Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi friends,

Here's a Tangent on generations discourse. Sticking Out Your Gyatt for the Rizzler, the Strauss–Howe generational theory, cyclical vs. linear history, Hegel, Marx, Fukuyama, Mark Fisher, Skibidi Toilet—all the hits.

This one would probably benefit from another editing pass, but too bad, time's up lol. I'm still planning to get two more Tangents out this month—will post a topic poll for the 15+ folks shortly.

Enjoy, let me know what you think!

-Natalie

P.S. Here's the video link, in case embedding doesn't work: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PWJ12HQ2onI

Files

Tangent: Generations

Thanks so much for your support! ▬ Contents▬ Part 1: Skibidi Toilet 00:02 Part 2: Identity & Categorization 07:35 Part 3: The Strauss–Howe Theory 17:36 Part 4: The Shape of Time 34:34 Part 5: The Failure of Millennials 48:14

Comments

Felix

Omg yay we're back baby

elliehotsauce

perfect timing, i was just about to go wage slave at my job i hate but now i can do it with natalie 🥰

Em

Skibidi!!!

lovelyabitha

The most excited I’ve been for anything in weeks YASSSS

Lily Stein

YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS GYATTT

Mars Hall

The moment I get home from work, I'll start watching this!

Monarobot

Awesome! Looking forward to watching it— Been loving the tangents, they’re great to work while listening to.

Dina

urge to comment OMG TJIS WAS SO GOOD 😍 when the video has been up for 10 minutes but it's an hour long

Connor Gibson

Two more tangents this month ?? We’re gonna be so spoiled 😭😭😭

Mindy

Thank you so much for all your hard work Natalie! 💖 The Twilight video was a triumph and I really appreciate you getting right back to it with the tangents. You rock!

Socrates Stamatatos

Natalie thank you for releasing videos during important deadlines of mine, and I have every reason to procrastinate 🤣 the cover is giving Ethel Cain album cover 💖

κίτρινο καναρίνι

My day has been significantly improved! I got this lovely notification, and the sun broke through the clouds. Miracles! ⛅️

Patryk Zep

always spoils my plans to go to bed 😅💗

Johanna Lill-Inger

It disgusts me that you still haven’t spoken about the genocide in Palestine. We gave you this massive platform for what? I thought you would do some good in the world. I hope you’re haunted by the same people you pretend don’t exist. Thanks for reminding me to unsubscribe, thanks for radicalizing me and thanks for making me see that there truly are no good celebrities or rich people. You are a selfish asshole, Nathalie.

Amy Morrison

Skibidi Toilet Madrigals broke me.

Kaylee Keller

Wow, 'we gave you'... Nobody owes you their opinion, or their platform. I hope Natalie sees your unsubscription as the win it is.

Pookiemookie

as a teacher of 6th graders, i found the beginning of the video very amusing. thanks contra!

Evan Michael

Thanks for the good food, Mother. Bon Appetit babes!

Ungulate Junction

This is something I've been noticing a lot, recently, like generations have become somewhat of a sibling continuum. Like younger brothers and sisters, with shorter intervals and age ranges. Anyway, Kurt Cobain was a Gen X INFP musician, and you're a Gen Y INFP musician and also YouTuber too. I think you'd definitely compare your charts and albums and possibly even your palmistry. Godspeed.

Yousuf Kazmi

2 more Tangents this month, feeling spoilt :) (no 'tube burn out pls x )

Sophie Shea

literally screamed MOTHER several times when I saw the notification

Yousuf Kazmi

bye, this is not an Airport. also she promoted Shauns video on the subject on Social Media (just recheck her Twitter feed)

Max

Granola Fascism is a topic I’m super looking forward to. I know fellow millennials who are hyper anti-science, hateful bigots who mirror the traditional, “Hippie”, mindset. It’s been a disturbing trend on the rise. Also, I’ve noticed more puritanical views on sex and sexuality in movies and TV lately. It’s now not just, “Oh it’s a bad sex scene.” It’s becoming, “Sex in media is bad, period”.

savannah brown

this rocked, helped me structure some thoughts, thank you

Adam Finch

For a moment I was excited to see a rant on Star Trek VII

Seed Oil Sommelier

I think the reason that millennials and Gen Z often perceive themselves as uniquely unhappy because of neoliberalism is your good friend and mine: envy. I think there’s a certain kind of millennial that thinks boomers had it so good because they came of age at the right time, reaping all the benefits of the new deal and their parents’ GI Bill only to rip it all away voting in Regan in the 80s. I think we deeply envy the relative economic security of the boomers as a generation and resent them for tearing down the means by which they secured it, thereby denying it to us.

Jaololpes

Thank you, Natalie ❤️❤️ (Ps.: 2 more THIS MONTH???)

Nora

This was amazing!

Gart Kundalini

tasty food for thought ~ thanks for all the work you do!

purpleforest

sooossoso cool!!! speaking of generations, i'm literally gonna make my mom watch this with me, since I'm already slowly showing all my favorite videos of yours to her!! :)))) <333

John

Please don't overwork, I'm happy for more tangents whenever, there is no rush at all, you don't owe me anything.

Garrett Duncan

Love you Natalie, and cherish these essays and your brilliant mind. Out of curiosity, if you divorce the "meninist" cyclical view of time from the obvious and very problematic bigotry and xenophobia, could it be viewed as a dialectic of struggle and apathy? A comfortable, complacent society can't conceive of worse times, or bother to protect what they have, and so are "weak" when confronted by those galvanised by struggle and disenfranchisement? I'm thinking about the global cycles of progress and regression, the rise of populism, liberals not bothering to vote because they couldn't take seriously the threat of a Trump presidency, liberals not bothering to vote because they thought Brexit was silly and impossible... I suppose it comes from a deep-down fear things are taking a turn for the worse on my generation's watch. Or are all generations in fact terrible, and none of us know what we've got 'till it's gone? Yours truly, a gay protected —> heroic millennial

M Cherry

“Taco taco taco taco . . . Wheeeeeeeeeere’s my mouth?!”

Pierre Brown

Wow. I have genuinely never heard of any of the content or the words in first part of this video. What a wide world I never see.

Eilean

Anti-psychotic studying can wait. Time to learn about what’s really important in this life (the rizzler)

Matthew Mendenhall

As a ‘97 baby this video is making me give up the millennial gambit. I’m just not a millennial. I am Gen Z. I don’t remember the 90s (though I do remember boredom before the internet which is what cleaves me from Gen Z). At the end of the day ‘08 changed everything about me as a kid. I’m risk-averse. I didn’t have sex until I was 24. I’m terrified of drugs in the instance I’ll by morally judged for it by people my age. I willingly sacrifice my passions on the alter of capitalism, employment, and middle class ambition even though it warps my soul into despair and cynicism. I just finished my Bachelor’s of English two weeks ago and actually feel pretty angry about my decision because now I’m unemployable. I will probably get my masters in finance or some other kind of soul-killing study. At no point in my life have I ever felt free or guiltless to do anything leisurely or passionately. I don’t even feel free to be rebellious because the threats to my security and well-being for being rebellious are extremely present and well-articulated. I feel like this is the Gen Z condition of young adolescence that Millennials did not have. The bummer of ‘08 was not that millennials didn’t get get their job at Goldman Sachs. The bummer is that after ‘08 we *have* to get our jobs at Goldman Sachs to pay the bills or buy a home. Also, I do think there is something to say about Millennials and Gen Z being siblings - in part because neither of us are ever going to afford to have children (ie the true next generation).

highclass_lady

Wow, oh my gosh I learned so much from this tangent! A lot of things make so much sense now! Obviously, individual people are going to vary infinitely but I feel like seeing generations more cyclically (even with all the caveats) is such a useful perspective! Going to need to watch this at least 5 more times to fully appreciate everything in it!

Thomas Kerr

Such an enjoyable experience listening intently to this after doing student theatre side quests all day! Thanks

Joe Johnston

Good lord, my kid won't stop singing this thing. Hi, I am old.

Joe Johnston

BUT I was the one who introduced my kid to Skibidi Toilet. So maybe I have a few Internet years left in me.

rei

gyattalie ❤️

Jessica Cheeri

I love that you see the generation sibling rivalry thing too. Really feels like there's not a huge difference. Although I do think I have to grudgingly accept that my generation (I'm an older cohort millennial) might really be big kids and it might not have been just the rug pull that was the 00s that did that. Personally still believe that, to the extent that Gen Z seem overly cautious, they were born just in time for internet ready camera phones and the dawn of social media. We just didn't have to grow up with PR considerations; they've kinda been on their own with that one.

August Ellis

I feel like there are a ton of potential future tangent topics that can piggie-back off this, in particular I've been thinking about how older generations are criticizing younger ones for not having children. I think that could be an interesting conversation, or talking about being childfree being more popular, and discourse about the 4B movement. All in all, I really liked this tangent! I think it's way more interesting to think about the passage of time as cyclical, rather than linear.

Kapelski

Two more this month? We're being spoiled...

Jaime

julia cudney on youtube made a pretty good video on this!

sienne

i don't think we gen-z kids have any right to complain about skibidi toilet when we recall the vine stuff we used to consume, lmao. anyways love this tangent and am SO looking forward to the next one!

Couch Table

As far as the Heroic generation goes as a thing, I'll never forget Rep. John Dingell (born 1926) tweeting in 2017, "Back when I was a pup, punching Nazis was encouraged!" The handwringing tended to come from people younger than he.

Sabrina Penna

You might like The Great Wave, by David Hackett Fischer. If anybody reading this did, I'd be so excited; Hackett really turned me on to a cyclical view of history. May I say, as a member of Gen X: I admired the Boomers some of the time - the music was great - but they weren't great to follow when we were teens. They didn't like us. They didn't want to have to think about us. It bears saying that you can't underestimate how every generation reacts against the others even as they long to emulate some of their best traits and achievements. And one generation can incorporate a love of a certain type of expression or entertainment into their identity, when that expression and/or entertainment is actually being produced by the minds of the previous generation for the consumption of everyone. Gen X, for instance, made all this technology everyone has taken for granted available;) It came from some longing we had.

Couch Table

I haven't encountered the Z stereotype of millennials as little babies, but as a veteran of the OWS activist milieu, I find it a bit, shall we say, off the nose.

Austin F

an extremely sobering moment for me was a few years ago, when i saw a "cringe things millennnials say" list, and almost everything on that list was something i had said in the past week (i never said 'doggo', though)

Munchy Lunchco

This was super interesting. I have been feeling kind of suffocated lately by the tone of a lot of discussions concerned with the differences between the generations. So I really liked hearing your observation about how gen Z and millennials have something more like a sibling relationship, generational-wise. It just helped things click together in my mind. Cause we're all on this cool journey aging through life towards maturity and eventually death together. Anyway, great tangent! I always get a little shot of excitement and happiness when I see a new one has been uploaded. Thanks, Natalie!

Cassidy Brinn

To get the right words to express Hegel's dialectic, go back to the Twilight video: 1) Master, 2) Slave, 3) Orgasm (as master and slave)

Wissa

I think the idea that older millennials had such a uniquely fantastical idealistic view of the future and our own talents is true. Of course, each generation has a lot of diverse dispositions that mirror the archetypes of other generations, but the extremes of each generation is going to define them. For millennials, it was us who were destined to be great artists and musicians where passion, love, and imagination leads to success, only to crash and burn. This is a story as old as time, but it’s like we were POSSESSED by it, in a communal reinforcing way instead of individually by chance. Anyways, long live t3h PeNgU1N oF d00m

Cassidy Brinn

So we have two ways to interpret history - as random events or as a single story with a unified structure? Those both sound so unsatisfying. And not in line with what I see as popular (commercially successful) perspectives of history. The dominant paradigm that I seem to see bouncing around is history as many stories. I.e. the only way to understand history is to understand multiple kinds of stories about it - the story of salt, the story of money, the story of this one woman, etc etc... we want everyone to give us their story. And, call me a creature of my generation, but that makes sense to me. Random events feels like an artificial deprivation, but a unified structure, like this 80 years idea? As someone living outside the US that feels wildly implausible. Not impossible, but you'd have to be a mystic to believe it. Which means I think Giambattista Vico and Yeats might be more promising paths than some social scientists throwing grandiose click-baity titles on some cherry-picked empirical data.

The Mad Jay Woman

*Quietly contemplating in GenX about largely being left out of this (as always)* It's very... INTERESTING watching Millenials reckon with the Generation Wars and come to terms with a lot of behaviours they themselves normalized, especially internet culture and ageism As a Baby GenXer I experienced all the same things Elder Millenials did, but my perspective is almost never spoken to because it's only ever framed through the Millenial view. It does reinforce a very ingroup/outgroup attitude

Annabelle_Thann

Oh wonderful EXACTLY what I need as my blooming awareness of my mortality while I approach the one year mark from college graduation sends me into constant spirals! Lemme analyze the SHIT out of my anxieties and their social causes

TashArrgh

I feel like a point to be considered between the generation who fought in WW1, and the millennials onwards is hope. I'd presume those in the lost generation, at the time, were going through unimaginable horrors, but they knew it wasn't going to last forever. Millennials onwards are living with the knowledge that no fucker that matters is doing anything about climate change. It's only going to get worse and they fear their children and the next generations are doomed to the predictions experts have claimed, such as famine, drought, more pandemics, extreme weather etc. We're the no hope generation. Lay off the future generations says I! Let them have Skibidi Toilet!

Bara

Again - an excellent episode. Thought provoking for sure. My thoughts have been provoked. I have long rebelled against the idea that I, as some one who was born in 1963, am a Boomer. There is so much about the Boomer generation that I just don't relate to. There is a lot about Gen X that I do relate to - but then I don't. Is being on the cusp of any generational shift its own category? Or is the Boomer to Gen X shift so profound that it needs its own generation, Generation Jones? Or is that just another example of Boomer exceptionalism?

