Green Lantern (Patreon)
Content
The problem as I see it is that most of the GLs aren't complete sentences. "The most powerful weapon in the universe is given to a human being and--" Guy Gardner: "He's a huge jerk," boom, story. Kyle Rayner: "he's an artist"/"he's an ordinary joe." Boom. Story.
Hal Jordan, it's just "the most powerful weapon in the universe is given to a human being and... he's some guy." He's a test pilot, which really doesn't seem to have anything to do with anything, since a magic space ring and a jet don't seem to have much in common. He doesn't have much in terms of personality. Sometimes he's alcoholic and I guess now he's a kinder, gentler version of Guy Gardner. In which case, any Hal Jordan story becomes more interesting if it's about Guy Gardner.
John Stewart, same deal. only "he's some black guy." I guess he's a military guy too, which, so was Hal and so is Captain Atom, and Captain Atom makes a bigger deal out of it.
You really need some kind of irony or twist to make the general story work, since by itself, a ring that can do anything actually isn't that interesting. It can do anything. Guy uses it. Story over. Poof. No wonder Sinestro's become a popular antihero in recent years. "The most powerful weapon in the universe is given to a guy, but he's an asshole" at least promises some conflict.
Even casting Hollywood cool guy Ryan Reynolds as essentially himself still doesn't really give you a story. "The most powerful weapon in the universe is given to the class clown with a six-pack abs" still isn't a high-concept premise, even if you add "and he's kind of a pussy jag-off for most of the movie."