Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • #389 - Don't Go Into the Light.mp3

Missing 1 full-res photo, 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

With the yuletide season upon us, our Superdelegate patron tier has voted for us to discuss the Bill Murray holiday semi-classic SCROOGED (1988). So we boiled up some hot chocolate and did our best to apply an ideological reading to this story of an '80s TV executive's path to Christmastime redemption. PLUS: Fiery hot takes on Avatar: The Way of Water, and an answer to the question on everyone's lips: what, exactly, is Elon Musk's "plan"?

Files

Previews only

Comments

Jackson Ayres

I saw Scrooged in its original theatrical run when I was a kid, and my brothers and I watched it every Christmas for many years. On the flip side, I cannot imagine having a sentimental attachment to Liar, Liar (which I've never seen). Definitely a generational thing. Also, I would have liked W+L to elaborate on their point about the 1980s NYC context for the film (and the Trumpiness of Frank Cross), which by extension is also about the changing place of the 1960s in the cultural imagination. I think it is interesting to see how a morality tale from Victorian England is transposed onto that specific milieu.

George Olken

i was intrigued by this take on EYES WIDE SHUT from the Jewish Currents Shabbat Reading List newsletter: Nathan Goldman (managing editor [of Jewish Currents]): "I’ve spent much of the past year binging episodes of the podcast Blank Check, in which actor and comedian Griffin Newman and critic David Sims discuss every installment in a director’s filmography. The recent episode on the 1999 psychological drama Eyes Wide Shut—part of a miniseries on the career of paradigmatic auteur Stanley Kubrick—inspired me to return to this magnificent, vexing film for the first time in a decade. "It’s a nice time of year for it. As Newman, Sims, and guest David Ehrlich acknowledge, Eyes Wide Shut is set in this season, and it’s become something of a truism that it’s a Christmas movie, its unsettling and graphically sexual subject matter notwithstanding; in his book on Christmas films, critic Alonso Duralde calls it “a Christmas movie for grownups.” Newman, Sims, and Ehrlich suggest that the portrait of the holiday in the first act, which features a lavish Christmas party, is one seen from a Jewish perspective: pure spectacle, stripped of even the faintest trace of sacred significance. This made me wonder whether the film’s entire understanding of Christmas might be understood as Jewish. (As the podcast mentions, the film’s source text—the 1926 Austrian novella Dream Story—was written by the Jewish author Arthur Schnitzler; Kubrick, himself a nonobservant Jew, excised its Jewish content in the process of adaptation.) "To call Eyes Wide Shut a Jewish Christmas film is perhaps provocative, considering that the movie follows a doctor and his wife (Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman, at the time still actually married) as Cruise’s character finds himself caught up in a cultic orgy of the abominably rich—and their seemingly homicidal conspiracy to keep their rituals secret. But in my reading it’s not the wealthy, sinister cabal that is coded as Jewish, but rather Cruise’s character. Goyish though he may be, the doctor is proximate to yet removed from the world of the ultra-rich at the film’s center in a sense that evokes the paradoxes of Jewish assimilation. In line with the Blank Check hosts’ observation that the opening offers an estranged, hollowed-out vision of Christmas, I wonder whether the film’s critical approach to the holiday is thus rooted in a distinctly Jewish sense of familiarity cut with alienation. The result is powerful: In the same way that Kubrick artfully and disturbingly empties sex of eroticism, he plumbs the ways holy mystery can metamorphose into a phantasmagoria of secular menace."