Moses Sloven

Imagine if Natalie got a low taper Faaaaaaaade 🎶

Eman Collins

Let's GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Marinousky

Small note @ 39 mins: that’s an Aztec calendar

Najeeb Khadim

I wonder if it's more that capitalism tends to encourage people to look at the material and sideline the spiritual? Or maybe that's just modernity as Charles Taylor argued. There was a scholar (Arif something I think) who argued that the 'return of religion' into politics since the late 1970s but especially in the 2000s is because with the decline of communism it is now the only alternative to capitalism

George Berberian

Hi! Absolutely LOVED your Twilight video. Super pumped to watch this one. Really appreciate you working so hard to get us the backlogged tangents. I want to make sure you take care of yourself first. I'm A-OK with a missing tangent so you can rest and recharge. You are a legit treasure and important voice! ❤️ G

King Scene

Mark Fisher just didn't go to enough raves in the 2000's

Liz Jones

This is a completely ahistorical perspective. You really think people whose entire lives were consumed by a WORLDWIDE WAR felt like, well, it looks rough now but I’m sure this will all turn out fine eventually! No lol. We only think that because we have the hindsight to know that’s what happened. There is a kind of narcissism in believing we have a more hopeless situation than any generation before us but that’s simply not true.

beakusfreakus

saw this clipped on insta and RAN HERE I *needed* the rest

Emily Broth

can someone plz tell me what her shirt's design is?? i love it!!

Alex

I enjoyed a less edited video. I'm a proponent of a "throw everything at the wall and let each individual take what ideas they will" type of education. I really connected with the Vonnegut shape of historical narratives piece. I've been having a long running debate with a friend that boils down to this difference of interpretation of history and it was very helpful to see it defined as closer to a difference of narrative opinion. I'll definitely be thinking more about the linear vs cyclical nature of history.

Kiki

Great video!!! I was wondering about your thoughts on generationalism and queerness— the prominence of age gap relationships, the effect of AIDS on older queer communities, the perceived novelty of certain queer and trans identities and pronouns, etc?

carly they themsen

eye wll be so happy f u really post 2 more tmes n aprl that would be huge for me

Halcy

Thank god for you, Natalie! How else would this elder millennial know about skibidi toilet and sticking out your gyatt for the rizzler?

Mormolok

I feel a bit cheated..Natalie did not explain the whole song ..Now I sit here in the dark and wonder what the heck ."Give me your Ohio" means

Tim 🦆

Easter does not actually originate as a pagan holiday. That is a very popular myth

Emerson Whittaker

Great video! I'm pretty sure something as complex as human history could never fully be modeled by a line or a circle, but it's interesting to see what insights can fall out of these simplified models. I wonder if the anxiety levels of different generations would be cyclical too if you could somehow account for the general public not knowing anything about mental health problems until recently. I know every generation complains about the youth and their technology, but I almost think that people today might be more anxious because the more time you spend online and the less disposable income you have, the less time you spend in person with family and friends. In my experience my anxieties are greatly reduced by talking people.

abi

Enjoyed the video! I work with kids for a living though and I will say, it's shockingly common how many 8-13 year olds have a below 2nd grade reading level. Not good. (I'm not just a pessimist I swear!)

Bruno Sauvagnat

I think the one thing I would disagree with is about the failure of socialist movements in the US. They have not seized powerby any mean, but political discourse has shifted. Biden has to put forward policies and discourses that are more left leaning. It absolutely rhetorical, but I do think that this ideological shift of socialism and even more radical ecologism have to be taken seriously in the political arena will lead to change down the road. Not in ways that are very dramatic, but in smaller ways that will make our lives better.

Ash Gabrielle

Is "sex positive" really used in a derogatory manner now? I can't even imagine how that would work. It sounds like an inherently good thing to me. Guess I'm showing my millennial age!

C.LiGS

the first five minutes is comedy gold. "I have spent hours -- days, even -- watching, STUDYING skibidi toilet"

Jake Bookbinder

people think skibidi toilet came out of nowhere as if little millennial children were not positively losing it to shane dawson and scatman john. it's sad

shinygiftcards

I heard the Ape Escape 'Time Station' theme, and suddenly felt all tingly and briefly floated out of my chair. Wonderful new tangent, excellent as always!

ContraPoints

Good eye. That’s the kind of thing a little extra research time would fix lol

Opinionated Online

No, don't. I'm also 1997 baby, and I strongly identify as a (younger) Millennial. Prior to 2018 or 2019, we were near universally considered Millennials. We were in our 20s and formed much of our identity before anyone called us Gen Z. I'm not going to let some polling company's ill-thought out generational range cheat me out of being a Millennial. And, I'm certainly not going to let 1996 borns be considered Millennials, while 1997 borns are considered Gen Z'ers.

Densifier

Pamtri Spongebob T-shirt!!

Pär Ahl

So, when you talked about the difference between you and your siblings, that really resonated with me. I am 34 years old and a teacher of 12-16 year olds in Sweden. When I leave my students, they make their first real choice of what education to pursue - basically their first career choice. And I have been so annoyed that so few chooses out of interest or passion - but only out of career possibilities and economic interest. This tangent really made me understand why.

Jonathan

Nayyytalie, what are these foreign words????

Teageen

Juxtaposing audio of skibidi toilet and renaissance madrigals was 💯🔥😂🤌🤌

Felipe Botero

Amazing video essay. I was a bit concerned about how homogeneizing any talk about generation can become, especially watching from Colombia, where I am from, but you definitely seemed aware about how USA-centric and, in that sense, relative all talk about generation is, so the homogeneization and generalization must always be taken with a grain of salt. In any case, I really enjoyed it, particularly everything about the cyclical conception of time against linear! Thank you so much!

triggthediscovery

I was reminded of your "is the world getting worse" video while watching it lol. Great minds think alike.

Lauren Danielle

Shitting on astrology and calling me old 😭😭 what a day

Opinionated Online

I was born in 1997, and I will always identify as a (younger) Millennial, and will never identify as Gen Z. I'm still salty about Pew's random generational range change in 2018 kicking me out of my generation when I was already in my 20s, and will never not push back against that. I don't have anything against actual Gen Z'ers, but I resent being called Gen Z because it is so discordant with my experiences. I was an elementary school-age child during the Invasion of Iraq and the height of the Iraq and Afghanistan Wars, which had a profound impact on me. It shaped my views on foreign policy, and more broadly the person I would become. Obviously, I was very young so I didn't understand all of the details, but seeing the images in the news and in newspapers (including graphic ones of dead civilians) had a huge impact on how important I find being anti-war, anti-violence, and pro-peace to be. I started paying to attention politics and forming political opinions in early 2012. I went through a Ron Paul phase. Him being anti-regime change war was a significant part of my early political awakening with me wanting to see a world with less death and destruction than I saw as a child on the news. Now, I have a much broader and better anti-imperialist vision, but the Iraq and Afghanistan Wars had a fairly significant impact on the person I am today. That's a very Millennial experience. Also, the whole War on Terror Era starting with 9/11 gave me news anxiety. TV and radio news would make me really anxious when I was young. I'm mostly over it now, but I will still get a bit anxious if news is on at public places where I can't turn it off. The sound of "news music" still makes me uneasy. Someone just a few years younger than me probably wouldn't have had all these experiences. I remember the optimism of 2015 and 2016 when I had recently come of age where it seemed like things were getting better and moving in the right direction in a lot of ways. I was (just barely) an adult when same-sex marriage was legally recognized nationwide and in my state. In general, I remember 2011-2016 feeling like a pretty optimistic, care-free time in society, but that's probably because I was a teenager. It was very different from what I associate with the stereotypical Gen Z teen feeling that's cynical and doomerish. Honestly, I'm still probably more optimistic about the future than many Millennials or Gen Z'ers are. I didn't get a smartphone until I was 16, and I only got one because it was cheaper or the same price with our cellphone plan (I wasn't begging my parents or anything). I never really had social media aside from Facebook until I was in my early 20s. I am absolutely not on TikTok and don't really watch short-form content otherwise. To this day, I've never used a social media app on my smartphone. In that way, I feel more like a Silent or something. I remember when I was 16-18 years old having a much better attention span than I do now. Social media was around but wasn't anywhere near as pervasive as it is today. I also didn't get an email and never used the internet until I was 8, and I barely used the internet at all until I was 10. For a number of years, my best friend was born in 1989 (eight years older than me). The group of friends and acquaintances that were most formative for me were mostly born between 1989-1998. I have a very mid-point Millennial sibling. My parents are both Baby Boomers (and are such Boomers). On the superficial side, I part my hair on the side, like low-rise skinny jeans, can't stand the current mumble style of music, love avocado toast, think using mason jars for cups is cool, and have used the term "adulting." So, in other words, I'm a (younger) Millennial. Some of this is individual which will vary from person to person, but I think 1999/2000 makes the most sense for a Millennial/Gen Z cutoff, though no cutoff is perfect. I definitely think 1997 is a later Millennial birth year. In any case, I identify as a Millennial, and I'm not interested in anyone telling me I'm Gen Z.

Count Crackula

It's fascinating looking at the heated responses to generational humor. It's never been so easy to pinpoint people who have never had an-honest-to-god sincere instropective thought cross their mind. I mean, my generation was all about the "trash"/low-value entertainment "destroying young minds." I would tune into WWE (WWF back then) weekly, where a man would, on occasion, rub his ass directly into another man's (sometime a woman's) face. It was hilarious. Of course, Saturday morning cartoons were also getting tons of criticism for similar reasons. This generational critique is so lazy and tired.

Opinionated Online

I feel like we also shouldn't downplay how scary it was living right after the invention of nuclear weapons and in the age of MAD. The threat of nuclear war loomed over people in the 1950s and 1960s. I'm sure that had a negative impact on people growing up during that time.

juliana peña

Thanks for putting into actual words that lingering feeling I got after watching freaky Friday

Hunter Hylton

Love the Ape Escape music for the title cards

lipdirt

FFS. This is not a news channel.

Sophie Cleverly

This was so good, I feel like this has actually changed my perspective on life. Thank you!

Elsie Hupp

I feel like the defining attribute of being a millennial is remembering life before 9/11. Basically, the defining attribute of being a millennial is being given the kool-aid of Fukuyama’s End of History when you were a kid.

Elsie Hupp

Shane Dawson? No, Salad Fingers.

Elsie Hupp

We Millennials reflect the narcissistic self-assurance of our Boomer parents, who told us we could do anything while simultaneously making sure we couldn’t. (Boomers gave us Nathaniel Branden.)

Elsie Hupp

Once your kid is old enough, though, you can introduce Salad Fingers…

Elsie Hupp

You remember 2008, but you don’t remember the Fukuyama 90s, before 9/11.

TashArrgh

Respectfully disagree. In times of war there is well documented comradery. 'Dig for Victory' 'If you're going through hell, keep going' etc. Also, not the entire earth is at war, so it is possible to leave, albeit incredibly difficult, but there are places to hide. In war you can hope it will end, global warming isn't something that's going to stop and there is no end and no where to go. I do agree about the nuclear warheads, but again, you can still hope the big red button isn't pressed

Elsie Hupp

It’s much cuter than Salad Fingers, that’s for sure.

Elsie Hupp

There was enough of a generation gap from WWII that a bunch of high schools built in the 60s and 70s ended up closing in the 80s and 90s before reopening in the 00s. I imagine the sine wave has gradually smoothed out, though.

Lady Bunnerkins

Ah fuck yes best $3 I ever spent let's go

Teageen

Maybe you live in an area where kids don't have much at home support? Just a guess as to why this could be

Teageen

Why the bunnies and eggs for Easter then?

Teageen

I'm interested in hearing more. I'm confused about what makes you a young Gen x rather than an old millennial

Teageen

This is going to not feel good, bc I think you were being sarcastic, but I think it's actually true that it will be beneficial.

Teageen

Bo Burnham has a lot to say about this topic. "If you can live your life without an audience, do it" or something along those lines. CJ the X has a long video essay in which they discuss this pretty thoroughly. It's called Bo Burnham vs Jeff Bezos and it's 💯

Teageen

97 kid here and I don't identify strongly with either. People can and will do whatever they are inclined to, but I think it's maladaptive to identify strongly with anything. I think it's all a big grey area (with pretty much everything, and I hate it, but especially something like this). I also think internet culture might be messing up the "generational divisions" to whatever extent they existed in the first place. Shit moves so fast in internet years.

Teageen

Catch my boomer grandparents complaining about socialism while using government funded healthcare that they voted against 😮‍💨🤦‍♀️

Teageen

Same 😂

Teageen

Someone needs to calm down and recognize that Natalie is just a person and can't do everything. jesus

Teageen

This attitude is exactly what is tearing the left (and also all of America) apart

Inferno Glass

Pointing out that being pro-sex is not inherently a young people thing, but rather a generational (boomer) thing, leads to the somewhat funny, and i think true, conclusion that today, being a "sex-negative" adult is in some way an attempt to "fit in" with the young.

Teageen

Maybe I'm reading a bigger emotional response from this than it really is, but a friendly advice (that is definitely going to feel unfriendly, partly bc you didn't ask for it) it seems like you really are hung up about something that doesn't (need to) matter that much. It's all made up and the points don't matter. Someone made up these categories and the lines are all arbitrary. Just like country borders. I was also born in 97 and I feel i had about a 40/60 mix of millennial and gen z experiences. I didn't have any older siblings that were staunchly "millennials" though to pull me into that culture. I don't identify as either, because I think generation labels (perhaps labels in general) are generally inaccurate and unhelpful. Probably the best they do is be funny, but even that can be harmful. It is a bit of a red flag to cling to a label like this so vehemently. Out of genuine concern, it seems like this is probably not a healthy framework for you. I hope you can get anything out of this comment and that it won't just make you upset. 🤍

Cleo Oops

Adam Conover did an interesting talk about this topic a while ago that I think is on YouTube.

