The B's Next Door! Complete by Inked Fox (Patreon)
Downloads
Content
The B’s Next Door!
By Inked Fox
© 2019-2065 QoSBookclub
All Rights Reserved
No part of this publication may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including photocopying, recording, or other electronic or mechanical methods, without the prior written permission of the publisher, except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical reviews and certain other noncommercial uses permitted by copyright law. For permission requests, contact us by sending a DM to patreon.com/QoSBookclub.This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents are a product of the author’s imagination. Locales and public names are sometimes used for atmospheric purposes. Any resemblance to actual people, living or dead, or to businesses, companies, events, institutions, or locales is completely coincidental.
CREATOR DISCLAIMER & CONSENT STATEMENT
All characters are 18 years of age or older. This work is a consensual adult fantasy depicting kink, power-exchange, and humiliation role-play between enthusiastic, informed consenting adults. All sexual acts, dominance/submission dynamics, and scenarios in this story are fully consensual within the fictional universe and represent negotiated fantasy play.
This content does not depict, endorse, or glorify real-world non-consensual acts, coercion, blackmail, violence, or sexual assault. Any appearance of reluctance is part of a pre-negotiated consensual non-consent (CNC) fantasy where all participants have safewords, ongoing consent, and the ability to stop at any time. In real life, consent must be enthusiastic, ongoing, and revocable at any moment.Bullying, non-consensual acts, and sexual violence are never okay in reality. If you or someone you know is experiencing bullying, abuse, or non-consensual situations, please contact the appropriate authorities or support services immediately.Readers are encouraged to practice safe, sane, and consensual kink in their own lives with proper communication, negotiation, and risk-aware consent.
The door swung open as Paul came in after a long shift working his administrative job. Another monotonous day at the insurance company. A tired sigh left him, his arms full of groceries Katey told him to pick up before getting home.
“Kate, baby! I’m home!” he called out as he walked into the kitchen to put them away.
“Paulie! Glad you’re home. Can you put those away for me? I’m getting ready for my evening spin class. Jenny called out sick, so I’m covering for her. Oh! Can you put tomorrow's roast in the oven too? I’ve got my hands full.”
Paul winced slightly. Not even five minutes home and already another thing to do. He didn’t complain, though. It was simpler just to do as Katey asked. “Yeah, of course, darling,” he called back and began putting things away.
Katey sauntered in moments later, a smile on her face. “Hey, cutie.” She smacked his ass, then reached over to set a jar he’d put away into another space. Paul noticed but let it go.
“God, I hope today’s class doesn’t drag. I had this total Karen in my last one who kept complaining about the seat of her bike and had to stop several times just to get someone to come in and adjust it. Ugh!” She rolled her eyes.
Paul watched her move around him with that easy confidence. He’d always loved that about her. Blonde and petite with those crystalline blue eyes. It melted his resolve every goddamn time.
“Oh, Paulie, I left the clothes in the wash. Can you switch those over?” she chirped, pulling down a shaker and her protein powder. “And the dishwasher needs to be refilled. And then that woman in my last class…” She rattled off another couple of things, and Paul mentally added them to the list.
“Yes, dear.” He smirked at her. “So bossy,” he teased.
“And yet everything gets done,” she purred, pressing into him and kissing his neck. The touch sent a jolt of electricity through him that settled right into his groin.
Stupid. He was absolutely stupid for her.
They laughed together, and Katey served him some dinner she’d made for him. “Anyway, Laura is coming in tonight. She is such a riot.” The blonde trainer leaned over and stole a bite off his plate, kissing his cheek again.
Paul leaned into it, drinking in every scrap of affection she had to offer.
The evening descended into their usual quiet rhythm as Katey got ready for work. Paul watched her from the kitchen, his eyes roaming her tight, fit body. The gentle sway of her slender hips. Everything about her made his heart flutter.
Their relationship of six years was comfortable. Funny, when he thought about it, he couldn’t remember the last time he’d picked dinner. Or rearranged a room. Or decided what they were doing on a Saturday. Dinner. Furniture. His clothes. Weekend plans. The budget. Even his side of the bed.
He shook his head slightly. Maybe he preferred it that way. It took the pressure off him.
Mostly.
Though if any of the guys at work saw how he lived, they’d call him pussy whipped.
He groaned inwardly, but the momentary irritation was shoved aside when Katey wandered back over and pressed into him. Her warmth and scent chased away any lingering doubt.
“Hey… Uh, Kate? Maybe we could do something tomorrow?” Paul began, his heart pounding in his chest.
“Yeah? Like what?” She tipped her head.
“Let’s do something together. Just me and you.” His hand slid to her waist, pulling her closer. He sucked his soft gut in slightly, not wanting her to feel how soft he’d let it get.
“Tomorrow is our gym day. You know that.” She pouted softly.
“Yeah… so? What if I wanted us to skip it?” he said.
A low affectionate hum rumbled in her throat as she kissed him and pushed closer.
“Skip a gym day?” She chuckled softly and poked his belly. “You need it.”
Her finger gently squeezed his side, the touch possessive and playful.
That stung. Paul let out an annoyed breath.
“Well… what if I don’t want to go?” He squared his shoulders and deepened his voice, a cheeky grin tugging at the corner of his mouth. “I’m the man in this house. I should put my foot down when I want to. Maybe you could spend some more time in the kitchen instead.” He scoffed with a sly smirk.
“Hah! You? Put your foot down? Besides, I think you spend enough time in the kitchen as is.” Katey giggled brightly and petted his stomach. She kissed his jaw and nipped his throat. Her lashes tickled his neck.
Paul gave a short laugh because obviously she was joking. Obviously he was joking too.
He felt his muscles beneath the softness flutter. An embarrassed heat crept up his neck.
“Tch. Whatever. I still think we should make time.” Paul shuffled away from her and went to change, suddenly feeling too exposed.
In the bedroom, he fished out some sweats and a loose T-shirt. He avoided the mirror as he changed.
His gaze found it anyway..
The swell of his chest caught his eye. The loose shirt pulled across him differently than he wanted. He tugged it once. Twice. No.
Suddenly, the loose shirt felt too tight. He pulled it off and reached for the thicker sweatshirt, adjusting it over his lanky frame. His eyes trailed back to the mirror as his hand rubbed the soft line of his jaw. Katey had always told him he was handsome, and maybe he could be if he carried himself with more confidence.
The next day, after an afternoon of working out at the gym, Paul and Katey returned home. Katey, as always, was still full of energy. Paul dragged himself in after her but smiled at her playful energy. They made after-workout snacks and showered together. Katey, all the while, was flirtatious and mischievous. Her sultry touches put Paul in a mood. He enjoyed being the center of her attention when no one else was around. He craved that from her. He followed her kisses and caresses like a breadcrumb trail, luring him into the bedroom.
“You did such a good job, Paulie,” Katey purred. “Ready for your after workout workout?” She giggled.
An almost bashful grin curled at the corners of his lips. He kissed her, backing her toward the bed. His fingers curled into her towel, tugging it away. Katey chuckled, yanking his away in turn. A plume of bravado took him, his confidence bolstered by her receptiveness. For once, she was following his lead.
He grabbed her wrists and pinned them above her head, forcing her back into a beautiful arch that left her perky breasts exposed and vulnerable.
Katey laughed and squirmed. “What are you doing? Trying to play He Man the barbarian?”
Paul grinned, his eyes sparkling with something predatory. His grip tightened around her wrists. “Just showing my woman who she belongs to…”
Katey laughed and gave him a soft, indulgent look. To Paul, it felt dangerously close to pity.
“Oh, you’re so cute,” she purred.
Cute. The word struck him like a flashbang. He was trying to be dominant. Trying to take control. But Katey was unconvinced. His grasp faltered. The familiar heat of embarrassment crept up his neck. He managed a laugh and smirked like it hadn’t landed.
“C-cute?” he stammered, blinking down at her.
She shifted beneath him with a casual confidence, and a second later he was the one on his back. “Yeah, cute…” she purred seductively, clearly mistaking his apprehension for bashfulness.
Paul looked up at her, at that easy grin on her face. A pang of disappointment settled in his chest, but he swallowed it as she leaned down to kiss him. Why couldn’t she take him seriously for once? The thought sat between them, heavy on his chest and invisible to Katey altogether. Just as their lips touched…
THUMP.
Something heavy hit the wall next to them. They both froze, confused, and turned their heads. Another crash followed. Then a peal of feminine laughter drifted through the wall separating their apartment from the one next door.
Katey’s brow furrowed, a pout forming on her lips. “What the hell was that?”
Saturday morning arrived, and something had shifted in the air. As Paul came home from his jog, something in the hallway caught his attention.
Boxes. Lots of them.
They lined the wall opposite his apartment. The door next door to his was propped open as music filtered out. Some kind of metal music poured in tinny distortion from a cellphone speaker. Paul gave the boxes an odd look as he was forced to step around a few to get to his door. Just as he pulled his keys out, a shout drew his attention.
“Fuck! Are you kidding?” a female voice growled out.
Another laughed behind the first.
“Babs, you bitch, did you not measure the doorway? I can’t get the fridge into the kitchen!”
Paul narrowed his eyes and tried to hurry past the open doorway, intending to ignore the disturbance, but someone called out to him.
“Neighbor!”
On reflex, his feet rooted to the spot.
He peered into the apartment and was met with the appraising gaze of two women unlike anyone he’d expected to find next door. Paul’s gaze swept over them. One was obviously a goth. Pale skin, jet black hair that hung flat-ironed around her shoulders. A choker around her neck, coupled with black shorts and a t-shirt that strained across her heavy rack.
The other was no less striking. Her style seemed more rockabilly-inspired. Like she’d stepped off some twisted pin up from the 1950s era. A red bandana tied her sleek hot pink hair away from her face. A pair of high-waisted shorts and a cropped top did little to conceal her exaggerated curves. And lots of tattoos.
“Um… H-hi…” Paul waved awkwardly.
“Hey, sweetheart! You’re our neighbor from next door, right? So nice to meet you. I’m Babs.” The one with the rockabilly style chirped. She gestured to her companion, who looked much less amused. “This is Ivy. As you can see, we’re just getting settled in. But we’re having a little trouble. Do you mind giving us a hand? We could really use a big strong man right about now.”
Paul noticed the faintest movement at the corner of Ivy’s black lips.
Paul looked between the women and the surplus of boxes. A fridge sat half jammed through the kitchen doorway. Several excuses were already spinning in his head. His mouth fell open to drop one out, but Babs stopped him.
“Please. We really could use the help with this stubborn fridge.”
Big strong man. Those words needled at his pride. They were just two women, after all, and surely he could manage pushing one damn fridge through a doorway.
“Y-yeah, sure. I could help you with that.” He rubbed his neck and stepped around the boxes.
“Oh, great! That’s so sweet of you.” Babs tossed a smile to Ivy.
Ivy said nothing. She simply stepped aside and folded her arms, her gaze following him toward the fridge.
Paul approached the fridge and frowned, the size slightly dwarfing him. He could feel their eyes on him. Their weight made him uneasy as he began to push. His arms shook, and he gritted his teeth to contain it. He couldn’t look weak now. He’d already agreed to help. If he wussed out, how would that look to these women?
He gave a firm shove, finally managing it through. His sweatshirt pulled taut over his chest as he leaned his weight into it. Shifting, he tried to angle away so they couldn’t see the softness of it. His eyes drifted up briefly, catching Ivy’s gaze. She tipped her head. Her eyes lingered for a moment before settling back on his face.
Paul tore his eyes away, telling himself he had imagined it. He focused on maneuvering the fridge the rest of the way and finally managed it. Once it was sitting aligned with the counter, he drew back and caught his breath as quickly as possible so as not to look as if he’d expended too much energy. Then he turned to look back at the women.
The chaos of their apartment caught his attention. Amongst the boxes strewn everywhere, there was also a mess. Clothes piled on furniture. Alcohol bottles from the previous night crowded corners, counters, and the coffee table. What looked to be club flyers and prints of tattoos littered the floor and the cushions of the couch. Heavy speakers sat in the middle of the foyer. Right away, Paul found himself missing Katey’s obsessive neatness. If Katey were here, she’d have an aneurysm.
Ivy finally spoke up. Her question was casual enough, at first. “So… how long have you lived here?”
“Oh, uh, four years. It’s a nice place. Quiet enough,” Paul answered and rubbed his arm. His muscles were already aching.
“Huh. By yourself?”
“No, with my girlfriend.”
“Girlfriend?”
“Katey.”
“How long?”
“We’ve been together for six years.” Paul chuckled nervously. Why did it matter?
