Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Happy new year everyone! It's a new year and it's almost time for a new season of stories! Have you ever watched a TV show or movie and wondered… what if the bad guy won? Well now you get the chance to see that happen! This new season of stories will feature ideas submitted by my patrons. All you have to do is write your idea in the comments below.

Now let’s get to a few rules. First off, and I know this rule isn’t going to be popular so I’m very sorry, but please no anime. It’s just not a style of writing I enjoy and I struggle to accurately portray the characters. Your idea must be from a TV show or movie. Please do not write detailed suggestions for the content of the story. These are not commissions, I will use my own ideas for the stories, you are providing the starting scene and I will carry on from there. Please format your idea like this: ‘What if Storm lost against Toad in their fight in X-Men 1?’ or ‘What if Drusilla defeated Buffy in the season two finale?’ Please be specific with the movie scene or TV episode you have in mind. One final rule, please try not to suggest anything too obscure. I need to be able to watch the scene you’re referring to, so if it’s impossible to find online then I won’t be able to accurately portray the scene.

Okay those are the rules. This post will stay up throughout January so you have lots of time to think of an idea, no need to rush. I will put the poll up in February and the ten stories with the most votes will get written. Then once the current group of stories are done ‘What If?’ season will begin! If you have any questions you can leave them in the comments, send me a message here on patreon, or you can ask in my discord channel: https://discord.gg/q2PjEWGzp8

I look forward to seeing your ideas! And as always, thank you so much for your support. I really appreciate it, and I hope to continue writing stories for you throughout 2025.

Comments

Gundam

First suggestion post: What if Ada Wong had not found the cure for her infection in Resident Evil 4 Remake?

TheWhiz

I got one from your own stories. What if Raven was abducted during the strip poker game?

Merrill Russell

What if wonder woman does not escape from fausta in Germany. What if babydoll escaped with sweet pea in sucker punch. What if Victoria lived in Van Helsing. What if Emma Frost defeated magneto and prof. X in first blood. What if Leia did not escape torture from the empire

Snidely's Wicked Tales

What if... Buffy the Vampire Slayer lost that fight to Warren in season six?

Jason M

what if supergirl in the episode human for a day ran into trouble on a day where her powers were flamed out?

V

What if the Batman decided to use his “prep time” to kidnap the superheroines of the DC universe

FreekyMonkey131

Ameilia Earhart from Night of the Museum 2 getting defeated in any of her many perilous situations she somehow cleanly escaped in the film.

Ashorty07

What If… The Cook in Sucker Punch overpowers and subdues Babydoll after overpowering Rocket?

Nick + 💪🏼🐧

Scenario from Supergirl season 3, episode 5 ("Damage"): What if, after his henchman knocked Lena out, Morgan Edge decided to kidnap and enslave her, instead of putting her on the crashing plane (optional side-"what if...?": what if they had used chloroform to knock her out and capture her instead of whacking poor Lena on the back of her head? 😆)

kjtrack

What if Thanos wanted to rebuild the black order using heroines in endgame instead of killing them?

Snidely's Wicked Tales

From Batman and Robin: instead of fighting Batgirl, Poison Ivy uses her pheremones on the innocent girl to make her surrender...

William Rawls

Wonder woman takes on the Furies and loses

Pollard

What if in Buffy the Vampire Slayer Season 4 episode 3 Harmony comes to Sunnydale without Spike, finds the gem and is able to defeat Buffy?

Kastlefreeze

What if Wonder Woman and Wonder Girl failed to retake their island (from the tv show, I forget the exact episode, but it’s the one where Drusilla gets captured and tricked into revealing where Paradise Island is).

Robert Painter

What if the Girls from SWAT (Chris Alonzo, Alexis Cabrarra, Zoe Powell) where captured by a gang of criminals?

Robert Terwillger

What if, after the movie ends, Supergirl (1984) is put on trial (and found guilty, natch) when she arrives home for causing the catastrophe in the first place?

Joaquin

Here's an idea: What If Lord Zedd successfully turned Kimberly (the Pink Ranger) into his evil queen? From Mighty Morphin Power Rangers Season 2, Episode 16 "Beauty and the Beast"

20cloudy10

What if the power-hungry Newtrich sisters, after draining Lois Lane’s Ultra Woman abilities and keeping her captive, drew the attention of Power Girl, who must outmatch their cunning and growing strength before she becomes their next victim? (Based on the episode of Lois and Clark)

Abraham Smith

Avengers what if Natasha is plan to let herself get captured backfired?

FreekyMonkey131

What if Wyrmtongue took Eowyn instead of talking with her in Lord of the Rings?

FreekyMonkey131

What if Ruby Roundhouse's Dance fight didn't work in Jumanji?

Robert Terwillger

What if Aladdin never returned to Agrabah, forcing Jasmine to try and defeat omnipotent Jafar herself?

20cloudy10

What if Syndrome had a bratty sister who targets Elastigirl for revenge.

Abraham Smith

Supergirl episode "Blurred Lines." What if James Olsen (Guardian) didn't show up when he did and Kara was trapped in the webbing?

Gabriel Becerra

What if Agatha had found another way to capture Wanda amd distract Monica (WandaVision Ep. 7)?

Abraham Smith

Wonder Woman Season 1 episode 2 What if Baroness Von Gunther's chains were strong enough to hold Wonder Woman?

Andy the Spiritfarer

What if the Psycho from Until Dawn used chloroform on Sam, and wasn't Josh (actually some random psycho)? Essentially, what if she was never rescued by Mike?