Tim 🦆

So eggs were a common teaching tool to explain the Trinity and were associated with God. And there's a story where Mary Magdalene turned an Egg red to prove Jesus's resurrection to Caesar, so that could be the origin. Rabbits are able to get pregnant while already pregnant, so they could give birth again very quickly after already haven given birth. An magical-seeming conception. That could be how that got involved The stories Easter descending from pagan holiday are really dubious and introduced later, sometimes by Protestants who wanted to undermine Catholicism Easter did get its name from Eoster, which was the name of the month. But the story of a Germanic pagan holiday that involved eggs and bunnies is not well evidenced. Nor did Ishtar have these associations with Easter-related things There's a lot we don't know, but it's a little disheartening to hear people confidently claim this stuff

Austin F

what initially really surprised me as a millennial with no kids was finding out how many kids don't have any idea how to use a computer...i mean, after i thought about it, it does make sense, because phones have taken over for so many kids, and a lot of smartphones give very simple instructions on how to do anything that you need, but it was still a shock for me at the time. i guess i just assumed at the time that not understanding technology that involves "The Internet" was only a boomer thing if there's one way millennials (and older gen Z, depending on your definition) got lucky with the time period we were born in, it's that a lot of us used computers so much as kids on an internet that was less guided, and we learned a lot of computer skills in the process. so many millennials (including me) know multiple website coding languages just because of designing themes for tumblr/myspace/others, a lot of us learned basic video editing and photoshop from making memes or youtube videos, most of us can type really fast, many of us know how to handle file sharing, many have had to fix simple computer issues, we have good internet safety, etc, and we learned these without even taking classes on them. it's kind of cool, actually. we had a whole internet to explore and figure out, sometimes entirely through experimentation. (obviously that stuff does still exist in some places, but you often have to seek it out specifically, so you don't just learn it while messing around doing 14 Year Old Things) edit: for the record this was not meant to be a flex lol, it genuinely is sad to me that others don't have the opportunity to learn this

Austin F

it is often used negatively, both by reactionary types that are mad at anyone who isn't straight and cis actually existing in public, and by younger people who dislike it because they think it leads to creepy things. it's one of those phrases that feels like it's been mocked out of normal usage for many people, and the ideas behind it are referred to in different ways because of it

Austin F

haha do you guys remember when so many people acted like paris hilton and her reality show meant that we were all doomed and stupid? or a few years later, when Jersey Shore caused the same reaction? i swear, people don't realize that "trash entertainment" has been around for sooooooo long. it's so funny to see this play out over and over with 0 self awareness

Jay Hill

agree with a lot particurlarly regarding the kinds of assumptions that people make about the youths or the olds based on what young people have been like in the past few decades. I remember there being a lot of 'discourse' put forward mainly be older people surrounding the issue of why do young people support socialism or bernie or corbyn in the uk that basically it was just what young people do - young people are just more leftwing because young people are idealistic or whatever and then we all become conservative when were older which just always struck me as very ahistorical and uncurious and a way of dismissing the substantive issues (worse financial outlooks, 2008, all of that). Its just not true that youngness = more leftwing or 'progressive' or socialist a lot of this seems to be pretty heavily based on the generational history or perception of boomers as having been leftwing, hippies, anti-capitalsit etc and then becoming less radical and more conservative with age and that just not being able to see past that. Re issues with mental health as a part of a political battle I do want to push back/argue for mark fishers analysis on the grounds that criticisms of the political/social/capitalist causes of poor mental health are not just about relative affluence. Obviously financial insecurity is not good for mental health but I think a good socialist analysis goes beyond this and also relates the ways in which a capitalist economy and social structure creates isolation, in which a consumerit culture encourages a focus on lack, the morality of capitalism (the protestant work ethic) is intensely critical, judgemental and shaming, and other ways in which capitalist society creates or facilitates mental illness and although my memory of it is not great I believe fishers arguments were largely more related to other grounds than simply material lack. Its right of course to point out how mentally ill a lot of rich people are but that is pretty consistent with a socialist critique of the effects of capitalism on wellbeing, for some of the same reasons it has a poor effect on the mental wellbeing as everyone else. Even Marx recognised that the factory owner was as much trapped in the system as the worker and thereby alientated from their fellow human beings. Not that socialism would banish mental illness forever but I do think that capitalism and particurlarly the neoliberal strain of the last 40-50 years has had a traceable negative impact on mental wellbeing at a social level.

Austin F

i think 'do you remember 9/11' (in the US; idk about other countries) is a good dividing line for the generation, because it was a single event with such a massive impact on history and culture, and almost anyone who was cognitively aware at the time has some memory of it. obviously this doesn't work for every individual, but it's the best we got. (personally, some of the comments people that are younger than millennials make about 9/11 make me kind of uncomfortable, which i know makes me sound old and lame. idk. i don't mind jokes, but i remember viral posts about how "cool" it apparently is to "not care about 9/11", and like...not only did 3,000 people die that day, but hundreds of thousands more died in the iraq war, many of them innocent civilians, and there was a massive increase in anti-muslim sentiment. i think people should find another way to be super cool and edgy and Pwn The American Imperialists.)

Lisa

Gen X here with 2 tweens and I am desperate to know the meaning of the last line of the song –– WHY OHIO?

peter mills

could have thrown in a tad of vico's cyclical historical theory to counter hegel and marx. grouse weirdo shit.

Archie Atkinson

Interesting seeing Sargon (2016 all over again) released a video on a similar topic within the same week

The Mad Jay Woman

Because I was born in the late ‘70s and therefore my childhood was in the ‘80s and thus I remember the ‘90s as a high school/university student I’m not being precious here, I’m significantly older than the bulk of Internet personalities who dominate online discourse

Erin Laura

so funny reina, you should make a video on granola facism was it? I would love that.

Josephine

Ok we can trade cuz I was born in 91 and I rly wish I was gen z I think my generation is so cringe and gen z is so cool lmao

harpy

Two things. 1) you are talking a lot of smack about horoscopes for being the most Libra that ever Libra'd. I say this as a fellow millennial Libra.❤️ 2) the seasons theory is interesting and should be taken with a grain of salt, but I wonder if the theory would make more sense if the 80 year crisis was more about how the generation or structure in place by the generation hold up to the crisis. Like that covid is the crisis and not the financial crisis because the population is so hollowed out of goodwill that it basically causes more chaos because it legitimately breaks the systems in place. Like crisiss happen all the time but perhaps the difference is how we respond and how vast the damage is. Seriously amazing video.

harpy

Also skipidy toilet or however you spell it feels like the spiritual descendant to crazy frog and the like. I also do not really get the mass terror.

Elsie Hupp

The fact that 9/11’s cultural impact was America-centric is a good observation! Though on some level I think most of these generation names are probably primarily American. (And, anyway, the United States certainly reacted internationally to 9/11.) I also definitely know that the American perception of a lull in the Cold War in the 90s was wildly inconsistent with the economic collapse of former Communist countries, not to mention the nasty civil wars in Yugoslavia and Chechnya. So perhaps the Fukuyama framing is better than the 9/11 framing. And the 2008 recession was the final nail in the coffin for this particular “end of history”. (There is a particular irony in the “end of history” coinciding with the Millennium, particularly because of millenarianism. So maybe the defining feature of Millennials is watching the world end, and then having to go on with our lives lol)

Elsie Hupp

As for being edgy about 9/11… dark humor is one thing, but obviously George H. W. Bush did 9/11. Accidentally. As director of the CIA. Oops! Bush, Sr., supporting the Mujahideen is about as brilliant as Netanyahu supporting Hamas.

Matthew Mendenhall

I am curious to know what it is about being a millennial that is so superior to being a zoomer to the point that you would feel cheated out of being a millennial if you were Gen Z. You talk about being a millennial like a “creative” would talk about being declined exclusive access to SoHo House member clubs. It’s not like Natalie was super on fire for the contributions or character of millennials. So I’m just curious about your thoughts - especially if you do believe Millennials are functionally better than zoomers.

TashArrgh

I hear you. My sister was born mid 70s while I was born late 80s. The main differences between us I think is that she is more cautious in life, had children early, and she has a much stronger work ethic. She also is able to power through her Anxiety and talk to people and form relationships much better, where as my anxiety just keeps me down and I don't form attachments easily. It's difficult to ascertain what is generational, cultural, individual etc, but I've seen a lot of these things in my sister's friends. I think the 70s babies should be studied more closely, the generation who were teens just after mass distribution of the internet vs those who were teens at the time, might give some useful insights into the affects it's had on people coming of age with it today

sam tapes

the clip of the lady talking about taylor swift is torturing me. i cant get it out of my head.

Frankie

As a person born in 2000 I saw all the articles complaining about these young millennials and assumed I was part of that group and kind of identified with it so i was kind of surprised when i found that by most definitions I am gen z, especially cause I'm kind of on the older end of the generation so it was weird to be told I'm in the same generation as people who were born in 2010

Frankie

The joke is that supposedly crazy things happen in Ohio, kind of like the Florida man memes. If somebody says something is "Ohio" it might mean it is bizarre or unusual. In the context of Sticking Out Your Gyatt For the Rizzler, it might be interpreted as "give me your craziness." Ohio jokes are often seen as cringe by gen z. I don't know if youve heard "in Soviet Russia..." jokes. It's a lot like that

Yana L

I was kinda affected by the comment about gen z not having sex. Because yeah i guess... But its not because of sex itself, its more because of vulnerability and how casual sex feels more like self harm and not even a fun kind. And you know, girlfriends leave you and even writing sad emo poetry about it stops helping eventually. I wish sex felt like what all these club banger from the 2000s sounded like. Mindless, fun, causally all-consuming, but without the horrors.

RmhWork.

Are you really that sure that we, millennials, won’t be affected by the climate crisis in our lifetime? Reflect on the fact that cacao prices have surged +1000% due to harvest failures caused by drought (consider buying chocolate stock, thank me later). Similarly, olive oil production has been impacted, and avocado cultivation is depleting water reserves in the lands where they are grown.

Evy

I think at any level of poverty, having more money would absolutely improve most people's mental health. I'm sure there are exceptions, but I think that's generally true. That's my one little area of disagreement. This was entertaining and on point as always.

Evy

I like therapy and spirituality but I do wish doctors could prescribe money.

Cigarette Juice

My little sister can relate. She was born in 98 but is culturally very much a Millennial, though she does understand and vibe with her more Zoomer-ish friends. I think having older Millennial siblings (born in 91) has a lot to do with that. She calls herself a Zillennial.

Ajey Pandey

I actually read Neil Howe’s latest book, and I’m kinda sympathetic to the cycles model…within limits. I think an underrated mechanism for the generational model is the slow forgetting of cultural memory. A Crisis (turning) is a Crisis in part because the people who remember the previous Crisis are mostly dead. In the case of 2024 America, the last people who remember a unified, functional government are in their 80s—and the people who built those institutions are all dead. And I think it’s best to think about generational logic at a population “bell curve” level. A given 18-year-old in 2024 may or may not be more promiscuous than an 18-year-old in 1968, but the difference is in the population data and in the outliers. It’s not that Zoomers are antisocial shut-ins—it’s that there are disproportionately more Zoomer NEETs, just like there disproportionately more Boomers who did serious drugs in high school. And like…it’s not ALL cyclical, but if Strauss and Howe can predict the future even 10% better than a random guess, that’s useful info.

Cigarette Juice

I agree. The fact that so many people support socialized healthcare, for example, is big win of socialist discourse. We may not see the effects *yet,* but I think we will once the older generations give way to much more leftist younger generations in time. Boomers and Gen X are particularly right-wing, and they are numerous and organized, but they won’t be forever.

Jack Dover

I do wonder whether Natalie has accidentally stumbled on an interesting theory of mental health that what we currently conceptualise as 'mental health' is actually two separate entities. One rooted in socioeconomics and the other in a more individualist self? An increase in affluence can address the first but not the second.

Bruno Wichinheski

As far as I know, afrofuturism and sinofuturism both dissolves linear time, so I think is safe to assume that the idea of a linear time with an inevitable end will eventually stop being the standard point of view. Funny thing, recently I read a paper on "recursive colonialism" that pretty much says that everytime the West White Men are losing its fixed position as the epitome of knowledge, progress and etc. they somehow evoke the End of The World, so they can continue their colonialism or something like that. And in their view, I can understand why they think it is the End of The World.

fae

I think the point she made was that millennials will not be more affected by climate change than other generations, not that they will not be affected at all.

