Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi friends,

The topic patrons voted on this month was "A curated collection of surreal and obscure videos from across internet history with in depth commentary and analysis." I decided to drop the "obscure" criterion for reasons explained in the video—I found that the videos I most wanted to discuss were not really all that obscure. So here is what would more appropriately be called a curated collection of famous surreal videos from across internet history, with commentary and an introductory ramble about surrealism in general.

This one took longer than I anticipated because I decided that in order for this to stand on its own as a video essay, I needed to include a lot of clips of the source material, which means more editing time than usual for a Tangent.

So I continue to fall behind schedule, and at this point I think I'm going to have to beg you to forgive me my Tangent debt. It's turned out not to be practical to produce more than one of these a month while also working on a main channel video. So there will be a June Tangent, but I'm abandoning my hopes of getting two Tangents out for one month.

I originally intended the Tangents to be more of a low-effort, minimally researched and edited type of thing, but at this point I just can't bring myself to slop out mediocre content. There's too many people watching—and I can hardly complain about that, but it does make me feel like I need to meet basic quality standards for the work I put out. I know some of you think you'd be happy to hear me read a bus schedule. But no, you wouldn't. So I appreciate your patience with my impressionistic approach to deadlines.

For the next few weeks I'm going to dive into work on a main channel video, because I have an idea for it that I'm excited about, and it's best to harness that excitement when it strikes. So hopefully I can get a script together by the end of this month too and ideally finish that video by the end of the summer.

Enjoy, and let me know what you think!

-Natalie

P.S. Here's the video link, in case embedding doesn't work: https://youtu.be/I8gmEhL2MRM

Files

Tangent: Surreal Videos

Thanks so much for your support! Featured videos: Salad Fingers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RdgnS5dEKxM I Feel Fantastic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=diY6Mt_uqYs Possibly in Michigan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iLJNSD3H5sg Pickle Surprise: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3GhN7v5SoGs Obey the Walrus: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pMbeP36I8Lg Lasagna Cat: https://youtu.be/NAh9oLs67Cw?si=8apTqJ0pr0jd96V6 Don’t Hug Me I’m Scared: https://youtu.be/9C_HReR_McQ?si=tezkyH42JDJQJChD runforthecube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T4r91mc8pbo Unedited Footage of a Bear: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2gMjJNGg9Z8 This House Has People in It: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x-pj8OtyO2I 11B-X-1371: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UDSfMmwNU2w RuUnion with Katya and Detox: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXb6APovQio L O C A L 5 8 T V - Contingency: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3c66w6fVqOI BLUE_CHANNEL: THALASIN: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Td2x8s9GZlo ▬ Contents▬ Intro: What Is Surrealism? 2:48 Salad Fingers 10:56 I Feel Fantastic 13:52 Possibly in Michigan 17:04 Pickle Surprise 19:30 Obey the Walrus 22:24 Lasagna Cat 28:11 Don’t Hug Me I’m Scared 34:54 runforthecube 37:45 Unedited Footage of a Bear 41:04 This House Has People in It 44:21 11B-X-1371 46:58 RuUnion with Katya and Detox 50:11 L O C A L 5 8 T V - Contingency 53:09 BLUE_CHANNEL: THALASIN 55:29

Comments

Megalomaniac64

Wonder where this will take me on my spiritual journey

Bethany

Yipee!!!!!

MJZ42

Hello mother!

Heather Wexler

I was hoping for I Feel Fantastic and you delivered, as always.

Diana Godin

Quality over frequency, always. Thank you so much for these.

Ted(dy)

I forgive ur tangent debt

Jesse “Heinous Crimes” Lovelace

The tangents are more than high quality enough for it to be okay to miss a few months now and then. You’re forgiven, mother mom!

AJ

HAIR!!

The Doom Merchant

quality over quantity is a perfectly reasonable aspiration, and we're certainly GETTING quality, so. glad to get everything we're getting, and i won't demand more than you're able to do!

Arianne

Thank you, I AM into “this sort of thing”.

George Berberian

Yay! Looking forward to watching. It's always a pleasure 💗

Ernie Tremper

Ooh, fun topic! I'm more than happy to wait when the results are this good!

ingerfieee

no complaints about missing a tangent once in a while when they’re all so well researched kween❣️

Jessica Cheeri

Going to have to watch this in a bit, but I think most people here would rather you make videos you're proud of regardless of when they're released. There's no Tangent debt as far as I'm concerned

Jack Beck

Take all the time you need! Really looking forward to this!

Ricky G.

Hi Natalie! I think it would make the most practical sense to switch Tangents into an “every two months” Patreon reward. I believe that after a year of Tangents, it’s proven itself to be a great format for not only us as Patreon supporters but for you as well. I’m sure everyone here has noticed the topics you research for your Tangents have been appearing in your main channel videos. It’s a cool little detail that makes being a supporter feel just that little extra special. But seriously gorge, we don’t need you to pump out a ton of these. You know we love quality over quantity! Much love and hope you have a great rest of your week!

MOX

Here at Contrapoints Industries we're in the business of supporting Natalie's rights. If Contrapoints Industries doesn't accommodate Natalie's needs, we'll be forced to call the Union Rep!

Katie

+1 for the "I don't want to be a source of pressure, these are wonderful, the debt does not exist" sentiment

Caribou-kun

ohhhh nooooo only ONE bonus video a month? T^T I am seriously in awe of your output to quality ratio, I was giddy to see this pop up! I'd be giddy with one every other month! Thank you for the update, cheers for the strike of inspiration!

Maxwell Douglas Kinghorn

I'm always excited for a new tangent. I wouldn't worry too much about getting a tangent out each month, I think 6-8 tangents a year would be fine. I haven't watched this one yet, but I feel like the quality of tangents has been increasing. You are doing a great job Natalie!

Trejon Dunkley

I appreciate your dedication to quality over quantity. I have yet to be disappointed by a tangent so as long as you need to make them up to your standards is all right by me :)

Nikee Star

This is genuinely fascinating. Thanks Natalie.

RJ Blue

“impressionistic approach to deadlines” is such a good phrase that I’ll probably use it for myself. no worries about missing one, I’m just glad we get them at all! 💕

Tanner Gore

i saw salad fingers when i was in seventh or eighth grade and the male lactation through nettle nipple torture episode took the last ounce of my innocence

Maíra Macário

I vote for you reading us bus schedules for the next tangent!

Cinabeeeeee

I haven't watched this yet but yes I'm perfectly fine with this tangent cadence and appreciate your dedication to fighting enshitification of all.

B

such a good video!! thank uuuu ~_~

Caley Spreitzer

Halfway through and I am entranced. I'm reliving my childhood in a way

Valentina Muccillo

Thanks contra broke both of my arms yesterday really needed this so great timing actually

Taylor du Chêne Royale

I haven't gotten even 4 minutes into this tangent, but I wanted to stop and acknowledge the little bit of self-deprecation about the academic urge to establish definitions. Of all the academic urges, this is one I really appreciate when done well. Obviously in less competent hands it just winds up as "the Oxford dictionary definition of x states that ...". However, I think a considered approach to "definitions" builds context and makes the conversation around a topic feel more complete. With this topic for instance, it's easy to bandy around the term "surreal", but I like a thorough investigation of precisely what the aesthetic, philosophical and historical underpinnings are and why that matters. anyway I'm gonna actually watch this video now <3

Rachel

A thought: from my outsider perspective, Jenny's rambles (react to this movie, top 10 favorite theme park foods, tour of my plushes) seem much easier to make than the tangents you're doing, but as a patron I totally love them and don't consider them low quality. Maybe it's different just because your channels are so different, but I wonder if you might have an easier time with these if the topics were lower stakes. Like just talking about your favorite movies or what you've been reading, rather than trying to make A Point. Regardless, thank you for all that you do and share with us!

