Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Fish Man Island Saga? [One Piece]

  • Please do the ORIGINAL version 167
  • Please do the NEW version 71
  • 2025-04-04
  • 238 votes
{'title': 'Fish Man Island Saga? [One Piece]', 'choices': [{'text': 'Please do the ORIGINAL version', 'votes': 167}, {'text': 'Please do the NEW version', 'votes': 71}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 4, 4, 12, 37, 23, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 238}

Content

I'm not all that close yet, but since it seems like it's quite the big decision, I wanted to put out a poll early to give everyone a chance to say which version they'd prefer me to do before I reach there.

Comments

mk9beatz

The new version is good. but there are actual manga panels cut so i recommend just doing the old version. it’s about the journey not the destination, who cares if it takes longer yk lol

KingMaani

New version? Is this about the One Piece reboot thing? If so I'd say just do the old one.

Kyle Kowalchuk

Old one is much better. They were overly happy to cut scenes that give critical context. There is way too many parts that make you question what happened.

KaitouLuminous

For that one Brook attack alone please do the original version his music is always a win

Burn Wolfdog

I think it's about the reedition of that arc with new animation. Toei was releasing it last year during the airing break.

Burn Wolfdog

I didn't reach that arc myself (I'm at the end of Marineford even though I'm watching the One Pace version) but I'd say it's still better to watch it in the original version.

Brandon Creyer

I feel like the understanding of the situation is a bit lost in the new one with what they cut. So if you want context, definitely the original.

Henrik Jessen

New Version wants to cut corners and cuts them too deep. On occasion this meant taking out the context. Big missed opportunity to make a definitive version, sadly…

Tigerguy

The animation is nicer in the newer version, but too much content has been cut from it and I wouldn't recommend it for a first time watch.

SonicKing2004

I'd say save the new version for the Sins video, maybe showcase if/where things that had earned Wins were removed from the original, and just how unnecessary the remake was.

Anime Wins

There's no Sins version anymore, meaning it won't ever be continued

SonicKing2004

😂 Then it's fine to just focus on the original. I personally think that the remake was just a project to keep the animators busy while they were waiting for sufficient material from the manga to work on.

Kody Tiffany

The OG is to long on an arc I despise; I just dislike the antags of the arc that much it overshadows all the things that were done right. basically it felt like we got the previous arc twice in a row where we are introduced to the time skip crew fight some chumps; then this arrc we get introduced to the crew again and face even more chumps. From a pure power level perspective one is greater than another. From a narrative perspective and if I filter out my own emotions to them its better. But in the end my issue is simple. I Loathe revenge plots; I loathe the oversaturation of "Southern Ettiquite" or "Natzi agenda" in antags... so yes doubling down and then making the leaders a joke is just one irration to many. If nothing else the redo of the arc I believe is shorter. Its Art is better. Lastly Fan Letter is connected to it and Fan Letter was amazingly well done for an OVA.

Sakomi Arorim

if I remember correctly the new version cuts the episode count to 1/3th of the original (which shows how drawn out the anime can be to prevent catching up to the manga) but from the few episodes I have seen it does cut scenes weirdly making it really hard to recommend first time watchers to see the new version over the original one

Zen quility

Id say do both! But if you have to pick one, the new one is obviously 3 times better in animation and pacing.