Opinionated Online

Teageen, I maybe wouldn't care as much if people would just stop talking generations so much. If it was the sort of thing that was rarely brought up that would be one thing, but in the last few years the levels of generational talk has become so excessive. It feels like I can't get away from the stupid Pew Ranges online. So, I'm going to push back when I see them used. I too do wish people would talk about generations less. I agree in the grand scheme of things happening it's not that big of a deal. I feel like I'm probably 80-90% Millennial and 10-20% Gen Z when it comes to life experiences and stereotypical traits (80/20 for experiences, 90/10 for traits). But, I was strongly identifying as a (Younger) Millennial back in 2015 before these new Pew Ranges came out. Then, the most most common ranges were either 1981-2000 or 1982-2000 (according to the US Census Bureau) for Millennials. I was unquestionably a Millennial, and it wasn't until 2001 or maybe 2000 that Gen Z started. I liked those old ranges, though I think the vast majority of 2000 borns identify as Gen Z so it should probably end in 1999. Growing up, people born in 1997 were universally considered Millennials, and I don't take kindly to people trying to kick me out of my generation when I'm already into my 20s. It wasn't just older siblings either that made me feel much more Millennial. Like I said, my best friend of my early adult years was born in 1989 and was not on in any way related to my having an older sibling. I will add that all my professors in college considered all 90s born Millennials when the subject came up in 2018-2019. There was a general census that Gen Z doesn't start until 2000 or 2001. It wasn't 2019 that I even heard about the new Pew Ranges when I was 21 almost 22. Even as early as 2011 or 2012, when I was 14 or 15, I had a strong sense of my Millennial identity. I also agree that generational labels are way overused and are increasingly seemingly only being used to cause more division. I tend to agree we should not being using them as much. I do like labels generally, and think they can be positive things. But, I think generational labels are the kind of labels that can very quickly become unhelpful and overused. However, since they're being used, I'm going to continue to push back against 1997 borns being considered Gen Z. It's one thing if people use McCrindle Range, which starts Gen Z in 1995. I disagree and think it's wrong, but at least it keeps 1995-1999 borns together as one generation. I have absolutely no tolerance for the Pew Range where 1996 borns are allowed into Millennials but 1997 borns are kicked out. And, I will always strongly oppose that. Maybe, part of it is feeling like older generations are allowed to define us and set limitations on us. It's a story of older generations defining and telling us 1997, 1998, and 1999 borns who we are without any input from us. And, I will not let anyone think they can kick 1997 borns, while keeping 1996 borns in. I have a close friend who was born in 1996, and he doesn't consider 1996 and 1997 to be different generations. Though, we both tend to feel that people born 2000 on tend to be different from us ("Zoomers"). He was also hardly at all impacted by watching the Iraq and Afghanistan Wars, while I was. Even though he was born in 1996, and I was born in 1997. I realize that no two adjacent birth years are going to be that different from each other, but the idea that there is anything meaningful different enough to separate 1996 and 1997 borns from each other is absurd. Literally, no actual 1996 and 1997 borns consider themselves different generations from each other. On the other side, I've met 1996 borns who identify as Gen Z. But, no one (or almost no one) who was actually born in 1996 or 1997 agrees with the Pew Millennials/Gen Z cutoff. To them, either we're both Millennials or Gen Z'ers. So, I'm not interested in older people (or younger people) drawing an arbitrary line between us. This should have input from the actual people it concerns and how they define their life experiences. We get to define ourselves. Not older people or younger people. The vast majority of 2000s born identify as Gen Z, and many seem perfectly happy to be considered the first year of Gen Z. So, why can't we give that to them? We don't need to drag people born in the 1990s into Gen Z. There's a general consensus among 1995-1999 borns that we belong together as a sub-cohort of whatever group they group us in whether that's Younger Millennials, Zillennials, or Older Gen Z'ers. I think it was such a travesty seperating 1995 and 1996 borns, and 1997, 1998, and 1999 borns into two different generation. Whatever generation we are, we all belong in it together. Sometimes, 1994 borns are included on the early side and/or 2000 borns on the late side, but 1995-1999 are nearly universally considered one group that should be grouped together by actual 1995-1999 borns. I'm not interested in older people or younger people imposing their ideas on us and arbitrarily cutting us apart. People born in the early 2000s seem to have a culture when it comes to fashion, music, etc. that is so foreign to me as someone who was born in 1997. It's not just because "they're kids" and "you'll feel more similar as you get older." They're not really kids anymore. Honestly, the older we get the less similar I feel. They have a very distinct cultural identity that I am not part of. For instance, I don't get the appeal of Billie Eilish's music. It doesn't in anyway resonate with me. And, that Older Gen Z subculture is fine for them, but I don't want to be grouped in with it. I find it much easier to culturally relate to people born in the first half of the 1990s. This is of course talking in generalizations. Obviously, there are individual Older Gen Z people I relate to, but they tend to be "old souls" who for instance are not on TikTok. So, I'm going to keep pushing back until 1997 borns (and 1998 and 1999 borns) are generally considered Millennials again like they used to be. At least get people in the media to stop repeating the Pew Ranges ad nauseam, especially when it's not relevant to be talking about an entire generation in their article. For what's it worth, my preferred birth year generational ranges starting with the Silents is Silent Generation 1928-1945, Baby Boomers 1946-1963, Generation X 1964-1980, Millennials 1981-1999, Generation Z 2000-??? (tentatively 2015), and Generation Alpha ??? (tentatively 2016)-present day. Sorry that I've written so much. I'm not upset at you or anything. I appreciate what you had to say and somewhat sympathize with it. This is just something I feel strongly about.

Hoodwaus

Love the Ape Escape music!!!!

Joe

This was so fascinating and articulated so many thoughts I wasn't quite able to pin down that I was having. One thing I might push back on a bit, at the risk of being the Old Man Yelling at Cloud... you seemed to dismiss the critique of younger generations being too dependent on technology, having ruined attention spans, etc. just based on the fact that the same critiques were made about us and the TV (and the implication being the same for the youth before us and before them). But I do think that our dependence on TV and technology made our attention spans objectively worse than the generation before us. And I do think the youth's dependency on iPads has made their attention spans worse than ours. And that what's coming next will be even worse. But rather than a failing of "the youth" - I see that more as sort of a depressing reality of increased technology, specifically as its architecture was built in Silicon Valley. So rather than dismissing the critique because it was made against us, I'd propose that the critique was valid when it was lobbied against us and continues to be valid. I think that's a much more productive starting point for any conversation moving forward than just outright dismissal. With all that said this was my favorite tangent so far.

Lewis Barrett

People freaking out over GMOD humour is so surreal it's like we live in an alternate timeline where machinima never existed.

Joe

Like, I very much think that TikTok is much worse for a child's brain than anything I had when I was a child. And that's not the child's fault - if anything it's ours.

Lewis Barrett

Everyone's forgotten about 2000's internet it's so strange.

Joe

And more, I think what's most disturbing about the skibidi toilet video is not the totally randomness of it or the crass humor or the content at all, but that a 9 year is so chronically online already that he's A) aware of those phrases and how to use them, B) existing in the same spaces with 3-4 generations of people above him, and C) that his words and actions are viral enough to be commented on and critiqued by thousands of people 10, 20, 30, 40 years older than him. That's what's truly dark to me. When I was 9, other than my parents, pretty much the only people who perceived me were other 9 year olds. Again, may sound Old Man Yells at Cloud, but I genuinely believe that to be an objectively negative phenomenon for a child's psyche.

Opinionated Online

I'm way younger so it's not really my place to say, but in my experience 1964 borns seem more Gen X'er than Baby Boomer, and 1963 seem like they could go either way. I know officially Baby Boomers is defined as 1946-1964, but I kind of seem like it should end a year or two earlier. In my experience, people born in 1960 seem quite different from people born in 1964.

Olivia Rollins

Anyone who says the older generations don't have anxiety has never seen my grandfather in an airport.

Luz

My biggest takeaway from this video was: wait, Mother has siblings??

Olivia Rollins

Really though, I know SO MANY older people with terrible anxiety. They just usually don't name it or recognize it in themselves. The hoarding of food, etc., by those who experienced the Depression is one manifestation of it.

Olivia Rollins

Also I'm six years younger than Natalie and I got humanities degrees with no clear plan for what to do with them, so idk what that says about me lol.

Bruno Sauvagnat

I don't know about how important generational difference will be there's people from older generations who are more progressive and vice versa. I think it's more a question of wealth and where they live (suburd, cities,etc.). I think our generations just weren't absorbed in the same mould that would have made us exactly like them because the social policies that made some boomer more conservative were abolished by them once they reaped all the benefits (housing is too expensive, education, etc.).

Opinionated Online

Hot Tea, yes, I think having a mid-point Millennial sibling is part of that. I also think what generation your parents are is another big part of that. My parents are both Baby Boomers so that's another significant reason that I feel like a Millennial.

Ana

Thanks, Natalie, I enjoyed this a lot. A thought on your last bit about the communist revolution not fixing mental health: I think the issue is more nuanced. Yes, money alone is not sufficient to heal depression. But that’s not the only thing that might come with the revolution. Along stable income for everyone, a different sense of community might emerge. In other words: the connection between degradation of mental health and capitalism does not have to do with money alone, but also with an atomization of society which lead to isolation of the individuals. The two are related but not the same thing. In this sense, although mental health is a matter of personal responsibility that is best dealt through therapy and religion, one could argue that a change of system might eradicate the kind of systemic mental health issues prelevant in the western world resulted from the extreme isolation and individualization capitalism fosters.

10 Ten 235 J

Someone thinking Hegel invented Dialectical thinking is a surefire way to know that person hasn’t ever read Plato.

Katie

LOL wait I still don't understand if skibidi is a good thing, the context of the song makes it seem good (singer wants to be the sigma of the skibidi / fanum tax person and receive their ohio(?)) but I have also heard it is bad? I might be overthinking this

Gabriella

I like this point. I think it could also connect to what Contrapoints was saying about how technology disconnects us from our natural rhythms (refrigeration, electric lights). Like the trend of technology is disconnection. Maybe it’s a cyclical trend too and not a linear trend, maybe we’ll return to the days of eating fruit naked on the river bank! But seems like probably not.

ijbol

not us entering an auntie/uncle era lol

Maxim Foster

mother has posted brilliance on the timeline once again

Miranda

It is WILD to me that people act like the 2008 crash was more influential on millennials than the other thing that happened that year - smartphones!! One of the few ways that generational discourse is actually interesting is the difference in technology. Surely my mental health is impacted by the fact that I spend 4 hours a day looking at a device that didn’t exist when a gen X’er was my age. And surely it’s impactful that a generation now exists who have no reference point for a life without smartphones. I recently read an article called “but it’s the phones though, right?” And yeah, I think in a way it really is

Sarah Slichter

This was such a great vid to watch today, bc I happened to ask my 6th grade students to explain skibidy toilet to me earlier 😂 I asked them if I should watch it and they said “no you’ll get Ohio brain rot,” thank you for helping me learn about gen alpha culture in a philosophically safe environment. Also as always such great food for thought.

Molly McCormick

Now I have to go rewatch Cringe to process my feelings on all these embarrassing millennial clips To your last point, I've always felt so frustrated with this idea that mental illness won't exist in an anarchocommunist utopia or whatever. Capitalism certainly influences the shape mental illness takes and its prevalence in a huge way. But alienated labor is not the only cause of "mental illness," a concept which is itself historically contingent. I could fill up my own hour long video on this but I appreciate you mentioning it and giving us this tangent. Could tangents cure my millennial anxieties? Hope to find out

Deconstruction Interactive

Love this tangent! I am of the view that history is spiral, with cycles but also linear progress (as you describe towards the end of the video). Also thank you so much for explaining that video at the beginning, that was gold.

Emily Broth

If anyone wants proto-skibidi nonsense music, there's Spike Jones (not the director). Spike Jones Goes Crazy is a genuinely amazing album imo!

Ginny

Skibidy is just like early Youtube

Opinionated Online

Matthew Mendenhall, it's not that Millennials are functionally better than Zoomers, but that they're different. If you feel you identify more as Gen Z based on your life experiences I can't tell you not to identify with that. Many of the things you say do sound more stereotypically Zoomer. It just feels similar to someone born in the late 1970s identifying as a Millennial. I'm sure a few do, but I think of them as Gen X'ers. I have less of a probably if someone is from the school of thought like the McCrindle Range that Gen Z starts in 1995, though I still don't agree. I really don't like the Pew Range where Gen Z starts in 1997. Either way is still Gen Z, but I really don't think 1997 should be the start of Gen Z and split up from 1996 and 1995. Farther down in the posts, I wrote a couple of long posts about why identify as a Millennial, if you're interested. I won't just repeat them here. I guess to be honest I do tend to find stereotypical Gen Z stuff more cringey than stereotypical Millennial stuff. Some Millennial stuff that is often seen as cringey I think is cool, but even when it comes to most of the cringey Millennial stuff. Well, it may be cringey, but at least it's my kind of cringey. I just feel like my life experiences and sense of self-identity is being denied by being called Gen Z. There are both positive things I experienced that I feel Gen Z'ers didn't, and negative things that I experienced that Gen Z'ers didn't. Farther down in the posts, I talk about what a big impact being a young child during the height of the Iraq and Afghanistan Wars had on me and my later personal and political formation. This is something that someone just a few years younger than me would have probably been too young to experience. It's different from most Middle Millennials' and certainly Older Millennials' experiences of that era, but when I hear them talk about it I resonate with it, and it feels like a shared generational defining event. It's a continuum of experiences, and I'm on the younger end of that continuum. But, I also know Middle Millennials, like my older sibling, who are seeming much less impacted by it today than I am. The War on Terror was not as foundational of a shaping event for some people who are several years older than me. And, that was already passed when almost all Gen Z'ers were old enough to have memories. And, most Gen Z'ers were born late enough where the fear about terrorism wasn't as big, or after the whole War on Terror Era. I feel like a stereotypical Younger Millennial childhood experience is being terrified about dying in a terrorist attack. I remember talking about it with my childhood best friend (born in 1998) about how scared of that we both were. There is all sorts of fear in the media, but you're too young to understand how unlikely that is. I feel like this is something that most people born in the 2000s can't relate to (aside from those born in the very early 2000s). On the other hand, my formative years were not interrupted by a pandemic. My early development was not delayed as a result. And, I got to have fun years in high school that some Gen Z'ers were denied. Looking back, I'm so grateful and happy that I got to have all that. I got to do theatre and be in lots of musicals when I was teenager. So, I definitely think people born between 2002-2015 (and maybe later) should be included as part of Gen Z because they would have been in primary and secondary school when the pandemic hit. That's one of the largest reasons why I think Pew's 1997-2012 Gen Z Range is so poorly thought out. A person born in 1997 is old enough to have graduated from college with a bachelor's degree and be working for a year, while a person born in 2012 would likely be in second grade when the pandemic started. Those experiences are not even remotely similar. It's just a random range of years. That's one reason why I don't take Pew's later generational ranges seriously. It was created before the pandemic and has not been revised since. That is the big sort of event and era that should matter for defining generations. I think Gen Z'ers (aside from 2000 and 2001 borns who were just barely adults) is made up of "QuaranTeens" and "CoronaKids" who had an important, fundamental time in their lives disrupted. There are probably other things that define Gen Z, but that's a big one. This is maybe my personal bias, but I feel like I was in the sweet spot when it comes to technology and the internet during my high school years. It was around enough to connect people, but it wasn't such a pervasive thing. Social media and the internet on phones was a new thing, and it hadn't gotten to the point where people would rather be looking at their phones than talking and interacting with people in public. I feel like aside from the very oldest of 2000s borns, Gen Z'ers missed out on that. The internet used to be a lot better and used to bring people together more. It seems like the major social media players with all the algorithms, ads, consumerism, and atomization is all that many Gen Z'ers have ever known when it comes to being online. My attention span is so much worse than when I was in high school. I could read books for hours at a time in my late teens. I can't image what it's like especially for the younger side of Gen Z'ers and Gen Alphas who are literally growing up with all this. I guess some of this comes down to how people can be born the same year but have very different experiences. It's looking at it through rose-tinted glasses, but I remember 2012-2015 as such an idyllic and great time. I feel nostalgic for that time often. It just felt like things would keep getting better, and society would continue to become more empathetic and welcoming. It felt like there was a lot of optimism in the air among people my age and even those several years older than me. In any case, society felt kinder, and less aggressive and less antagonistic. Of course, things weren't that good in a lot of ways, and a lot of progress has been made in certain ways, and this is adolescent nostalgia. But, I don't at all relate to the Zoomer Doomer adolescence stereotype. That was almost the opposite to what I experienced. I feel like Younger Millennials and even some Middle Millennials had their own experience of an "End of History" in the early-to-mid 2010s, though it was more US-specific. I suppose we maybe had more economic pragmatism than those a bit older, but there was this "Society is moving in the right direction" and things are getting better feeling. In young adulthood, we had to grapple with things not exactly being like, at least to the extent we thought. Though, a lot of the economic problems were there but not as apparent to us. I also feel like Millennials should be divided up into three or four subgroups. Assuming a 1981 start date (though that is not entirely noncontroversial), I think Older Millennials were born 1981-1986, Middle Millennials born 1987-1994, and Younger Millennials born 1995-1999. And, Middle Millennials could be broken up further into two subgroups of Older-Middle Millennials born 1987-1990 and Younger-Middle Millennials born 1991-1994. I could see a reasonable argument for including 1994 borns in with Younger Millennials, but I put them with Middle Millennials. Maybe, all this is just trying to make order out of chaos, but it makes sense to me and is kind of fun. This is long, but here are some thoughts from a fellow 1997 baby on some reasons that I identify as a Millennial and not as Gen Z. I'm not claiming my experiences are the same as most Middle Millennials let alone those of Older Millennials. But, I feel like they fall under a sub-cohort of Millennials, the younger ones. If people born in the early or early-to-mid 1980s can reasonable identify as "Elder Millennials" than I think people born in the late or mid-to-late 1990s can reasonable identify as "Baby Millennials" or something like that.

swiftyfor2024

This is the part of the video that gave me pause as well. Did hunter gathers get ennui?

