Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I’m sure we’ve all (Americans, everyone else who’s affected) taken three days to wallow. The day of not getting out of bed. The day of substance abuse and doomscrolling. The day of playing Skyrim for 14 hours. I don’t feel ready to get up and face the situation, but I think I’d better.

I’m not very interested in the various autopsies of “what went wrong.” The Democrats were too woke. Or not woke enough. They should have turned to the camera and specified they’re the exact kind of communist I am.

Trying to reason with or about the American public feels like trying to use Kantian ethics to explain to Ted Bundy why he shouldn’t kill you.

Reason won’t save us. Probably the best thing that could happen now is if SNL runs a sketch implying that Donald is a tinydick babyboy cuckold on the leash of the Heritage Foundation. Project 2025 would be scrapped the next day.

I’m grasping for crumbs of solace here. Elon Musk, RFK Jr., JD Vance—probably some pleasure will be had watching all these vampires suck each other dry. The Republican Party is a cult of personality, and the personality is 78 years old. We’re waiting for one miserable old man do die, and then we get another chance to replace him with something less horrible.

In the meantime things will get very bad very quickly. 2025 is not 2017. This time Trump is backed by a detailed plan to remake the government in his image, and by a Supreme Court that has granted him immunity to do anything he wants. He’s also likely to appoint two more justices, meaning that for the rest of my life the judiciary will be ruled by this man’s ghost.

I’ve been trying to figure out if there’s a future for me in this country as a trans person in media, and if there are any plausible alternatives. I’ve updated my passport and other documents in case I need to leave quickly. More realistic scenarios include a blanket ban on gender-affirming care, in which case I’ll have to hope I’m protected by the blue state I live in, or resort to DIY methods.

Project 2025 plans to criminalize pornography, and it defines all LGBT-affirming content as pornography. So there may be some threat to my career. It’s possible I’ll have to take down a lot of videos and avoid “promoting” anything L, G, B, and/or T in the future. If making videos is even still viable or worth doing at that point.

I’m aware that I’m very far from those most vulnerable to these things. More likely scenarios involve total bans on schools teaching anything about LGBT existence, bans on using students’ chosen names/pronouns, etc. In which case non-institutional online content will be among the only resources young LGBT people have. And in that case, I’d better step it up, not pull back.

We could spiral about this forever. I know these thoughts are inadequate. How could they be? I haven’t scratched the surface—reproductive rights, mass deportation, Ukraine, replacing vaccination with colloidal silver or homeopathic essence of bear brain or whatever else RFK Jr. thinks is medicine. Etc. etc. etc.

Today I’m going to get back to work on the video I’ve been making since April. It’s not explicitly about The Situation, but... it’s not unrelated.

Thank you all as always for supporting me, and for supporting each other. Stay strong.

-Natalie

Comments

Lov3maker

I read "the situation" and thought the next tangent is going to be on the jersey shore.

dm

just imagine if kamala ran on something like the four-day workweek or lowering the retirement age :/

Ashton

In solidarity 💛

Adam Clark

Sending so much love to you Natalie. I’m not in the US but I feel desperate sympathy for everyone who’s going to struggle under this regime. Please be well and thank you for all the good you do. ❤️

Leon

🩷

mz givings

Thank you for everything that you do. I can't overstate how meaningful it is 🤍🤍🤍

Allison Otting

Take care of yourselves and others, everybody. Community is sometimes going to be all we have.

India

I’ve been doomscrolling to your incel video in the background to keep me grounded

DoggoDuck

We love you Natalie. ♥️ The right can’t tell a joke to save their lives, you’re funny and brilliant. Make the left cool again. That’s what you do.

Pidge

I have nothing to say but a deep thank you for writing this.

Miles Nerenberg

I admire you so much Natalie. Thank you.

Thilda

Im so sorry. For you and everyone else subjected to this godawful government in the future. But in spite of that, or even especially because of this - thank you for everything you do. It truly means so much.

Fan Fan

We are all really scared right now. Please stay strong.

Robert Snader

I'm still working out, "did America vote for him despite of him quoting Hitler, or did they vote for him because of it."

Freyaok

We love you. Please care of yourself.

SophieT

Thank you for the considered and super relatable reply. It makes me significantly happier to know you are moving forward with the stuff that brings you joy and helps literally everyone see more clearly. Much love and hugs,

Max

Thank you for this post. The first paragraph is definitely something I empathize with. Everything just feels heavier, more difficult. I hadn’t smoked a cigarette in years but broke down this week. It’s awful, I’m petrified I’ll lose my job because of my sexuality. I’m scared for my safety and the safety of the whole community.

Sophie!

Thank you for your words, your videos have been a comfort!

Grace Carroll

Across the pond - I can't imagine how you feel right now and I'm so, so, sorry. I'm thinking of trans people in the US every day right now. Your content is really important and I hope you carry on as long as you can, but even if you have to stop for whatever reason, I hope you always know that what you do really matters. I discovered your stuff when I was 18. It's changed everything about the way I think about gender. This stuff matters. Stay safe.

