Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 760624070.mp4

Downloads

Content

What an incredible episode!! Can I just say how captivating this Master is? The actor is knocking it out of the park. His mannerisms, his eyes, his shaky breaths. I'm SO impressed.

Great finale, great story. Mind blown indeed!

(a little personal note, I've been a bit absent in the comments here and on youtube. I've been feeling a bit off mentally, which is a common symptom of my autoimmune disease and it's just been more difficult to be present or mentally there, if that makes sense. There's not much I can do but my medication to help with my disease is working, it just is a slow process. I'm okay!! But I just thought I'd let you know.)

yt edit: https://youtu.be/ysCTjkI38A0

Files

Comments

Alice Summers

Brace yourself for the comments on this one. The Timeless Child twist is probably the most controversial thing the show has ever done and unfortunately I'm one of the large number of fans who strongly dislike it. I'm not sure how many actively like it instead of not minding it and it doesn't help to have the exposition the way it did, without dialogue and narrated by the master. Maybe it would have worked better if either the Master was the Timeless Child (and it's interesting to see you speculate on that) or they didn't just kill off the Time Lords (again) depriving the story opportunities of having the Doctor confront them. There seems to be a trend in the revival of each showrunner wanting to impose their ideas more. Moffat was guilty of it as well but compare this to the War Doctor which was just as much a retcon but also one that was done really well. It sums things up that Chibnall eventually confirmed a popular fan theory that the child that pushed the Doctor off the cliff was the Master... except even with regeneration and the long lives of Time Lords, many generations would have lived and died in that time and if the Master had been around all this time to see it all happen then it wouldn't have been a revelation to him producing that reaction. It was very much a case of ignoring logic and common sense to push a certain story and twist. In fairness, the show has never had a continuity set in stone and it had long been a fan debate whether the First Doctor was really the first, but aside from one Fourth Doctor story that implied other previous lives, every time the issue of lives and regenerations came up it always fell on the side that the ones the viewer had seen were the only ones. Aside from preferring that, I've never been fond of when the show pushes the Doctor of being different or special compared to any other time lords. We also got the Fugitive Doctor as the main good thing to come out of it, and it finally confirmed that there was a difference between Time Lords and regular Gallifreyans (which had also been a major debate with the show starting off implying they were the same before gradually shifting in the other direction). Fair enough if you liked it though, and I actually agree about the brilliance and intensity of the Master's performance.

Luxx_67

I actually love the 'timeless children' episode and how it delivered more mystery to The Doc and really makes a lot sense as to why the Master has this internal anger and jealousy but the way he delivers that revelation to The Doctor makes you wonder if possibly the timeless child could actually be the master. Sacha Dhawan as the Master is the highlight of this era of Doctor Who and I'm also glad you found him very hard to watch but also very good, as much as Missy was a brilliant incarnation of the Master I think Sacha will forever be my favourite only one word to describe him...SPECTACULAR!

Martin

The timeless child is probably the biggest divisive moment in modern Who, some people love it, bunch of people HATE it lol I go between, initially I didn't like the change in the Timelords but then other days it's like but it means opening up so much more and it gives you that cool new Doctor as well, so yeah it has good and bad points, and WILL set fans off lmao However, like you say the episode itself is really good, the Graham and Yaz scene is excellent, the Master is superb, him and Jodie are so good together too, all their scenes are always great and yeah that scene at the end with the bomb was awesome. A great Master and really good Master/Doctor dynamic is crucial to the show and with Capaldi and Missy and now this, think they've really nailed that aspect of it certainly.

erume

to explain the brendan scenes, it was the doctor's actual past / childhood, but tecteun coded the image so it doesn't seem remarkable to anyone. doctor wasn't actually a brendan, brendan is like a mask for anyone who's watching brendan is a lost child found on the road (the timeless child found at the pass into another universe) by his about to be adoptive father (by tecteun the explorer). brendan falling from the cliff after being shot is coded image of the timeless child falling down the cliff. brendan just doesn't look hurt after the shot and the fall, the timeless child regenerates. then brendan's father accompanies him to enroll into police (?) vs tecteun creating the division and making the timeless child a part of it. brendan's memories being deleted on an electric stool references how they wiped the doctor's memories why? that's the fugitive doctor's story. remember she said about the division "a job that you can't leave, believe me i've tried". so some conflicts definately happened there. considering that the division was described here as an authority to intervene into all sorts of events, i can clearly see why the fugitive doctor eventually grows cross with the division!

erume

the timeless child story is chilling. like what do you mean tecteun kept her research through the child's multiple (!) regenerations? kinds dont die so many times naturally. has she killed the child she adopted, again and again, to understand their biology? what did she say to the child before killing them? that it's alright and mommy needs to do this? that's so wrong and so cruel imagine a mother who treats you less and less like a person as you grow up

erume

can't believe fam been to Gallifrey! insane haha

Joe Cleveland

I really like the Timeless Child story. It makes the Doctor an adoptee, which Chibnall is himself, and gives the Doctor all the questions an adoptee has about their origins and identity and how much it matters whether or not they know where they came from, etc. It also brings in themes of empire and colonization, with the Time Lords built on something they took without consent. I suppose it makes the Doctor "special" -- but they're not special in being able to regenerate, since that ability was stolen from them..They are certainly not the only adoptee that's ever existed. In terms of their abilities and qualities, even as the Timeless Child the Doctor is no more special than the Doctor ever has been. Or: the Doctor is still as special as we always thought the Doctor was. The Doctor is special in the way they were abused and experimented on, I suppose, but so is anyone who has experienced abuse. When have we _not_ seen the Doctor as special, really? It's the specialness of the Doctor that draws us to the show! Part of the brilliance of the Timeless Child story is that it isn't a retcon. It doesn't change anything at all about the life of the Doctor as we've seen them live it in the show. It doesn't say that there are some stories that we were mistaken about. All of the Doctor's journey from Totter's Lane onward is as it has been. The Timeless Child does add layers of corruption and meanness to the Time Lords' backstory, but lots of show runners / writers have done that. In fact, I can't think of a show runner who has _not_ done that!

James Evans

If someone hasn’t explained it, the Irish story of Brendan was an allegorical filter to disguise the memories of the Doctor’s hidden past in the Matrix. Brendan represents the Doctor, a child who was found abandoned and adopted, who as a teenager was recruited into the police, which represents the Division, a Time Lord black ops organisation. The scene of old Brendan being taken into the back office and memory wiped represents when the Doctor was recaptured by Division and were regressed into infancy/had their memories stolen, becoming the First Doctor.

James Evans

I completely get the issue people have with the actual Timeless Child concept of the Doctor being the origin of regeneration, that was a mistake, but everything around that one concept adds so much to the Doctor and builds on what is already there. Like for example, the Doctor was never just another Time Lord and them being one of the early pioneers isn’t new. In the second ever story The Daleks, the Thals ask the First Doctor where he gets his knowledge from, and he shares his envy of the Thals getting to rebuild a new world, and when asked to stay by the Thals to help out, the Doctor tells them that he’s much too old to be a pioneer, but was once amongst his own people. This then gets brought back up in the Seventh Doctor’s era with the plot-line of the Doctor having been around at the founding of the Time Lords and were one of the pioneers alongside Rassilon and Omega. I don’t think we should be able to fully grasp who the Doctor is, that’s a central part of the character, otherwise the show shouldn’t be called Doctor Who.