“Six?” Ivy quirked a brow.
“Oh wow! Congratulations! That’s so sweet,” Babs interjected with a warm smile. “Lucky girl, eh.” She winked.
“Is she the blonde one?” Ivy continued.
Paul froze. So they’d seen Katey already. “Y-yeah.”
“She seems… organized,” Ivy added, her arms crossed.
Paul couldn’t put his finger on why the pause before ‘organized’ bothered him.
“She is. Very.” He laughed a little too hard.
Ivy’s gaze lingered on him.
“Paulie?” Katey called from next door. She had heard his voice.
She appeared from around the corner outside the apartment and peered in. Right away, the temperature in the room dropped. Her eyes shifted between the two women, lingered, and then settled on Paul. Her jaw subtly tightened before a smile bloomed across her lips. A smile that didn’t touch the clear blue of her eyes.
“Oh… hello,” Katey greeted them in a cheerful voice that came out sounding slightly hollow. “I see Paulie made some new… friends.”
Babs grinned. “We were just talking about his lovely girlfriend! Come on in!”
Ivy simply stood by, a faint smirk touching her lips as she watched.
“You sure? I would hate to intrude…” Katey stepped in anyway, heading straight for Paul.
Paul went stiff the moment he noticed Katey’s expression. “K-Katey! I was just helping them with their fridge.” He chuckled nervously and rubbed his neck. “Uh, this is B-Babs and Ivy.”
Katey scanned them over with that same tight smile. “So… nice to meet you both.” Her eyes lingered on the fullness of their figures, but she made no comment.
Babs brightened the moment Katey stepped inside. “Wow! Aren’t you the prettiest little thing! So slender. You work out?”
Katey laughed and waved it off. “Oh, just here and there. Gotta stay fit, you know!”
“Yeah, that waist is ridiculous. I’d never have the discipline.” Ivy grinned.
Babs playfully swatted at her cohort. “Seriously, girl, you look amazing.”
All the while, Paul wanted nothing more than to melt into the floor and disappear.
Katey let out a strained laugh, then looked at Paul. “Paulie, are we going?”
Ivy’s intense gaze shifted to him.
Paul winced internally, feeling that gaze on him, but smiled and nodded. “S-sure, all done here. Nice meeting you two.”
He fell into line behind Katey as she led the way out and back to their apartment. Once their door was closed, Katey cocked her hips and crossed her arms. The mask of her smile fell away into a displeased frown.
“So?” she uttered pointedly.
“So what?” Paul asked back.
Katey scoffed, her brow furrowed in annoyance. “You didn’t notice?”
He had definitely noticed. The air in that room had grown thick with something unnameable, heavy all the same.
“Noticed what? They seem fine…” Paul scratched the back of his neck.
Katey gave him a look that could peel paint.
He flinched. “They just moved in, Kate. Give them some time to adjust.”
Katey held his gaze for a beat, clearly unconvinced. She didn’t press the issue, just turned and headed for the kitchen, grumbling, “They’re going to be a nightmare…”
Next door, a peal of feminine laughter came muffled through the adjoining wall.
Over the following weeks, what began as awkwardness between neighbors slowly but surely turned into a subtle war of attrition.
One afternoon, Babs came over, knocking at their door. Paul answered and greeted her, friendly enough.
“Hey, sweetie. Do you have a bottle opener I can borrow? Lost mine in the move.”
“Yeah, sure. One sec.” He popped into the kitchen and came back with one in his hand.
Babs thanked him and accepted it, then launched into a spiel about her day at a photo shoot and how she was in dire need of a drink. The woman was a natural conversationalist, holding him hostage with her quirky anecdotes. Katey heard them chatting and wandered by, popping her head through the door.
“Oh. Hi.” She gave that tight smile again. “Need something?”
Babs smiled back. “Just a bottle opener. Thanks, honey!”
Katey didn’t even wait for her to turn around and leave. Her smile stretched just a little too wide as she uttered, “Great,” and shut the door.
The next day, the music began, thrumming through the walls late into the night. Katey frowned, glaring daggers at the adjoining walls. Paul only raised the volume on his TV to drown it out. It was around midnight the following night when it started again. Katey, driven to a migraine by the noise, slammed a cabinet as she went looking for her sleep aids. Paul winced and rolled over in bed, squeezing his eyes shut.
The following week, he ran into Ivy in the hall. He gave a polite nod as he passed her, but she called out to him, stopping him briefly.
“Look at you. All corporate today.”
Paul rubbed his neck and gave an uneasy smile. “Oh, it’s nothing important. I’m just a junior administrative assistant.”
Ivy’s smirk deepened slightly, then she slipped into her apartment.
On another afternoon, Babs, ever the friendly neighbor, left a few containers of leftovers by their door. Katey spotted them on her way home from work and looked down at them with obvious disgust.
“Hey, Paulie… did you see this junk left by our door?”
Paul came out and looked down. “Hm. The girls must have left that.” He stooped to pick them up.
“The girls?” She scoffed, obviously perturbed over the nickname for their nuisance neighbors. “Ugh, whatever. Just throw that shit out. It’s stinking up the place.” She pushed in past him and headed for the bathroom to shower.
Paul sighed deeply at her growing irritation. He brought the containers in to do as asked but paused when he headed into the kitchen to dump them. Admittedly, the chicken and rice inside smelled pretty good. He paused, grabbing a fork and eating some of it. His eyes darted to the bathroom as he swallowed. It felt almost silly treating a simple meal like it was contraband. Still, he tossed the rest away before Katey could catch him sneaking bites.
Seemingly at her wits’ end, Katey finally exploded. During dinner, she got up and began pacing. Music from next door was filtering into their home again. It was a slight she could no longer stomach.
“For fuck’s sake! Why do we have to live like this?” She tossed up her hands. “Noise! Noise! Noise! All the damn time! They think they’re above us or something! The way they act! It’s ridiculous! And they have weird guys coming and going at all hours! Their damn beer bottles are just sitting in the hallway! Literally a trash dump right outside their door! Ugh! You would think they’d have some courtesy for their next door neighbors!” Katey gritted out. “And have you seen how they walk around? Like half dressed circus freaks. It’s like they came straight from a Rocky Horror show cosplay contest!”
Paul remained quiet as he ate. The thought crossed his mind: why did it matter how they dressed? He did recognize that she had some points, but he didn’t think they were too bad. The noise was annoying, sure, but Paul had started to suspect it wasn’t really the noise anymore. Something about the women themselves seemed to crawl under Katey’s skin.
His silence seemed to set her off further. Katey whirled on him, pinning him with a cold glare. “You seriously don’t think they’re trashy?”
His body went rigid. His shoulders raised slightly. He knew there was only one acceptable answer that wouldn’t send her through the roof.
“Uh… Y-yeah. They’re totally trashy.” His eyes avoided hers, but he could feel her gaze boring into him.
There was a pregnant pause as she watched him and then finally asked the real question. “Do you think they’re hot?”
A flash of both girls zipped through his head. Ivy with her awesome pale rack, and Babs with her sultry womanly curves. They were total opposites of Katey’s sporty body type, but attractive in their own right. Perhaps it was because they were so different from Katey that it added to their allure. But that didn’t mean he liked them more than Katey. Ivy and Babs were simply novel. Of course, he knew saying that out loud would only spell his death.
“No! Not at all!” he blurted out. Too fast.
Katey narrowed her eyes at him, staring at him long and hard.
Then, finally, she let out a light laugh, which was worse than actually chewing him out. “Okay, babe,” she said with a smirk and walked away.
Paul shrank in his seat, suddenly feeling twelve years old.
That Friday night, another straw was added to the camel’s back.
Paul and Katey settled in for a quiet night. Paul, exhausted from work, was looking forward to some peace and quiet. Meanwhile, Katey had an early morning spin class she needed her beauty sleep for. They were lying in bed, relaxing and watching TV, when the music began thrumming through their wall again. The deep rumble of bass vibrating through the picture frames on their walls.
The couple looked at each other briefly, then turned their focus back to the TV. Paul hit the volume button, raising it. Katey said nothing but an annoyed wrinkle appeared between her brows. They hoped to wait it out, but it became apparent that Ivy and Babs were only getting started. The sounds of a party next door grew louder.
A burst of laughter rang out. Paul hit the volume button again, putting it at max. Katey took a deep breath and checked the time. A little later doors began slamming open and closed. Heavy footsteps echoed up and down the hallway.
“I need to get up around 5:30…” Katey grumbled and glanced at Paul. He, in turn, pretended not to notice. Instead he shut the TV off while Katey turned her white noise app on to full blast.
Another wave of boisterous laughter broke over the loud music. Katey growled and turned over, stuffing her pillow over her head, but he could hear her breathing becoming more irritated. Paul squeezed his eyes shut and sighed. Then a loud crash, followed by even more laughter.
Katey had had enough. She sat up sharply in bed and snarled. “Alright! That’s it!”
Paul stiffened next to her, sensing the impending storm. He didn’t even need to look at her. The instant the mattress shifted beneath her, he knew exactly where this was going.
“You need to go over there,” she huffed at him.
Her tone drew a jolt from his wiry frame. “What? Why me?” He groaned and curled tighter in bed. “You’re the one who wants them to turn it down.”
“Because you live here too,” she muttered at him.
“But why can’t you do it?” He whined and shifted in bed next to her. “You’re up already. Why does this have to be my job?”
Katey just glared, those clear blue eyes searing through him like lasers.
He opened his mouth to argue again. The phrase ‘put your foot down’ came back to him with irritating clarity. He could do it now. Just say no. But he could feel Katey staring him down. Paul glanced at her briefly only to tear his eyes away.
“Tch. Fine…”
Grumbling, he threw his legs over the side of the bed and began tugging his shoes on.
The moment he went out into the hall, the six feet between their apartments suddenly felt like six miles. His heart clenched in his chest as he took his first step. His mind was already reeling over what he would say and how. Paul began rehearsing exactly what he’d say the moment that door opened up.
“Could you maybe…” No. Too soft. He needed to sound more serious. They were the ones overstepping, after all. “You need to…” Ugh. Bad too. Too forceful now. It wasn’t like he was their father. They’d look at him like he was being ridiculous. “Hey, ladies, nice party. Would you mind…?” Nope. Way too simpy. “Foot down, Paul… Foot down…”
He took a deep breath and pushed forward. The music was pouring into the hallway. Beer bottles lined the area around the door like forgotten soldiers guarding the entry.
“Ivy, Babs - I know it’s Friday, but you really need to…”
A little better. More reasonable, but would it be enough to quiet down a room full of drunk idiots? He winced and considered just going back to his apartment and telling Katey he tried. Though that didn’t seem ideal either. She’d just look at him like he was a wuss, and she’d be right.
Swallowing his discomfort, he marched the rest of the way and raised his fist to knock. Just as his knuckle came down, the door swung open.
Ivy stood there in a black crop top and a pleated argyle skirt. The fabric strained over her tits. Her eyes flicked briefly to his raised fist before settling on his face.
Her black lips parted into a smile. “Oh. Hi, neighbor.”
Right away, he lost half the words he had picked out. His mind went blank.
It took a minute for his brain to reboot. Just beyond her, he could see the flashing lights and the shifting of bodies. Their party in full swing.
“Hey, uh, Ivy… I know you guys are busy right now, but, uh… me and Katey are trying to get some sleep, and the music is kinda…” He drifted off, unable to finish as a knot of anxiety curled in his stomach.
“Oh, is it loud?” She tipped her head, that easy smile on her face.
“Uh… Yeah.”
Ivy chuckled. “Like… really loud?”
“Yes.” His hands balled slightly at his sides.
Babs, having overheard, stepped over to the stereo and waved at Paul as she lowered the music slightly. “Better, sugar?”
“Y-Yeah. T-thanks.” Paul gave an uneasy smile back. “I… should go.”
He began backing away, but Ivy leaned against the doorframe and asked, “Your girlfriend send you?”
He paused and blinked at her, caught off guard by the question. Heat crawled up his neck. “W-what? N-no…”
She quirked a brow at him, unconvinced.
He tore his eyes away and glared at the floor, the heat creeping into his cheeks. “Y-yes… she did.”
Babs let out a charmed laugh. “Awh.”
That rubbed him the wrong way. That knot in his stomach bloomed into a spike of pure embarrassment. A muscle in his jaw ticked. “What? Some of us actually have jobs in the morning,” he growled.
Right away, he could feel the temperature drop. Ivy’s easy expression changed. Her smile faded. “What do you do?”
“I-I’m an administra—” he began.
“Junior administrative assistant. That’s right, I remember you said that. What time do you usually start?”