Amelia McLean

I stumbled onto the Local 58 and Thalasin videos. I still find them deeply disturbing on one level; however, I’m also to the point that they serve as calming bedtime watches to settle my endless rumination—if I can be comfortable with this, is there anything I’m worried about that would be horrible enough to prevent me from going to sleep? Also, when I was 19, I fell asleep watching TV and woke up in the middle of the night to a blaring Rap-mix version of the Slap Chop commercial. I told everyone i knew that it was the most surreal thing I’d ever experienced and, alas, no one has ever validated this feeling.

Austin Luther

I'm happy for tangents whenever they occur. I certainly don't expect them on any kind of timeline. I agree that some people get too caught up in trying to "decode" surreal art. I'm one of those people, in a way. I try to make sense of what I'm seeing until I have to accept that it doesn't make sense and I can't force it to do so. I can't solve a puzzle when I don't have all of the pieces and the pieces I do have aren't for a puzzle.

Jesse Oswald

Omg red hair, now I know it's a sign for me to finally dye mine

Jesse Oswald

For 2 dollars a month i get my portion of manna from heaven, literally bless this patreon

g.c0r7

It's ok for you to place ideal goals and fail to meet them perfectly. They're supposed to be used as a guidance and accountability system, and holding space for flexibility and adaptation as life unfolds is a healthy thing.

Bruno Sauvagnat

It's quite fine that you don't produce them at a great speed. They're always enjoyable to watch and I'd prefer quality over quantity

Thistle Pass

I am calling for a TANGENT DEBT JUBILEE! All debts are ceremonially forgiven. These tangents are very high-quality and greatly enjoyed and appreciated, but I for one don't feel like I'm paying enough to be *owed* a constant stream of excellent content. I view my patronage here as a form of thanks for all the free content you've made over the years. If you can't abide producing "mediocre content", just know that I (and I'm sure many others) will continue being a patron even if these delightful tangents become less frequent.

happyknucklz

Clearly you need to sacrifice quality for consistency. I needs ma fix!

Reed

What if you just did a podcast episode with someone and realized on the tangents channel first as a the “second tangent”?

Madison McClellan

I'm a simple person. Patreon tells me Mother has posted again, I click, I watch

Narcissa Deville

I honestly did not know some of these even though I should have because I was def of the age group. Salad fingers and don't hug me I'm scared I kind of found later but others I had never heard of so this was fascinating.

Lauren Kawulicz

Your hair!! Loved the other way too but I just in general am partial to this color! <3

Austin F

impressionism is the best way to approach deadlines. if deadlines were so important, they'd be called alivelines (excited to watch, ty queen)

Aud

Very cool to revisit these videos more thoughtfully (and with a full grown brain) through this tangent. I’m sure I’ll be chewing on this for the rest of the month! Thank you! Wong Ping, joe cappa, and umami are all animators I’ve stumbled upon on YouTube. They do other stuff too, but my introduction to all three was their surreal work. Highly recommend!

Crescent Minor

Darling, I watched all of these more than enough times to forgive you an alleged 'debt' that you inform me needs forgiveness. Granted, granted.

Gautam Madhivanan

Love the hair. But also, I must have that shirt!

XavierTeatime

At least put "Natalie reads a bus schedule" on the next poll and let democracy work

Vítor Medeiros

As someone with "an impressionistic approach to deadlines," who is also generally very busy, I totally understand and appreciate the current scheduling of tangents. If they were more frequent and low-effort, I'd probably like them way less. A decently well-put-together video every two months instead of a monthly slopfest is something I'm more willing to continue paying for! So as always thank for the great work you do!

Simon_Dinosaur

Tangent: Natalie Reads a Bus Schedule - we all know Natalie would start out planning to just read a bus schedule, but over the course of three months this would slowly transform into a 90 minute long thoroughly researched insightful and funny teardown of the failures of American public transit systems. Don't threaten us with a good time Natalie!

Cleo Oops

Happy to see Possibly In Michigan on here. Do we know which character in DHMIS Natalie perceives to change gender? Imo that series is another that worked best capped at a few videos, but the creators seem to have heeded to the fans' desire to overexplain and decode everything.

Beth S

It was interesting to me how much the meat stuff seems soo directly influenced by Czech surrealist Jan Svankmajer, yet for some reason I have a hard time believing the people making these are really consciously consuming other capital-S Surrealist art as influences. I have this vision of these ideas floating in the void, gravitating toward a hidden reality and coalescing around it. So it is perhaps, fittingly, a form of objective chance. This is probably for the best, but I have not been able to find the most surreal video experience of my life, which was an upload of an early 90s interview by white supremacist Tom Metzger at his most fuddy-duddy with the deeply weird, cult-like and hyper theatrical goth band Radio Werewolf. There was no real dream logic to it, yet it had an intense feeling of unreality because of its absurdity, like the rules of reality would never actually allow this to happen. After the third time or so that ultraconservative stuffed shirt Tom Metzger praised this band that looked like Gary Numan and talked like Victorian vampire cosplayers who also believe in the Bermuda Triangle for getting the kids excited about Hitler again, and the lead singer telling him he didn't understand that Hitler was just a puppet in the grand design that is the ascendancy of Radio Werewolf, while essentially calling him an idiot to his face and Tom not even understanding THAT, it did feel like a performance art piece. Found-art surrealism on the internet or something.

John Giacobello

Goddamn Pickle Surprise, was not expecting that. I saw it in college; a friend found it on a VHS tape someone left at his NYC apartment in the 90s… that and “Strawberry Shortcut”, plus “V is for Violet” by Todd Verow. Excellent acid viewing.

SuperMaria

Throwing it out here: consider the possibility of switching back to AMA streams (or any other lower effort stream) as a Patreon reward, just while you work on the main channel video! Keeping this one as a reward to myself for when I finish my weekend adulting goals. Thank you sm from one redhead to another

D.A.R.

I believe the "indistinguishable from magic" quote is by Arthur C. Clarke.

J

No need for a makeup tangent. I vote you do whatever is sustainable for you ❤️

E

Absolutely love these tangents, they're the reason I'm a patron!!!! Also, this is my favorite "surreal" video online. I'm not sure if it quite fits the definition, but it does hit analog horror and it makes me feel simultaneously less alone and horrified. https://youtu.be/rhMZARyC98w?si=Px07xD3n3WdIXHTv

C Jose

Natalie maybe do one AMA, it has been a while since the last one... I think we can all agree that we also want to know how you're doing personally

C Jose

100% we need a new AMA

Saoirse

One lower effort option could be to do a lottery or voting based AMA?

highclass_lady

As long as the bus schedule was from a very liminal year you reading a bus schedule would be super f*cking liminal

roxyamused

I have a few videos I haven't seen here that look great. The whole like edgy 80's queer thing wasn't just a queer thing, like GG Allin got "big" during the 80's and bands like the Mentors were in their heyday of obnoxious shock rock singing about edgy shit just to be edgy, and that was all it needed to be subversive.

Lynn Dawson

I hadn’t seen any of these before. Then again I wasn’t super into surrealist stuff. But your note about teens having a higher tolerance for the grotesque definitely struck a chord with me. When I was in high school I could read Encyclopædia Dramatica for fun, look at Goatse or Lemon Party without issue, and just feel like wow I’m so edgy I found the edgy part of the internet. And now I’m like… I avoid that stuff like the plague and I have an overall distaste for anything sexual outside of my own actual irl sexual encounters in the bedroom. I cling to content warnings much of the time now. I wonder why my distress tolerance has gone down. Something to bring to my next therapy session I guess lol.