Jenni

Lots of love from the UK, can't imagine how hard things are over there right now ❤️

Dakota Harwood

Our brains are aligned. Thank you for continuing to get up off the floor, I’ll be doing the same. We can’t just roll over and die like they want us to.

Valerie

I'm not sure what to say, the words that come to mind don't do anything any justice. Just. Love you, lots. Even beyond the parasocial aspect of this, I'm glad to know of you and forever grateful that you decided to share your mind with us.

Alice Distelberger

If you do decide to move, Vienna would be a great shout. Good trans healthcare, great music, art, and the Freud Museum.

Lily Stein

thank you always for your words❤️

JulianL

Dark times ahead. Stay strong, stay safe.

CharleyB

Thank you for continuing what you do. I myself took two days off of work and had to jump back into the fire yesterday. It was a slog to get through. And the next few weeks, months, and years will be even harder. I'm rooting for everyone out there. We will not let this stop us. I will need some stronger THC stocked up ASAP, but Imma get it together to fight for all of us in the future.

kaje

Much love to you and hoping for the best in this crazy country!!

Boi Anachronism

Yep i had this conversation with my family. It could get very dangerous for me to live here very quickly and i am in the southern united states as well.

Derodek

It's real crazy out there. Stay safe

woahnelly

Sending love from the UK ❤️ I'm so sorry

Espresso Afterglo

Thank you Natalie for your words. I know this was probably hard to write. I've been grapping and grasping for some sort of solace as well. The only thing I can think of is: learned helplessness is the mode they want us to be in. I'm not done mourning, being exhausted, crying. I'm trying to address my maslow's hierarchy first. Today I was able to sleep for 10 hours finally after weeks of restless nights (thank you hydroxyzine), and the only thing I can do right now is keep myself as healthy and clearheaded as possible. I'm getting angry though and the other thing I can think of is to be as loud and annoying as possible, and use my privilege to my advantage. I have no conclusion to my ramble. So. Solidarity. Forever.

José Luis Batres

My heart goes out to all my American pals, and to anyone whose life will be affected in the coming years. Truly hoping for a better future. Maybe reason will not save us, but let's help each other keep our sanity. And thanks for all you do Natalie.

Dylan

sending my heart from Canada . i can only imagine the fear, but the work only gets more important each day

Tuesday Sellers

I hope you find the strength to keep going and keep making things. I think that's going to be the only weapon a lot of us have 💖

Tivvv3

Here's hoping RFK Jr. will get to seriously improve the US health situation at least.

Kylie

thank you mother

Tyler Ray

Can anyone explain to me what exactly he plans to do regarding LGBT rights? I try not to follow politics as it’s so polarizing and find it difficult to find the truth.

Ethan Good

I really like the idea of a political sketch about Trump being cucked by The Heritage Foundation. Just imagining that has improved my mood.

Rumen Dimitrov

Natalie, having found you all these years ago and supporting you til this day I want to thank you for everything you've given me as philosopher, psychologist and a general aesthete. You are one of the people who made me fall back in love with academia and made me the empathetic and not so quick go judge person I am today. I hope these words bring you some joy and I hope for the best for you, for me and the rest of our community. Thank you.

F.

these past few days i keep coming back to what you said about self care in the spirituality tangent, and what you said in gender critical: "that, right there, is the single greatest quality of trans-feminine culture, the resilience of trans women" i'm cis but the whole community needs this resilience, trans people for themselves and cis lgbt people so we can stand with you. we all love you so much 🤍

Jenny Rodriguez

Please, don't leave the US, Natalie, many other countries are shifting right as well and may not remain LGBT friendly for long, you will probably be insulated from the majority of things that will come, I'm not saying it will be bad, but realistically that's the truth, I think people need your guidance the most and best to face it head on.

TV

May the world weather this storm, and have enough remaining to rebuild after. Gods willing, we will overcome this.

Gautam Madhivanan

Definitely going to be a dark 4 years. Seems like there are going to be a lot of people that are going to need mutual aid of some kind. So hopefully those who stay here can get involved in organizations to provide that support.

Thomas Kerr

I’m from Ireland and I remember you saying you’d consider emigrating here. I’d advise against it. Housing is extortionate. Musicians etc emigrate so there’s not much culture you can see. Go to Scotland if you want the nice people and the pleasant British-Isles-but-not-England thing (my plan lol)

highclass_lady

Natalie you have my support! Please take as good care of yourself as possible in the days ahead. Please know that you are not alone & you will always be appreciated no matter how visible your work is. As a longtime friend told me "you deserve to live the best you can & thrive more than he [Trump] does, or they [consertives, republicans, the alt right] do (they don't)! I want to outlive Trump so I can laugh & toast champagne when I've outlasted him." In other words, one of the ways you beat them is by living your best life & being so much better than those who hurt you. Wishing you only the best always & will continue to be here to support you! 💜💜💜

dm

i think that there if you are looking for hope and solace imagining an alternative can be helpful. otherwise all we have is some inexplicable horror that happened for no reason. she is not wrong to feel her feelings though

Anton

I hope art and the community will bring you some solace these days, stay strong Natalie and all US folks; do not go gentle into that good night ✊

Ruby Power

You're such an inspiration to me as well to many others on here. I understand this is a very tough reality many in the US are facing and will face in future but I want you to know that your efforts and content haven't been for nothing. Thank you for everything.