Aderyn Albarelli

How am I being surprised by almost every description you gave of the generation that I'm in? 😶 "What you get are *desperately tries not to use a slur*" -Camille Paglia I think it's plausible to hate Fujiyama's end of history because of the decades before, as well. A lot of what we worry about, in modern far right politics, was was getting it's skeletonn in the 70's(?), culminating in Regan rhetorically attacking a specific California college. Then financially attacking higher education, where he could, while claiming it was fiscally responsible, resulting in the expected groups of people being barred. Right along side GE beginning rank & yank and using share prices to as the measure of success (I still gotta ask mom if the standardization of that is why she got laid off from AT&T, then viasource). a lot of people may not hear "why yes! We've achieved stability, we need only maintain it!", But might hear instead, "in the hole, you go". (Do I dare find out what else happened around that time?)

Leanora

When my youngest sister (now 24) was 9, she thought Annoying Orange was the height of comedy. As far as I can tell, there is no meaningful difference between Skibidy Toilet and Annoying Orange

Austin F

yeah, this generational discourse often is so america-centric; even though some events were pretty universal (like world war II or covid), some were much more localized. i do think 9/11 had some impact on most of the west just because it was such a big event, but i doubt it was as much worldwide as it was here (and in the countries that got invaded, i suppose). that got me on this train of thought: assuming the concept of generations (or at least some of the ways they manifest that are a bit more objective, like people having different attitudes) exists elsewhere, i wonder if other countries, especially non-western ones, have entirely different generational divides? for example, would an indonesian person divide a generation after the 2004 tsunami? or would an eastern european divide one by the fall of the berlin wall? just an interesting thought experiment

Sondra R

I showed my 12 year old son the first part of this video to see if he knew what you were talking about and to my amazement, he knew most of the words to Sticking Out Your Gyatt for the Rizzler and what they meant 🤔

Josh

A tangent on granola fascism would be fabulous

mado

next tangent: mental health and capitalism?

Tanner Gore

Lol the “heroic generation” sounds like some jordan peepeeson shit for real 😭

Chantal Sorrentino

I refuse to believe Gen Alpha exists. Gen Z is the kids of Millenials. Gen Z isn't really old enough to be having kids yet. Little kids should be still Gen Z. Millenials have like a wide range of ages, but still are millenial. Same should be with Gen Z

Jo Quigley

I watched the Mary Poppins sequel with my son recently which weirdly reflected this video in interesting ways. It takes place when the Banks kids from the original movie are grown up. The son is messy and still bit of a kid, struggling to take care of his house after his wife died. The daughter has basically become a third wave feminist, who lives on the poor side of London as a single lady and fighting for workers’ rights. The Banks kids are also dealing with the Great Depression. But Michael Banks’s kids are the complete inverse of their father from the first movie. Because their mom died and their father’s such a mess, they take pride in taking care of themselves. Long story short: Mary Poppins Returns is a millennial sequel for a boomer movie.

Raoul (just me)

PLEASE elaborate on granola fascism 😄

Opinionated Online

Yes, and it ignores what the US was doing across the globe through its foreign policy in the decades leading up to the that time and during the 1990s.

Opinionated Online

If anyone is interested in a really fascinating book on generations, I would recommend Generation Gap by Kevin Munger or Generation Gap: Why the Baby Boomers Still Dominate American Politics and Culture. I haven't read it yet, but it's one book I want to read soon, and I've listened to all of the interviews with the author about it that I could find. It's not just a hating on the Boomers or "Why Boomers All Suck" kind of book. But, it does lay out that, yes, Baby Boomers have had an outsized influence on the US throughout all their life. In politics and business, they got involved early and are, in many cases, leaving late. It's also about the influences that have made Baby Boomers a very unique generation. As someone with Baby Boomer parents, it's easy to often be very frustrated with Baby Boomers, but learning some of the concepts from the book has helped me have more empathy to try to understand all the events and trends that made Baby Boomers who they are as a whole (not that all Baby Boomers are the same).

demolitionwoman

Really enjoyed this one, thank you! Kept thinking about that Utah Phillips story (Bridges on the album The Past Didn’t Go Anywhere) where he says “….that whole idea of decade packages. Things don’t happen that way… No, that, that packaging of time is a journalistic convenience that they use to trivialize and to dismiss important events and important ideas. I defy that.” I’m also now thinking a lot about what you said about Gen Z conceptualizing themselves as adults earlier and how/if that’s a factor in how often I see people under 24 in kink communities identifying as littles/engaging in non-sexual age play.

Chloe

Honestly the most interesting tangent yet. Really made me think (especially in regards to how I've assumed linear time/history is the only way to view history, and how there's some magical point in the future, like a utopia, that we're heading towards. Never thought of it in any other kinda way before). Thanks for uploading!

Teageen

There's a study that I can't link to unfortunately bc I can't remember what it was exactly, but it showed that well being increased until about a 70k$ annual income for a family (probably was at least 10 years ago that the study was done, so the money is different from inflation). But after ~70k$ it plateaued. I think my friends that are unfortunately still in food insecurity due to a low income from unstable minimum wage jobs would have much better mental health if they didn't have to worry about picking between eating and paying rent

Teageen

What a 💯🔥 comment, so well written

For Autumn

Wonderfully insightful! I've been having an ick about gen z vs millenial content, but I could never quite pinpoint the source of my misgivings. (I work in marketing, so this has been a major issue, because I just refused to engage with this type of categorisation. :D) Thank you so much for this video, I have a lot to think about!

WaitforRain

Important question: How does Richard Dawkins little jar of honey fit into gen discourse?

ibi

haven't started this yet but just wanted to say that skibidi toilet is rly good - it's comedic of course but I also understand why people get sucked into the lore

phastinemoon

Just a sidenote -- I've NEVER heard of 4 being a 'feminine' number and 3 being a 'masculine' number. If anything, doesn't 3 have more femme connotations, because we associate it with the moon, and witchcraft, and menstruation?

JackWhoWanders

As a sidenote to that sidenote, I just want to ask why there's necessarily four seasons since that's not the norm everywhere. Some places have fewer seasons, some have more. Its not universal.

Catharine

re: "don't trust anyone over 30" Tim Leary was born in 1920!

Folks,,

Two thoughts (haven't finished the video yet but love this one and feel compelled to comment now!) 1. Re: the crisis --- I agree with everything you say, but to me the biggest crisis indicator (I might even add "by far") is school shootings. Sandy Hook was the tipping point, obviously. The psychopathic social acceptance of children being murdered for no reason other than "I want gun" is, to my mind, the starkest departure from how American society was conceptualized up until this point. Talk about social trust. 2. I was born in 1989 to economically secure parents (mid-level lawyers) and I was told to do what I love and follow my passions. Majored in English and Medieval Studies and tried my damnedest to be a writer after being told by basically every adult in my life that I was excellent at writing. Now I'm a software engineer and champing at the bit to tell my own son that he can do what he loves as long as he's getting straight A's in math as well.

Folks,,

I mean yeah homie, this is true

Folks,,

Yeah, this reminds me of a great DFW quote (naturally I can't remember it) about how reading poetry and learning definitions of ennui doesn't magically create problems in people; it allows people to name and categorize immortal problems (and hopefully get better at dealing with it)

Kelsey Davis

Frankly, it’s disappointing to hear you say that mental health is a poor lens for leftist analysis on the basis that your personal experience as someone who grew up admittedly wealthy (going to music school says a lot) is that your mental health hasn’t improved since accruing more wealth. I don’t think someone who has gone from upper middle class to upper upper middle class could grasp the impact of growing up on an empty stomach, the threat of homelessness, the forms of violence that poverty exposes you to, the chronic instability, the feeling that you shouldn’t allow yourself to hope or dream because those are activities for the bright, shiny children, or the knowledge that you truly have no safety net no matter what goes wrong. Current research on the social determinants of health shows there is no greater determinant of mental health than income, and homelessness is a form of torture (characterized by chronic sleep deprivation, freezing temperatures, starvation and societal alienation and abuse) that quite literally drives people into psychosis. You said that millennials couldn’t grasp the realities of trench warfare and therefore it’s silly to proclaim that they have the “worst mental health ever” - I wholeheartedly agree - however, wealthy people cannot grasp the mental burden of poverty in a similar way. Moreover, the fact that millennials continue to be so miserable despite not experiencing traumatic events comparable to conscription - by all accounts things are pretty cushy nowadays and people should be happier - says a lot about alienation and anomie, which, in my opinion, needs to be considered at least partially through theorists such as Marx and Durkheim.

Folks,,

Oh one last thing -- imo bit of a misreading of "we're the unluckiest generation!" because I think the meaning is "we're the unluckiest generation still alive" which...I mean, I'd say that's broadly correct at least in terms of financial outcomes, which in turn is probably the most important single "indicator" of generational wellbeing.

Folks,,

Yeah my mental health and the mental health of my millennial friends fucking skyrocketed with my income when switched careers in my mid-20s. Contra maybe didn't see the same correlation because her income increase came at the cost of being famous, which is like mental health poison.

Sunbeam

Thanks for this! Personally, I don't mind the rougher editing; these Tangents have a more cozy, relaxed feeling than the main-channel videos, and I like the contrast. I'm one of those people in-between Millennials and Gen Z and yeah, I've never felt in either camp. Really nice video, it's funny how age is such a central yet nebulous part of our identities. I partially agree with the ambivalence on using mental health as a leftist starting point, although that part was pretty clearly an aside in this video. On the one hand, I actually do think there are situations where having mental health as a basis for leftist politics is useful, especially with things like poverty, because so much indifference is based on ignoring suffering that isn't physically visible. On the other hand, I personally greatly dislike it when used for something like homelessness, because the situation is so dire that a person that would be convinced by the basically sound arguments would likely already support the homeless politically, so the conversation frays into how homelessness causes x, or how the solution to x is politics. And while one can say there's a positive correlation, there's no way to tell whether politics will help any specific case. To me, it feels cynical, like giving false hope, to claim to stand for a group, but dismiss personal solutions, because sometimes they really are what a person needs. Sorry for the long tangent :).

Matt W

The lady Gaga clip isn’t nonsense lyricism. She’s just singing the first 1.5 syllables of “Romance” (I.e., “Roma”)

Enname

Or my 80 year old mother when someone else is driving.

Enname

As someone born in 81 not in the US, I don't really fit well into any group - gen X was the cool group above me, millennials the cool group below me. I find it depends on who I am talking to and what they want from me or project onto me. Which fits with my understanding of this as a historian (who focuses on story telling as ethics) and the way in which personal and societal story telling works, as well as memory and culture. Mostly though, I enjoy getting to look back over me and my understanding of recent history and realising 'oh, wow, did not see this pov at the time!' and being able to grow from that. Re: mental health. Unless Marxism can fix my brain's inability to process progesterone, pretty sure removing capitalism won't help much.

Brooke Austin

Ohhhh, atomization. A great concept. Maybe it can veer towards suburbanization and car-centric society leading to the eradication of third places and like, people getting all lonely and such. The concept of “the man cave” or a “gym room” in your house is just symptomatic of *some* people having excessive wealth but ultimately few friends and few common spaces to socialize and build real communities.

Brooke Austin

Also that Americans are uniquely insulated from a catastrophe largely of our own making. The person working those cacao fields (PSA: often illegal child labor) are the ones who are at risk of dying of starvation or wars of resource scarcity. Millennial pearl-clutching about the price of olive oil at the grocery store was exactly the point of her comment.

Brooke Austin

Polyamory groups with strong consent culture can reduce many of the negative aspects of shorter term, mostly-physical relationships. Also cuddle parties.

Brooke Austin

“Stop being happier than me!” -Reactionaries

HughJaneous

In regards to the Marxism stuff towards the end of the video, I don't really think that its fair to say that many Marxists don't act as though the 20th century never happened. Marxism has continued to be theorized even past the capitalist restoration in China and the collapse of the USSR. I would argue that Maoism is one of the modern sects that actively tries to grapple with the events of the 20th century, especially with the concept of cultural revolution being an answer to the continuation of class antagonisms under socialism. I agree that I think a lot of Marxists do tend to fall into a bit of a trap by conceiving of communism as the end of history, and conceiving of it as inevitable, but I'd also argue that most activists would say that its inevitability doesn't imply inaction. I personally think some things from the cyclical view of history fit nicely with the Marxist understanding of the progression of history. Contradictions sharpen and dull at various points throughout any period of history, but the error is putting a generalized time-frame on it. For the failure of movements pushing for socialism in the past decade. I would argue that they are in their infantile stages, and that the US has failed to have any meaningful socialist movement because of remaining cold-war institutional and cultural inoculation against ant-capitalism. Because of that inoculation, not only are American "socialists" largely ignorant of the developments of the past century as you pointed towards, but they are also ignorant of methods of effectively organizing in times of crisis. I think this is being mitigated somewhat in the aftermath of 2020, and even before 2020 I think there has been an increase in thought towards this stuff since Occupy. So, in other words, the US socialist movement is having to re-invent and re-discover the wheel.

