Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello! We're doing a topic episode Monday (brief lull in content) and wanted to talk about the best and worst changes when adaptation comics into movies. I already know all of these but any suggestions are welcome

Files

Comments

Harris

As for worst, can I say Venom as a blanket for all three movies? Even if you were going to eliminate Spider-Man, couldn't you at least make Eddie Brock something interesting? Especially with that third one. For best changes, I think Legion is a really underrated show that used its premise really well while eliminating pretty much all other X-Men. It even incorporated the time travel element from LegionQuest in the final season.

Nate Gonzales

The Mask comics vs The Mask movie, quite the downgrade and shift in tone. I think enough time has passed that they could attempt a reboot that is darker and riskier like the comics (sounds like an ideal Seth Rogan property to be honest). Maybe an ongoing live action series where the mask changes owners between episodes or seasons.

TheOfficialCasron

i always thought Ultron was a bummer in the MCU. having him be a one off villain, writing Hank Pym out of his creation, and worst of all giving him lips… my favorite change by far though is making the Vulture into an actual character rather than having him just be a villain of the week for spider-man. he really felt like a perfect foil for peter in that movie. truly a bummer he’s stuck with Jared Leto forever.

Cameron Blake Dawes

Thor love and thunder is definitely a worst as an adaptation of Jason Aaron’s work. I would say Netflix daredevil is probably the best adaptation we’ve had as far as translating the character and themes to the screen.

Declan Rabun

Should something be said for Sin City? that was a big deal at the time. We had never seen such a distinct style transfered so successfully.

Rhys Thomas

I mean for me my top three (in no particular order I find these wild) are 1. the wonderful choices they made in xmen origins wolverine and probably the damage they first trilogy did to anyone but wolverine, Magnus and Charles. 2. arrow making green arrow Batman and what for me was adding lost into the show randomly with the whole island shenanigans 3. bvs lex Luther

Harris

I know this might be controversial but there were two changes in The Batman that I disliked. The first was the convoluted reasoning and mob ties behind the death of his parents. I'm not sure if this counts, but the second was their version of Riddler. I know there's a lot of different versions of Riddler so there can't be a direct adaptation, but I felt he lacked the fun witty spark I like in Riddler.

Harris

On the same token (Frank Miller directed), I thought his version of The Spirit was among the worst adaptations. The Eisner comics are so rich and beautiful, and instead he just did Sin City again. Except with Sam Jackson and Scar-Jo as literal Nazis. I still think there's some retro potential in an adaptation there.

User_Name

Best: I personally prefer having Joker kill Batman’s parents as it makes their connection stronger and more personal imo. Worst: Having Rogue not fly, use super strength, or hook up with Gambit

Harris

Worst: Eternals are robots who regularly get their hard drives erased. Worst: Turning Steven Grant from a 1940s pulp playboy to Mr. Bean in Moon Knight Best: Removing Sentry's Golden Age hero but everyone forgot about him through wizardry backstory in Thunderbolts*. I think it's interesting conceptually but if they couldn't do it well, which they couldn't, better to not do it at all.

Ryan

Best: the time they changed that one bit and it was rad. Worst: the time they changed that one bit and it sucked.

Ronaan

Controversial perhaps but Barbara Gordon in Batman: The Animated Series and The Lego Batman Movie, specifically her being romantically entangled with Bruce, is among the worst for me! Even when they age her up (as in the Lego version) it still seems icky because I'm so used to her being a contemporary of the Robins. Speaking of the Robins, an oldie but a baddie is The Dark Knight Rises' take on the boy wonder. It's never made sense why a film that's so allergic to the mere concept of a Robin would find naming a character after the mantle less cringe than using an actual name like Dick Grayson (who, like Robin Blake, is frequently a cop in the comics!!) And, speaking of Batgirl AND Robin, Rocksteady's decision to pair up Babs and Tim Drake in the Batman: Arkham games is also in the worst category. It just feels someone misread the wiki and saw Batgirl got with a Robin without checking which one – a mistake which really stands out in a series that otherwise reads as such a love letter to the Batman mythos! Joel Schumacher's take on Batgirl and Robin is, however, one of the best things to happen in the history of art.

