personable, admirably straightforward and self-aware, very easy to like. On the other hand, it didn't surprise me when one of the fellow climbers working on the film crew referred to him as Spock. Nor when his mother said that his father (now deceased) would today probably be diagnosed with Asperger syndrome. Armchair diagnosis can be unfair but there does seem to be something spectrum-y about Honnold's slight genial detachment from just about everything, including his girlfriend (now wife) and the prospect of dying. Vasarhelyi (who we never see) and Chin (who we frequently do) appear to be aware of this but also understandably reluctant to explore or emphasize it, and that cautious middle ground flirts with blandness at times. (The one slightly pointed moment we get is Sanni saying that she tells Alex she loves him every day and he [brief rueful pause] shows her that he loves her every day. Clearly they've made it work, though.) And then NatGeo apparently insisted upon ruining Honnold's most effusive outburst, when he looks straight into the camera and clearly says "Fuck yeah!" after successfully navigating what's called the Boulder Problem (via a physical maneuver you can't believe anyone would willingly undertake without multiple safety precautions), but his words are dubbed by someone else—possibly Yello's lead singer or the Kool-Aid Man, it's unclear—as "Ohhh yeah!" Even at the summit, having just achieved something nobody had ever done or I think even attempted, he keeps saying "I'm so delighted," which sounds like what an android thinks a human would say in that circumstance. ("I think the movie would be better if I burst into tears, but I don't really want to. Well I do want to, kinda, but...") So it feels to me as if the film is dancing around how odd its subject is.
Given that reticence (which, again, makes sense, as the alternative would likely have alienated someone who'd just as happily climb—would more happily climb, in fact—without being filmed), I wish significantly less attention had been paid to Honnold's personal life and much more to his preparation and process. Or just more of him scaling El Cap, which took four hours—there must be a lot more footage, unless they chose to film only the most treacherous pitches (i.e. sections; there's a whole mountain-climbing lingo, naturally). Which I suppose is possible, because many of the shots that are in the movie make you wonder where the hell the camera could possibly be. Did someone invent a helicopter that's capable of perfectly still hovering? A documentary about the making of this documentary might be almost as astounding.