His eyes darted around, looking for an escape route, but he’d already stuck his foot in his mouth. “At… eight.”
“And what time do you usually get off work?” Ivy continued.
“At five…” His shoulders began to rise towards his ears.
“Well, I usually work nights at the bar. Sometimes to two or three in the morning. And Babs, she has shoots that run late too.”
Paul winced. Put like that, his comment sounded a hell of a lot worse than it had in his head. He had essentially marched over here and insulted them all because his girlfriend had gotten annoyed over the noise.
“I… I didn’t mean you don’t work. I just meant…”
“No, of course not, dear.” Babs stepped over and put a hand on Paul’s shoulder gently. “We get that. You need your rest too. We were being inconsiderate.”
Ivy shot her a curious look but just folded her arms and sank back, watching the exchange with a raised brow.
“It’s okay, we’ll keep it down. Won’t we, Ivy?” She looked back at her cohort.
Ivy simply met her eyes and tipped her head.
Babs shrugged with a smile, then sauntered over to the stereo and lowered it a little more. “There, no harm done.”
Paul’s eyes widened slightly. Glancing between the two of them, he had braced for more resistance. His eyes lingered on Ivy, expecting her to object, but none came. After that tense exchange. Was it really that easy? Even with his rudeness, they were actually going to just lower the music? He almost couldn’t believe it. Or worse yet, the whole thing felt… off.
“Oh. Um. Thanks, Babs. Ivy. I’m sorry about the whole– you know…” He rubbed his head and backed away. “Okay… Good night.” He turned and hurried back to his apartment, his heart in his throat.
Katey was already waiting for him by the time he got in and shut the door behind him. She stood, hips cocked and arms crossed. “Well?”
He gave an uneasy smile and cleared his throat. “I-It went well… They turned it down. At first Ivy seemed a little annoyed…” The words caught in his throat as he replayed the awkward argument in his head. He could have told her about the whole exchange. About how Ivy remembered his job, and how stupid he’d felt standing there. But what was the point of that? The music was down. That was all that mattered. “...well, anyway. It’s handled.”
Katey’s face softened into an affectionate smile. She reached out to him, drawing him in for a kiss, her lips brushing his cheek. “My hero,” she cooed.
Paul leaned into the kiss but hardly felt like he deserved it after how everything went down. In fact, he felt like a child being praised for learning how to tie his shoe. Katey headed back to bed to get some much needed rest, leaving him standing there.
Through the wall, he heard Ivy’s distinct laugh, and for a moment wondered if they were laughing about him. She probably was.
The next day at work, Paul sat at his desk, his mind swimming with the events from the previous night. They gnawed at him as he sifted through a monotonous mountain of email chains and spreadsheets. The fluorescent lights buzzing overhead put him in a sort of trance as he replayed the moments at Ivy and Babs’ door. His gaze drifted upward, briefly settling on the fluorescent lights, pulling him back to the flashing party lights in the girls’ apartment. The dull silence in the office seemed to echo with Ivy’s sharp laughter. Why did he keep thinking about them?
It wasn’t because the whole thing went poorly. He had certainly stuffed his foot into his mouth, but it was because he caught the recognition in Ivy’s eyes. She had seen right through him. Through the posturing, the excuses, the way he folded the moment someone pushed back, and it had left him feeling exposed. Vulnerable. He hated it. He was supposed to be a man, unshakable by meaningless glances from women he barely knew, and yet…
Before he knew what he was doing, he clicked away from his emails and typed in Ivy and Babs’ names, searching social media for their pages. For what? Even he wasn’t sure. But curiosity held him hostage as he scoured pages, eventually stumbling on an alternative bar page where Ivy was featured as a bottle service girl. He clicked through, finding her personal page. For a moment, his cursor hovered over the add button, but he hesitated, then moved the cursor away and closed the page. Then immediately reopened it again, navigating to Ivy’s page and then Babs’. His cursor once again hesitated over the add button. The sound of his supervisor’s voice broke him from whatever trance he had been held in.
“Hey, Smith. I need that report on my desk by the end of the day. Also could you fix the header and date? Thanks.”
“Y-yes, sir!” In a panic, he navigated away, opened the last report, and fixed the header and date.
Pausing, he stared at the open report, and something unnerving clicked into place. Everyone told him what to do, and he always did it before he even thought about whether he wanted to. What was wrong with him? Katey. His boss. Worse, he had felt it around Ivy too.
Was this what his life had amounted to? Bowing his head and bending to everyone else’s will because it came naturally? More naturally than asserting himself?
That evening, when he returned home, his thoughts followed him like a judgmental phantom, shadowing his steps as he came in through the front door. However, the uncertainty he felt was chased away by Katey’s warm welcome. She seemed to be in a very good mood, kissing him as soon as he came in. His dinner was ready on the table.
“There’s my man. Come sit. Eat up.” She winked. “You’ll need your strength for later,” she purred and sauntered off to clean up the kitchen.
The sudden change in dynamics surprised him, but it was a welcome one. He sat and ate, watching her, wondering if this was his reward for handling Ivy and Babs yesterday. He didn’t have to wonder long as Katey answered her cellphone and began gabbing with her friend. Her tone was light and pleased as she gushed.
“Hey, Steph! How was your day?”
They bantered as he listened in, catching only bits and pieces until she mentioned ‘the neighbors’.
“Ugh, the neighbors have been such a pain in the ass lately. Yesterday they had this stupid loud party, but Paul handled it.” She cooed with a hint of pride in her tone.
His ears flushed. His own chest swelled with that same pride. For once, he had been recognized for taking charge, and he liked the taste of that small victory. It gave him a hunger for more, especially if Katey was going to be pleased about it. Her praise swam in his ears as he ate, tuning everything else out as he basked in the feeling of finally becoming the man he wanted to be.
As he finished dinner and went to wash his plate, Katey hung up and pressed into his back.
“Paulie,” she let out a heated hum and looped her arms around his slender waist. “You know… I’m kinda in the mood.”
That tone. That touch. It sent a plume of heat straight to his groin. An almost boyish grin split his face. “Yeah? Right now?”
“Mhm…” Katey gripped his tie and led him towards the bedroom.
He was slightly surprised, but pleasantly so. Maybe putting his foot down with the neighbors had turned Katey on. This was his moment to shine. He followed her into the bedroom, mentally working up the courage to take the lead. Feeling a rush of masculine thrill, he laid her down and loomed over her.
“Let me…” he whispered, taking his time to undress her.
His heart was pounding. Finally, it felt like she was handing the reins to him, but now that he had them, he almost didn’t know what to do with them. Her lithe feminine body stirred a hunger in him. His mind drifted to his modest penis pressed into the fabric of his trousers. Usually his insecurity would give him pause but he was too buoyed by Katey’s praise to dwell on it. He knelt at the edge of the bed and peeled her panties down her shapely legs. A healthy bush of blonde curls greeted him. She was breathtaking, and he wanted nothing more than to please her.
“Mh, Paulie… touch me…” Katey sighed and arched her back, spreading her thighs.
For once, she wasn’t pressing him into the bed, riding him until he came undone. Now it was his turn to unravel her. He kissed her thighs, enjoying the way she jolted at the touch of his lips. Her warmth and musky scent drove him wild. He could hardly pace himself before burying his mouth and nose in the glistening trench of her pussy. She tasted sweet, a brackish feminine flavor clung to his taste buds as he licked broad strips along her flesh. Katey hissed and groaned, clutching the blankets. Her eyes shut in bliss as she let him devour her. His tongue slid over the bud of her clit, and that threw her over the edge. She cried out and came hard on his tongue, leaving him buzzing with triumph.
Standing, he began stripping off his trousers.
“Babe, can you get me some water?” Katey asked.
He seemed confused, then went to get it. Once he came back, she was lying in bed and smiling contentedly.
“Mind setting the alarm? I’ve got work tomorrow,” she asked.
His earlier bravado slowly faded away. Whatever shift he thought had happened between them seemed to vanish instantly.
“Sure…” he murmured and handed off the water.
What had happened in those two minutes he had stepped away? Had he ever been in control to begin with?
As his mind reeled, a thump came through the wall. Then another. Then a third. The pulse of bass slowly picked up, and he watched as Katey turned her head and glared at the wall it was thrumming through.
He sighed, already knowing what came next.
Katey’s eyes fell on him, and Paul immediately recoiled.
“Ah, ah… No way. I’m not going back over there. You go.”
A frown tugged at her lips. “I’m not starting drama with those women. Just go. Please.”
“Tch, by sending me, you ARE starting drama. Why can’t you go this time?” He huffed and crossed his arms, looking away.
“Come on, Paulie. You’ve already established a better rapport with them. The boundary is already there. Just go enforce it, yeah?” She softened her brow and tipped her head.
He hated when she gave him that puppy dog look. It made it even harder to say no. He sighed heavily and dragged a hand down his face. “Katey…” Somehow, the boundary she wanted had become his job to enforce.
“Please, babe – you’re better at handling them. You already talked to them. It’ll be weird if I go over there now,” she pressed.
Better at handling them. If only she knew…
Irritated with having to yet again carry out her order, Paul snapped his belt closed with a sharp yank. Muttering under his breath, he shoved his feet back into his shoes, gruffly tightened the laces and marched for the door. His mood simmered hot as he reached it and tossed it open. Whether he was angry at Katey, Ivy, or himself hardly mattered by the time he stepped into the hallway.
This time, he was going to let them absolutely have it.
Unlike the first time, his hesitation was gone as he raised his fist and knocked. To his surprise, the door opened almost immediately.
Ivy stood in the doorway dressed to the nines in goth regalia. Fishnet stockings, a tight black shirt, and a short skirt. Her jet black hair was tied up in spiky pigtails. Pale eyes stared at him, half lidded and framed in smoky eyeshadow.
Babs stood not too far away, looking in a mirror as she smeared on some lip rouge and touched up her cheeks.
The music played like a heartbeat through their apartment. The cloying scent of their perfume wafted into the hallway. As always, they seemed to dwell in a den of mess and chaotic energy. The same piles of clothes and beer bottles decorated almost every surface.
Paul let out an annoyed breath and began to launch his complaint.
“Come inside, I can’t hear you.” Ivy nodded towards the living room.
He gave her an odd look, the command throwing him off balance but also grating on his already raw nerves. “No.”
She turned and walked further into the apartment like she hadn’t even heard him. Her stride was confident, as if she knew he’d follow her.
Dumbstruck, Paul stood there for a moment and looked around. Part of him was ready to turn around and go back to his apartment. Say fuck it and tell Katey he tried. Another part wanted to storm in and give them both a piece of his mind.
His foot shifted, torn between the two before something like curiosity gnawed at him. Babs looked up from her vanity briefly, smiled at him and then went back to powdering her nose. Ivy had already made it halfway across the apartment, and he was still standing stupidly in the doorway. The music thumped on, taunting him.
Why did she want to talk to him inside?
“Tch.” He was only going in because she clearly couldn’t hear him from the doorway. That was all.
Giving in to that treacherous wonder, he stepped inside.
Then he shut the door behind him.
Paul moved stiffly through the apartment, his eyes fixed on the couch. He pushed some clothes out of the way and sat, his arms crossed defensively over his chest. Ivy went to the stereo and lowered the music just enough to talk, and Babs, ever the hostess, stood and asked if he wanted a beer.
“We also have some good whiskey if you prefer something with a little kick.” Babs smiled that easy smile as she offered.
Paul shook his head. He wasn’t here to drink and shoot the shit. He was here to set a boundary. “No, thanks… Can we, uh, focus on–”
Ivy cut him off. One of her brows raised as she narrowed her eyes at him. “Katey doesn’t let you drink?”
A pang of frustration shot through his chest. Katey didn’t really like it when he drank, but it wasn’t like he couldn’t have one if he wanted one. “She doesn’t care,” he grumbled.
“Then have one.” Ivy nodded to Babs, who headed into the kitchen to fix him a drink.
“I…” He began to protest, but it died on his tongue. He didn’t even particularly want one. But now saying no felt worse. “Fine, fuck it. Sure.” Paul sighed.
The corner of Ivy’s lips twitched as she sat across from him. “So… you and Katey. You said you’ve been together for six years. That’s a long time.”
“Yeah, I adore Kate. She’s a good girl,” he answered as Babs returned and handed him his drink. “Thanks…” He sipped at it, trying to get his head back on track, but Ivy was steering the conversation now.
“How’s it going, you and Katey?” Ivy tipped her head.
Babs sat across from them in a loveseat and just watched like it was a tennis match.
“Good. It’s going well. We have our rhythm,” he said.
