Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Resuscitating reviews I wrote at festivals that Patreon’s crap search engine wouldn't previously have delivered because the titles weren't in the subject line. The film(s) in question will generally have just opened theatrically in New York City when these posts appear.

In alphabetical order and also, coincidentally, order of preference (though they're all basically B–minuses):

Everytime (Sandra Wollner, Austria/Germany): 60/100 [TIFF ’26]

Relentlessly interesting, which you might instinctively grasp is a descriptor that cuts two ways. (Also you saw my rating.) For close to 90 minutes, I’d estimate, it’s essentially a study in deferred emotion—something tragic (and quite unexpected, if you go in cold, plus the shot in question is a real stunner) happens toward the beginning, following which Wollner leaps ahead…well, not all that far, actually, but far enough that everyone’s already processed their grief and moved on, at least superficially. That in itself was Interesting to me, though less so as the film progressed and what had been skipped over began resurfacing. But then things take a paranormal turn that’s really…Interesting. And becomes still more Interesting as it vacillates between seeming purely symbolic and being something that’s clearly actually happening. “That was very Interesting,” I thought as the closing credits rolled. Which is by no means synonymous with Satisfying, and in truth I respect Everytime more than I like it. But what I saw of The Trouble With Being Born didn’t impress me, whereas now I’m…Interested.

Paradise Lost (Yeon Sang-ho, South Korea): let’s say 59/100 [TIFF ’26]

Incredibly dumb, but it kinda won me over at the end with sheer bleakness. Far livelier, at the very least, than Kore-eda's Sheep in the Box, though this resurrected child is a virtual AI entity rather than an android and appears to be a reasonably convincing approximation (utilizing data culled from videos and such). So far so Black Mirror, but the movie’s entertainingly inane twist sees one child who was believed to be murdered (along with 12 classmates) nine years earlier suddenly return (ID genetically confirmed), forcing Mom to choose between her 10-year-old fake son, who’s a perfect little angel, and her 19-year real son, who’s a psychopathic serial killer. And will reveal the location of his latest victim (still alive, he tortures them first) only on the condition that she’ll delete his younger digital incarnation, because that’s something a screenwriter (or novelist; this is an adaptation) could decide to have him do. Plus if she turns him in she’ll almost certainly lose the avatar, because who’d allow pre-adolescent Ted Bundy to keep roaming around a playground app? Utterly absurd from start to finish; by the movie’s gratifyingly fucked-up finale, I was no longer sure that’s necessarily a bad thing. Have even started talking myself into the idea that Killer Son’s complete lack of psychological and behavioral credibility intentionally parallels Digital Son’s shallow constructed affect. Fans of Train to Busan, however, should know that this isn’t in any way an action movie. Arguably takes itself far more seriously than is warranted. Hence my hedging.

[6 NOVEMBER: I appear to be on the high end; most critics just find it ludicrous.]

Wild Horse Nine (Martin McDonagh, Chile/USA): 57/100 [TIFF ’26]

Often very funny, but it’s ultimately too funny for my taste. Or too glib, rather. In Bruges and Seven Psychopaths (both of which I liked; this is the first of his films I’m mixed on) reveled in bad behavior, but they never felt to me as if they were being cavalier about real-world horrors. I can shrug off all the stuff here about Malkovich's CIA assassin being responsible for JFK (though trotting out the three fucking hobos as gunmen is pushing it), but everything involving Allende and post-coup torture/execution/disappearance—note that Wild Horse Nine is set in 1973 but prior to 11 September (and it ain’t an Inglourious Basterds fantasy), so there’s a lot of casually frank dialogue about impending violence that will in fact take place, albeit unwitnessed by this movie—left a bad taste in my mouth. McDonagh unquestionably intends for such scenes to be brutal and discomfiting, but juxtaposed with his usual profane badinage and one character’s ostensible redemption, I dunno, it just didn’t sit well with me. No idea whether it bugs anyone else, at this writing. Pretty good movie if it doesn’t, I’d think.

[6 NOVEMBER: A few others do appear to be similarly bugged, but it's apparently less of a dealbreaker for them.]

Files

Comments

No comments found for this post.