Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

52/100

SPOILERS ahoy.

At long last Fulci. (Amazing that one can watch thousands of old movies over closing in on four decades and still have numerous sizable holes to fill. Not deliberate avoidance, in my case—mostly just luck of the rep-screening draw.) I'd always mentally filed him alongside Dario Argento and Mario Bava, the only giallo filmmakers I really know at this point, so expected a surfeit of dazzling style + extravagant gore, most likely anchored by a murder mystery of some sort. Don't Torture a Duckling, however, turns out to be significantly less outré than its odd English-language title suggests. (Certainly I didn't anticipate that the duckling in question would be Donald Duck[ling], in the form of a child's doll. Apparently that's clearer in the original title, which explicitly refers to the Disney icon by his Italian name.) Not great news for me, as my problem with gialli has generally been that they're mediocrity incarnate between their flamboyant horrific setpieces, of which this example has virtually none. It's a conceptually straightforward, narratively convoluted serial-killer thriller that employs the supernatural as a red herring, its ostensible witch revealed as innocent (though she believes herself guilty and confesses—a nice touch) some 45 minutes before the movie ends. Duckling, I'm surprised to say, works best neither as mystery-horror nor as a formal exercise (despite some visually striking moments) but as...sociology?! It's the only giallo I've seen to date in which the killer's identity and motivation, rooted in an unmistakable theme (modernity co-existing with ancient superstition), are more memorable than are any of the film's murders or stalking sequences. A variation that's highly interesting without ever being terribly exciting. Still had my standard complaints: thin characters, weak acting (not helped by the usual dub job; I watched it in Italian, since the English version was no less out of sync even for those actors who spoke their lines in English), the omnipresent sensation of gears a-grindin'. Happened to revisit Polanski's The Ninth Gate 24 hours later, and the atmospheric difference was palpable.

I'm not inclined to write Fulci off, though—not on the basis of one film that may or may not be representative. While Duckling never looks astonishing, à la Suspiria or Blood and Black Lace, it demonstrates a strong eye for location right from the beginning, when Maciara unearths an infant skeleton on a rise that's bisected by an elevated highway.

The subsequent return to this spot, after she's been fatally beaten with a thick metal chain (the film's sole spasm of graphic violence, unless you want to count an obvious dummy head banging its way down the side of a cliff), boasts a nightmarish grandiloquence—serene landscape ruptured by a bloody hand grabbing hold of a rock, followed by Maciara expiring as cars indifferently whiz past—that the movie could have used a lot more of. So, too, does its most disturbing scene, in which a pre-adolescent boy delivers orange juice to his mother's employer, finds her lounging in the nude, and proceeds to get taunted by said nudity as the woman sadistically puts on a faux-seductive display, walking over to give him a better look, confident that he's far too timid to do anything but simultaneously cower and drool. It's extravagantly fucked up, much more in line with what I'd expected...but it's also kind of irrelevant, except insofar as the woman automatically becomes a suspect when that boy turns up dead. Not only does Barbara Bouchet's modern woman (clothes! how provincial) later become one of Duckling's sleuths, in a wholesale recalibration that comes out of nowhere, but this scene's theoretical connection to the killer's deranged intention—protecting the village's male children from sin by killing them before they can become little perverts—is undermined by (a) the boy's utter passivity (in pointless opposition to an earlier scene in which several boys gleefully spy on adults having sex, something they clearly do on the regular) and, more important, (b) the killer neither witnessing nor hearing about this episode, known only to its two participants and we the viewers. Which is typical of my frustration with gialli. Rarely do they seem to have been thought through beyond their homicidal showcases. This one arguably functions better than most on the fundamental plot level but omits the splashy homicidal showcases. Not the tradeoff I was looking for.

Files

Comments

Raúl

I've only seen 8 of his films, but from those I’d say A Lizard in a Woman's Skin is probably one of the few Fulcis you'd rate above 50. That said, even if he isn't your thing, you should at least give The Psychic (whose soundtrack you'll recognize instantly) and The Beyond a try.