Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

77/100

[As you may have heard, one element of this film has been omitted from its marketing. I got the impression from inadvertent glimpses on social media that this is a startling cameo, but it’s not—it’s kinda the movie’s entire second half, and theoretically guessable/foreseeable if you possess certain cultural knowledge. Having been surprised by it myself (apart from being aware of an impending unexpected appearance), I actually don’t think that it needs to be a big surprise. But if you’d rather not know, stop reading after the second paragraph.]

Advance word prepped me for something unusual, and I just assumed, based on Fielder’s prior history, that it’d be conceptually unusual. Which You Can See Everything does eventually become, but only after spending well over an hour as Autumn Sonata: The Documentary. Many of Fielder’s one-on-one interviews with Elizabeth Holmes are more bizarrely intimate than you’d imagine an unscripted project could ever possibly be; Oppenheim (and Fielder, I suppose, but I’m gonna default to crediting Oppenheim for formal aspects and Fielder for his onscreen role) shoots both subjects in close-ups that verge on invasive, as Holmes strives to (?) look maximally transparent despite her naturally unnerving mien and Fielder achieves levels of self-conscious uncertainty never before captured via camera. It’s surpassingly weird, and so grandiose at times (Ari Balouzian’s urgent score infuses nearly every moment with import) that it’s as if we’re watching a quixotic attempt to comprehend the unfathomable, like an astronomer gazing into the distant cosmos. Is this woman for real? We’re allied with Fielder in at once doubting her sincerity and feeling uncomfortable with our doubt, and I cannot stress enough that the film achieves this visually, by the way that it’s shot and edited. (Fielder’s even introduced as if he were perpetrating a home invasion, which must be very disconcerting if you don’t know who he is and hence don’t ID him as one of the directors.)

At the same time, You Can See Everything does also function as journalism of a sort, with Fielder attempting to determine whether Holmes genuinely believes herself wholly innocent of wrongdoing, as she’s always maintained. On the one hand, many questions he asks her (and her husband-in-all-but-name, Billy Evans) are bluntly direct in ways that nonfiction filmmaking normally doesn’t countenance, exemplified by the early, ostensibly offhand moment that sees Billy take over eggbeating duty from Elizabeth (grabbing the bowl and spoon from her without asking) and Fielder immediately, reflexively ask why he did that. The inquiry into semantics that culminates in Fielder showing Holmes “Who’s on first?” (which she pretends to find amusing—or maybe does find amusing, who knows?—despite not getting the joke) blends empathy and cruelty so that it’s hard to be sure which is which. Given the film’s concerns, though, I’m bewildered by avenues left unexplored. Didn’t need Fielder to conduct a full deposition of the Theranos fraud case, but it’s very odd that he repeatedly asks about whether the blood-testing machine could actually do what Holmes claimed (getting hung up on her precise wording, whether what she said was in fact what she meant) but never once brings up Theranos’ use of other companies’ non-miracle devices for what were purportedly its own blood tests. Which was a big part of why she was convicted. She did phony demonstrations for investors! Never comes up. And even if one argues that the film is about Holmes herself, and only tangentially about her crimes, why the hell didn’t Fielder address the fact that Holmes spent years affecting a deeper voice when speaking publicly? Does that not seem germane to what’s being interrogated here? I have legit Qs for a Q&A.

[Here’s where you should bail if you don’t want the surprise ruined.]

Incredibly, that’s only You Can See Everything’s first half (or so). Fielder and Oppenheim had just a few weeks to shoot before Holmes reported to prison, which of course concluded the intimate intensity that so beguiled me. Fielder’s eventually permitted to visit her, but can’t bring a camera, or any other recording device. He therefore taps Amanda Seyfried, who played Holmes in Hulu’s 2022 miniseries The Dropout, to essentially reprise the role in this film, based on Fielder’s memory of the conversations and meeting we don’t see. Most critics seem to find this meta-element even more compelling than they do the Holmes interviews, and it’s definitely more conventionally audacious—a phrase that sounds oxymoronic, but hopefully you take my meaning: Seyfried’s re-enactments openly tinker with documentary protocol (they are, in fact, very much in line with what I expected You Can See Everything to be, even if I wouldn’t have anticipated the specific approach employed), whereas earlier scenes do what docs ordinarily do but they do that fuckin’ weird. And this part raises several fascinating questions. Can even a great actor ever really capture another human being’s essence? (For all of Seyfried’s talent, she never remotely duplicates Holmes’ uncanny affect.) Is it possible that Fielder became so emotionally involved with Holmes back in 2023 that he’s unconsciously protecting her? (Credit to him for acknowledging the possibility.) To a large degree, You Can See Everything’s back half is about Billy, who’s fully revealed as an ultra-controlling narcissist to whom Holmes has seemingly surrendered her will, in what’s arguably a pattern for her; there’s a confrontation between him and Seyfried (as herself, but clearly identifying with Holmes) that it’s hard to believe happened on-camera. Compelling though all of that is, however, it pales for me beside the cryptic Holmes-Fielder dynamic, his doomed effort to get to the bottom of her, to solve her. That’s the movie everybody thinks Zodiac is.