Luiza Lodder

One thing you must understand is that the content you make lives and lives and lives in our hearts and minds long past the day you release the video from whence the content came, so technically, youve met your deadline 1000x over. (if that makes sense)

Wobtax

WOW never seen a video more made for me!! I love the "There Is Nothing" video---I had never seen that before and it really hit my nervous system hard. Also ooooh thank you for letting us post some in the comments :3 Deadtime Stories for Big Folk! 1. Door: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1xDDkmTDdJJ3qovNRu8m4S7XZiummGlPf 2. Deadsy: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1c7BV1rfCYGKSA2rGomsBW6rvuz1NAu_U I think the really good one is Door, as Deadsy is (yeah) a little transphobic. Both use these thin shadow figures who are dead but still flickering, but Deadsy layers on kind of an agp narcissism trope... Modern Appetite! https://vimeo.com/31734869 Force feeding as a religious experience, a sublime act of surrender. Priit Parn, The Triangle https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6Xzu7BOdh4 Definitely wanted to include this because of the dream logic: she keeps taking her face and breasts and putting them in the food she's cooking... The composer Marcus Fjellstrom (he did the music for some David Firth stuff) made his own animations: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wWn-cXbG6U8 They feel like slower, dusty film reels from an eastern bloc basement archive. Let's Visit the World of the Future! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FHx2nLFMAzE Prefigures a lot of "sleep in the pod and eat bugs" paranoia. Of course the real source is the firesign theater's I Think We're All Bozos on This Bus...what is it about clowns and the future hologram world?

corvus + crux

"artists shouldn't know about psychoanalysis it destroys their innocence" called me out SO HARD. holy crap. Why did you need to come directly for my trauma 😂😂😂

Tyler Shankel

One of my favorite current surreal creators is Alex Kister (YouTube channel of the same name). The videos are surreal horror, yes, but also build off each other and iterate into a sort of worldbuilding that you get drawn into. Almost like the horror of surreal colliding with and subsuming the real.

Ed Sylveste

this tangent is so good that it is somewhat a surreal obscure internet video that most of my friends can't access. just feeling a lot of love towards you again mother, here we go

Andrew May

I shit you not, just today one of my students shared this analogue horror short film they made. I can interview a sixteen year-old who’s into this weird genre if you’re looking for a quotation!

Toni Zadravec

You've been super productive since starting the tangents, and they have all been great so don't beat yourself up over missing one or two. An idea to maybe ease the pressure - you haven't done an AMA in a very long time. I suppose it's less work for you than a tangent, and I'm sure a lot of people would love to revisit the format once in a while :)

Karin Hernmarck

A little bit well, actually… but here it goes. About the checker board in nature. It’s not perfect but there is this flower called Kungsängslilja in Swedish which is pretty close to being checker board patterned in the petals.

Franco del Rosario

Super interesting tangent! I find it interesting how most of the surreal videos cited have a horror element. (Or were made with the intention to be unsettling) For me, I’ll always associate surrealism in the Internet era with the humor of Tim & Eric Awesome Show Great Job (and from there, you can draw a direct line to The Eric Andre Show or even some of the analog horror stuff with their retro stylings.) I’d argue some T&E sketches also have a dream-like quality to them. Like you have all the parts for a “normal” infomercial or skit, but they’re just arranged in a weird way

Queen Bee BumbleGee

Wonderful tangent Nat! As much as I like the idea of you reading a bus schedule (I would use it as content to fall asleep to) I love that you take the time to create quality videos. Pride in one's craft is a thing best earned after all. A favorite surreal scary of mine is BDG and Karen Han's "Teaching Jake about the Camcorder, Jan '97" which I think beautifully weaves the unnerving aspect of memory with the relationship between father/son into a great analog horror. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RXZy8BbMz_U I'm also a huge fan of Felix Colgrave whomst makes delightfully surreal and chaotic cartoons. The animation is highly detailed and feels almost visceral to me. However I think the sounds and music he makes for his videos is what puts his work over the top. I've always said that his videos are much like the ballet in how movement and music and storytelling come together. I especially recommend his stuff with a quality headset or set or speakers and cranking the volume. I'll include a link to "Throat Notes" but I'm at least gonna mention that "Donks" as well as "Double King" are just as worthy of a look. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qhVehcHwOB8&t=328s These are probably aren't particularly obscure vids, but they're a couple of my favs :) <3

taili huang

Please consider your tangent debt forgiven!!!

Olivia Smith

This was the wrong video to watch whilst staring into a hotel mirror to do my makeup in a brightly lit bathroom, alone, before leaving my room and walking down the dark, winding corridors, also alone. Felt like I was in a nightmare the whole time. Great video, though!

Dariusz Dywan

Not normally into these, but I have enjoyed some of u m a m i's work on youtube. An interesting, I guess mspaint-ish aesthetic +liminal. Also my mother tongue is surreal? Why was I not informed?

Aderyn Albarelli

Damn, I missed out on some neat stuff! Would I have understood the divine nature of Garfield, though? I wonder if watching that video, before reading Garfield without Garfield, would put the second in a different light. Huh, never thought about why I'm more sensitive to horror than I was as a kid, but what you described feels like it tracks. I always attributed it to the "I don't feel discomfort" iteration of masculinity I was trying to fake, before I realized a thing. It's comforting to hear that it's a more universal experience.

Aderyn Albarelli

I look forward to stuffs you have planned! 🙌 And I think impressionism is a solid approach to a schedule (my manager is wrong and I will fite him), you engage with topics really thoughtfully, thank you 😺 I too will side eye the cycles

CrystalJade

Always makes my day to see you pop onto my screen! That’s because you produce such thought provoking content. We’re all caught in what we perceive as the desire of the other. It’s mostly a reflection of our own ideas about what that might be. It’s always best to meet your own expectations first for this reason. You can’t please all of the people all of the time. Looking forward to watching this tangent later today!

Charlotte

I am very happy with the number of new videos I’ve been able to watch since joining the Patreon! (Of course there was initially a backlog to binge, but there also have been 4 new videos since then - I don’t notice if the tangents are not exactly 1 a month.)

Chazie

The android lady sex doll thing reminded me of the "violon gay" videos that were very popular in the french-speaking surreal video enjoyer spheres https://youtu.be/g48RqjF7mLI?si=3OlGHHdUPPvMch7- (if you don't speak french he's presenting his "violoneux" and telling him to play the gay violin or he'll eat his mullet, over and over again) I think even if you don't understand french the combination of the uncanny doll, the audible camera whirring sound, his repetitive dialogue, the loud bonking on the mannequin's head and the general serial killer vibes make this video interesting to watch (if you do speak french the québec accent is also inherently surreal). Also one of those videos that the 2000s internet edgelords love to say slurs about unfortunately Other contribution, I'm sure some of us are familiar with this one: https://youtu.be/Ntf5_ue2Lzw?si=HiJkYbD_7qiDaYcm like don't hug me i'm scared, claymation makes horror way scarier Thank you for posting such high quality bonus content, none of us would be mad at you for not putting out one of these every single month, they're way higher quality and effort than what a lot of creators are posting to their main channels. I don't mean "keep raising the bar queen" I mean you could be making lower effort stuff and it would still be excellent!

SuperMaria

1. What would be more surreal than falling asleep to Natalie reading a bus schedule though? Like now I legit want that as a Patreon reward 2. What if the hair is edited? 👀 After watching this I am now doubting reality

Jack Dover

Really interesting. I never really got the appeal of surreal videos like Salad Fingers (what I think we would have called 'random' humour at the time) when I was a teenager but I definitely think I have much more of an appreciation of why it appeals to people having watched this.

infinitygaze

Really enjoyed the video, thanks Natalie! It made me really think about why I don’t enjoy surrealist art myself. I suppose I’m too invested in the rational progression of events and narrative and 9 times out of ten I find the dreamlike intrusions disquietening in a way that doesn’t “reveal” but just onscures further. You mention Breton but the quote of his that stays with me most is “beauty will be convulsive or not at all”, which now I think about it strikes me as a threat!!

Jayemdee

All right so. This video actually bothered me. I'm feeling a bit perturbed and everything is seeming to be very surreal at the moment. This is not to say that I didn't enjoy the video, I thought it was really great. I hadn't seen or heard of most of these surreal videos before today, so the act of watching them and hearing about them at the same time was...interesting. It was a lot of surreal all at once, on several levels. If your intent was (at least partially) to cause a feeling of unease with this video, mission accomplished. Bravo.

