The Rivals of Amziah King (2025, Andrew Patterson) (Patreon)
Content
58/100
Nobody on Earth can beat Andrew Patterson right now when it comes to making the first ~20 minutes of a movie. In fact, I think he should make a feature that resets at every (theoretical) reel change—much like the first two parts of La flor, it could be a series of bravura openings that never conclude. His conclusions, and indeed his plain ol' extensions, still need a lotta work. What's remarkable is that Amziah King barely resembles The Vast of Night, apart from unfolding with similar bold self-confidence; the two films are distinct not just tonally but also formally, with Patterson here fashioning a hectic rhythm from rapid-fire cutting and unexpected freeze-frames. Only the dialogue's a giveaway—I'd forgotten that he used the same pseudonym on Vast, paused to look up "James Montague" 11 minutes in, when Amziah says of Colmar "He's a combative little scoop of a man, ain't he?" (It wasn't that line alone, but that was when I thought "No way is this not Patterson.") Anyway, the movie's one magnificent WTF after another for a while, with a jam-band intro outside a sandwich joint somehow giving way to extremely detailed apiculture that then takes a turn for the hilariously grisly, so that you can't help but wonder, in pure delight, "What is this movie?" It's such a joy to see something so locked into its own offbeat trajectory, confident that you'll come along for the ride without having a clue about what the destination might be. (Tony Revolori's presence inevitably makes you think of Wes Anderson—totally different vibe, but a similar disregard for convention.) McConaughey fits right in, too, making the words and attitude his own. But I'd heard tell that it doesn't last...
Alas, it does not. I feel uncomfortable suggesting that The Rivals of Amziah King goes south when it shifts focus from a white dude to a young Native American woman, but honestly I winced before Kateri even appeared, because Patterson's direction abruptly turns hack-y when setting up her entrance: Amziah sits down in a diner booth, and I swear I knew, just from the way that the camera was deliberately keeping the server out of frame for no apparent reason, that she was about to become the movie's female lead (despite my having no advance knowledge that there was a female lead—hell, I didn't even know McConaughey's in it). Not Angelina LookingGlass's fault, by any means (though imo she at this point lacks the innate charisma and/or technical skill to be as central as Kateri becomes)—introducing that character re-weights the film to a degree that kills the established vibe, replacing it with something that's still unusual yet somehow more ordinary, or at least less exhilarating. The potluck scene in which Amziah has a cute little anecdote for each dish felt sweaty/pushy in a way that nothing previously had (there's even a running gag about someone repeatedly walking into glass doors), and I was frankly ready to bail at 40 minutes, following a lengthy beekeeping primer right out of a nature doc. Stuck with it because a. the film still wasn't bad or anything (I could just intuit that I was gonna wind up 'mixed') and b. I estimated an 80% chance that I'd need to watch the whole thing come year's end, so might as well keep going.
Then something happens that I did not anticipate (or, rather, I assumed it would come much later in the film than it does; certainly Patterson establishes the possibility early on), which I will not reveal so as to avoid a spoiler warning, but which decidedly did not help. The revenge/heist tale that follows has moments (mostly courtesy of Jake Horowitz) but also—and I'm relieved to see that others feel similarly—goes bizarrely astray by having Kateri take actions that are wildly disproportionate to what she's avenging, without making any identifiable attempt to complicate our feelings toward her. The movie seems to fully approve of what she does, and I must say that I do not.
And then she looks straight into the camera for the final shot. Cut to black. Et tu, Andrew?
* For those few who care, that's why I didn't add Amziah King to my Survived My Sample Project list. It wouldn't have survived in a vacuum. I can just think of three different ways that it'd eventually land on my must-watch-in-its-entirety queue, and whiffing all three seems unlikely.