Sappho's Friend

i think she mentioned it in her earlier vids at least once. not sure

Sappho's Friend

For me as a person from ex Yugoslavia (born 2000), this discourse feels pretty alien. I was a tween when i first learned of 9/11, and i found all the generation based sureddits aggressively americentric and gratuitously tribalistic. It was a hostile experience to visit these spaces, i was like tf is this. But beyond my relatively unllustrative example, people who grew up in the 90s in my region grew up during the war, as genocides were raging in their neighbourhood. Meanwhile americans were swimming in endless comfort and consumerism of the american 90s. This is where an example of an extreme disconnect occurs. overall, obviously i feel tentatively closer to someone born in 1996, than someone born in 2009, despite how we are arbitrarily categorised. But, as an autistic woman, i have always had a tendency to befriend people much older than me, so even this loses relevance, it all feels so arbitrary, and i think we should all feel much closer and less tribalistic based on these made up categories, especially in light of the political fight we need to continue. when it comes to musical scenes that are making a comeback, i must note that what i see is a simultaneous return to the 2000s in the mainstream (including the pro ana discourse...) and a return to the 80s in the rise of dark wave/post punk and EBM music. I believe this rise of dark wave music tracks the "new cold war" era we are in

Sappho's Friend

I found your comment on marxism and mental health flawed, because it relies pretty much on a strawman, despite agreeing with your ultimate conclusion that socialism (or whatever) won't end suffering and that this is an almost religious utopian idea. Much like with patriarchy not ultimately benefitting men in absolute terms (despite a common strawman of feminism being "patriarchy is when men have it great"), the marxist argument about mental health is not that wealth under capitalism leads to mental wellbeing, so we should try to make everyone affluent to replicate that. The argument is that the capitalist system itself harms everyone, even the ones on top, who supress their guilt about systemically exploiting others, having a high environmental impact or whatever else.

RmhWork.

I thought mentioning avocados and millennials would be enough to make the comment ironic, but obviously it wasn't. I'm European and don't see how Americans are protected from climate disasters. California droughts? Florida flooding? Also, I suppose you meant North Americans, because, for example, the entire Amazon, clearly the most obvious example, is in crisis, on the verge of collapse. In Europe, among leftist groups, it's widely assumed that millennials will face and suffer from the consequences of climate crisis, both physically and ethically. I can recommend two good reads on this topic: 'How to Blow a Pipeline' by Andreas Malm and 'If We Burn' by Vincent Bevins, an American author who also wrote another really good book called 'The Jakarta Method'

James

This is amazing. Your thinking reminds me of some recent books that tie the unipolar ‘end of history’ moment (and the overconfidence it produced in neoliberalism) to many current issues in democratic politics: Millennial childhood occurs during a transition to digital technology - producing young adults who are incentivised to enter higher education - financial crash happens producing an educated electorate of gig workers unable to put down the sort of roots necessary to really achieve political influence - boomers dictate the political agenda meanwhile the next generation reacts to the new economic conditions and their political beliefs shift accordingly. Everything you touch on feels like a microcosm of this larger trend. How do you put it in the Twilight video? Epicycles around a larger cycle?

Hoshino Radio

I don't suppose you've read George Orwell's "Wells, Hitler and the World State"? He discusses several of the ideas you talk about in this Tangent, like the reactivity of generations, the cyclical nature of history, and the flaws in the idea of a Socialist utopia that will be the end of history. https://orwell.ru/library/reviews/wells/english/e_whws

ContraPoints

Yes! Completely agree with this analysis of the boomer/millennial/z dynamic

ContraPoints

yeah I’m sure there’s a plausible version of the argument that capitalism is bad for mental health in certain distinctive ways.

Mair Perkins

I thought the climate crisis was downplayed too. There are people of all generations including millennials who are suffering from it right now in the USA. Wealthy people will be able to insulate themselves from the impacts of the climate crisis but the poorest and most marginalised are already suffering and dying from climate breakdown in the USA. Low paid agricultural workers are getting kidney disease or dying from working outside in extreme heat. Homeless people suffer similarly from extreme heat too. The poorest can’t afford to get out of town for a hurricane or to repair their homes after. Poor people can’t afford air conditioning in heat. Rich people can protect themselves from the smoke from forest fires more. The climate crisis is also a factor in rising food costs - crop yields are being negatively impacted by extreme weather.

Mair Perkins

Really interesting, insightful and entertaining. I was wondering throughout if the climate and ecological crisis and the strong likelihood of the collapse of civilisation would be mentioned. Or maybe a mention of the cycles of Earths epochs and mass extinction events. I know it’s super depressing but I’ve read a fair bit about the collapse of human societies. It is extremely likely that millennials and younger generations, including in global north countries, will experience social collapse in our lifetimes. While not everyone in a generation is going to be aware of or accept the evidence for this, it is something I thought would be worth exploring as an impact of generational psyches. I thought the climate crisis was wrongly downplayed when it was mentioned. There are people of all generations including millennials who are suffering from it right now in the USA. Wealthy people will be able to insulate themselves from the impacts of the climate crisis but the poorest and most marginalised are already suffering and dying from climate breakdown in the USA. Low paid agricultural workers are getting kidney disease or dying from working outside in extreme heat. Homeless people suffer similarly from extreme heat too. The poorest can’t afford to get out of town for a hurricane or to repair their homes after. Poor people can’t afford air conditioning in heat. Rich people can protect themselves from the smoke from forest fires more. The climate crisis is also a factor in rising food costs - crop yields are being negatively impacted by extreme weather. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/aug/06/jef-goodell-heatwaves-racism-the-heat-will-kill-you-first-book

dysgregulated

Same, I got into tech at just the right time and went from making less than 30k/year to 120k/year with a single job change (and have since increased that by quite a bit), and it changed my life so much that I have a very hard time even thinking back to the hardship of choosing to pay rent or buy dinner. I now have much more than I need and have phenomenonally better mental and physical health, far more capacity to volunteer (time and money), AND can actually experience leisure. I am not naive enough to say that leaving poverty is what made me this way, but it has enabled me to be my true self. Poverty must be ended, for good.

lily c

yea, this is a bit of my own ideas but i think natalie spoke from her own background a lot in this video, like when she was talking about how each generation hates on the next for their technology use and what’s new. like i do get that first it was television then computers and smartphones but a lot of the discourse i hear from gen z is actually worried about gen alpha and their smart phone usage because if we’re being honest, short form content is completely different and mentally damaging compared to just tv or smartphones. so yea gen z is already getting their taste of hating on the next gen, but i don’t think the concern is only due to generational divide reasons

lily c

thank you for vocalizing this bc i couldn’t find the words to do so! when she said that socialism won’t make mental health better no the socialism itself won’t inherently do so but the societal change and individual/collective lifestyles that change and emerge from that can drastically change mental health (in comparison to our car infrastructure and everything being 20x human scale, go america!)

lily c

i think that what she meant by the older generations lack of anxiety is that it’s not as tied to their identities in the same way young people have tied it to theirs in a way. like i know a LOT of old people with crippling anxiety and depression but for cultural stigma reasons they would never call it that, instead they just drink a bunch of beer and forget it exists. gen z, millennials, and few gen x’s on the cusp have grown up with or become accustomed to mental health talk so we recognize and accept it a lot more than the older generations do

Olivia Rollins

Yeah totally, that's basically what I was getting at—they don't recognize it as such. And it may well be something that was on Natalie's mind, but it's not a point that was actually made in the video, so I wanted to voice the fact that tons of older people do in fact have anxiety.

Luz

Yeah I think in Envy she mentions a younger sibling at one point.

KJ Xiao

Nearly choked lunch at work when the cringe millennial dissing gen Z vids appeared. So much so that I had to text my student's group to apologise about that. Those of us who are doomed to hear astrological cycles in areas near Buddha-land, the concept is usually prescribed as helical time. That yes, there are cycles, but the helix allows for linear progression too. So then truly horrific stuff do not necessarily have to repeat, and progress can happen. And yes, we had our angry orange and happy tree friends. I have always thought that my students are somewhat smarter than our own generation. Let people enjoy their silly bits.

Zindagigi

Cyclical theories of history is something I've long resisted. It always just seemed like simplistic 'one weird trick"-ism based on highly selective pattern-seeking. But this video actually has me changing my mind a little. I'm intrigued by the idea that such a cycle would be driven in part by generational effects: of course a generation that grew up in the middle of a "great" war would feel a certain way about the government, patriotism, education and art, etc., and their attitudes will influence the culture, providing a system of thinking that the next generation has to live with--and react to. I can see how, theoretically, anyway, it makes sense for there to be some kind of complicated pendulum effect. But of course it kind of depends on what the war is and how things shook out. But I see how it could be compatible with the cumulative reality of history--we know our past and also we live with the consequences of that past. So the cycle never really repeats.

James

I do agree with your critique that the cyclical paradigm is a bit close to astrology though. It’s very self aggrandising. I can think of a few novels set after the 1848 revolutions that capture it better - young people aren’t so much regarded as prophets but as too preoccupied with the failure of their elders and too secure in their ideals to notice the scary stuff coming next. If you decide to re-visit this topic or make another video about voting before the election I’d love to see you approach it using something like that.

Siiri Viljakka

Thank you, Natalie! This tangent was funny, helpful and informative. I am writing a scifi graphic novel set in quite far future and this gave me ideas on how to use the cyclical theory in the story. Awesome stuff!

MarmaladeSparrow

Gen Z aren't the kids of millenials though? Generations don't quite work like that. Most Millenials' parents are Boomers, most Gen Zs parents are Gen X-ers and most Gen alphas parents are Millenials.

Jack OD

Thanks for another very interesting tangent - I generally avoid all of the "generations" social media discourse, it always feels to me like overly online dorks tripping over each other to go viral by striking some chord in their generation's cultural consciousness. It is certainly a lot of "narcissism of small differences." What was a lot more interesting is all of the theories of history, and finding an empathetic way to see how different generations are shaped by their experience of history. And engaging with "cyclical" theories of history feels incredibly important to me right now, and resonates with the arc of my own political consciousness. I was born in '97, grew up in an affluent white liberal family - one of my first memories of a real political event was an election night party in '08 where everyone seemed excited about a new era in american politics. The narrative I had absorbed was pretty much that the cold war was over, history had ended, and we were in a long new era of prosperity, where we might even have a "post-racial" society. (I was 11, and didn't exactly have the tools to think critically about any of that.) It was pretty much linear history: we've made it, and now it's a long, slow, asymptotic ascent to everything being better for everyone. The first thing to really shock me out of this mindset was, well, Trump's election in 2016. And everywhere I've looked, and everything I've learned since then, has made me think things will get a lot *worse* before they get much *better*: the continuous gutting and gig-ification of the economy; skyrocketing cost of living pretty much everywhere; more and more billionaires shaping reality to their whims, with less and less shame about it; and yeah, climate change puts a pretty firm horizon on how far I can picture the future! I can picture myself in 2030 maybe, but 2040? What the hell will the world look like then? The best solutions the Democrats come up with seem much more like incremental tweaks to the status quo, rather than transformative change it seems like we need. In other words, in about a decade I went from picturing history as steady linear progress, to worrying that I'm living in the dying days of an empire. The possibility that we're on the down slope of cyclical history makes perfect sense to me, and probably for most of my generation - you gotta think the explosion of post-apocalyptic fiction in my lifetime has something to do with this.

David Naber

Wow, this was one of the best tangents yet! incredible work, as always queen

Sam

That was so fun. As a Pisces astrology fan I bought the Strauss-Howe theory too eagerly. Also the other most popular philosophy misunderstanding is that the categorical imperative means "X would be bad if everyone did X"

Pippa Russell

I’m glad you expressed skepticism about the generational “personality types” segment of this. It’s interesting, because I agree not all generations are the same, but I would think about it less as being cyclical and more as being kind of like evolution trees. Similar conditions can produce a similar generational character (like convergent evolution), but generational character is determined not by cycles but by what conditions exist at developmentally important times. Which is sort of the argument minus the disasters only happen every 80 years part, which seems silly and ahistorical imo

Simon_Dinosaur

TY for ruining Hagel for me Natalie. <3

Rachel Muir

I came for the catgirl. I stayed for the scholarship. Natalie, you have said that you left academe because the price of admittance was narrowing your interests to some minutia. I get that. But you excel at finding and cultivating the seeds of ideas sown over the vast (and often barren) plain of social media while simultaneously finding where they have touchpoints with classic philosophy. Rizzer move, I dare say. One note; modern evolutionary therory is heavily chaotic and has been for decades. The term seems misapplied in historiography; the science has moved on.

Audrey M

does anyone by chance take down a list of the books mentioned in the tangent? I am trying to find this one book that popped up on the screen for a second, but my detective work is failing me. thanks!!!

Almeno Gonçalves

Thank you for this video! I'm not sure I got all of it since I'm not a native english-speaker, it's easier for me to understand when there are subtitles embedded. I do not quite agree with the cyclical generation types, it might work if you only look for it but you'd have to ignore a lot of contrary data and it definitely doesn't work for Portugal where there was a dictatorship until 1974 that sort of 'flatened' out any possible kind of generational variety. About history as a whole, it seems to me that there is a lot more chaos than a sort of outside order, linear or cyclical. World War I was not even an actual world war as most of the planet was not involved, so I don't think it's reasonable to consider this as an universal crisis... It's like trying to fit a whole wardrobe into a small suitcase and not being able to: why not get a bigger suitcase instead of leaving clothes behind? If, however, there is such an order and we can figure it out, I'd prefer the metaphor of a spiral rather than the one of a cycle. In any case, what you say is wonderful, I always enjoy listening to you and thinking about it later!

lucidzen

Though I agree, I do think that if we ever reach the point where our all mental health issues rooted from our material conditions is eliminated, there will still be a lot of people struggling with mental health. Not only are we still Stuck with other humans, but new issues (hence what ContraPoints hinted at when she said somehow communism is assumed to not have any contradictions) will arise. And again, her ongoing theory is that history may repeat itself and capitalism will find a way to come back. Given the cycle of people’s behaviors with the generations, there will always be some psychological conflicts. I feel like I’m stating the obvious here and it’s not to your point but perhaps that’s where she was leaning more towards.

