Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

62/100

As is so often the case with contemporary horror movies, I dug everything unrelated to personal trauma and healing. Actually think this one might've been more effective as pseudo-horror, its apparently supernatural elements indeed revealed as hokum; McCarthy kinda tries to have it both ways, creating what's essentially a very corporeal escape-room thriller hinging on irrational fear and then throwing in a bunch of largely arbitrary jump scares just to meet consumer demand. But my perverse affection for unlikable protagonists had me chuckling nonstop during act one, as Adam Scott gradually expands his characterization from self-righteous to brusque to obnoxious to rude to outright cruel, culminating in an unexpected development that had me truly excited for what might come next. Which turned out to be: spooky production design, a deeply sad answer to the question of what befell the movie's most sympathetic figure (the costume really makes it haunting), and some problem-solving seemingly inspired by games like Myst (I'm old), as our borderline-despicable hero works out how to e.g. recall a dumbwaiter using objects in the room where he's trapped. All of which would have been plenty effective without a witch or a ghost—especially minus the latter, who initially shows up before Ohm (I've been trying not to use his goofy name) even goes to Ireland and is sometimes seen by us but not by him, undermining any suggestion that she's merely a guilt manifestation. Still, I mostly had a shivery good time, and appreciate that while Ohm predictably emerges from his ordeal a nicer person, his self-loathing finally exorcised (and his latest novel revised to end less nihilistically), he's still prone to making gratuitous smart-ass remarks. "If you wanted something to pass the time, I could bring in my manuscript." "Haven't I been through enough already, Alby?" He then agrees to read it, but Scott plays that as dutiful, not eager, which makes all the difference. Baby steps.

Files

Comments

Devan Suber

I was rather pleased there was in fact a scary witch roaming the halls, and that she does seem to be "real".

Michael Sicinski

Agree with this review 100%. But I will be keeping tabs on McCarthy.