“You two go out much?” She asked.
“Sometimes…” Paul stared down at his drink.
“Who usually picks?”
Swirling his glass, he hesitated. “I mean… she usually does… but…”
Babs shot her friend a look. “Ivy, don’t be nosy.”
“What? Just curious.” Ivy shrugged. “What about friends? Got any?”
Paul’s brow furrowed slightly. Was she actually trying to get to know him? Why? He had come here to silence the noise. Regardless, not answering felt rude, and he assumed he’d catch more flies with honey. “Yeah, some guys from work… We hang out… Sometimes.”
“Sometimes?”
“I’m usually busy.” The words came slightly clipped.
“I’m sure Paul’s got a lot on his plate. Don’t you, honey?” Babs said softly.
His shoulders dropped slightly at the tone of Babs’ voice. “Yeah… Just a lot of hats to juggle, is all.”
“Speaking of hats. Why do you always wear sweatsuits and baggy stuff?” Ivy interjected.
Paul frowned lightly.
“Oh, there’s nothing wrong with a man wanting to be comfortable.” Babs tossed her hand.
Paul turned away from Ivy, focusing on Babs. The resident goth noticed right away. Her eyes flicked between them.
It was just easier talking to Babs. While Ivy’s questions felt like an interrogation, Babs had a softer way of handling her words.
“Y-yeah, it’s just… I wear button downs and slacks all day at work. It’s annoying. I like to… wear looser clothes when I get home,” he murmured. His gaze twitched from his lap to meet Babs’ eyes a few times before settling on his knees again.
“Why?” Ivy pressed.
His fingers curled into his pants. “Just cause, okay…”
“You seem kinda nervous, Paul… You good?” Ivy purred, a smirk curling at the corner of her mouth.
Paul’s heart clenched in his chest at that question, but he didn’t let it show on his face. Instead, he shifted in his seat, attempting to look relaxed.
“What? I’m not nervous.” He scoffed and sat back with his arms still crossed, though it looked more like he was trying to soothe himself.
“Right…” Ivy said flatly and sat forward. “Indulge me for a sec, Paul. Why does it seem like you’re scared of your girlfriend?”
“I’m not scared of Katey. Why the hell would I be scared of her?”
Ivy glanced over to Babs, who sighed and shook her head softly at Ivy, as if she knew what the goth was doing.
“Ivy, let the man breathe.” Babs sighed and fixed the bandana holding her bright pink hair away from her face. Paul noticed the spider web tattoo by her temple, and for a moment, he felt like a fly that had wandered into a similar web.
“I’m just curious. Why’d you come here twice after she told you to? She sent you tonight too, didn’t she?” Ivy pointed out.
Paul tensed and scowled. “She didn’t—I’m the man of the house, okay? It’s my job to settle shit.”
Her lips pressed into a tight line but almost twitched into a smile. A glint of mirth in her pale eyes. Heat crept up his neck, immediately feeling ridiculous for saying that when he knew that was hardly the case. His mind flashed back to the bedroom; Katey’s pleasure, the glass of water, the alarm.
“Are you?” She curled a brow and tipped her head. Those keen eyes burrowing past his defenses.
Silence fell. He didn’t know what to say. A lie would have made him feel more ridiculous. And the truth hollowed his chest out.
“Oh honey… Ivy—That’s enough. Don’t mind her, Paul. She’s just pushing buttons. Why don’t you tell us what you like to do for fun? Here, let me refresh that drink.” Babs slid in and gently took the glass from his hand.
He should go. He told himself he should peel himself up from the couch and walk right out. Despite Ivy’s pointed questions, Babs’ welcoming warmth drew him in. He stayed for another drink and let Babs steer the conversation. Her questions were lighter and more fun. Ten minutes passed. Then twenty.
He got to know a few new things about the girls. Babs’ rockabilly pinup career, Ivy hanging out with metal bands during bottle service hours at the alt club she worked at. He told them about his old hobbies. Collecting figurines, cosplay—the uncomplicated things he used to do before life became work, his relationship, and endless responsibilities.
By the time he left and headed back to his apartment, he was lightly buzzed and had totally forgotten why he had gone over to talk with the girls in the first place.
The moment he made it back into his apartment, reality crashed in on him. Katey was already in the foyer, waiting. Her arms were crossed, an impatient wrinkle formed between her brows.
“What took you so long? Did they kidnap you?” she scoffed.
Paul froze, his eyes darting around as he scrambled to come up with an answer that wouldn’t annoy her. He could tell the truth. That they had invited him in. That he had sat with them, drank and talked. But he knew Katey’s jealous streak would rear up to bite him for buddying up with them, and he could already imagine the questions that would follow. So he came up with a comfortable lie.
“I told them to turn it down, and they started arguing with each other.” He rubbed his neck. A tell if Katey was paying close enough attention. His gut knotted with something heavy. He hated lying to Katey, but it was easier than getting into a standoff over how he handled the neighbors.
“Well? Are they going to turn down the music or not?” she asked with an exhausted sigh.
As if on cue, the bass rumbling through the walls faded away into a less noticeable thrum. Katey glanced at the adjoining wall, a small triumphant smirk on her lips. “Ah… Good. At least they listen to you.” Satisfied, Katey turned and returned to bed.
Paul watched her go and let out a breath he hadn’t realized he’d been holding in. Thank God she bought it. That guilt sank deeper into the pit of his stomach. Why was he so relieved she’d believed him? Maybe he was just too tired to argue. Regardless of what it was, some small thrill settled in next to the guilt. He had gotten away with something. At least for tonight…
Several days later, as Paul came home from work, he ran into Babs in the entrance hall checking her mailbox. Maybe he could squeak by with a nod of his head, but his feet planted the moment he met Babs’ warm gaze.
“Howdy, neighbor. How’s it going, Paul? Thanks for hanging out with us the other night.” She smiled. “We should do it again sometime. Invite Katey too.”
He almost flinched at the mention of bringing Katey. “Hah… yeah—It was nice. Maybe hold off on bringing Kate along. She, uh… doesn’t know I stayed to hang out.” He rubbed his neck and slightly bowed his head.
A questioning look wrinkled Babs’ perfectly painted brows. “Katey doesn’t know?” She tipped her head as if digesting that. “Was it supposed to be a secret?”
His head shot up, eyes darting around as if searching for an escape. Was it? He hadn’t thought of it that way. He had only lied because explaining the truth would have been a pain in the ass. “Well—I mean, not exactly…?”
Babs just chuckled and tossed a hand. “Don’t worry, babe. I won’t say a word. Your secret is safe with me.” She winked and grabbed her mail, heading back up to her apartment.
That should have put him at ease, but as he trudged up to his own unit, that phrase stuck with him—your secret…
It followed him into the bedroom as he went to change.
It followed him into the kitchen as he grabbed his dinner from the oven.
It sat with him as he settled on the couch and Katey called out to him asking about his day at work.
Your secret…
Except it wasn’t his secret, was it? The more he thought about it, the more it felt like it was.
That weekend, he ran into Ivy this time as he was heading back from throwing out the garbage.
“Hey, Paul.” She smiled at him. Her smiles didn’t feel as warm as Babs’, which put him on edge right away.
“H-Hey Ivy… What’s up?” He tried to step around her, and she slid into his path.
“Are you busy? I could really use a hand,” she said.
He narrowed his eyes at her. “Actually, I am kinda busy right now.”
“Oh? Katey keeping you on a short leash? It won’t take long. Just a shelf that needs hanging.” She shrugged a shoulder nonchalantly, but there was a slyness to the smirk on her lips.
The mention of Katey and her proverbial leash made him bristle. He could almost feel his teeth grinding. His girlfriend didn’t dictate EVERYTHING he did. With a heavy sigh, he muttered, “Fine, just make it quick.” Then motioned to her apartment.
He noticed Ivy’s smile grow deeper as she led him in and handed him the shelf she wanted hung.
Paul made quick work of it, hanging the shelf and straightening it. Just as he was about to leave, Ivy called him over to help shuffle the couch over. He rolled his eyes but figured he’d do it since he was there already and the couch was too heavy for her alone. Then she pushed a case of beer into his arms and told him to place it on the top rack of the fridge. He did so, just to get it done. However, when she held out a bag of garbage for him to take downstairs, it hit him. She’d suckered him into doing chores for her.
He stopped just as he was reaching for it and drew his hand back, glaring at the bag.
“What? What’s up?” Ivy scanned him over. Her head tipped as she scrutinized him.
“I—you…” He chewed his words, feeling a flush of humiliation creep up his neck. She just kept telling him what to do, and he kept doing it. Had he really been that easy?
“Cat got your tongue, Paul? I thought taking out the trash was a man’s job.” That smirk came back to her lips, like she knew what she was doing.
The sentiment made him bristle again. He stumbled over his words as a plume of annoyance shot through him. “Even if it is, it’s not like—what are you getting at?” he growled.
“Nothing, Paul. You seem pretty sensitive about the whole macho image. It’s kinda cute.” She chuckled.
Paul went red in the face. Fury and humiliation collided in his chest like a toxic cocktail. “I am not sensitive.”
Babs came in just as he opened his mouth and read the room right away. “Ivy, are you pushing his buttons again?” She laughed softly and patted Paul’s shoulder. “Don’t let her get to you, honey. She’s always like this.”
“Not sensitive?” Ivy let out a small laugh. “Then how about it, Paul? Wanna play with us girls?”
“W-What? What the hell are you talking about?” He sputtered, taken aback by the idea. Did she really think this was a game? Was this really fun for her?
“Yeah—since you’re so SECURE, why not try something out of the box? You’ve got nice hair and a slender frame. How about you let Babs style your hair, and I’ll get you something cute and frilly to toss on for like a minute. If you don’t crawl out of your skin after a minute, that just shows how confident you are, right?” Ivy nudged Babs.
Babs laughed and swatted her. “Oh, stop teasing him. Though, he does have nice nails. Would you let me paint them?”
He was red again, but this time he was blushing at the idea they were painting in his head. “N-no!” he spat out and recoiled.
“Okay.” Ivy shrugged and walked away with the garbage.
That was it? No argument? No need to defend himself? Had he just proved her right? Had refusing made him look even more insecure?
“W-wait…” he muttered and rubbed his arm.
Ivy paused and looked back.
Babs’ eyes flicked between Paul and Ivy, curiosity cresting in her expression.
“Just for a minute… That’s it.” He couldn’t believe the words were coming out of his mouth. He told himself he was only defending his pride, proving he wasn’t insecure. Still some treacherous little part of him wondered what they would actually do to him.
“Sweetheart, we were just joking, you don’t have to—” Babs started.
“I know, it’s fine. It’s just a stupid game, right? One minute and then I’m taking it all off and going home.” He grumbled and walked into the living room.
Ivy said nothing, though a faint smile touched her lips.
“Just get the stupid clothes. I doubt you have anything that would fit me anyway. I’d probably stretch it, and that’ll serve you right.” He scoffed out a dry laugh, trying to play off his nerves. But then, why was his heart racing?
Babs and Ivy looked at each other with passing surprise and then amusement. They disappeared into their room and came out with the tools to his destruction. Hair ties, an outfit that was clearly Ivy’s clothing, nail polish. They went to work, giggling like girls at a sleepover cornering their crush. The quiet excitement and playfulness was infectious as he relaxed under their attentive hands. Surprisingly, Ivy’s clothes fit him a little too well, and Babs had combed his hair into two cute pigtails. He found himself smirking at the ridiculousness of it all as Babs painted his nails.
“Hehe, time for Paul to meet Polly.” Babs chuckled and grabbed a mirror.
When she turned it to show him, Paul went pale. He hadn’t expected to look so… good. It was like looking at a stranger. Somehow, every insecurity he had about his body as a man was suddenly elevated by this feminine illusion. His slenderness, his softer features, the swell of his chest. It all looked like it… belonged.
And that thought shook him to his core.
Babs seemed tickled by his reaction and handed the mirror over so he could take a closer look. As he gawked at himself, Babs raised her phone and snapped a picture, meant to be a playful keepsake. But Paul’s reaction was visceral. Whatever magic had been cast over him by his reflection shattered in a bout of shock and mortification. Panicking, he tossed the mirror aside and shot to his feet.
“Delete that!” His voice cracked.
Surprised, Babs flushed and hastily went to thumb the delete button.
“Wait,” Ivy chimed in, halting Babs, who glanced over at her, unsure.
“Delete it! I’m not kidding!” Paul bristled, his face flustered.
Ivy leaned over Babs’ shoulder and looked down at the picture. Her pale eyes flickered up to Paul’s dismayed face. Something like recognition flashed in her eyes.
