Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

63/100

In which a single huge asset outweighs, for the most part, a single huge liability. If you've seen the movie, I don't even need to ID the asset (not for anyone attracted to women, at least): Few actors have ever been as utterly adorable as Veronica Lake is here, clad mostly in men's pajamas (or naked beneath a coat) and embodying playful malevolence. Her entire performance—arguably even after Jennifer drinks the philter that future scientists Jerry Lieber and Mike Stoller would christen Love Potion #9; while that alters her goal, it doesn't change her personality in the slightest, and havoc-wreaking continues—confirms future philosopher Billy Joel's hypothesis that the sinners are much more fun. It's the little-girl-smirking-into-camera-as-fire-blazes-in-background meme (Jennifer and her father actually do burn down multiple buildings!), but with a perpetually horny, ludicrously beautiful adult woman who gets off on flirtatiously inflicting misery. This creates an imbalance that the movie struggles to correct, even as it burdens Fredric March's Wooley with a standard screwball Nightmare Fiancé(e), played by Susan Hayward in dragon-lady mode. Jennifer wants to destroy Wooley, as part of a centuries-old curse, and rooting against what Jennifer wants proves nearly impossible, because the alternative is sheer boredom. A reason why we'd be glad to see him marry a witch must therefore be concocted.

Turns out the concocting was originally done (in a novel that he died before finishing) by Thorne Smith, whose best-known work is Topper. Which makes perfect sense—with the benefit of hindsight, I can readily perceive how Topper-esque I Married a Witch often is, in terms of both its plotting and its sense of humor. Both of which I'd characterize as...adequate. (It's been 24 years since my sole viewing of Topper; I didn't write anything at the time but do recall being underwhelmed.) Certainly one imagines its various non-lacustrine* elements would've been considerably zingier had associate producer Preston Sturges chosen to make this film instead of The Palm Beach Story. In any case, the solution someone (presumably Smith) came up with was to have Jennifer unwittingly (or, rather, unconsciously) drink her own love potion, so that she now adores Wooley and seeks only to help him, in her demented way (e.g., by enchanting the state's entire population so that he receives literally 100% of the votes for governor, including his opponent's). I kept waiting for a complication that would somehow cancel or reverse the spell, such that Jennifer would realize that she genuinely loves Wooley, but that doesn't happen. She just remains in a love trance forever. That clearly wouldn't be satisfying were the roles reversed—no joy in seeing them live happily ever after while knowing that his ardor's artificial—and it isn't entirely satisfying to me this way, either, though I can semi-rationalize it as the only decent option given her intrinsic nature.

Bottom line: Do not see this movie if you don't find Veronica Lake pretty damn bewitching. That's most of what it has to offer.

* Look it up if it's not clear from context. Not gonna pretend that I knew that word 30 seconds ago.

Files

Comments

No comments found for this post.