Eli

As someone whose early humor was shaped by weird Internet stuff my parents thought was completely inscrutable, I kinda get skibidi toilet

J L Herchenroeder

What's always felt off to me about the generational conversation is the disconnect to, let's be frank, the poors. I was born in the 80s and grew up POOR without parental support or help, and the very concept of a helicopter parent, or having trouble "adulting" is wild to me because there are so many of us that simply never had a choice but do it, or die trying. I get the anxiety though, it took me a lot of extra years to get through college and into a good career, and economic anxiety + no safety net is a real threat to health and happiness, but as much as I do like to watch cartoons I can't imagine calling out of work over it. I have cried in my car and gone back in with the best of 'em. I wonder if ignoring the outliers is a result of survivorship bias, the urge to tell a single cohesive narrative, a bias toward "mainstream" experience, or just trimming off the plot points.

Sappho's Friend

oh hello, i didnt expect a reply. Yes, i believe there is, i simply dont believe this is the best system we could have, i believe theres a lot of unnecessary suffering (plus various profitable quick dopamine hit addictive schemes) that we could alleviate with a better system (which would improve mental health). thanks for stopping by, and have a nice day.

Jenny Rodriguez

Loved the video, it doesn't quite apply to me being from Nicaragua born in 1990, but I did find your insights about the generations on a US perspective, I do disagree on your conclusion about socialism and mental health, but I think that stems from your own privileged background as you have explained.

Zacry Spears

Honestly you spilled with "it can be much worse" for millennials. I heavily support the idea that we are probably one of the luckiest generations in the history of modern human civilization in terms of material conditions. Oppression Olympics incoming... Extreme poverty in the US (among the poorest of the poor) does not even begin to compare to the material/physical/mental conditions of poverty in/on many foreign lands. (e.g public health, sanitation, infrastructure) And yes I would also like to know "what war"? I also want to add that even with the immense privileges of being a white-middle-class-American, major financial insecurity coupled with lack of community support is paralyzing and radically damaging to one's mental health. I'm not exactly sure that Socialism/Communism would solve this problem and I remain highly skeptical of these anachronistic, euro-centrically authored studies of systems of organized government. (Marx just stole his masterwork's thesis from the Iroquois but whatever pop off Marxists.) I didn't ask to be born and Norma McCorvey wasn't sacrificed at the altar for us to live in vain forcibly subject to credit scores and private equity.

jessamyn

Natalie, you really earned an award here for breaking down pop culture into academic intellectual language. At first, I thought maybe this was an April Fools post but no, it’s much better than that.

Rosie

Great video but the concept has already been explained to me by Abba in Waterloo

Aqua Burton

I would honestly love a tangent that is just dissecting the skibidi toilet lore

CyanideCrystal

I actually love skibidi toilet memes and the new slang and I really despise the instant hatred for the new generations by the previous ones. We had the asdf movie and Charlie the Unicorn, millennials and gen Z loved random humor but suddenly they're above it all? Nah.

CrystalJade

Late to the party…. How Gen X of me! Very interesting tangent. Only here will you see a discussion of the shape of time! I like the concepts - the possibility that shared experiences at stages in life have some sort of group relevance. I agree though it’s not something that can be universalised to the individual. Similar problems arise in theories made about things like birth order effects on personality between siblings - they make some intuitive sense, but social reality depends on so many things. It’s really great to see you on my screen again - always such a pleasure!

artificialladybug

This video helped me connect some things I've been thinking about for awhile. Sorry for the long comment Humans cannot be as carefree about sex as bonobos because of our biology. Pregnancy and childbirth is much harder on the human body than other mammals, and our childcare is very intensive taking many years of basic survival care as well as education. I think that this causes an innate anxiety about sex in individuals and in our culture. We’re always creating regulations and taboos, the concept of marriage with its many rituals. Gen z aren’t having sex for a lot of reasons. It has become economically risky to have children, not a very good investment like it used to be (and in some places still is and we see higher birth rates there). I think that the pandemic has caused both sex to go down and socializing in general. We have better sex education, busier schedules, and access to more pornography and sex toys than ever before. (Something I find interesting is that there seems to be an increase of sexual nonsexual relationships. Best friends or strangers doing roleplay. Nsfw artists and their friends or followers. Not only do we have totally new types of sex work, but look at any fandom on twitter and you will see friends basically sexting each other using fictional characters. We were told to practice safer sex and I guess that’s what we’re doing.) The increase of sex in the sixties can be explained in a similar way: decrease in child mortality, birth control, good economy. Overall I think this is great! The loss of patriarchal and religious power really shows us that we don’t actually need this top down regulation of sex. Giving agency back to women has very positive outcomes. I think it’s really cool how sensitive humans are to these types of changes. We are good at self-regulation and cultural norms shift to accommodate changing realities. People are having a panic about the loneliness epidemic right now, but I think that this period of social distancing is both rational and temporary.

artificialladybug

I don't understand. How can someone associate themselves with Mao Ze Dong's name while accounting for the failures that happened in the 20th century. That seems contradictory.

HughJaneous

Well to clarify, being a Maoist is less about holding up the cult of personality of Mao, and more about recognizing the contributions of the Chinese revolution to the field of Marxism (similar to how Leninism is more about recognizing the contributions of the Russian revolution than a dogmatic reverence for Lenin). The most significant contributions of the Chinese revolution are typically recognized as being 1) the development of the concept of the mass line, which aims to keep the party accountable to the people 2) the importance of the cultural revolution to handling class antagonisms that continue and intensify during the era of socialist construction. All of these are responses to issues of socialist construction that occurred in the USSR which eventually led to revisionism and collapse. The development of these ideas occurred in part due to the failure of things like the Great Leap Forward which was heavily influenced by soviet methods of industrial progress which didn’t suit the material conditions of china. Ultimately, as far as the cultural revolution is concerned, I think it was ultimately proven right given that capitalism was restored in china immediately after Mao died and it ended. I should add that the cultural revolution is a more complex situation than the disorganized and often chaotic events that happened at the beginning, and the later years were characterized by the building up of more Democratic forms of government in workplaces and local towns and villages, as well as a push to keep party members accountable

HughJaneous

1Dime actually has some pretty good videos on the cultural revolution that I found super helpful to understanding it

Mathew

Maybe it's just anecdotal on my part, but I'm Gen Z (by some metrics) and lots of my friends are having sex and doing drugs. I'm not personally, but I have always been sort of an outlier in my experience. Anyway, great video! You really articulated a lot of my thoughts and feelings about the generation discourse. Especially how the divisions are not clear cut. I still have my almanac from the late 2000s stating that Millennials (or Generation Y as they were called) were born 1980-2000 and Gen Z is 2000 and onward, and the year slowly moved further and further backward until 2018, when people started talking about Gen Z activism and the year became very solidified in the public as sometime in the mid-1990s. Also, I'm old enough to remember back in 2015 when it was "politically correct millennials" who were the target of public ire, vs. the "woke Gen Z cancel culture fiends" that gets propagated today. And to relate to your point about how you're not convinced these generations are that different, I can sort of agree with that. Because 2015 was not that long ago. It doesn't even feel different this time. Jonathan Haidt even has a book out. I haven't read it, but it seems like while he's using new arguments and making new suggestions the "young people" he chooses as his subject aren't much different than those he wrote about in his "Coddling of the American Mind" article in 2015 (that in my opinion started started the whole "these kids are too PC/woke/fragile these days!" fervor).

Mathew

It seriously reminds me of 2012 YouTube

Keegan Deathman (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-14 12:00 People keep telling me Gen Z is having less sex and I find it hard to believe because of how much and how hard I fuck
2024-04-12 02:23

Sappho's Friend

i can try to do it for you. Essentially the right wing uses hippie aesthetics and wellness/healthy living and self help to funnel people into QAnon and as a result, fascism. Mainly through conspiracist strands of New Age beliefs (which originally split from the hippie movement) JP Sears is a famous example of a far right hippie. So you'll have various channels and creators that start with "healthy living" (generally with a high amount of fad diet pushing), and gradually take you over to spiritualistic and ruralistic fascism definitely look up New Age conspirituality.

M

I also think some of the impetus to create the generational discourse we see in media comes from the fact that pitting us against each other in as many ways as possible is a good way to prevent solidarity between generations that can lead to social change. The generational discourse, when it focuses on our differences in a negative way, is helpful for divide-and-conquering us. The more mutually-distrustful categories we can be divided into, the less able we are to work together. A millennial who generalizes all people from the boomer generation a certain way can't build movement solidarity with the people in the boomer generation who want the same things they do. While there can be shared experiences and common threads, every generation has lots of different kinds of people, and the more people from any one generation resent people from any other generation by default, the less likely we'll be able to work together effectively enough to make things better for anyone.

Opinionated Online

That's what I think about the incessant generational click-bait, which I regret to say I have given it to at times. It feels like it's gotten especially bad in the last year or two.

Buddha

I'm a history professor who structures narratives around cyclical processes. :) The problem is that recent history does not conform to the same pendulum shifts as in the past, making me question my approach. But linear models are always nonsensical.

jessamyn

Yes, please!

jessamyn

Mind reader!

Opinionated Online

Apparently, "Ohio" means something like "weird" or "crazy" to small children today. Kind of like how "Florida" can mean "weird" or "crazy" to the rest of us as in the case of "Florida Man" (or sometimes "Florida Woman").

Ty P

Surprisingly generations have little meaning in social science. Especially in quantitative research. The whole scientific framework that Natalie presents sounds like nonsense to me. Obviously it cannot work for other countries but it more or less assumes a constant repeat of a certain muster which has to go along with important historical events. History does not work like that. Societies do not work like that.

Jen Fehsenfeld

Just wanted to say that I love your new (to me :-) Tangents series. It reminds me of a lot of your older content - less formal, but no less engaging and insightful. Don’t get me wrong, I still love your main content too. I don’t know what the answer regarding whether to make these available to non Patreon is, but again, I really love that you’re making them.

Mick A

Just wait until you're 30 and decide to stop using condoms. It gets even better and to be honest, more frequent.

Maxwell Douglas Kinghorn

I just saw someone post a video of Mongol Toilet in discord today, and it sounded pretty cool. It will be interesting to see how gen alpha's meme culture evolves. Also the whole generations repeating stuff sounded like complete bs to me. It just doesn't feel like it works like that. As Natalie said, it's basically the same as horoscopes.

Katherine Jannakos

Love this tangent! I just wanted to jump in and offer that in Orthodox Christianity we have two conceptions of time. One being "Chronos" or linear time (days, years, etc.) and the other being "Kairos" or "God's time". This is considered to be outside of Chronos (before a church service the clergy pray for God to essentially "suspend time" to enter into Kairos). This includes the Liturgical Calendar, which both cyclical and eternal. Thus events like the Crucifixion and Resurrection are both historical "Chronos" events (to us) and events outside time that we participate in and experience through the Liturgical calendar united with all Christians, everywhere and anywhere, inside the realm of "Kairos." This is a gross simplification of a very complicated idea (theologians are gnashing their teeth at me as we speak), but also shouldn't be thought of in absolutist or legalistic terms. A big part of Eastern Orthodoxy is the acceptance of things that are essentially mysterious and defy human understanding. Hope this made a little sense, regardless!

Zachary Pareizs

Horrifying to reveal this, but as a high school teacher, the youths actually are having lots of sex and doing lots of drugs. And many of them are doing them at school.

Ayjayy

As an early 00s baby, I am proudly gen z. I never heard of early 00s say that they are millennial.

carmen

im gen z firmly and i love my gen though we r way too self serious. i had many millennial influences growing up so i actually tend to love millennials. those were the cool big kids to me. anyway shouts out my fellow gen z who actually were doing drugs and fucking. we are rare but we are here!

Lasha Bezhashvili

Guys, I know this is very not relevant to this post but pleaseeee read this. So, I'm writing from Georgia (the country!) and our government recently initiated a bill that bans transgender people, no matter their age, from accessing any sort of gender-affirming surgery (they're introducing lots of other horrible things but including this one). I don't know what I can do to stop this but one thing I have as an idea is making University of Pennsylvania issue a statement against Georgia's new anti-transgender bill. The reason I'm targeting UPenn is because I know the son of one of the politicians initiating this bill is studying there and they (meaning our virulently anti-LGBT politicians) do definitely care when prestigious American universities make a stand. Anyone here who has any sort of connection to that university?

Lasha Bezhashvili

Btw the guy who created the skibidi toilet series made them here in Tbilisi (Georgia's capital) so Georgia matters!!!

Squash fei

One of my parents went there, but they're not affiliated... if a petition was started, I bet I could get him to sign it tho

Jaclyn Yocom

I'm gen z and 75% of everyone my age does lots of drugs and has lots of sex. The rest are too scared to leave the house and have a much more online presence.

a. j. archer

that cherubic child's voice singing about brain-melting internet bullshit activates my maternal instinct like nothing before

Lasha Bezhashvili

Hey! Thank you so much for replying! Do you know if they are in some sort of alumni Facebook group or email group? I could make a statement and they could send it out. Would that be too much of a problem?

Sondra R

Yes, amazing doc!

Ann C

Like all of us, Natalie has areas of specific interest that spark her creative energy, and we all love it when she's sparkling. We have no idea what she does in her private life, such as supporting charities and writing to her senators and representatives, something we all should do to be sure our views are getting through.

Rachel Burns

time cube guy was on to something

Torval Pecker

I just heard the song "Ecstacy (Super slowed)" by Suicide-Idol, and INSTANTLY recognised it as the tune for the Skibidi song, had me wondering how many other people were thinking "sticking out your gyatt for the rizzerler" at the mall today

Bob Appleyard

having studied history at university i don't think it has a shape as such, but maybe different parts of it can be assigned shapes. there are certainly cycles embedded in there. straightforwardly, each year is a cycle. the theory of generations you share is weird, but there is something there! however, it is still the case that life is materially different today than 200 years ago, if only due to the existence of vaccines and clean running water. stuff like that is historically relevant. that doesn't need to imply some kind of whig/hegelian/marxist arrow to history. but there have been long-term developments that are not simply cycles, as well.