Austin F

on the pipe strip video: as someone who's been pretty closely associated with academia for years, i totally relate to your experience watching this. it's honestly kind of cathartic to see that other people think academic review gets so ridiculous sometimes 😭i have read way too many insipid papers doing things like trying to deeply analyze tv shows for preschoolers or make plant trimming into a statement on queerness

Molly

Seconded! I’m just happy whenever they show up. Wouldn’t mind if they were every other month or otherwise less frequent.

Tara

My edible kicked in right as you began your appreciation of Lasagna Cat which made the entire segment both really funny and really horrifying.

Austin F

also, i live in northern virginia, and it's always strange (dare i say...surreal) to be reminded that you grew up in the same place i did. loudoun county is just northwest of my own county. i have a crazy take: northern virginia is liminal. a lot of people find it unsettling. northern virginia is suburbia, full of upper middle class people, but it's much more liberal and diverse than the rest of the state. my county is actually minority-majority, despite being one of the richest in the US. for people who don't live in virginia, the southern half of virginia is a traditional 'The South' area. and a whole lot of the conservative rural types there have so much resentment towards northern virginia, an area of high immigration, wealth, and education. northern virginia has started to take over the state politically, and virginia has been blue in every presidential election since 2008 because of that; northern virginia is a huge Democrat stronghold now. they feel, even subconsciously, like the place they live in has been 'invaded'. a bunch of immigrants and elites and government workers are taking their traditional home. it all seems very contradictory and scary. i feel like there's going to be some dumb conservative "art" piece that takes place here soon enough lol

Ann C

I love this because, as a Boomer, I haven't seen most of these videos, and I found out about the ones I have seen (I Feel Fantastic), from Natalie's occasionally mysterious tweets. I found "You are on the Fastest Route to Your Destination" on my own, and it creeped me out because GPS does send people down dirt roads and dead ends, or even into the ocean (happened in Maine) if you're not careful. Anyway, I plan to watch some of the videos mentioned in this Tangent, but I know I won't be able to resist delving in and trying to find out more about them.

Marinousky

This brought up some deep memories

Jenkka

wtf I just saw Blue Velvet for the first time yesterday. This is... surreal.

highclass_lady

I wonder how the distinction between analog horror & nostalgia can be described. I think the appeal of analog horror, which is I think inherently intertwined with nostalgia triggers, is at least partly in rooted in the condition that nostalgia can feel a little bit uncomfortable, inaccurate, dishonest even. If the past (childhood) was always a mix of difficult & scary along with the good parts, then romanticizing it (as interpretations of nostalgia often do) can feel inherently ambiguous in a way that's (at least partially) ill at ease. Analog horror often acknowledges this unease, which may be part of why shared appreciation of some media & art depicting horror can help people feel seen. For example, it often taps into past anxieties with things like advancement in technology which can be re-applied to overarching, often timeless issues, we as a society are facing today. There's something oddly satisfying maybe even almost validating in artists acknowledging the fears, unease, & eerieness that sometimes companies the nostalgia of the past.

Emily Griese

One of my favourite cinematic depictions of dreams is the season 4 finale of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, titled "Restless". I think I watched it for the first time when I was 12 or 13 years old and it blew my mind. Looking back now, I can see how they took a lot of inspiration from things like Blue Velvet but I think it still holds up. Here's a compilation of scenes without context to make it extra surreal. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p9ETPypz-zs

Junior

Any video from MotherContra is going to super fun to watch. You keep us fed 🍣 and we appreciate you. ❤️❤️❤️ Even the YouTube lives are super fun to watch after the fact. (Hopes for more Sim 4 🤞)

Matt Dear

I also saw the pipe strip for the first time while on acid in 2017 or 18. It was... transcendental

December Vesalius

I don't know if it would be considered analog horror, but you should play on stream Amanda the Adventurer. The VHS tapes, especially those that are film with real people would probably be the closest to analog horror, if at all

Geok103

Couldn’t recommend the “Don’t Hug Me I’m Scared” TV series enough. It’s luckily all on YouTube. Absolutely hilarious and ingenious.

Jessie Lees

This was quite the video to watch after fully waking up from hypnopompic hallucinations. What pushed me to wake was a weird sound reverberation from someone's phone on speaker in their truck outside, that sounded like it was coming from inside my house while I'm alone. I almost feel like I could still be dreaming.

Vítor Medeiros

Lacan (whomst Natalie seems to be reading & liking quite a bit as of recently) even said that the unconscious IS the Other's desire. It's his best definition of the unconscious imo

CrystalJade

I seem to be at the edge of the hole in human knowledge staring right into it and wondering what’s down there….. Again. For me this is what surrealism is all about. It’s ontological openness gives that feeling of something beyond, curiosity for the unexplained - a sense of mystery that can as easily turn into phantasmic fear as it does pure laughter. Curiofearter as they say! Loved your take on the surreal!!

CrystalJade

I really like some of Lacan, although sometimes his metaphors go right over my head! Reading his seminars bit by bit before I go to sleep does seem to put me in a state of lucid dreaming. It’s almost surreal in that way too!

Grady Wiehe

You look like Shirley Manson in a 90’s music video. Stunning

Noah Carlin

So many of these are new to me on the border of gen z, and watching these during work has brought that sick, twisted, lovely feeling of getting away with something that I felt in middle school watching salad fingers

RamblesAboutStuff

OK OK OK, I know I haven't even watched the video yet, and since you've transitioned people comment on your appearance way more but a) I used to be a hairstylist (color specialist) and b) well I guess I'm just people, so... I love this new hair color on you! Even though the platinum blonde highlights were a great look, I love this light warm brown (or dark warm blonde, however you want to put it) you've got going. OK, and now I'm gonna watch the video. ^^

fae

love ur new hair omg!!! it looks so good on you!!! 💖

pjkc

Broke: Fashionably late Woke: Impressionistic approach to deadlines I'm so stealing that turn of phrase LOL. Really looking forward to the new main channel video, especially if you're excited about it! Good work takes the time it takes, no shame in that at all, and foremost take care of yourself!

Jarod Karls

Brought me back. Salad fingers, when you are 12, def can be a lot and this video made me reflect on that because I, too, remember seeing that at a friends house and thinking "I don't like this..." "the internet is scary" 😅 so glad I got to relive some of this with you and I have some new recs now, so thank you! Also related to that weird realization that some of these were some of my first experiences with queer people and gender non-conformity.

Kiki

mother…I’m loving your tangents…again ! also the red hair looks great!

Reed

Few things have made me have to stop a video and laugh uncontrollably as when Natalie said the sentence, "Sometimes I'll be trying to sit quietly, in meditation upon Garfield, and my intrusive thoughts will all be 'TIEME TO COME ALIEVEY ESCAPEE THE PATACKY'"

Jess

Still not fully done with the video! But I just wanna say I FELT what you were saying about the pipe strip video and spiritual laughter. One of the best times I ever had was tripping on acid with my partner while watching cartoons like "Bravest Warriors" and "Bee and Puppycat" and getting super focused on little details/unnecessarily analytical with it. Only to burst out laughing at the absurdity of it all. At one point one of us summed it up as "we're just babies laughing at the universe" and it was one of the most transcendent experiences of joy I've ever had in my life. Okay, now back to the scheduled programming...

Ann C

As a relatively new patron, I've enjoyed all the Tangents. They're an excellent bonus for patrons. They all look like they take a lot of work and are high quality, and we benefit from that. One a month, or whatever you can manage as you work on a main channel video, works for us. I'm happy you're excited about a main channel topic, and I look forward to seeing it.