Ivy reached out and tapped on Babs’ phone, sending the image to her own.
The color drained from Paul’s face completely as he realized what she’d done. “Ivy…”
The only one who seemed to have any sympathy was Babs. Her expression softened as she looked between them. “Come on, Iv… Don’t be cruel.”
Ivy softly chuckled to herself and thumbed through her own phone. “I’m not being cruel. He wanted to do it. It’s just a nice little keepsake.”
Paul sputtered and opened his mouth to argue, but the words died in his throat because she was right. He had been the one to willingly play their ‘game’. For the first time since Ivy and Babs had moved across the hall, Paul understood that the dangerous thing wasn’t what they could make him do.
It was what they could convince him to admit he wanted.
That realization slithered up his spine. For a moment, he was at a loss. His eyes darted between the women, his mind short circuited and tumbling through panicked thoughts. Finally, he defaulted to indignation.
“Ivy,” he said firmly. “Seriously. Delete it now.” His fists clenched. His jaw tensed, and a vein throbbed in his slender neck.
The goth woman regarded him with a raised brow, almost surprised by the shift in his tone. Even Babs peered over at him, seemingly taken off guard by the firmness in Paul’s voice. Paul wasn’t backing down this time. Or at least his panic fueled bravado made it feel that way. He stepped forward. “Ivy, I’m not kidding. Get rid of it,” he gritted out.
Ivy regarded him silently for a few seconds, then tipped her head, watching him with a dangerous, birdlike tilt. “Why?” she asked.
Paul stumbled over his next demand. The question struck him like a brick. Why did it matter if she had that picture of him? “B-because I said so! This was just a stupid game! I didn’t say you could take pictures!”
“I’m just asking why it matters so much. It’s just a keepsake.” Ivy shrugged her shoulders. Her nonchalance irritated him.
“B-because it’s embarrassing, okay! I… I look ridiculous, and you know it!” he spat.
Babs smirked behind her fingers. “Actually, Paul, you look great. Like… actually convincing.” The compliment was meant to soothe him, but it only confirmed what he feared.
“S-shut up! No, I don’t! Just get rid of it, please!” The bravado was wavering as another insidious thought trickled in. Did he really look good?
Ivy’s dark lips peeled back into a sly smile. “You’re afraid Katey will see it, aren’t you?”
He stiffened like a bolt of lightning had struck him. Eyes wide, mouth partly open to rebut, but the words never came. He was definitely terrified of Katey seeing it. Any masculine points he had earned with her would fly out the window if she knew he had done this.
The look in Ivy’s eyes lit up with an amused glint. She had found it. His pressure point laid bare. The mention of Katey’s name had shifted something in the room.
“What would Katey think?” She snickered, pressing the fault line she had found.
“Don’t. Katey doesn’t need to know about this. Just…” He held up a hand, almost reaching for her phone. Any confidence he had built up faded, leaving a shattered look in his eyes.
Babs shifted into place, her brow furrowed as she watched the exchange. This was no longer a playful prank. “Ivy. Knock it off. We were just having a bit of fun. Don’t be mean to him.”
The goth sighed, her smile softening as she looked at Babs. Babs had only been enjoying the joke. To Ivy, this was something more. “Relax. Nobody said I was going to send it to her.”
But Paul heard the unspoken ‘yet’ linger in the air.
“I was just curious, is all. Maybe she’d get a laugh out of it,” she added in a way that left his skin crawling.
He suddenly felt like he couldn’t breathe. Trapped. He was trapped, and Ivy was holding the executioner’s axe. Something hot and venomous curled in his chest. He needed to get out of this apartment, away from these women. Paul rushed away to the bathroom to change his clothes and rip the hair ties out of his hair. He washed his face in a hurry and then headed for the door without saying goodbye to either of them.
“See you next time, Paul~” Ivy called after him in a sickeningly sweet tone.
Paul paused and shot a furious glare at Ivy, his teeth bared for a moment like he was ready to spit acid. He couldn’t stand being in the room with them a second longer. The door slammed behind him as he stormed out, leaving Babs and Ivy standing in the living room.
Babs frowned and shook her head softly at Ivy. She gave her roommate a flat look. “Was that really necessary, Ivs? You’re not actually going to send that to his girlfriend, are you?” she asked, folding her arms over her chest.
Ivy paused and glanced from Babs to the photo on her phone. Her lips twitched slightly, then she tossed an innocent look over at her friend. “No.”
The air grew thicker for a second as Babs narrowed her eyes at her.
“Probably…” Ivy chuckled.
Back in Paul’s apartment, he found Katey relaxing on the couch with an afternoon snack, watching TV. Completely unaware of the debacle he had just run from. The normalcy of the scene churned in his gut. His apartment felt worlds away from the one he had just left, and that left his heart racing, knowing that the calm could be shattered at any moment. Yet, oddly, that insidious pang of thrill snuck its way in.
Katey didn’t know…
Several days crawled by like a dying animal. The entire time, Paul felt the sword of Damocles hovering over his head. The lingering silence was somehow worse. He spent those days wound tight, bracing for impact. Each day, he found himself checking his phone or avoiding eye contact with Katey.
His heart climbed into his throat any time he saw Ivy in the hall, or passed Babs in the stairwell. Yet, every time, he got smiles from Ivy and polite greetings from Babs. It only put him on higher alert. Were they waiting for his defenses to be down before closing in? When nothing happened, Paul began to talk himself down. Convincing himself that the entire incident was over. The picture was just a novelty sitting in Ivy’s phone that she chuckled at in private. He sighed to himself, relieved and, in a strange way, almost disappointed.
Then his phone went off. He checked it, fingers shaking when he saw Ivy’s name followed by a skull emoji in his notifications.
“Fuck,” he muttered and scanned the message.
“Hey, neighbor. I need a favor. Can you come over?”
His mouth went dry as he replayed what happened last time in his head. There was no way in hell he was going over. He set his phone down and decided to ignore it.
Then another chime. Ivy again.
“Pretty please?”
His jaw went rigid. He glanced at it and dragged a hand down his face. No. Absolutely not. He could sense the trap.
Then a third message slid in like a serpent.
“Would hate to bother Katey instead.”
“That bitch…” he growled under his breath, his heart plummeting into his gut. He couldn’t ignore it anymore. He could already imagine Katey’s phone going off and that damn picture sitting right there in her inbox. Paul peeled himself up and stormed out the door, stomping next door. Some choice words were already forming in his head by the time he reached Ivy’s door.
He knocked once, and the door swung open. She had been waiting. That grin on her face.
“Hey, Paul.” She could see him seething. The slope of his brow. The tightness around his mouth. Fists bunched at his sides. “Sorry to bother you, just need a hand with a few things.” She ushered him inside, unbothered by the anger radiating off of him.
Paul felt like a coiled spring about to snap, but followed her in. He was about to open his mouth to spew something vitriolic. Set boundaries, demand respect. But then she shoved a box into his hands.
“Can you take these downstairs? It’s pretty heavy. Me and Babs did some spring cleaning.” Ivy smiled and nodded to the door.
The mundanity of it caught him completely off guard. Chores. She had summoned him over for chores. The audacity was offensive. He sputtered, looking at the box, then glared at Ivy.
“Seriously? You threatened me for this?” He scoffed, and gave her an incredulous look.
“Threatened? Who said anything about threatening? I was just asking for a hand.” There was an ease to her tone that grated on his nerves.
“You said…” he began.
“I said what? That I didn’t want to bother Katey? I don’t. That’s why I texted you.” She tossed a shoulder and smiled.
She knew what she was doing. Paul saw it. His mouth hung open. Technically, she was right. She hadn’t overtly threatened him, but the danger was there. A threat so expertly veiled it made a vein throb in his temple. He shut his mouth, molars grinding as he stiffly turned toward the door.
Babs caught him at the door, envelopes in hand. “Oh, since you’re heading that way, can you place these in the mailbox? Thanks, you’re a peach.”
Paul’s eyelid began to twitch. He swallowed the lump in his throat and went downstairs. When he came back up, there was already a task list. Move this here. Grab this. Toss this out. Hang these. Minutes later, he was cleaning their kitchen, watching Ivy do her makeup in the hallway mirror. He stopped and looked down at his gloved hands, scrubber in one, cleaning solution in the other.
“What am I doing?” he muttered flatly.
Ivy peered over with a lazy smile. “Cleaning?”
Paul glared over at her. That’s not what he meant, and she knew it, but the truth was too dangerous to let drift into the air like a noxious gas. Ivy gave him a knowing look. Paul narrowed his eyes at her, but she said nothing else and went right back to her makeup.
Babs, however, approached with a glass of lemonade and handed it off to him.
“Thanks so much, Paul. You’re a gem.”
Her words were a balm on his chafed pride. He took the lemonade and mumbled a thank you, drinking it down. At least Babs made him feel useful, while Ivy’s utter indifference made him feel like a total schmuck. While he didn’t mind doing favors for Babs, doing them for Ivy felt like a sacrifice.
By the end, he returned home, exhausted and annoyed. Katey was waiting for him, already making dinner.
“Hey, babe. Where have you been?” she asked.
“Laundry room.”
The lie came smoothly this time. He didn’t know why it had come so easily, but the fact that it slipped out naturally scared him. Was he becoming that kind of man now? He pushed the thought away. No way. He was just stuck doing chores for some troublesome neighbors.
That was all… right?
After that day, things changed. Not all at once, but in a slow march. Like boiling a frog, Paul didn’t notice the ritual until it had already sucked him in.
The messages came sparsely the first week. Babs texted, needing him to help her carry groceries. He didn’t mind if it was Babs. She made the work feel worthwhile, chatting him up and laughing at his stupid jokes as they hauled the bags inside.
Later that same week, Ivy sent a text. She needed her apartment vacuumed. A party, she said. Didn’t want it dirty when her friends came over, she said. Paul read the messages with disgust and told her he was busy. Her only response: the picture of him in women’s clothes. The threat was clear without any words needing to be exchanged. He gritted his teeth, grabbed the vacuum, and headed over to do it.
The second week, it was Babs again. Sweet, unassuming Babs with her warmth and lemonade. She needed the faucet fixed. Paul didn’t ask any questions and showed up with his toolbox and an easy smile.
By the end of the second week, the routine was locked in. Paul showed up with the vacuum cleaner in hand. No summons. Just knew the carpet was dirty from the last time he showed up. Ivy quirked a brow at him as he walked in and went to work. She said nothing, didn’t have to, but filed it away. Paul told himself he was just preempting. Saving himself the time and humiliation of Ivy ordering him to come clean the carpet. In some small way, his own form of rebellion… maybe.
He moved through their apartment, the rules already tattooed into his brain. Shoes off at the door. Cleaning supplies under the sink. Ivy’s favorite glass. Where Babs left the laundry. When to be out before they both went to work.
Usually, Babs was there chatting with him as he worked. It made every chore mindless, easy to forget he’d been suckered into doing this.
One day, Ivy stood outside the bathroom, watching him scrub the toilet. She never told him to do that. He lifted his head and caught her staring. They both paused as if processing. Then Ivy smiled.
It struck him like a truck.
What the hell was he doing?
He tossed the brush down, but it was already too late.
Back at home things were the same and yet changed. Katey was still running the show, managing the household chores and delegating to Paul but instead of placidly carrying them out like he usually did, now each task she set out for him rubbed him the wrong way. He began to notice the shift slowly but surely.
Whenever Katey asked him, “Can you grab that?” A plume of irritation crawled up his spin. And yet, whenever Ivy told him to “Bring me that.” He felt something else entirely. Something he didn’t have the vocabulary for yet. It was confusing, leaving him baffled by his own feelings. As he sat in his office he thought about what was going on with him.
When Ivy ordered him around, he followed through because he told himself there was a looming threat there. That if he didn’t, there would be tangible consequences. That stupid photo. That had to be it. That unnameable boogey man keeping him in line. Meanwhile, Katey was just his girlfriend who had gotten complacent.
“What the hell is wrong with me?” He laid his head down on his desk and groaned.
Later that day, he was back in Ivy and Babs' house doing chores once again. A towel in his hand, wiping their windows down, lost in deep thought.
“Looking good there, Polly!” Ivy called with a smile.
Polly, not Paulie. What Katey usually called him. Something about that nickname was like a record scratching in his head.
“What did you call me?” He glared over at her.
“Polly.” Ivy grinned.
“Hehe~ Polly, so cute! I love it.” Babs chimed in.
“Don’t.” Paul grits out.
“What? Katey calls you Paulie, why can’t we?” Ivy tipped her head.
