Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi everyone

Development of the mod is back on track.

In this post I will be discussing the balancing mechanics of the mod.

Scaling

As discussed earlier in this post:

In order to somewhat preserve the game's challenge, I have implemented my own baseline scaling manager within Dark Souls II seamless co-op which will - by default - be set to 80% increased health per friendly player

This is, of course, adjustable by the session host so that the difficulty of enemies and bosses can be tweaked for the most enjoyable experience.

However, in that post I also mentioned that damage scaling would be implemented (with a default of 0%). I've decided against this in retrospect, as enemy damage scaling is a very rare setting for players to actually want. I have added a substitute mechanic which may make the game less of a cake-walk and help to preserve the challenge - as described below.

Curse Soul Fragments

If you're familiar with the "Rot Essence" mechanic in Elden Ring seamless co-op (or the "Crimson Blossom" for Dark Souls: Remastered) there is a penalty when a player dies.

The reasoning behind this is, as opposed to the normal game, enemies do not respawn when you die in a seamless co-op session. Instead, a debuff is applied to the player until the next time they rest at a bonfire - which in turn will respawn the enemies. This is option of course, but discourages players just hitting their head against enemies over and over until they win with no penalty.

In Dark Souls II seamless co-op, I have added a similar item acquired on death - Cursed Soul Fragments.

These items are slightly different to the mechanics in the other seamless co-op games. They are shared amongst the session, and everyone will be afflicted. They work in a similar way to Black World Tendancy in Demons' Souls.

There are a maximum of 5 carrier per player, and the penalty is calculated based on percentage saturation carried in the session. For example:

6 players, each with 5 fragments = 30/30 fragments = 100% saturation

2 players, each with 5 fragments = 10/10 fragments = 100% saturation

3 players, each with 2 fragments = 6/15 fragments = 40% saturation

The penalty is not applied to players directly, but instead the world becomes more hostile. Between 0 - 50% saturation, enemies will become gradually more alike to black phantoms. They will hit harder, and give more souls upon defeating them.

Between 50 - 100% saturation, your world will become more vulnerable to disasters - I will keep this a secret for now as I wouldn't want to completely spoil it.

For players who wish to play this mode without needing to get full stacks of Curse Fragments, there is also an alternative way to enable the more powerful enemies and disasters via an in-game item.

If people have suggestions or issues with this mechanic, I am still open to making tweaks. That being said, note that the Curse Fragment acquisition is entirely optional, but will be enabled by default to make the game less of a pushover given the advantages of playing cooperatively.

Thank you for your patience, and a huge thank you to all of my supporters <3

Take care

~ Yui

Files

Comments

vuko

Beast!

TheChesireMouse

Wait that's awesome! Glad to see you not just going with a plain damage increase. I'm very excited to see this play out and develop. Thank you as always!

Haunted Reaver

That is a very neat way to balance coop play. Does it also apply to bosses?

Hidden Is Classified

You are the best <3! Thank you for still finding the time and motivation to work on such complicated project with your busy schedule. You are amazing, I can't wait!

Yui

It does indeed

Enki

this sounds very interesting I'm assuming sitting at a bonfire will remove cursed soul fragments

Yui

Yes, sitting at a bonfire will remove all of the fragments for all players

Pascal Łosiewicz

Thank you for all the work you do for the souls community! By the way, what are your pronouns?

Easy Perrin

You once again prove why you are the GOAT of fromsoft modding, banger idea for the enemy scaling. Super looking forward to this!

Matthew David Beutler

also, the shards are a super cool idea/mechanic and it will add a bit of replayability and actual difficulty to those playing. The fact you can also choose to enable it from the item is great too. This sounds great

speeris

This sounds AWESOME, i’m really excited to see how this affects the games balancing.

Yori M.

This sounds awesome! This game already has more replayability than the other fromsoft games but this makes it even better. Can't wait for this mod to come out!

Fentiman

I normally turn off rot essence but this is such a cool idea holy shit

Fentiman

How all are black phantoms different than normal enemies? Is it just damage done or are they more aggressive too?

Luke Davis

My fellow Bearer of the curse! If you by chance require a tester to help assist in your magnificent production I would gladly help. I do hope to get a response even if it’s a no.

Yui

Still not ready for a public test, sorry

Yui

Right now it's just damage. I may also increase their aggression range

Luke Davis

Oh no! I fully understand, thank you for taking the time to respond. I wish you luck in your continued journey to finish Seamless!

Sage

Great update I like the sound of this cursed soul fragment system! I have a couple of questions hopefully you can answer and thank you in advanced if you do. With the increased enemy HP scaling and longer encounters, are there any planned adjustments to weapon durability loss or repair systems in seamless co-op? Also, how does hollowing work in this mod do players hollow on death, and can hollowed players still participate in seamless co-op sessions?

Yui

The durability bug with SOTFS will be fixed base in seamless. Hollowing on death is unchanged, and hollowed players can engage in co-op and invasion.

PerrenChromE

Do dlc bosses still get a truckload of damage reduction in co-op? Doing a boss like Sinh or Ivory King with 3 players is very tedious.

Khunkurisu

Late response but loving this post. One minor nitpick cause it broke my brain for a second: the 3-player curse example has the wrong fraction, doesn’t it? It should be 6/15 (40%), not 6/10 (60%) unless I’m missing something. On the topic of the enemy behavior changes as your saturation increases, I’m not certain what engine limitations there are or anything else, so I’m hesitant to get too wild with ideas. Aggression range like you suggested in another comment is probably a pretty simple one, but I don’t know how noticeable it’ll be without becoming ridiculous on smaller, tighter maps. Probably still worth fiddling with though. Perhaps give them an initially very minor regeneration on hit, akin to Malenia though we’re talking a fraction of a percent scaled up/down based on the attack’s weight values (or whatever they’re called, it’s been ages since I looked into the engine stuff) so fast multihits barely do any healing individually. You could also likely have a health threshold for some enemies where they try to call in reinforcements, either spawning in new enemies entirely or triggering aggro of more distant foes and causing them to pathfind a targeted player’s last location. I do know souls games handling “spawning enemies” weirdly and I have no idea how well DS2 enemies handle pathfinding, so I’m not sure if either of those options are technically feasible and honestly idk if I’d even find them fun, they’re just what came to mind while rambling. Speaking of which apologies for this wall I hope some of it is at least coherent even if it isn’t useful and I’m very excited to see more progress on this mod!

Yui

You're right on the fraction, thanks for pointing it out I've fixed it. In terms of additional mechanics I do have some interesting things planned but I would like to keep them a secret for now!

Mr Imagination

I think it'll be like in the other seamless co-op mods where we can adjust the % in the config file. So you could have the bosses be even more tanky or less tanky if you want.

Its SrS

Is there atleast a spitball of a release window? Been following the mod for quite a time and played through all the other seamless mods. Thanks we're excited

Grey

Thats so amazing!!! I can't wait to try this out, thank you! A small critique- the red color for the saturation on enemies will make it confusing in new game+ cycles where red phantoms spawn. Could it be done with another color? If you need to swap from an already in-game effect, the Abyss phantoms spawn with a blackened aura

Jacob Parker

"These items are slightly different to the mechanics in the other seamless co-op games. They are shared amongst the session, and everyone will be afflicted. " Fantastic addition

Jacob Parker

When a group of 5 played seemless Elden ring and DS1 there was often conflict between people who wanted to sit to get rid of debuffs, whilst others were charging forward on a segment still. It became frustrating to be mid fight with an enemy, a party member sit elsewhere, resetting the enemy you were fighting. This addition makes it a party issue rather than an individual issue. this is great!