Bob Appleyard

oooh! on the concept of "history has a shape" there was a school of history called the annales school. they conceived of history as a river! worth checking out!

L

love things like this that challenge my ("younger" millennial) perspective. the point about linear vs cyclical views of time really resonated. i often fall into the trap(?) of looking at my little digital calendar and thinking of time as linear. but it feels freeing to think about how, in a similar way that individual feelings are rarely "new," collective experiences aren't either. like every generation is just trying to deal with whatever thing they have to when their time comes. idk i'm sleepy. anywayyyy great tangent as always. i love this patreon and channel <3

cealesti

Great tangent all in all, but I especially resonated with the idea that the current conceptualization of generations is incredibly usamerican-centric. My parents, for example, are generationally boomers on the cusp of Gen X, but they spent their formative childhood years living under a far-right dictatorship that shaped them a lot, followed by a successful military coup and the consequent instability. While they certainly lived with material conditions more associated with Boomers later in life, their generational experience necessarily differs from American Boomers, right, both in terms of political events but also access to wealth and their family history.

Jaco

Identifying my generation with the PS2 is less US-centric than defining it with 911

Yei

Sorry this is late (only just got round to the tangent), but I feel that I also have to point out that it is not a calendar either. It has calendrical symbols, but no actual dates. Instead, the sun stone is an imperial funded art piece designed to depict the unity of time and the heavens under Aztec (well, Mexica to be precise) control. In other words, its propaganda. Actual Aztec calendars were actually very similar to ours, in that they were depicted in grids.

C.LiGS

I would like to speak to whomever decided on using FIVE colors to cycle through the FOUR archetypes in Strauss-Howe generation flowchart. was the additional slightly paler green worth the built in off-by-one error? "diagram readability is my passion <3" and they didnt even make any of them pink >:(

Evan Deo

Another way to distinguish between generations could be around developmental milestones and how you socialize with your peers. A US-centric version could look like this: For Boomers/Gen-X Did your peers or their older siblings serve in Vietnam? Did you and your friends play video games growing up? For Gen-X/Millennials How old were you when you bought your first house? Where did you meet your first serious adult partner (work/bar/friends vs online)? For Millennials/Gen-Z Did you and your peers get drivers licenses as soon as possible? Did you spend a lot of unstructured & unsupervised free time with friends outside of school/home? I can totally see Gen Alpha rebelling against the insane college app rat race and helicopter parents to reclaim free-spirited independence as a hallmark of youth.

Andrew Hanson

If we're living through the 90's again you young-us about to suffer through boy-bands and popper-pants. I feel so sorry for you; we thought you'd been spared. Although does k-pop count as a boy/girl-band era?

Duck

aw shoot I just realized that the skibidi toilet guy is a pun because he's "scatting" in a toilet

juliette

Just watched this, these are ideas I think about a lot. I think when it comes to critiques of linear frameworks of time and of a linear progression towards progress and freedom, Black feminists for example have a lot of rich theory. Saidiya Hartman's "Scenes of Subjection", for example, explains how the glorification of historical events like Emancipation reinforces the neoliberal notion of a history that always tends towards progress, but hides the lasting structures of racism. The racism does not disappear but shape-shifts, through cyclical movements. And interlaced with that, the same dynamics happen with the shape-shifting nature of sexism (ex, new ways of policing femininity). When you talk about the plausible causes of cyclical history, in my mind there's certainly something with power structures and politics themselves that kind of... keep finding ways to change form, but remain? And each generation having to grapple with that in different ways.

Kristina

As a mother of a nine-year-old, I'd like to mention, Captain Underpants is still very much a thing that is read.

Zindagigi

Oh my god, the fucking shade at Thoreau just kills me!

Drew Franzblau

Ok but what does “give me your Ohio” mean?

Pikaia Glass

I presume it means "give me your everything/all your power," as in the "Wait, it's all Ohio? Always has been" meme portraying Ohio as an enormous, powerful globe-spanning force.

Minivet

If my generation had had YouTube we would have been rapt by animated version of the shooting-Barney playground song.

Eliza

mix-sir-lot-dian sounded so much like mixolydian at first lol

Drew Franzblau

Give me your ohio... for this wet ass p-word

estesicoro

i think you'd like wb yeats' "Shape of Time" theory. it's very similar to a cyclical shape but with the distinction that these are two connected spirals that widen and shrink as we move through time. for him times was not a circle, but shrinking and widening gyres. i think this sort of reconciliates the linear idea (of progress within liberal democracy), while maintaining the idea of repeating patterns as the gyres shrink and widen.

David DeBoe

I'd be very curious to hear Black sociologists' take on these ideas (generational identities and the shape of history).

Hanna Lemon

Rly tempted to refute the entire concept of generations, not just their progression and/or cycling now as horoscopes.

Alex Moody

Ahh I forgot about this one! Yay, more tangents for mee

Femininja

I love your videos 🩷 I always thought that the whole "generations" thing is very stupid, but I love to hear you talking about it and analysing it this deep. I would like to hear more things that aren't this related to USA. The experience in other parts of the world is not remotely similar to the USA (there are millennials in wars right now. And gen z and alpha and etc.). Also, as a not-US-american, I have to say that the rest of the world already knows that socialism is impossible in the USA xd

CyanideCrystal

I wanted to bring up the inverse of the "zoomer cuspers who insist they're millenials". Nowadays, especially on tiktok there's been an influx of zoomer cuspers who insist they're zoomers and not old/millenials, trying to hold onto their youthful interests/communities when it feels like everyone is younger then them and they are insecure about it. I've been that person before as an "older zoomer".

Wendy Thomas

Thanks for mentioning the return of underground rave scene, tehehe. As long as we keep Musk out of berghain... ;D)

Sara

True. I was born in '97, making me amongst the oldest of Gen Z's... recently had a younger Gen Z "reassure" me that I "still counted as Gen Z," whereas Millennials are quick to roll their eyes when I talk about feeling distant and alienated from the rest of my cohort. Can I just call myself a Zillennial in peace and call it a day?

CassieWasRight

Now that Gen Alpha is creating culture, I think the moment is right to finally recognize that Gen Z and Millennials are actually the same generation - a young millennial has as much in common culturally with a young gen Z as with an older millennial. We never were separate and now we can finally accept our siblingship with minimal fuss

Ordinary Snowflake

So late to this party but that dichotomy of linear vs cyclical time is something I think a lot about. I spent a lot of time around neopagans and counter to the mainstream tendency you describe of preferring linear time they tend to be really obsessed with cycles, especially seasonal holidays (like the Spring rebirth you mention). As a Marxist though I find myself drawn less to a pure linear interpretation and more towards a dialectical relationship between the two. I heard one dialectical materialist (I think Bertell Ollman) describe the correct, DM take on time to be less a cycle or a line, but a spiral. Where crises and tendencies repeat but intensify over time. I suppose the derivate of that spiral is basically just another line depending on how you slice it but it feels more accurate than either/or to me.

amesville

GenX, again, just sits back and watches. (We’re so small, we can’t even make a ripple.)

Anne

Watching this for the third time. Genius!

Rynn

The connection to Marx as a form of progressive history is interesting in that Marxism as understood by most people, including Marxists themselves, is indeed seen as a theory of linear progress. However, research into Marx's writings after publishing Capital indicates he became more open to a cyclical understanding of time. Marx got really into the natural sciences, or what he called the natural metabolism, after Capital. He basically adopted what we would call degrowth communism today as he realized that the levels of resource extraction under capitalism could not be sustained in a communist future due to the limits of the natural metabolism. He spent a lot of time looking at nutrient depletion in agricultural soils for example. For Marx, this represents a pretty significant break in his understanding of time in my opinion. He incorporated respecting the natural metabolic cycle(s) into his thinking to the point that communism could not be inevitable out of capitalism, that the ever increasing levels of production and technological advancement could not be sustained because natural cyclical processes and the inherent limitations of existing on a planet with limited resources means the line can't keep going up forever. I'm not saying Marx rejected a linear view of history wholesale, but late Marx was not nearly as tethered to this understanding of history as young Marx. Slow Down by Kohei Saito was very illuminating on this topic.

Chloe

I’m a gen-zer and I’m skeptical that the decrease in sex and drugs is quite as stark as people think it is. I mean I’m not saying it hasn’t lessened but being a college student there’s a lot of sex and drugs going on

Connor Gibson

as a fellow collegiate gen z sex-haver & drug-doer, i agree with Chloe lmao

Vinni

Re: Connor and Chloe's comments! I'm also skeptical of an actual decrease in de facto decadence, but I do think that the trending generational voices may now be utilizing anti-decadent values for their own rhetorical means. That would be in stark contrast to the rhetorical emphasis on freedom of sexual expression that we've been accustomed to in the millennial media sphere.

Elizabeth

All this talk about generations and not one mention of juvenoia. Just a vague sense of it lurking in the background.

mink

"I used to be with it, then they changed what it was. Now what I'm with isn't it, and what's it seems weird and scary to me. IT'LL HAPPEN TO YOUUUU!!! "Could I really be that out of touch? No, it's the children who are wrong."

José Miguel Rivera Ladino

How does Strauss-Hower applies outside of the US and also in the context of globalization?

Sabrina Muscat

OH MY GOD the random clip from 'now is the month of maying' at 4:17 had me absolutely gobsmacked because i sung it years prior. what a great deep cut from natalie

Imme

"Skibidi toilet is fun because. a man's head. pops out of. a toilet." As a parent of a 10 year old, YES thank you how is this complicated to anyone? Somehow, "great surreal poop jokes!" are never among the top 100 listed things parents harass childless people about missing out on. That is too bad, because I figure it would make those dinner conversations much more fun.

Skyler St. John

Watching this post-election introduces a lot more potential to what crises the 20 years we’re in the middle of may yet hold for us to be more on-par with the civil war, revolutionary way, or world wars.

Noel S

The Lost Generation and The Great Generation had anxiety like no other!! They just didn't name it. But they were seriously messed up by it

Martyś

Still thinking about this tangent & generations in general due to preceding conversation with my younger cousin on generations and the perception of what gen z/millenials/boomers are like vs our lived experience. Keep meaning to try & find some research on generations in different countries -- 90s kids in Poland are a very different group than 90s kids in the US, etc.

Zach Goff

“Masculine Muslim barbarians are totally gonna assblast the American they/them pussies” is an amazingly out of pocket quote.

Luna Tic

Super late to the party but I agree that money is incredibly important for mental health, and I was a bit surprised Natalie thought differently. My mental health has improved and devolved directly in line with whatever affluence I have had, lost, and regained. Also, yes to the idea that milennials do not know how good they have it. I study political science and most people who are also into history, do not believe that gen z's children will be as spoiled as milennials were. We were born at a lucky time, historically speaking

kellyanne

fwiw natalie i work at an elementary school and the kids have informed me gyat stands for butt and comes from "girl your ass thick" and it is not related to "gyat damn" (at least according to this cohort of children)

Callie Thompson

I feel like class and income play a role in relating to a certain generation. I was born in 1999 below the poverty line. Most new technology and fashion were out of reach. I watched older movies on VHS long before we got a DVD player. We didn't have cable, but we had an antenna to watch PBS. I only had access to a computer or the Internet in the computer lab at school. I only listened to new music on the radio. Buy new, popular CDs other kids my age listened to wasn't possible. I wore secondhand, clearance or thrifted clothing. I share more nostalgia with Millennials than my own "generation". Nostalgia would be an interesting tangent.

Pamela Boudreau

I'm a Gen X and I remember Boomers and other Gen Xers talking about what an unholy mess the Millenials were. They were never going to make it, no one would ever hire them, blah, blah, blah. Now I hear Millenials saying the Gen Zs are doomed. What is the big deal? Don't we get it? It just means you're getting old now and you resent the fact that there's a new young hot thing getting all the attention. Give them their moment. Pretty soon they'll get old too.

Pamela Boudreau

"Sorry. I just ruined Hegel for you." Ha!

rk

This is great! Your perceptive opening explanation of the moral panic surrounding youthful slang, silliness, etc and placing it within the tradition of Medieval drolleries, Rabelais, etc is Brilliant! Rationality & Empathy! 🙏 I miss that wide-eyed optimism & indulgent learning (I studied semiotics in Peking opera in college… so many job openings 🤣)

rk

Fascinating… how can we combine the best of cyclical & linear/progressive thinking (probably some chaotic thinking, too) in order to care for our planet, freedom, people, and promote scientific progress? I wish the answer was simple or easy (perhaps it’s not the best way to frame the question).

rk

Yeah, I still agree with Bernie Sanders, and I worked on Bernie’s campaign, but I voted for Hilary when I had to.

rk

Oh! A Hegel Tangent! ❤️

Viviane P.L.

I genuinely thought the kid was singing nonsense scatt - 👵🪦

Shaymin

Heard "nonsense lyricism" and immediately mentally prepared for bad romance to pop up lol

Imogen

I'm GenX and I find this generational discourse kind of hilarious. Older generations have complained about the imminent doom of the younger generations for time immemorial. Same goes for the younger generations. You know, being "unkool" or whatever. I do think that the more recent obsessive labeling of generations has to do with the way we've been chunking time together, especially in the 20th and 21st century. I suppose what I mean by that is: the 19th century is defined almost exclusively by Victorianism. But starting in the 20th century, eras are shorter. Edwardian, 1st WW, Roaring 20s, Great Depression, etc.

Ashley Knowlton

The more I think about generational theory the more it feels deeply unserious. Strauss-Howe in particular has a strong just-so powerpoint astrology vibe. I hate it. At least astrology has a fun aesthetic! However the generational memes are great, even if I think the theory is otherwise useless. I'll admit I was feeling some GenX erasure watching this tangent 😂 "The left got the NFL in the divorce" omg so topical again this year

demlet

The Trump era culminating with January 6... How innocent we all were.