“Because… you don’t mean it like she does and you know it.” He grumbled.
“I think it’s charming, don’t take offense, Polly! You’re one of the girls now!” Babs joked. She meant no harm, just teasing affectionately.
Paul faltered, the fight drained out of him. He began wiping the windows harder. His shoulders hunched around his ears. Face flushed. He didn’t mention it again, but as he laid in bed that night with Katey, that stupid nickname came back to his head. Paulie was Katey’s man. While “Polly” was something else. It echoed in his head as he tried to sleep, and with it, the memory of himself dressed as a woman.
A few days later, Paul headed over to Ivy and Babs’ expecting another cleaning session. However, when he stepped through the door, Ivy was standing by the couch, her lips pulled tight as if fighting a giddy grin.
“Oh, Polly~ I got you something. I remember you said you liked to cosplay. Well… I got you a uniform to wear while you clean. Relive some of those otaku days, huh?”
Paul paused and narrowed his eyes at her, sensing the trap. “Cosplay… you… got me a costume?”
She stepped aside. On the couch was draped a long bag with a hanger jutting from the top. From where he stood, he could already make out the silhouette of frills and an apron.
“That is not what I think it is… is it?” His face went white, then red, then white again. Eyes wide. For some reason, his heart was beating fast. “There’s no way in hell…”
“Oh, come on. Think of it like a maid cafe. I’m sure you’ve seen those in anime.” Ivy waved a hand.
Babs walked in, sipping her tea, watching the two talk like she was observing a tennis match. “What’s up?”
“Nothing. Just got Polly a uniform so his clothes don’t get dirty while cleaning. Would hate for him to have to explain any stains to Katey.”
“A uniform?” Babs glanced over at it.
“No. Absolutely not!” Paul backpedaled.
Babs went over to the bag and peered inside. “Oh my gosh! It’s so cute!”
Paul grimaced and shook his head. “I’m not wearing it!”
“Aw… that’s too bad. I spent good money on it too.” She sighed, but her hand drifted toward her phone.
Paul tracked the movement and gritted his teeth. “Ivy! No! Don’t you fucking dare!” he snarled.
Babs’ head shot up, and she glanced between them, concern knitting her brows. “Ivy, he said no. He’s already doing us a big favor by helping out. Let him be.”
That seemed to halt Ivy in her tracks. She huffed a soft, “Fine. No uniform.” She shrugged, dropping the issue, and walked away to the kitchen.
With a bitter taste in his mouth, Paul began cleaning around the house like he usually did, but every few minutes, his eyes drifted toward the bag. Ivy watched him from the kitchen, noticing every time his head turned toward it.
“W… What’s in there anyway?” he muttered before he could stop himself.
“A maid outfit. One of those ones the girls in anime wear,” she answered with a playful smirk.
He paused, his eyes glued to the dark bag. Something about that gnawed at his fascination. The cute frilly outfits girls in anime wore. He could almost picture it.
“Would… Would it even fit?” he muttered.
“Only one way to find out.” Ivy laughed.
He froze, blinking at her slowly as if mulling it over. He could satisfy his curiosity and then strip it off before anything happened. “Fine… just for a minute. Just to see if it fits. It doesn’t mean anything.”
A glint flickered in Ivy’s eye. “Sure it doesn’t.” She was already moving to the couch to strip the bag away.
What did that mean? Her quick agreement didn’t sit well with him. Did she doubt him? Of course she did. Well, he was going to prove her wrong. He’d put it on just for a moment, feel ridiculous, and tear it off. It wouldn’t mean a damn thing, and Ivy would have wasted her money on something stupid.
She held the hanger up, and his throat went dry. It was, indeed, a maid outfit. Frills everywhere, black and white with a bow and apron. Even the damn head frill. It was so dumb. He chewed the inside of his cheek, snatched it from her hand, and went to change.
However, the moment he pulled it on, he felt different. His skin prickled with goosebumps as he passed by the mirror and caught a glimpse of himself. A stranger stared back at him. A cute stranger.
Then Babs and Ivy peered into the bathroom, and grins bloomed across their faces.
“Oh my god! Polly!” Babs squealed. “It’s even better than I imagined. So friggin’ cute!”
Ivy just stared, quietly studying him.
Paul was right about one thing. He felt absurd. Then something warm and invasive settled in the pit of his stomach. He expected disgust. Prepared himself for it, and yet it was that stubborn curiosity that kept coming back. He turned slightly in the mirror, inspecting the stockings on his slender legs, the way the outfit narrowed around his waist, the bow at the slope of his throat. Like a stone dropping into still water. Recognition rippled outward, followed by something that disturbed him even more.
Relief.
Paul’s face flushed red, and violently he shoved it away, covering his humiliation with a familiar plume of anger.
“Knock it off! It isn’t cute, damn it!” he snarled.
Ivy just smiled and handed him a bucket with cleaning supplies.
“You’ve gotta be kidding me?” he gritted out.
“You’re already dressed.”
He should leave. Rip the stupid thing off and stomp out right now. His eyes flicked to the door beyond and then down to the bucket.
Instead… he grabbed the bucket and went to work.
Days later, Paul watched his phone religiously. The adrenaline from wearing that stupid outfit still pulsed in his veins. He kept replaying the image of himself in his head every night as he lay in bed with Katey.
Then he got a text from Babs. Not an order to come over and do chores. No threat. Just an invitation to hang out and have some drinks before the girls went to work. He read it once. Then twice, as if searching for the trap. He told himself he shouldn’t go. That getting friendly with these girls was a mistake… but maybe if he befriended them, they’d have less to hold over his head. After all, he’d already worn the maid outfit.
Against his better judgment, he showed up at their place after work. Babs ushered him in, petting his hair back, which oddly put his nerves at ease. He sat on their couch, fully expecting the maid outfit to come back out, but instead they pushed a drink into his hand and just… talked.
Babs chatted with him about Katey, but Ivy asked about him. He didn’t know why the words poured out like they did. Maybe it was the beer, maybe it was the fact that these two women had already seen him at his most embarrassing. What else could he say to lower their opinion of him anymore?
“I don’t know. I hate my job. Sometimes I just feel invisible wherever I go. My boss doesn’t take me seriously. My coworkers push their work off on me. Katey is practically my boss at home. Sometimes I just sit there and imagine what it would be like to be in control of everything. Be the boss for once, you know?”
Ivy watched him, the look on her face thoughtful before she sipped her drink and asked a question that made him pause. “And why haven’t you taken control? You could just say no.”
Paul stared at the can in his hand. “I… I don’t know… Maybe I don’t want to disappoint anyone.”
Babs and Ivy exchanged a look before Ivy’s pale eyes slid back over to him. “Don’t want to disappoint? Or maybe it’s just more comfortable to submit? Maybe you don’t actually want to be the dominant person. It’s too much pressure on you.”
That thought struck him like a lightning bolt. He tensed and shifted in his seat. The very idea of control becoming a stressor resonated deeper than he was willing to admit.
“T-that’s not it at all. I can take the pressure. It’s just… nothing, okay. Stop trying to psychoanalyze me,” he bit out.
Ivy gave that enigmatic smile and shrugged. She didn’t bring it up again. Babs watched him with something like sympathy in her soft eyes. They moved on, talking about other things. The mood shifted into something more playful as alcohol swam through their systems.
Then the doorbell rang, and Babs went to answer it. A man walked in, skin like mahogany and built like he hit the gym five times a week. Apparently, he was a friend of Ivy’s from work. He had tattoos crawling up his neck and settled in to drink with them.
“Hey, Marcus. Me and Babs are thinking about opening a maid cafe. Wanna see our star server?” Ivy winked and stood up. She retrieved the maid outfit from the closet and set her eyes on Paul.
Paul’s eyes went wide, heat rising into his cheeks. He shifted in his seat, uncomfortable. That odd electricity ran down his spine and pooled in his gut.
“Oh, Ivs, don’t do this to him now. Paul, you don’t have to stay for this. You can go. Ivy’s up to no good again.”
Marcus curled a brow and glanced between the three of them. “Hold up, who’s that for?”
Paul shrank and blushed deeper. “I…”
“It’s your time to shine.” Ivy winked.
His time to shine. That’s right. Paul never felt invisible whenever he wore feminine clothes. In fact, he felt seen. Too seen. His heart hammered in his chest.
“Just… for a minute… okay? Then I take it off.” Paul stammered and rose to go change.
Marcus watched, fascinated and amused. “Yo, seriously? Aw, man, I gotta see this.” He sat back, legs spread as he settled in for the show.
Moments later, Paul reappeared in full maid regalia. His hair tied in pigtails. Eyes sheepishly glued to the floor, but he was blushing up to his ears. Ivy grinned. Babs giggled. And Marcus watched him with something hungry in his eyes.
“Gawd damn… If I didn’t know any better, I’d think you were the prettiest little bitch I’ve ever seen.”
Paul flushed crimson. His heart was beating wildly, and yet he felt more intoxicated by the surge of adrenaline than any amount of cheap beer.
“W-welcome home, y-young master.” He dipped into a curtsy. His voice pitched higher and feminine.
Babs burst out laughing and slapped her thigh. “He’s so cute! I can’t stand it!”
Marcus grinned and shifted in his seat. His cock was half hard already. “I’m in love.”
Ivy just watched with that quiet smile, her eyes half lidded.
“Come here, sweetheart. Sit on master’s lap.” Marcus patted his thigh.
Paul straightened up, looked between the women, then back at the door. His throat was tight. Babs sat observing like this was better than her soaps. Ivy continued watching him from across the room, waiting to see what he’d do next.
Paul took a step. Then another.
Inside, he was screaming at himself to stop, turn around, and leave. But that other part of him craved this attention. The humiliation coiled so tightly with that forbidden thrill he could barely breathe. He lowered himself into Marcus’ lap and hated how his body reacted to the hard press of Marcus beneath him.
What the hell was wrong with him? Was he actually enjoying this?
Paul sat there in Marcus’ lap, his slender thighs trembling. His groin tingled with something he refused to name as arousal. Marcus’ hand rested on Paul’s thigh and slid upward, under his skirt, and he never pushed it away. His heart nearly beat out of his chest, and yet he found some filthy part of himself craving more.
At eleven o’clock, Marcus went home, but not before giving Paul’s ass a squeeze and promising to come back for another visit. The moment he was gone, Paul stood up and ripped the head frill off. White hot shame curdled into that familiar and comfortable rage.
“You guys… You let him… You made me!” He jabbed his finger at Ivy, glaring at her with tears in his glassy eyes.
“No,” Ivy simply said and folded her arms. She lifted a hand to point at the door.
He could have left. He didn’t have to put the costume on. He chose to stay. He chose to perform.
Paul’s mouth went dry as his rage fizzled out. She was right. Of course she was right. Babs had even offered him a way out, and he stupidly stayed. Paul stormed to the bathroom and changed, then trudged for the door with his head down, cheeks burning. Babs followed him out.
“Paul… honey, are you okay?” she asked kindly.
“I’m fine,” he muttered and shut the door behind him.
He was not fine…
The following week, Paul threw himself back into his routine with Katey. They went to dinner. They attended the gym together. Sat together watching TV. He paid the bills. He washed the laundry. They even began having sex more often, Katey usually on top. He always made her come.
He was putting effort into things that were once normal. Working hard at a routine that no longer felt like routine, but a disguise.
Katey didn’t suspect anything at first. She praised and doted on him, seeing these changes as improvements in his confidence. She asked for help in the kitchen and he’d take over cooking an entire course just to please her. Her pride in him only doubled his guilt, and yet he still found himself going back over to Babs and Ivy’s place.
Their apartment had become his secret world. A double life that belonged only to him and his secrets. Every time he stepped foot into that world, he shed his skin as Paul and, for a few hours, existed as ‘Polly’. Cleaning and having drinks with the girls. They’d tease him and push his buttons, but Paul found himself craving the rush that came with it. At home, he was Katey’s Paul. Sweet and attentive, even slightly awkward. But next door, among Ivy and Babs, he had become another version of himself entirely. Babs would smile at him and ask for a drink, and Paul already knew which glass and how much ice to place into it.
Marcus became a frequent visitor, stopping by to check on his ‘favorite maid’. Slowly but surely, every glance and touch shared between them removed a brick from the walls of Paul’s limits. He found himself increasingly comfortable in an apartment that didn’t belong to him. Opening cabinets without asking. Knowing where certain things belonged without being told. Sitting in Marcus’ lap. Letting the man touch his thighs and whisper in his ear until his face flushed red. Letting Marcus steal brief kisses and touch his ass.