RamblesAboutStuff

Watched the video: loved it, I actually have fond (?...) memories of the videos that I already knew and was very interested in the ones I had never heard of, as well as really enjoying your overall analysis. Great Tangent(TM) once again!

Carl

LE RAVISSEMENT DE FRANK N. STEIN (can be found on yt)

Alexa D

This was so interesting (/disturbing) and REALLY helpful for reminding myself that some of the wild things the youths are doing online these days are not so different from the horrors of salad fingers I watched (did not remember salad fingers being THAT dark).

Sophie Clem-Whiting

I watched this video last night in my college apartment alone and stoned. I didn't realize how spooky some of the videos were going to be and I started freaking out (especially during I feel fantastic bc I left my bedroom door open and the hallway was pitch black). I think I'll probably go back and watch it sober now hahahaha

Tasha J

It's not an internet video (originally), but Wonder Showzen predated Don't Hug Me I'm Scared in the surrealist kids parody what am I watching genre. It was on MTV2 and frequently made us all say "what the hell am i watching" in the best of ways. You can find a lot of clips on YouTube. https://youtu.be/hMGzoxMoGkg?feature=shared

Jessica Memphis

This was a fun one. Little walk down memory lane.

lovelyabitha

I love Cecilia Condit’s work so much. She has such an interesting creative vision. I went down a rabbit hole a few years ago about her and her process, just such a cool woman

Wissa

Have you seen NOPE? Imo it got the dream ‘logic’ down really good, subtle at first but by the end with each photo and glance at the ufo it was like one of those dreams that you know is metaphorical in some way but I could never pin point “what it meant” even though it felt like I’ve lived that metaphor in some way a thousand times. Still cant’ articulate it, but I relate to it. This is another tangent I wish could go on longer.

Amalia

This is one of my favorite tangents yet, surrealist horror is so creative

Dana Migdal

Have you seen Beau is Afraid? I'd be really curious to hear what you think about its dreamlikeness (or nightmarishness, really)

Amy Bee

Great watch as always. I’m very glad you are unwilling to read us the phone book! Curious - have you seen I Saw the TV Glow? It’s this lovely trans surrealist horror(?) movie that’s out now. Obviously more structured than these videos but still brought to mind again by them.

Fillory

"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic" is an Arthur C. Clarke quote

Christian Colombo

Regarding the checkerboard motif, in addition to it being instantly recognisable as unnatural, I think it also effective conveys scale and vastness as the squares shrink off into the distance. That kind of pattern is used in CAD software as a default, I believe for this reason. In the rabbit-hole scene from Alice in Wonderland the pattern is distorted at the threshold. The pattern is otherwise depicted as pristine and geometric, the viewer can trust in its consistency and reasonably expect that it doesn't change. I feel it communicates that spacetime itself is distorted at the threshold.

Andrew May

Are we throwing Food Party into this category?

Emily

Wow, thanks for introducing me to Cecelia Condit. Making/watching horror movies bc you're so full of fear all the time is deeply relatable 😅 Also, I love what you did with your hair, that colour was made for you! Gorgeous.

Lily Stein

we analyzed pickle surprise in one of my undergrad classes last semester. sick as fuck to see you talk about it a bit here.

David Kal

It's all good, the content is awesome, no rush!

Lars Overdale

I haven’t even watched the video yet, but I’m loving the reddish hair!

Opinionated Online

This Tangent seems relevant to what I did yesterday for a special event with some others. We walked around nearly every square inch of an old mall that is going to be mostly torn down soon. It was a very liminal experience as almost all the stories were closed and empty/partially empty but, in some cases, the lights were still on inside.

Anna the Smiling Cat

Interesting. I did not know any of those videos, probably being somewhat older and in my own internet bubble. Was an interesting watch. I did not think two tangents a month was a realistic goal and I'm glad to hear that the main channel video is going forward, Those are the reason I'm here, tangents and streams are just extras.

Annie Hanlin

Here to be that person, I’m sorry. This hair color suits you so well

Austin F

i'll never forget The Slave Song, which honestly feels so much more biting now after that whole time of governments/corporations constantly "thanking essential workers" and trying to "be positive"💀

Godel Escher Monkey

Oh! Oh! I get to be a horrid pedant! The "Any sufficiently advanced tech = magic" quote is Arthur C. Clarke (see Clarke's Three Laws).

Maria Paganopoulou

Thank you for creating incredible content, the effort & depth of the tangents is much appreciated!

Renfield

please look into Shaye Saint John, def late 90s/early 00s uncanny drag surreal performances. there used to be a highly interactive website made by the artist that is no longer up....

Ethan Good

Though this wasn't a Tangent topic I would have voted for (if I had voting privileges), I was pleased to see Salad Fingers, which was the first video I thought of upon reading the topic and the only video on her list I had actually seen. If anything, this video highlights the degree to which Contra lives in a completely different area of The Internet than I do, which is interesting in and of itself. Also, I enjoyed her explanation of why Inception is not surrealist at all. I had never really thought about that before.

Tasha J

Yes, same here.

Silsool

I'm happy to wait a bit more for better content, personally. It's great that you're keeping a rythm but I'm team quality

leo over monroeville

begging you to familiarize yourself with german liminal king Bernd Das Brot (Bernd the bread)...... a talking nihilistic depressed loaf of bread who was on repeat at night on the biggest german childrens tv channel

Telly

Well done👏👏👏

Emerson Whittaker

Mother, I'm watching Natalie Wynn compliment Local 58 and Katya Zamolodchikova again!

Zhakrah

I was kinda hoping you'd bring up Putrid Sex Object, with it being a horror/surreal internet video with some genderfuckery happening. Still, I had a great time parasocially reminiscing on the early internet and on Wham City Comedy's work.

Zhakrah

Yes, her old website was so cool! It's such a shame that it's barely been archived (AFAIK) one of the biggest losses of the web 3.0 era.

Luc Gendrot

I don't think it's necessarily that we'd watch you read a bus schedule, just that we are happy with whatever you do choose to put out. We're all here voluntarily and I think I speak for all your patrons when I say the last thing we want is for our patronage to create a dreaded obligation. So if that means the occasional delay, or a missed month or two, then so be it!

Lotopauanka

Not video but Sopor Aeternus for me checked all the boxes you’re talking about in this video. Year 2006?

Sappho's Friend

few people know about neoclassical dark wave lol

Lotopauanka

I thought it was gothic. But yeah, I’m the only person I know who knows them lol

Victoria H

When I was around 13 all my theater camp friends wanted to watch salad fingers and I refused and literally sat by myself in another room while they watched it bc I was so afraid of just the concept of salad fingers lol. But I do feel now that that fear was validated, so thank you for your service!

Melanie Davis-Kay

I love these types of videos and I totally thought Hand Thing/ the Shaye Saint John ouvre would be on here, but alas. Thank you for the trip down memory lane!

Lissi

Love the Dana Catherine scully era❤️

Petter Sjölund

I feel like Videodrome should be mentioned in this context, as it is really prescient about the experience of finding disturbing, possibly illegal and harmful stuff online (although it is on-the-air in the movie, of course.)

JP Burke

As someone with a psych degree, your take on Freud is incredibly interesting, as a lot of his foundational ideas have since been debunked. You still seem to rely on him for a lot of your psychoanalysis, so if possible I would love to see you do a tangent related to Mr. Freud and your relationship to his ideas and influence on modern society.

Julie Cohn Design

Tom Rubnitz was my boyfriend in art school. He and other friends of mine worked on many video projects including Freda in collaboration with Barbie Lipp and Tom Koken when they all moved to NYC. There are a series of interviews with artists who created the Pyramid Club as well as a documentary coming out about its history. There is a catalogue on Tom Rubnitz's work from a show in Paris several years ago. Tom was funny, warm, fearless and talented. He was also one of the founders of Wigstock. He is deeply missed.