Files

Comments

Elias Smith

As improbable as it may be, I like to think that a lot of Amanda's scenes were reenactments, be they portraying Elizabeth or portraying herself. It really sells the theme of Fielder openly questioning how documentaries frame their subjects/how much truth the camera can show. Dinner sequence is 100% unscripted and is that much more insane for existing, though.

Joseph Hoeffner

I loved the movie, but I was pretty baffled by their not touching on The Voice at all. In the NYT profile they spend a good amount of time obsessing over, it mentions that she's speaking in her normal voice -- but in the documentary she's doing The Voice (albeit less pronounced than usual). Not even a passing mention!

Dan

"culminates in Fielder showing Holmes “Who’s on first?” (which she pretends to find amusing—or maybe does find amusing, who knows?—despite not getting the joke) " I read this at face value like you seemed to but most people think she was pretending not to understand the joke to sell the idea that she "just sees the world differently." It is odd that even after he explains the joke there is never a moment where she expresses understanding.

TCE

I also thought her not getting it was sincere. If anything it felt Fielder was offering her a small out by giving her the chance to just say she never tried to be deceitful, or lie, she just doesn't understand how her sincere statements come across to other people, and she wasn't able to take advantage because she genuinely didn't get what he was going for.

Thunderoo

Have you seen The Rehearsal, Mike? Because re-enactments are totally Fielder's thing. It would have been more annoying to me that the second half of the movie became very Rehearsal-like except that I really like The Rehearsal, Fielder is better at doing The Rehearsal than straight documentary, and the second half was the better for it.

Mike D'Angelo

I have not yet seen The Rehearsal. And I gave up very early on The Curse. Have seen all of Nathan For You. I much prefer the Holmes half to the post-Holmes half not because I dislike the re-enactment approach but because the second half is exploring what are to my mind less interesting questions, and doing so conceptually rather than formally. Whereas the filmmaking in Del Mar or wherever they were living is exquisite.

Cameron Watson

In that case why no Finding Frances log? I feel like that one’s pretty unanimously categorized as a TV-movie of sorts

The Foochie

If you loved this formally, I assume you’ll like Primetime a lot

Mike D'Angelo

No. It’s the final episode of season 4. The fact that it’s longer doesn’t magically turn it into a film.

Andrew Doerfler

The similar formal stuff in Primetime doesn't complement the material as well as it does in YCSE.

Colby Beiler

I agree. Primetime's visuals felt a little more overwrought by his visuals. Here, the long close-ups and tense score felt like they were building towards larger questions without answers, which felt right.

Colby Beiler

One of my questions was whether Billy was actually being a narcissist or was all a show for him? There were a couple of times when he really looked like a guy playing a narcissist. Could he really not realize that he's coming off as a controlling jerk in these pieces that he knows will be allowed in the doc? Maybe it was part of the contract he signed....

Henry Adams

I like to believe that this (and the outsourcing of lab testing, as Mike mentioned) HAD to have come up but just didn't make it into the final edit. For Fielder and Oppenheim, litigating Theranos that wasn't the point so much as trying to convey the mystery of whether she genuinely believes her lies. Still: these particular points would've been interesting, so I would be curious to know what that material looked like

Henry Adams

Much of what you love about the first portion of this movie is present in Oppenheim's earlier doc SPERMWORLD. It, too, is "more bizarrely intimate than you’d imagine an unscripted project could ever possibly be," with incredibly poetic visuals for a documentary. Can't formally request it since I'm not a higher tier patron atm but I hope it piqued your interest now that you loved this one and know what Oppenheim is capable of.

Mike D'Angelo

I watched the first 10 minutes and didn’t get into it. Same with Some Kind of Heaven. It may be that his approach only interests me in this specific context. (Though SKoH is in the random draw so odds are I’ll see the whole thing eventually.)

Henry Adams

Glad to know you had given them a chance! And I look forward to SKoH getting drawn some day

Stephen Mlinarcik

Speaking of avenues left unexplored, I'm curious why Fielder didn't attempt to get a one-on-one interview with Holmes' father, who seemed interested in talking about his daughter despite Billy's interruptions.

Lucas L Holloway

Ostensibly Nathan sets out to find the truth. However, omitting details like the voice and important aspects of the crimes are a tell that Nathan has a different goal (I would even bet there is footage on the cutting room floor of those very subjects). The problem is those things are so incriminating that they would threaten to destroy the facade of plausible deniability. The movie carefully obfuscates to give us the illusion of a deeper mystery. The scene where Nathan alters Holmes’ dialogue from “it” to “something” is Nathan showing his real intent. Why? The character Nathan Fielder may have fallen in love with Elizabeth Holmes, but I think this too is a manipulation. The moment Nathan acknowledges the possibility that he unconsciously protected Holmes is a cryptic taunt to the audience that he has created this Penrose Stairs of doubt.

Alden Sargent

Maybe he did and the follow up didn't yield very much and also undercut the oppressiveness of Billy's control.

Breakbeatzors

Honestly, my read is that Billy is oblivious bc of all the cocaine he seemed to be doing. Or the Texas ragweed is _really_ wrecking his sinuses.

Stephen Mlinarcik

Possibly, or perhaps he wasn't interested in interrogating how she arrived at this moment, and instead focused on whittling away at why she maintains her innocence even now despite the evidence.