Jim Desmond

That's a tough one, so many on either side 👀 best off the top of my head is Captain America: Winter Soldier, deftly handled the beats of the comics run and made it work really well with MCUs version of cap. Mainly the emotional core of it. I liked first avenger but I loved winter soldier and that was the perfect movie adaptation. Worst... X-Men pick any one of the Dark phoenix saga movie adaptations. The X3 version suffers from being overly stuffed and cramming in about three or four other story lines in front of what should be Jeans story. Second Dark Phoenix makes weird changes to characters and, because of the prior films, suffers under the baggage of continuity, and again, not giving any meaningful time to Jean's character so all of the beats fall flat and also, why is it so dark? Like literally dark 😅

Ross Jordan

I think among the best is making Hellboy more entangled with the BPRD. While I love reading about him walking around the moores, I really liked his interactions with human agents in the movies.

mwiggins505

Best: Bullseye’s journey in this MCU from Daredevil Season 3

Stephen Andersen

Leather!! Best on Blade and worst on Daredevil. X-Men gets a free pass, same for Catwoman on Benjamin Bratt’s performance alone.

Robin

Batman the animated series just in general made so many changes to the lore that have now become part of comic canon (Mr. Freeze, Harley Quinn, kevin Conroy playing Batman as the real person and Bruce Wayne as the mask, etc.) that I’d go as far to say it’s the greatest adaptation of comic book characters ever. All the changes they made to the source material made the source material better.

Robin

Honestly I’ve never read “wanted” but I’ve heard the movie is completely different than the source material, and honestly I love that movie (caravan of garbage?)

Simon Buchan

Obviously Blade: A half-vampire cool guy is so much better than what the comic was doing. In the 90s movie vein: Steel is a truly bizarre set of choices.

Robin

No shade to Batman forever but Tommy Lee jones as two face has GOTTA be one of the worst adaptations of a comic book character ever.

Robin

And to state the obvious having Batman kill in Batman versus superman literally ruins the character imo so that’s gotta be one of the worst changes. Love Affleck in that movie, but yeesh way to miss the mark Snyder. That’s like his whole thing… bro doesn’t kill 💀

Jonah

I’d say probably one of the worst was giving the x-men leather outfits and not embracing the sillier side of their books. Vaughn did a good job incorporating the yellow suits in first class and I really feel for Days of Future Past and Apocalypse, films set in the 70’s and 80’s, the time for more colorful costumes would have been good to have

Tim Hogan

I think the new supergirl movie. It was so boring to look at for a cosmic adventure. Nowhere near as Interesting as the woman of tomorrow book

steve munoz

Best, Ozymandias convincing the world that Dr Manhattan attacked the Earth instead of a large squid monster. Worst, all of SPUMM. Venoms personality was great, but thats the only part of those movies I enjoyed.

Travis Bow

Best: The Silver Surfer in Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer Masters of the Universe (2026) Worst: Masters of the Universe (1987) (I still love it but it really is not much like the source material)

RedVIII

So, we're finally getting a different video outside of Caravan and Weekly Planet? Because it's been forever and I would love it. I also miss videos like "Guess the review" and stuff like that.

RedVIII

Worst has to be Venom in Spider-Man 3 and also kinda in the Venom movies. Obviously in Part 3 he is way too small, he doesn't have the tongue and he doesn't speak in the "we" form. It's just all wrong. In the Venom movies he at least has t he size and the tongue, but he is missing the Spider-Man symbol since he obivously has no contact to Spider-Man, and I also hate that they introduce him as a loser and an antihero, I like my Venom scary and a threat, the way he was protrayed in the Spider-Man 2 videogame (even thought it wasn't Eddie in that version)! Also, I do not like th organic webbing of Spidey in the Raimi movies. Just a weird, unnecessary change.

RedVIII

I disagree somewhat. I hate the direction comic book movies are going. Movies are a different medium, and some of those silly suits are just not working in live action. Wolverine and Deadpool felt like I'm watching a cosplay convention. The new Superman movie looks more like a live action version of the Justice League cartoon, than something that I would consider real or believable. Yes, there is a balance that can be achieved, and I guess First Class did it ok and didn't went too far. But again, In D&W, Wolverine just looked dumb in his yellow outfit, and Tatum looked like a Gambit Cosplayer. I much prefer how Taylor Kitsch looked as the character.

Jeremy Mele

I’ll always hate that they brought the Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver into the MCU without having the rights to Magneto, so they had to write him out of their story. What makes it even more egregious is that the comics then did movie synergy and retconned away Magneto being their father. Decades of continuity, and a really fruitful and interesting relationship, just completely undone. It’s rare that an adaptation choice damages the source material, but this one did.