Jaco

"No matter how good a mood I'm in, I cannot fly" really hits home for the bipolar girlies

Clare F

I guess they were made for BBC and aired on TV, but I first encountered Look Around You on the internet. They are a more joyful version of surrealism

Cassidy Brinn

I understood her as saying that the Garfield video isn't insipid, but rather insight into a monad à la Leibniz which contains the truth of the universe, and therefore a legitimate spiritual object of meditation. And I loved that and totally agreed and would add that a pantheism à la Spinoza might get you there too

Cassidy Brinn

I adore Blue Velvet as the frame for this tangent, thank you!

Chris&Magnus

I really enjoy videos where Natalie reacts, talks and show us videos she likes.

dogtorlog

Yes, as a psychiatrist (who is stoked about the turning of the field back toward psychotherapeutic interventions and psychodynamics) I am quite interested in Natalie's thoughts on psychoanalysis and its evolution throughout the 19th to 21st centuries. Clearly, there is a role for philosophy to play in helping my patients understand their values, identities, being, and the ways in which they make (or do not make) meaning in their lives and in this world. All that to say, PLEASE DO A PSYCHOANALYSIS VIDEO, NATALIE

Christopher

Videodrome is a *fascinating* watch for the internet era. One of the first times the descriptor "prophetic" has authentically come to mind for me.

Lauren Devine

i was waiting for you to bring up i-be area until i remembered that it's technically a film and not an internet video. would love to hear ur thoughts on ryan trecartin's work!

Petter Sjölund

Indeed. To be fair, it is also a case of reality being bad beyond the human imagination, as the most horrifying thing Cronenberg could come up with was "a tv channel that broadcasts torture 24/7 and destroys the viewer's brain" , which seems pretty tame compared to some of the stuff that can be found online today.

Mollygdala

Oh goodness, Obey The Walrus had been locked away in my memories for over a decade until now. It and the discussions around it were my first exposure to the concept of trans people as well. I think hearing your reflections on it gave a young part of me some catharsis I never knew I needed lol.

Erin Laura

Girl, you should watch drag race again.

Deconstruction Interactive

Excellent video. I love this kind of weird stuff even though it's super disturbing. Thinking about gender roles and surrealism, I think there is an argument to be made about surrealism having traditionally (in mainstream white US culture anyway) feminine themes of mystery / dream and correspondingly traditionally masculine themes of discovery / exploration / unveiling supporting the conspiracy theories you described. But it probably doesn't break down quite so cleanly if I think about it some more...

Katie

....maybe you're seeing something that was always hidden...

L

love what you said about not having to “figure out” or analyze every bit of surrealist art. i feel like sometimes people turn their analysis outward to avoid analyzing inward when it comes to art that strikes a chord.

Hellström

I don't have a whole lot to say, so I just drop a bit of my fave bits of weirdness: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GskLpgYGAX4 THAT MAN'S THUNDER by Cory McCabee. Unlike most so-called AI art, this isn't using AI to mask the creators lack of talent. Rather, a solid song is juxtaposed against the grotesque aestetics of AI generated footage. https://archive.org/details/the-cube-1969-jim-henson-movie THE CUBE (1967) by Jim Henson (The Muppet Show, The Labyrinth, etc) is an existentional horror-comedy which was comisioned to be about the television medium, but is more inspired by the (then sci-fi) idea of virtual reality (I noticed some clear inspiration from WORLD ON A WIRE) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XbwVAHPAdbo GOOFY GOAT ANTICS (1031) is one of those old cartoons which are just distilled dream logic. Everything melts and transform for no logical reason. https://web.archive.org/web/20160909034632/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ZmM-2gj5Gc The highly controversial 9/11 themed mattress commercial. This is one of those things so far out that you're just about to do a reality check. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NhevjBvlro4 WAN TOO (by Doop) is a music video combining Lolita fetish, Japanese kitch and general weirdness. It even got the much talked about checkerboard floor tiles. I guess weird music videos are a category in itself. There's BLACK HOLE SUN too, with truly crazy-ass lyrics. But the music often hides how weird they truly are.

Stephanie Billie Heard

Finally found a surreal video to share! The ballet Midsummer Night's Dream choreographed by Alexander Ekman and first performed by the Royal Swedish Opera. Certainly not ground-breaking in the surrealism discussion, but as a lifelong dancer, it was really cool to see the Joffrey Ballet in Chicago perform it this spring. It's an entertaining departure from traditional, classical technique, plot- and/or character-driven ballets. Also, it's probably full of obscure Swedish references. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4dwHxkRliTM

Edgar Allan‘s Hoe

Oh the memories of watching him for like 2 hours on New Years Eve, because it’s the only children‘s channel still broadcasting, an infinite loop of a bread, begging you to turn off the tv, and being dropped in surreal scenarios by a smug omnipotent voice

marco

TBH I did actually think the last tangent was too unedited for the length it was and I think we all appreciate your attempt to be held to some kind of temporal accountability on these things

Mary Thompson

These were all new to me and now I have to go search them all down and watch. It's an exciting new rabbit hole. Is there a list of all the videos you reference or do I just need to watch again and make my own list? I love all your tangents and other content, btw. Keep up the good work.

zambonita

Amazing video. Btw that quote about tech being indistinguishable from magic is from Arthur C Clarke.

Ruby Valentine

Ahhhh the ending voiceover you gave me goosebumps 😅😂

Aly

Amazing as always. Maybe you could alternate between tangents and AMAs? So there's video content every month but you could do a low effort AMA when you don't have time in a month to do a tangent. Or Patreon exclusive video game streams?

Wilder

hey as a teenager who likes some of the analog horror stuff on youtube, i guess i like it for some of the reasons you mentioned, it resembles youtube stuff that we watched as kids. like i think gen z may have inherited the aesthetic of vhs and other slightly earlier tech bc of it being used in weird videos online like the ones discussed in this tangent. i guess also it reminds me of how 19th century horror novels would often have a framing device to make it seem real, like in frankenstein its supposedly the captain transcribing this real story and then you the reader happen to find it. analog horror seems like a natural progression of this trope translated to film or video

Sophie Weston

These tangents are the best few dollars I spend each month. I love them so much

juliette

Had a great time watching this, thank you.

Eric Lei

I appreciate the effort you put in, and understand not wanting to mass produce mediocre content. If the deadline for tangents was promised every 2 or 3 months I would still subscribe.

leo over monroeville

he inspired me to stare at the RAUFASERTAPETE for hours...... so influential

Rachel Muir

But seriously; not to banter about definitions but I think of your representation of "surealistic" is more akin to "phantasmagoriacal". And why, with few exceptions, the connections to horror? Why not images of flying, conversations with lost loved ones, having an exchange with a tree? Amine is full of such images and you have referenced them in the past. My dreams are full the unreal but not the unpleasant.

ana

Gonna have to skip this one. Never watched salad fingers cuz it creeped me out and the clips upset me. lol will miss yall this month.

Damon Drury

someone please tell me what song MOTHER sandy crisp is singing at 24:31

Kevin

i'm so grateful for you natalie, thank you for making my queer overeducated mind feel so validated and comfortable

Tom Burke

Sallyana Grande, The Badussy War

Wilder

Omg i love opal and jack stauber in general

Shane Hall

this is “Rejected” erasure but I imagine you didn’t talk about it bc it’s too obvious

Jesse Lewis

Horrifying thing to send, but who cares what you have to say if you aren't the hottest of your extremely minority group?

J P

I really love your videos

Megan Penny

I'm obsessed with opal it's so good

Megan Penny

I love surrealism especially the kind of videos like the ones you've pulled up but I also enjoy those shitty explanation videos. For me it's not I need it explained I want to think about the media for longer almost like in fansy world building novels - you wish you could spend longer in that world. Also it can be funny and interesting to see what other people read into and focus on.

Kai Lewen

Oh wow. I lived through this while living in a different country at that time, but I didn't know it was a thing. I had two terminally online high school friends who interacted with Americans kids, so I guess it makes sense somehow (?).