He had stopped thinking about why it made him feel guilty and began just existing in this new headspace.
When Katey began asking questions, he no longer panicked. Now he had answers prepared and ready to go whenever she asked why he was late or where he had gone. Sometimes he’d tell her work ran late. Or that one of his friends had called. Other times, he told her he was doing the laundry or running errands at the store.
He began to remember each lie and when he had told it, ensuring his alibis were already airtight. What should have scared him was how good he was becoming at deception.
Katey, however, wasn’t as blind as he’d hopefully believed. She began noticing patterns, though she had no evidence to prove that something was amiss. He’d shower at odd times. Guard his phone from her. He started doing laundry more frequently, never letting her touch his clothes anymore. Sometimes she’d catch him staring at the hallway whenever they’d hear Ivy laugh through the walls.
She’d narrow her eyes at him, and he’d pause for a brief moment, then shrug it off and laugh. “Noisy neighbors, right?” Then walk away.
One day, she cornered him. Her blue eyes scanned him over for any inkling of guilt.
“You’re not hanging out with them, are you?”
He met her eyes and answered, “No.”
A week later, Ivy texted him the details of a party they were having the following day. Paul was being invited. The thought of being in their apartment, surrounded by strangers who had no idea what he’d been up to while there, made something icy crawl up his spine. Too many people equaled too much risk. Plus, what if Katey came home early and heard him next door?
“Sorry, Ivy. I don’t think I can make it,” he texted back.
Ivy texted back a thumbs up emoji, and that was the end of it.
Paul stared at it. That single emoji stung his pride. Was he really that unimportant to her? After everything he had done for them? After what they had shared? She wasn’t even going to offer a crumb of pushback? That thought gnawed at him, but he put it out of his mind. He simply could not get caught in a group of people that large, knowing the influence Ivy and Babs had over him.
That Saturday night, the party was in full swing by the time he got off work. Katey was working late at the gym, so luckily she wouldn’t be there to complain about the noise. But Paul could hear it all through the walls. Every throb of the bass. Every peal of laughter. It sounded like a great time. He could even pick out the low timbre of Marcus’ voice, mirthful and chuckling.
He tried drowning it out with the TV, switching on some drama show he barely remembered the plot to and cranking it up as far as it would go. Even then, he couldn’t stop himself from glancing at the connecting wall over and over again.
Then his phone went off. He expected it to be Katey, but it was Babs.
“Hey sweetie! Are you alive over there?”
Paul’s thumbs hovered over the screen as he mulled over how to answer. “Yeah, just relaxing after work. How’s the party?” He didn’t even know why he asked. He could hear it through the walls.
“It’s going great! You should stop by and have a drink. We miss you!”
Babs was always so damn sweet. A part of him didn’t want to disappoint her. Another part was just plain curious to see what was going on over there. Another part wondered what Marcus was doing.
“Nah, Babs. Thanks, but you go on and have fun. I’m just going to chill tonight,” he wrote back before he began questioning himself deeper.
“Okay, hun! We’re right next door if you get lonely!” she texted back.
He stared at the text. Put his phone down. Picked his phone back up. Then put it down again and shifted in his seat. The music track changed, and his eyes slid back toward the adjoining wall. Katey wouldn’t be home until much later, but he wasn’t obligated to show up. No threat of repercussion, and yet…
Suddenly, he was up on his feet and heading for the door.
“One drink,” he told himself. “One drink, and that’s all.”
He was across the hall before he could stop himself. One knock on the door, and Babs tugged it open with a grin.
“I knew you couldn’t stay away. Come on in, sug!” She ushered him in with a gentle hand and then announced his arrival. “Neighbor’s here!” she chirped.
Several heads in the room turned toward him and smiled, warm and welcoming.
“Hey!”
“Welcome, stranger!”
“Who’s this cutie pie?”
The crowd was a wild mix of styles and flavors. A crowd of night owls, dressed in varying degrees of alternative. He could tell these were Ivy’s and Babs’ nightlife friends. The way they called out and waved without reluctance. These were confident people. Loud personalities all sardined into one apartment. Most were gathered near the couch. Others hovered in the kitchen or danced in the living room. Marcus stood near the living room, a twinkle in his eye as he winked at Paul from across the room. Paul’s ears went red and he averted his gaze too quickly.
Babs took Paul around, introducing him to a few of them.
“This is Jasper, he’s in a band.” She pointed out a man with an afro mohawk who smiled and nodded. “And this is Lucas.” She gestured to another man with cornrows. “He models with me.”
She went down the line, eventually putting a drink in his hand.
Paul found a spot on the couch near Ivy and sat. She smirked at him and nodded.
“You made it. I knew you would.” She nudged him.
Paul sank back, watching the partygoers chat and have fun. His shoulders dropped as he sipped his drink and became part of the flow.
Rafi, a man with russet skin and neon dreadlocks, tapped Ivy’s leg. “So how do you two know each other?”
Paul smiled politely. “Neighbors. I live next door.”
Ivy chuckled and sipped her drink. “He’s our housemaid.”
An awkward laugh rippled through the crowd. No one could tell if she was joking or not, but Paul knew.
His face went white and his smile died as his eyes darted over to Ivy.
Ivy’s smile simply grew wider as she hid it behind the rim of her glass. The gleam in her eyes was unapologetic.
For a moment, Paul’s stomach sank. That familiar flush of humiliation tangled in his gut. He went back to his drink, and Ivy went back to hers, but every so often he could feel her eyes shift to him, something mischievous building up there.
“Hey, Paul. Go grab some drinks out of the kitchen, yeah? We’re running low.”
Before he could even question it, he was up and out of his seat and into the kitchen. When he returned and began handing them out, Ivy chimed back in.
“There’s snacks in the fridge. Grab those too, while you’re at it.”
Again, no argument or thought. His body was on autopilot. The partygoers began to notice and at first assumed he was helping to host. Then Babs called across the room, “Polly! There’s a spill over by the table. Can you get that?”
“What did she call you? Polly?” Rafi laughed. Others joined in.
Paul chuckled weakly. His smile was tight at the corners, but he didn’t hesitate. He simply grabbed up a towel and went to wipe it up.
Marcus laughed. His eyes locked onto Paul’s ass as he stooped over to clean. “Damn, shawty. You gonna slip on your uniform while you’re at it?”
Paul froze, realizing what he was doing, and flushed a deep scarlet. The attendees laughed along, sensing something going on. A sharp glint glittered in some of their eyes.
“You know what? That’s a good idea.” Ivy laughed. “Why don’t you slip on your uniform? You can run a proper maid service.”
Babs stood back, watching with a playful smirk on her lips. “Don’t mind her, Polly. You can head home if you want to.”
There it was again. The open door was being offered, but something held Paul’s feet in place. The attention. That ugly humiliation mingling with something arousing.
“N-no… It’s fine. You want the uniform? Fine.” He wasn’t going to back down.
The party watched as Paul disappeared into the back. Breaths held as they curiously watched the door. Marcus, Ivy, and Babs could barely contain themselves, already knowing what was about to come through that door.
Then Paul appeared in full maid regalia, frilly skirt pulled up into a curtsy.
“Welcome home, young masters.”
The entire party went silent, eyes wide. Then all at once, the party exploded. Most were laughing. Others had their mouths hanging open. A few of the guys watched on with a hungry look in their eyes.
“Shit, you’d have me fooled.” Jasper, with the afro mohawk, chuckled, wiping his eyes.
Rafi and Lucas were grinning and nudging each other, murmuring into each other’s ears as they watched Paul cross the room.
Paul’s heart was hammering in his chest. He felt absurd. Shame poured into his gut, and yet the tightness of thrill settled between his thighs. They were watching him. All the attention was on him.
Soon enough, he had become the party’s personal maid. When someone called for drinks, Paul went and got them. When a mess was made, he swept over to clean it.
Lucas caught him by the waist, pulling him to the impromptu dance floor. “Come dance with me, Polly,” he purred in his ear.
“I-I… I’m not that good…” Paul tried to protest, but the larger black man’s arm was like an iron band around his waist.
The others watched, whooped, and cheered as Lucas began dancing with Paul, grinding his cock against Paul’s ass. He hated how the other man’s hardness made his own penis tingle and twitch beneath the frilly petticoat of his maid uniform.
Before long, Marcus cut in, dragging Paul onto his lap, making Paul pour his drinks while Marcus’ hand fell to the swell of Paul’s ass. Ivy sat back and watched, smirking and giggling with Babs as they watched Paul be passed from Lucas to Marcus and then seated between Jasper and Rafi, who shamelessly gripped at Paul’s thighs and the back of his neck.
Paul was cherry red in the face as he became the evening’s entertainment.
The air thickened into something predatory as the group of men closed ranks, chuckling huskily as they tugged at Paul’s stockings and groped at his flat chest. One of them, Lucas, pulled him in for a kiss, catching Paul off guard. At first, he pulled away, but then melted as the man slid his tongue into his mouth.
The crowd watched, enraptured by the scene, and began cheering it on, making Paul’s heart beat harder in his chest. The line between shame and excitement grew dangerously thin as he swirled his tongue with Lucas’.
His chest clenched as his thoughts drifted to Katey.
What the hell was he doing?
Paul sprang up, flustered and breathing hard. He ran for the bedroom to change, throwing on his other clothes and leaving the maid outfit on Ivy’s bed. He pushed through the party crowd and headed for the door in a panic.
“Hey! Where are you going, fine shit? We were just getting started!” Lucas called with a grin. The others laughed and beckoned him back over.
“I-I gotta go!” Paul called back and rushed for the door.
Ivy and Babs stood by the door, smiling at him.
“Thanks for coming, Polly.” Ivy chuckled with a glint in her eye.
“You did so good, honey. Come back again and play with us next time.” Babs winked and opened the door for him.
Paul rushed out and stood in the hall, catching his breath. He had crossed a line, and he knew it. And now there was no going back.
His secret no longer belonged to only Babs and Ivy.
Here’s the lightly corrected and properly formatted version, preserving your voice, prose, and existing dash exactly as placed.
The next morning, Paul awoke with a splitting headache. Sunlight peeked through the blinds, searing his eyes. He groaned and turned over, Katey sleeping soundly by his side. He peered over at her with one eye barely cracked open.
Flashes from the night before trickled in. The party. Having drinks. Ivy and Babs telling him what to do. His obedience. And then that damn maid outfit.
What the hell had he been thinking?
Embarrassment flooded in like a tidal wave. He had gotten too comfortable. That idiotic thrill seeking had dragged him into a situation he knew Katey would never forgive him for. For the rest of the day, he couldn’t quite meet her eyes, and Katey noticed right away.
“What’s up, Paulie?” she asked as they stood in the kitchen together.
Paul chewed the inside of his cheek. “Nothing. Just tired.”
“Tired?” Katey narrowed her eyes at him. “Tired from what?”
A lump formed in his throat as he thought up another lie to set her at ease. “Nothing… Just went out for some drinks with the guys at the office.”
Katey crossed her arms and tipped her head at him. “Huh… Is that why your shirt from yesterday smelled like cigarettes and booze?”
He jolted but quickly covered it. Had she smelled that on him? “Uh… Yeah.”
Katey stared at him a minute longer but didn’t press. She just… walked away.
And somehow that was worse.
He suddenly felt ill. Had Katey caught on? Nah, she couldn’t have. He was just being paranoid.
Later that afternoon, Paul ran into Ivy in the hallway. She still had that smug look on her face, and it made him bristle. Gritting his teeth, he stomped over to her.
“This is your fault. I should have never come to that stupid party. I can’t believe you guys made me—”
“Ah, ah.” Ivy stopped him right there. “We didn’t make you do shit. You came over because you wanted to. You started serving drinks when you could have said no. You put on the outfit because you wanted to be the center of attention. No one threatened you. You did it because deep down in that perverted little degenerate heart of yours, you know you fucking like being treated like a pretty little bitch.”
Paul was stunned. Ivy had never spoken to him like this before. She was always subtle in her manipulations, but this was Ivy laid bare, and she was exposing him just as much. He sputtered and growled, fists clenched, but he couldn’t deny it. He chose to stay. He chose to put on a show.
He had liked it.
Ivy grinned, knowing she had him by the balls. “Tell you what, Polly. You can keep coming over to play with us. Live out all your dirty little fantasies, and me and Babs won’t say a thing. We have another group thing tomorrow. Just Babs, me, Lucas, and Marcus. You like them, right? ’Cause they sure as hell love you. I’ll send you a text, and you can come over and have some fun with the boys. Deal? Katey never has to know.”
Paul swallowed hard. He wanted to tell her no right then and there, but the word failed to form in his mouth. Instead, he went red from brow to chest, turned, and stalked off.