Matthew Cronin

Best: making Blade a half vampire man. Worst: removing Spider-Man from all of his villain’s origin stories.

J. Michael White

From Hell adaptation, bad. Wanted adaptation, bad. League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, bad. Super rooks cartoon, good/underrated. Constantine, good movie but bad adaptation. Spawn, bad.

Patrick Lewis

Dont know if this counts but for best - Grappling Hook to grappling gun* from batman 89. Worst - I’d say pretty much every version of a celestial-scale villain from dc or marvel. Eternals, green lantern, fantastic four (4-stic and first steps)

Piltheser

Deep cut, most of Ducktales is a really bad adaptation of the comics of Carl Barks and Don Rosa.

Ethan Burkhalter

The loss of color from the comic to the screen in Supergirl. I wish the movie studios would understand that we don’t want grey/brown mush colored movies

Jonathan Stine

They were cowards not to make Death a sexy lady that Thanos wants to marry in Infinity War and Endgame. Absolute cowards

Garrett Mitchell

Worst: Thanos not being motivated by being a psycho in love with death Best: turning Peacemaker into a character people like

paulohmygod

I think the Mask is a great movie but I would love to see an accurate adaption. I'd like it animated though

paulohmygod

Does it count to include the studio getting scared of the fact they were adapting Ultimate Fantastic Four when the film was basically finished and then butchering it?

Harris

Here's another worst, but I only know it because James and Maso brought it up on a previous episode. In BvS, Thomas Wayne tries to punch Joe Chill, which is what gets him shot. That's so different from him dying trying to protect his wife and son and loses an important element of their deaths.

Jesse Lopez

The best changes I can think of come from Batman The Animated series. The change to Mr Freeze's backstory, also the creation of Harley quinn, and the addition of the grapple gun to Batman's gadgets. The worst adaptation has to be for Thor: Love and Thunder. Too may adaptations and all of them done poorly.

hyperevisceration

I think it would be worth talking about both how the Symbiote in adaptations makes you evil is not necessarily a good thing As well as this shift of trying to make Peter Parker a kind of pristine golden boy who never did anything wrong as seen in Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man and in interviews where they’re like MCU Peter probably wasn’t responsible for Ben’s death. Not something exclusive to the MCU, Tobey’s Peter really dialed up huge dork and that may be the start of it

Scott Handsome

Best: I don't love the entirety of the show, but I've seen a lot of people argue that The Boys is miles above it's source material, and from what I've read of it and seen seasons 1-4, I'd have to agree. I also think that the MCU (mainly the first Avengers movie) did a pretty decent job of taking inspiration from the Ultimates and using what worked and avoiding what didn't. Worst: Pretty much all film adaptations of Alan Moore's work, but mainly Watchmen for me. What upsets me most about Watchmen is the removal of the typical comic book silliness and tropes. A lot of people who've read the comic and seen the movie like to argue that it works to benefit the story and make it more believable, but I think that by doing that it completely removes a core element to the aesthetic of Watchmen, which is that it's a parody of superhero comics as a whole. A major aspect of Watchmen as a piece of media is that it IS a comic book story, whereas people tend to think it is a good story that just happens to be a comic book.

Vincent

Worst: no giant alien squid in Watchmen Best: no giant alien squid in Watchmen

Penelope

So, first, I may be the only wife who loves the podcast and my husband doesn’t listen 😂. He did, however, get me a patreon membership for my birthday, so he doesn’t hate the pod! My husband is a big comic book guy and his comments are: the HBO Regina King Watchmen series for taking a classic comic that had already been adapted a few times and turning it into something new and meaningful without destroying the source material. Although the show was far from perfect, we both loved Tatiana Maslany’s portrayal of She-Hulk and the show for breaking the fourth wall in a really fun way. My husband totally agreed with the poster who said how disappointing The Spirit was.

mantis toboggan

+1, venom has been my fav comic character since i was like 6 but i couldn't even be bothered to watch the 3rd one.

Zack

I have mixed feelings on Superhero secret identities, but the MCU dropping them entirely was very interesting. Thor was the first comic I ever tried reading, and the Donald Blake stuff was so confusing and uninteresting I never tried again. Going all in on him just being a god was the right choice IMO