Mary Bedell

The fact that John Blyth Barrymore looks so much like Leslie Feinburg is really selling the Garfield video to me

Max Hermann

Oof, this tangent sure left me unsettled. Can we extend the content warnings to: "Not suited for viewers who have to go to sleep in 30min because they have to start work at 7am."?

Max Hermann

What I'm saying is: I am feel uncomfortable.

Ivy Jenkins

I want to mention that the Youtuber Patricia Taxxon has a really fantastic video on Don't Hug me I'm Scared

Wobtax

I love The Cube! My headcanon is that he could have left when they told him to, and he caused the gorillas to exist by predicting they would be there

Jackie Walczuk

I love how this tangent coincides with a Don Hertzfeldt double feature showing in my city this month. Surrealism sure isn’t dead!

Max

So glad that run for the cube came up because I too did not stop speaking like that for MONTHS after the first time I saw it

Saint Augustin

This video feels like a Jenny Nicholson video but it was made by ContraPoints. very surreal

Jare Bozinko

I am 22, born only 2 years pre-Salad Fingers. I watched each of these videos over the course of my unrestricted youth internet access (tm) just like you did. The difference is that I was like 8 when I started discovering them 😭 these videos weren’t “kind of scary,” rather, to me at that age, I would always feel like I was going to cursèd-ly die in my sleep after watching any of them, barring pickle surprise which I only discovered as an adult (thank god .) same goes for Possibly In Michigan (double thank god.)

Jare Bozinko

these videos would have me literally praying decades of the rosary and wearing the shoulder scapular thing ( I was in catholic school at the time)

C

When I was a freshman in high school back in the early 2010s, my art teacher would take recommendations for videos about art to play at the beginning of class. I emailed him the original “don’t hug me I’m scared,” and thought I might get in trouble. On the last day of school, he played it to my class of largely apathetic seniors who were just trying to get their required elective credits and they lost their minds in disgust and horror. It was beautiful.

Clara Korfmacher

Really? I actually found it to be one of my absolute favorites! I kinda loved to to follow her train of thought through this insane overlap of esoteric and fascism. Maybe it's a taste thing. Did you like this one better?

Izzy Wakeman

Anyone know the song Goddess Bunny was lip syncing to? It sounds so familiar

Isaac_Enver

Local58 is one of my favourite analog horrors, I've also noticed an uptick in analog horror on TikTok and this weird infection au storytelling in media like Peppa Pig, Horrid Henry and My Little Pony: FIM. Fascinating stuff really.

Wendy

lol I did nope out of salad fingers (though I remember the red water line), which might explain why I haven't seen any of the rest of these

Emily E Crawford

This topic is perfect for you. I know it isn’t an internet video per se, but “Possibly in Michigan” found new life online and reminds me of so many of the videos you discuss here.

Անդրանիկ Սարեան

Watching this made me think of 'Skinamarink'. I know it's probably not going to win but I'd love to hear your hot takes on that film.

Pauline Drillet

I watched this just after waking up from a dream where I met with a friend who had totally different face from her own but still it was absolutely her… I think a movie that’s better at conveying the absurdity of dreams is The science of sleep by Michel Gondry.

Oscar De León

Hey Natalie, I really loved this tangent, this whole thing about the relationship of surrealism with the need to decode hidden messages reminded me one of my favourit films, the 2018 Under the Silver Lake, by director David Robert Mitchell, I think it portrays a sector of people who grew up under the influence of pop culture and conspiracism, in addition to other topics such as male gaze, pornography the exploitation of people in the medium of spectacle and the nihilism of millionaires. I hope this can contribute to the dialogue and analysis. Greetings from a teenager who grew up with surreal videos on the internet.

Jenny Robins

I'm an Art teacher and I've been giving my year 7s (I think 6th grade is American equivalent) some free reign at the end of the year. One group is drawing an enormous skibidi toilet head. I would never have known to encourage them without your education. Thank you.

Elin Lennox

Would it be possible to post a picture?

Trevor Young

Need Natalie's opinion on I Saw the TV Glow

Ola Biskup

Hi Natalie would you ever consider doing an episode on Sex Work considering both the pro SW and Abolitionist (ie Nordic Model) sides of the issue? I’m curious what your thoughts are, but I’d absolutely understand a „no” from you since it is a very controversial topic. xoxo gossip girl

Silsool

Hey Contra, I was listening to your interview with Adam and your mention of the predator/prey dynamic in het couples reminded me of this manga/anime called Beastars, which explicitly explores this subject. You should give it a watch if you haven't already (and if you have time) :)

pidge

i watched this high off my ass, it really enhanced the experience and i’m scared to go to sleep.

Mark keogh

I love what you say about Lynch. ‘Stop trying to explain it.’ That’s why I like it so much. Intellect is totally overrated.

jesse sa

the wonderful thing about having a terrible memory is getting to experience all of these for the first time again just vaguely knowing i've seen them before, truly every day is new to me

jesse sa

except run for the cube... i'd never forget you run for the cube 💚

Adam Finch

Other good examples of when something that should be surreal but has its surrealism explained away by a logical structure to the inexplicable are the British series Look Around You, and the Don Hertzfeld cartoons, Rejected. Like Inception, the elements are dream like and surreal but through being framed as instructional videos or rejected cartoons the artists intentions are alway present.

Carrie Gavin

We just watched the interview yesterday.

Samantha Snow

Absolutely adored this tangent! I too was molded by bizarre pre-youtube and early youtube videos. I kept expecting you to talk about Shaye Saint John's Hand Thing since that's a formative surrealist video for me, but honestly a lot of the topics you addressed in the other videos (gender ambiguity, body horror) could be applied to Hand Thing.

Saoirse

Speaking for myself, I am just excited to be able to experience your videos wherever they come out. I know it's always a balance of quantity vs. quality, but I wouldn't feel too bad erring on the latter side. It's not like we don't have content to tide us over; your existing videos give us plenty to still learn, ponder, and enjoy upon rewatch. Honestly if you just wanted to share little updates about how your research process is going or a randomly selected Q&A session, that would be great!

Maryanne

I just wanted you to know I only started an account with Patreon because I saw the interview where you stated that you had extra videos on here and I can’t get enough of your content. This video is wonderful - salad fingers was such a wild ride

Rob

I’ll vote to forgive your tangent debt in exchange for your next video being about Satanism ❤️

Kevin

ily natalie

Kevin

ur da best

Danika Neubauer

Honestly one of my favourite tangents. I’ve watched it countless times and do not plan on stopping. This is my pipe strip.

Miriam Sved

These tangents make me feel sorry for everyone not on your Patreon

Alex Iacuzzo

mother we yearn for the july tangent

Oscar Q.

Tik tok Ms.Points we're waiting eagerly for the next tangent

Bookreader

I must share this with my 13-year-old who has always had a love of the weird, surreal, and macabre.

Delfina

This video, despite coming out over a month ago, feels like it "came to me" at the perfect time. I don't think I could emotionally explain it, but I want to thank you for it. I love hearing your thoughts on just about anything, but this was a particularly fun one. Now to catch up on the other tangents!

Allison Reneé

I hope you’re okay. Love your content a lot. You mean a lot to a lot of people.

Delfina

Coming to back to say, would absolutely love to hear you talk more about fiction, horror, and the like. This and your liminal spaces video have been my favorite so far. So soo fun as a fellow eerieness enjoyer

StarIsALittleWeird

There already is! It's part of the Envy video. Starts at 1:06:03 :)

Antonio Calvo Elorri

Missing so much this month's tangent, is there going to be one?

Maya

Really missing and desiring a project 2025 or similarly political analysis video of where the alt right headspace is. I know you’ve moved away from your debates with Tiffany Tumbles and Tabby and such but I loved granola fascism because it felt so true to your older content.

