TIFF 2026: Day Five (Patreon)
Content
Actually had what I consider a full five-film day, mostly from my shortlist (added one buzz item, which wound up being my favorite today), concluding with a 164-minute epic of sorts that went past midnight. Hence my not having time to post this report until now.
Bitter Christmas (Pedro Almodóvar, Spain): 55
Second consecutive movie (across two days; previous instance was Paradise Lost) that I thought had lost me until it unexpectedly rallied at the end by going totally nuts. This was a very different experience, though, perhaps unique in my long filmgoing life: I had a laundry list of complaints about Bitter Christmas—most of them structural; the film seemed bizarrely incoherent, forgetting all about key characters while abruptly introducing others far too late—and also felt mostly annoyed by its meta-frame whereby most of what we’re seeing is yet another blatant Almodóvar avatar’s semi-autobiographical script-in-progress. But then Almopseudóvar’s long-suffering assistant delivers a withering critique of said script that I kid you not hits every single mental objection that I’d filed over the preceding 90 or so minutes, making it clear that those weaknesses were deliberate, part of the film’s grand design. Not unprecedented, I just realized—it’s kinda like Adaptation’s janky home stretch, which doesn’t “work” but nonetheless does because we understand it was written by Donald Kaufman. In this case, you have to apply that understanding retroactively, and I’m not convinced that the present-tense frustration (which makes the movie feel much longer than its 111 minutes—nothing drags like apparent randomness) is really worth it. Still, bold move from an oldster.
The Beloved (Rodrigo Sorogoyen, Spain): 59
Second consecutive Spanish movie about a filmmaker’s tempestuous relationships and how they affect the creative process. This one’s easily summarized: It’s Sentimental Value had Reinsve’s character accepted the role in Dad’s film. (Javier Bardem plays the legendary director, Victoria Luengo—who, for additional continuity from the previous entry, was in Almodóvar’s The Room Next Door—his daughter. “Illegitimate” and barely recognized, in this case.) Much more emotionally straightforward, and to my mind significantly more effective, largely because it’s not cluttered with barely germane artistic curlicues. Boasts an absolute barnburner of a sequence featuring take after take after take of a superficially undemanding shot, as the director’s understandable frustration gradually crosses the line into abuse—it’s like Babylon’s “Hello, college!” scene, had that gone from hilarious to genuinely harrowing. Like too many films at this year’s TIFF (glorious exception: Bucking Fastard), The Beloved doesn’t end so much as just decide to take a permanent breather, and it didn’t really come alive for me until the aforementioned sustained on-set nightmare (which was past the midpoint, I’m pretty sure). But these felt like genuine characters, not symbolic constructs.
(Sorry, that was mostly just me taking more belated shots at the Trier, wasn’t it? Moving on…)
Once Upon a Time in Harlem (David Greaves, USA): 56
Friends dug this a bit more than I did, and I’d argue that the (terrific) movie they describe only really emerges during the last half hour or so. That’s when the soirée (held at Duke Ellington’s home in 1972…though, oddly, Sir Duke’s never seen) gets a little contentious, in a friendly way, with various luminaries asserting a salon-appropriate version of “I’ve got the conch!” and challenging each other’s memories and perception of the Harlem Renaissance. Bit of a polite free-for-all, invigorating as well as informative. Prior to that, William Greaves’ footage* plays a lot like standard-issue talking-head interviews (supplemented with archival stills), even when said heads talk whilst partying. (Looks to me like sometimes W. Greaves corralled people into another room in order to get more conventional uninterrupted documentary soundbites.) Historically invaluable, needless to say, and I can easily imagine it being a regular future double-bill with A Great Day in Harlem (same basic idea except they’re all jazz musicians). But I preferred the cacophonous conversation to the lengthy series of individual statements.
* ANAL-RETENTIVE CREDITING CORNER: Both TIFF and NYFF attribute the film’s direction to both William Graves and David Greaves (William’s son). Onscreen, however, it says “Conceived and filmed by William Greaves,” followed by “Directed by David Greaves.” Which I take to mean that David was primarily responsible for assembling the footage (all of which was shot in ’72, I believe, though there’s a little recent voiceover) into an actual movie. I therefore also consider it a 2026 film, unlike say Amazing Grace which I placed in 1972 because it’s clear that Pollack completed it back then apart from the soundtrack issues.
The Debut (Jesse Eisenberg, USA): 63
Always fun to bear witness to the birth of a classic comedy bit—something you know, even as it’s still in progress, that you’ll be seeing in awards-show montages for the rest of your life. (Only hindrance here is considerable profanity that’ll require bleeping.) Accurately described by Vikram Murthi (who may have been paraphrasing someone else, not sure) as Julianne Moore accelerating from Carol at the end of Safe to Magnolia’s pharmacy scene in roughly three minutes. Rest of the film’s often very funny, too, though some of it’s pitched too broad for my taste; as a community-theater vet, I was driven a little nuts by Eisenberg’s penchant for making Mona maximally clueless by not having Giamatti’s tetchy director give obvious notes like “Say that line more forcefully.” (Instead, he has her repeat it half a dozen times, gives no notes, then pulls her aside for what’s admittedly the finest acting exercise since Topsy-Turvy.) I laughed hardest at Mona’s various overcorrections in rehearsal—shouting every line at the top of her lungs, refusing to do anything that she can’t logically justify—while only occasionally chuckling at the outré flophouse stuff. And something about Eisenberg’s formal approach comes across as pushy to me, though I guess that’s arguably apropos here. His fake showtunes are magnificently mediocre, though, almost literally low-Rent.
The Dreamed Adventure (Valeska Grisebach, Austria/Bulgaria/Germany/France): 50
But ignore me if you loved Western (54/100; Skandies #6 for 2018), as this is very much in the same vein. (I’m still waiting for another Be My Star.) “Frustratingly remote,” I called that film, and Dreamed Adventure likewise failed to elevate my pulse much over the course of nearly three hours, even as it never sets a foot identifiably wrong. Narrative’s at once skeletal and hard to encapsulate, shifting protagonists maybe 45 minutes in (eventually returning to the original one for a while) and observing corruption and threats of violence along the Bulgarian-Turkish border. (I guess Greece is in there as well, consulting a map. Don’t recall much talk of Greece, though.) Protag #2’s an admirably tough archaeologist, and her refusal to take shit from the region’s petty tyrant—throughout, but particularly in their final scene together—gives the film some much-needed juice. But I can’t imagine a less apt title for this anti-oneiric portrait of characters just warily roaming around. Mulholland Drive is a dreamed adventure; this is as much the opposite of that as anything could possibly be. Which isn’t a bad thing per se. I just can’t pretend to have been excited by it, on any level, when I decidedly was not.