“That’s not a no! See you tomorrow, Polly~” she called after him in a sing-song tone.
Paul hated himself for waiting for the text to arrive the next day. When it did, he didn’t bother answering. Just waited for Katey to leave for the day and went next door.
As promised, Babs and Ivy were waiting with Lucas and Marcus. There was no warm up. A crop top with a pair of too tight shorts was pressed into Paul’s hand. Babs styled his hair into pigtails, Ivy did his makeup. Lucas and Marcus sat on the couch, awaiting their favorite little piece of ass.
Paul served them drinks, sat in laps, kissed, and let the other men grope him. Ivy laughed and treated him like a dog, making him beg and crawl across the floor. Babs praised him and petted his head.
“Such a good boy, Polly. Why don’t you give Marcus another sweet kiss?” she’d coo at him.
Paul found himself drunk on a heady mix of shame and arousal. He knew it was wrong. Knew he was sinking further and further into something he could never crawl his way out of, and yet he found himself craving more.
These private parties continued for weeks, where Paul would come over simply to be stripped of his dignity, poured into too tight women’s clothes, and fondled by black men as Ivy and Babs watched and encouraged it.
Meanwhile, Katey was starting to notice his long absences. She’d even mentioned the smell of perfume on his clothing. They had started to fight, followed by long stretches of them not talking. It actually made it easier for Paul to sneak away.
One afternoon, Katey pushed him too hard on his whereabouts, and Paul finally blew up at her.
“You treat me like a goddamn child! Will you lay off?? I have a life too, goddamn it!”
He had never spoken to her like that before. Betrayal and a deep hurt settled over her features as she glared at him. There was no resolution to that argument as Katey took her things and went to work.
That same evening, he was back in Ivy and Babs’ apartment, perched on Marcus’ lap. Hugging the man and calling him ‘daddy’. Paul knew he was too far gone, and in that knowledge, he was strangely free.
That night, things escalated. After fighting with Katey, Paul just wanted to forget that side of his life, and Ivy was all too willing to play devil’s advocate. She had Babs mix up cocktails and pass them out. The edges of Paul’s world began to soften.
Slowly but surely, ‘Polly’ took over, emboldened by the attention. Paul began to give them lap dances, laughing and giggling as he ground himself into Ivy’s and then Babs’ lap. They slapped his ass and cheered him on.
Before long, Marcus had him pressed into the couch, roughly kissing him. It was hungry and aggressive, a devouring that promised more. Lucas, meanwhile, had unzipped his pants, taking out his cock and stroking it as he watched Marcus swirl his tongue into Paul’s mouth.
Paul moaned and arched, his head swimming. He was beginning to feel more and more like a desirable woman, and the sensation left him buzzing for more. Ivy and Babs stood by the kitchen doorway, laughing softly and murmuring to one another as they watched.
“Hey, bruh. It’s my turn to use that mouth.” Lucas reached out and gripped Paul’s hair.
Marcus sat up and saw Lucas with his cock out, already erect and thick. The tip was slick and throbbing. Paul tilted his head, following Marcus’ eyes. When he saw Lucas’ fat cock out, his breath hitched and his heart lurched.
This was new. Another threshold begging to be crossed, but he hesitated.
Was he really considering going this far?
Marcus was still on top of him. He felt the man grind his hips forward, making Paul gasp again. He was just as hard. He could feel Marcus’ dick pressing into him. A wave of shame and heat rolled through Paul. His heart raced at the implications. Two big men had him pinned on the couch. Both with their dicks hard and hungry eyes locked on him.
Paul whimpered and pushed against Marcus’ chest, but he was solid as a brick wall.
“Ah, ah… You’ve been teasing us for weeks, baby. You ain’t going nowhere.” Marcus grinned and sat up, gripping Paul by the back of his neck. “Go on. Use that pretty mouth.”
He pulled Paul up and pushed him toward Lucas. Lucas wore a similar grin as he reached out and caressed Paul’s hair, then fisted his hand in it and slowly tugged him down toward his awaiting cock.
“Come on, baby. Just a little kiss.”
He rolled his hips, pressing the tip of his oozing dick against Paul’s lips.
Paul winced and flinched, but Lucas held him in place, rolling his hips again. Smearing salty precum across Paul’s mouth. Paul gasped, but some traitorous reflex made him lick it off his bottom lip. The musky taste exploded on his tongue, sending his own pulse into his ears.
He flushed scarlet down to his chest, but eventually gave in to the steady pressure of Lucas’ hand in his hair. Paul whimpered as his mouth opened and Lucas bucked into his mouth. The thickness of his length stretched Paul’s lips almost painfully. Tears formed in Paul’s eyes, and he gagged, but Lucas didn’t let him up. Even as Paul’s slender pale body began to tremble in a mix of fear and excitement.
Meanwhile, Marcus sat behind Paul, watching the tiny white man take his first dick. He began stroking himself with one hand. The other came up and slipped beneath Paul’s skirt, finding the pale globe of his ass cheek. He palmed it and began kneading it, slowly pushing Paul’s underwear aside to prod and tease the tight cinch of Paul’s asshole.
Paul gasped and sputtered around Lucas’ cock, arching away from the intruding fingers, but he was trapped between them.
Lucas was guiding him now, forcing Paul’s head further down his shaft as Marcus licked his fingers and went back to playing with Paul’s asshole. Ivy and Babs watched in rapt silence, smiles on their faces.
Paul hissed and moaned, arching away from the intruding fingers as Marcus worked him open. His mouth was still sealed around Lucas’ cock, now almost eagerly sucking the other man’s dick, if only to keep his attention away from what was happening with his asshole.
Lucas threw his head back and hissed. His hips angled off the couch to press further into Paul’s mouth. Paul gagged, saliva pooling around his lips and trickling down Lucas’ shaft.
Marcus leaned forward, pushing Paul’s skirt up around his narrow hips and tugged his underwear down, exposing his modest penis. The skinny length of it was hard and dripping into his underwear.
“Haha… You act like you don’t want it, but your body doesn’t lie, pretty boy.” He spread Paul’s cheeks apart and dragged his tongue through Paul’s crack in a broad, hot strip that left the skinny white boy shivering and moaning around Lucas’ girth.
“Oh fuck, that’s hot.” Ivy bit her lip, watching as Marcus began eating Paul’s ass out.
His tongue dipped into the tight rosebud of Paul’s anus, loosening it with each pass. Paul jolted and arched, moaning and drooling more obscenely around Lucas’ cock. Lucas gripped Paul’s neck and pushed his head down, holding him in place as he began bucking into Paul’s mouth, chasing his orgasm as he used Paul’s throat. Paul’s neck flushed red as the other man stuffed himself back.
Marcus, fully erect and hungry from Paul’s taut little body, stood up. Paul could hear the jingle of his belt buckle as Marcus pulled it open and the zip of his fly. He tried to pull off Lucas’ cock, but the bigger black man held him in place, fucking his face while Marcus yanked his boxers down. Paul whimpered and yelped around Lucas’ cock as he felt Marcus press the swollen end of his dick into his tight hole.
“Just breathe, white boy,” Marcus purred through a growl and gripped Paul’s hips, thrusting forward, smooth and slow.
His fat tip breached, and Paul saw stars. He began wiggling, trying to get away, but both Lucas and Marcus held him fast between their hard bodies. Marcus let out a guttural groan as he seated fully into Paul’s anus.
“Unngh! Fuck, this little bitch is so fucking tight. I’m not gonna last.” He chuckled huskily and began moving.
Paul cried out, but the sound was muffled in his throat. Lucas continued thrusting into his mouth. Marcus spat on the girth of his cock and jammed it in, further slicking Paul’s entrance. The end of Marcus’ thick crown collided with something inside Paul that made his vision go white. His slender length throbbed shamefully between his legs.
Lucas tossed his head back and howled, unloading into Paul’s throat. Something hot, musky, and pungent doused Paul’s tongue, and he retched but couldn’t spit it out with Lucas’ hand still gripping and pushing his head down.
Marcus was battering into his anus. His hips pistoning into Paul. The sound of his hard thighs slapping into Paul’s ass filled the apartment.
Lucas finally let him go when he felt Paul swallow down his semen. Paul yanked his head up, whimpering and groaning out in a mix of pleasured pain. The sensation was a maddening mix of agony and ecstasy. Every time he curled his back in, Marcus yanked his hips back.
“Stay still, baby. Stay still. Daddy’s almost done.” Marcus panted out and kept fucking him.
Humiliation and arousal shivered powerfully through Paul’s frame. He tried to hold it in, but it was too much. Marcus’ cock pressed viciously into Paul’s prostate, and he lost it. The slender white man cried out and shook violently as he came, orgasming into his yanked down underwear.
Marcus groaned and leaned over him, changing the angle and following him over as Paul’s anus fluttered around his thick hilt.
“Fuck! Fuck! Fuck!” Marcus cursed and slammed into him, holding his hips flush against Paul’s reddened backside. He stayed there, cock pumping hot load after hot load into the snug canal of Paul’s body. The taboo sensation left Paul dazed and groaning, drifting in a heady, intoxicating high.
But that high came crashing down when he lifted his head and heard a voice say his name.
“P-Paulie?”
Katey stood there in the doorway. Ivy, in all her malicious mischief, had opened the door for her. Paul hadn’t even heard her knock or when the door had opened. He had been too busy gritting his teeth through agonizing ecstasy.
His body clenched in shock, pushing Marcus’ softening length out of his ass. Katey saw it. All the blood drained from her face, her eyes wide and glassy. She took a step back and covered her mouth. He could see the utter disgust and horror on her face, and it made his heart fall into his stomach.
“Katey, baby! I can explain!”
Paul jumped up, and Katey gasped, seeing the full picture. The rumpled maid outfit. The ruined pigtails. The running mascara. Cum on his chin and dripping down his thighs.
“Oh my god!” she screamed and ran next door, tears carving paths down her cheeks. “You’re sick! You’re fucking sick!”
Paul scrambled after her. “Wait! Kate! Please!”
He tore the maid outfit off and grabbed his clothes, only managing to yank his pants on before rushing out the door after her. By the time he burst into their apartment, Katey had already pulled her suitcase from the closet and was throwing all her things into it.
“I can’t believe you, Paul! I can’t fucking believe you!” she shouted through a sob as she hastily threw everything into her suitcase.
“Katey, baby! Let me explain, please!” He begged and threw himself at her feet.
“Explain!? Explain what!? I saw you! I saw you getting fucked by two men! And you were dressed up like– like a–!” She couldn’t even bring herself to say it. It was too depraved. “I knew something was off! I suspected you were cheating! But I thought it was with a woman! This is worse! So much worse!” she shouted angrily, zipping up her suitcase.
Paul’s vision blurred with tears. “No! Please, don’t leave! It’s not what you think!” His voice broke. His world broke. It was all collapsing around his head.
“What? That my boyfriend of six years is gay?!” she shrieked at him.
“I am not gay!” He shot to his feet defensively.
“Then what the hell was that?!” Katey threw her hand in the direction of Ivy and Babs’ apartment.
“You don’t understand! It’s not that I like men, it’s just—” How could he explain that he liked the humiliation? That being the center of attention for all the wrong reasons aroused him, and he hadn’t figured out why. “You just treat me like a child! You control everything! I just wanted something for me! Just me!”
Katey gasped and looked at him in disgust. She snatched up her suitcase.
“Yeah! Well, now you can have it ALL to yourself! You sicko!” she snarled and stomped out the door. “I’ll send for the rest! We are over!!”
Katey’s voice echoed down the hallway as she went for the stairs.
His legs turned to jello, and he collapsed to the ground. A wet sob tore from him.
It was over.
It was really over.
No more Katey. No more of her affection or her sweetness. He stayed there, crying into the rug she had bought. Sobbing until the tears ran dry and chilling clarity trickled in.
No more Katey. No more being made to feel less of a man because she controlled everything. No more needing to sneak around and lie to her about things that felt right to him.
His entire life as ‘Paul’ had been fully usurped by ‘Polly’.
He slowly stood up and looked around his now empty apartment. It felt like a foreign land. A place he no longer knew. His eyes drifted toward the door.
He could go shower. Go to bed. Try to rebuild tomorrow. Try to call Katey and explain.
Or…
He stepped out into the hallway and drifted back toward Babs and Ivy’s apartment and knocked. Babs opened it with a sympathetic look on her face.
“Oh sweetheart. You poor thing. Come in. You shouldn’t be alone right now.”
She took his hand and led him inside, and oddly, Paul felt like he was finally home.