Emily

I think a video on the liberals who don't seem to realize 'project 2025' has been tacitly cosigned by every democratic president who didn't codify your rights into law when they had ample opportunity would do you more good. Or one on how it's a not-so-secret bipartisan tactic to hold those rights over your head, and keep you in a binary system that requires you to choose between two genocidal imperialists who will both use your tax dollars to carpet bomb refugee camps full of Palestinian families. But if your content preferences are driven mostly by nostalgia, and if right-wing rhetoric makes you angry but not pretty much every democrat continuing to fund the most digitally documented ethnic cleansing in world history for 9 months, then I'm likely barking up the wrong tree. I was a 'blue no matter who' 4 years ago, fully agreed with Natalie's video on how voting is a strategic choice, but the landscape has changed since the era you want to return to. Anyone paying attention has realized at this point that fixating on the alt-right symptom of the larger imperialist disease is myopic 2019 dialogue and serves mostly to make us feel like the good guys in a valiant fight against evil. Rather than increasingly powerless expendable citizens who need to divest from it and show that we have collective power, instead of acting from a place of short-sighted desperation and continuing to enable it.

Tasha

@emily But why not work towards all that great stuff, while also having a democrat as president? I can’t imagine that another Trump presidency will make your goals any *easier*, correct?

Maya

please chill, I get you discovered leftist ideology and you're (or at least present as) a white woman and from the bottom of my mother fucking and father fucking heart that must be super fucking hard for you. I went through my hardcore communist moment at like 15 years old partly bc I'm a trans POC n white supremacy is a fact of life for ppl like me. but who the fuck said I'm a liberal or am angry about the alt right or thinking that Kamala Harris is gonna save my godforsaken life. White supremacy isn't news to me babes. i don't need to watch a video about liberals n imperialists n genocide bc that's my whole goddamn life, plus people like you spewing the talking points you learned a few months ago bc you were enlightened from the 2020 BLM movement because you need to see POC bloodshed to believe in white supremacy. If you must know. I love the alt right videos because it gives me insight into a life I know little about. Extremists end up with similar ideology, it's best imo to learn the talking points, the dogwhistles, and I enjoy developing a deep understanding of what they're talking about and why they believe what they believe. Also helps if you know people who accidentally stumble upon some alt right rhetoric that seems convincing, which happens surprisingly often.

ContraPoints

There is a little Justice Part 2 in Envy, but I’ve been considering another video on a similar topic too

Aaron Stier-Cohen

everyone deserves a daddy. you can have Freud. your flaws make you human ❤️

Aaron Stier-Cohen

this is a banger. ❤️ you could reword it to be less scoldy and more about your own preferences but it's still a banger.

Alamareth

It's funny because it is your videos that I am watching being high. It is like a super smart, surreal late night therapy. I love your stuff, it's banger ❤️

Doctor Tony

Natalie is the best! Time to rewatch the liminal spaces video.

Teageen

@emily i agree with you for the most part. do you have any suggested actionables for this?

Teageen

Thank you for bringing this to my attention. I strive to be as informed as possible on these important issues, and I apologise for this oversight.

Nihilore

new patron here, loved this retrospective of the kind of shit me and my mates would share with each other in the mid 2000s. some weird nostalgia here

Evelyn

GARFIELD SHIRT

Mikayla Holland

My friend’s little sister who is maybe 12 made this short film recently that was soooo surreal and creepy and it was the strongest “the kids are alright” moment I’ve had in a while. It’s really unsettling like analog horror but the whole plot is just that they brushed their big fluffy dog and froze the hair it shed in a ziploc bag, and then got one of the neighbors to take it. That’s the whole plot.

rj

I love the texture and the spookiness of digitized records and wax cylinders from the 1900's. Something far enough in the past or depicting a far enough future has a perceived classic timelessness.

Novak Radic

I can't describe it in a very eloquent way, but i am extremely terrified by these videos. These for me are not eerie or slightly creepy, they are ouright horrifying. I had anxiety/paranoia for hours after watching. Salad fingers made me have nightmares for several nights in a row as a child. I don't know what this is about. Maybe i'm just a sensitive SJW who can't handle the macabre?

The Noid Master

This video is BEGGING for a caveat on disability and surrealism. All the stuff about body horror and what bodies are and are not correct and the horror of sickness and the boundaries between the dead and the living. !!! so interesting

sammy

u have always scratched this rly particular itch in my brain that no other YouTuber can scratch. ily.

Tormuse

Random thing: I was reminded of your surreal video tangent by a video game I saw called "Amanda the Adventurer," which centres around a found footage style VHS cassettes of an old children's show that gets increasingly unhinged as the story goes along. Could be a good game to stream for Hallowe'en, maybe. :)

Ish The Dark Lotus

I was thinking about this too, especially with the faces. Aside from being unethical, I think disability horror is just cheap, similar to jump scares or gore. It triggers a primal part of our brain, but beyond that, there isn't anything deeper in it. Aside from that, there is often a fear of old people, with crones and witches having aging bodies, and also fear of identical twins. I am also wondering about commentary on cyberpunk with proesthetic arms and limbs and how it effects social views on disability.

Alfred Jaremko Young

I think naked lunch by david cronenberg does a really good job of being "dreamlike" - for instance the protagonist accidentally kills his wife early on in the movie only for her to reappear later as somebody else's wife but the two sort of recognize each other and elope iirc

Beatka Absalon

Made me remember all the "rathergood" videos like "Frightened Boy"

Feid

around 34 mins in you mention dopplegangers- another important aspect of surrealism is repetition (freud talks ab this when he analyzed the uncanny), and I think repetition shows up in a lot of these videos :)

Zoë Collis

Wait which parts of leviticus is Natalie referring to at 40:45 ish

Lisa D

Have you read A Sunny Place for Shady People by Mariana Enríquez? It’s a collection of surreal and unsettling short stories that a lot of these videos gave me vibes of. I really enjoyed the book.

Paola Nicoll Alzuru Castillo

I would scream of euphoria if my two worlds collide like that, I've already recommended her Cortázar in the liminal tangent. It would be amazing if she reads those amazing argentinian authors

Jessicka Anne

If you loved this tangent - watch “Hug the Sun” series on YouTube. So many excellent surrealist tropes.

L E

I genuinely got so much out of this video. It has helped me enjoy surreal film so much more and expanded my thinking about these kinds of videos. Thank you and I hope you feel called to make more videos like this at some point

ro cull

loved this! as someone from outside the US who did their dissertation on analog horror, i adore the Morthamshire County Council channel. you're exposed to old images of American TV all the time through movies and different media but there was something chilling about seeing an unnerving account of a surrealist news story, using the bumpers and TV channels I grew up with. completely threw me off guard and made it all seem the more real, which then made it feel unreal. definitely check out the dont hug me im scared tv show if you haven't yet. its surprisingly hilarious!

Julie

I’m a little jealous of anyone who got to experience this internet as it occurred.

poopee doodee

genuinely so scared after the first two entries. 🫣🫣🫣🫣🫣

raggedy-jenna

Well I'll definitely be checking out Lasagna Cat. Missed out on that one during its prime

Viviane P.L.

I would never have guessed conspiracy video seedlings here

phastinemoon

I don’t think that you’re too sensitive, it’s probably just that you have a higher sensitivity TO THIS, which isn’t a bad thing - like how some people are more sensitive to hot and cold foods, or some people have a higher tolerance for bitterness or sourness or spice. I’m willing to bet there’s stuff that makes me squirm that you probably shrug off - it’s okay!

Novak Radic

Thanks for the encouraging reply. Yeah, it could just be hypersensitivity to this particular type of content - maybe it’s the fact it doesn’t only scare, but also deeply disturbs the soul.

Ahri Clevinger

Is there a creepy lady in your fireplace?

Sara Irisz Papp

I think the katya video reflects upon the German tradition of life circle representations.

AJ

Watching this as part of my Halloween festivities

Nicky

I’m late to watching your tangents but I enjoy them a lot 💚 thank you for all your work!