Luigi Cree

Take one day at the time ❤️‍🩹

Alan Macedo

Sending love to US friends from Europe x

Tivvv3

I'd be surprised if Trump does much of anything to do with Project 2025 but let's see.

Karen

Love all your work, Natalie! Stay strong and stay safe!

Jax Lynx

Love you Natalie. I'm free from the peppermint oil-guzzling Christian transphobes (and now enjoying The Mouthfeel) in large part because of your work. We are scared too. And we have your back all the way.

Dinah Sanders

Stay strong. Stay safe. Keep your voice alive, strategically silent if necessary. I'm channeling my fear energy into cooking and inviting friends over for soup. It's a good time for us all to strengthen our in-person connections and learn about mutual aid, and would be so due to natural disaster risks even if Harris had won. Adding defiant rewatches of our favorite Contrapoints episodes seems like a good additional seasoning.

demolitionwoman

I understand it feels inadequate, but reading your words does give me a feeling of commiseration and solidarity, and that does help a little. Appreciate you 💖

Daniel

Not Austrian, but I was in Vienna last month, and so many parts of (the tourist parts of) that city looked like the set of a Contrapoints video ❤️

Carly Fries

I would recommend looking into the kinds of things Florida has done over the last couple years as a rubric. Trans people can be arrested for using bathrooms in Florida, they can be charged with fraud for having their gender identities on drivers licenses, gender affirming care has been all but banned for everyone (it's still technically available bit only if prescribed by PHD Physicians where previously RNs could also prescribe). That's in addition to the don't say gay bill and all the banning of books that have lgbt characters in it from both school and public libraries. I don't like to throw the word fascism around, but it's pretty fucking fascist.

August Ellis

We must not panic or spiral. Project 2025 will not accomplish its goals without severe resistance.

Julia

I'm not American, but this whole mess is so disheartening to watch, I can't even begin to imagine how you're feeling right now. Thank you for all that you do, and please take care! I'm sending lots of love and strength your way 🤍🫂

F.

take away gender affirming care, keep trans women out of sports, 'eradicate transgenderism' (his words) and project 2025 says something about banning pornography, which affects queer, especially trans people, in the way natalie explained in this post

Donovan M Grant

I won’t give up. I’ll spend the rest of my life fighting for equality, for all of us. Your work has inspired me to keep it up, and whatever you decide to do next, I thank you for giving me the fuel to keep going ✊🏾❤️

Suse Zink Diesel

I really really hope you are right, but we have to prepare for the worst.

Gart Kundalini

From one shell shocked heart to another. It's probably time to say some Oms.

Nathan Sundkvist

You are a huge inspiration to me and many, many others. You have the ability to inspire change. But remember that your own safety is always a priority. We all need to support each other during these times. Sending you love and support from Finland. <3

Monica Cruz

Thank you Natalie 💜💚💛

elliehotsauce

Honestly Natalie you should just build an underground bunker for trans people at this point. Fallout new vegas wasn’t a meme for trans people - it was a premonition. we yearn for the vault & you as our overseer

Daniel

The result, especially the popular vote, was gutting to watch as a straight-ish cis person in Australia. I cannot fathom how hard it would have been for trans and other vulnerable Americans. My heart goes out to you all.

infinitygaze

As a friend across the pond, I’m sorry to see this outcome. Your work was a breath of fresh air when you arrived in the midst of the anti-feminist online poop heap that was YouTube in the mid-2010s and your videos and thoughts have been a great comfort to me over the years. Take heart that there are millions of us that will never stop fighting for a just world. Sending solidarity and love.

GracethofMoon

Natalie, you are incredible and we will all be working to help each other survive, and ultimately thrive. I look forward to what you have coming for us next. 🫶🏻🫶🏻

Pamela Thays

Sending love from Brazil. It is really sad to see such great country with amazing people suffer in the hands of oligarchs and irresponsible governments. The once land of freedom and opportunities is turning it's back to it citizens, to the people that help build the nation. Please take care of yourself and stay strong.

Frostfalls

Thank you Natalie. I happened to already be in the process of moving to Japan before the election. It's a bittersweet feeling. On one hand leaving to a more stable, peaceful place is a big plus. On another, some guilt weighs on me as someone who is many spots farther down the chopping block (cis white gay man) than some of my friends. It feels like I'm leaving them to the wolves.

Madison

It's gonna get dark. We need to lean on this community to spread information about what's happening and where.

Leo Kyle

It's been a shitshow of horror oh dear. One option is: You would certainly be accepted in Taiwan, since you would qualify for a gold card, since you have demonstrably contributed to the online commons for more than eight years (which is one of the conditions for obtaining such a card). In any case, keep sane and keep well. We'll al come out the other side of this

Katie

Natalie--you are one of the people I look to to make sense of things, and I hope this will continue to be a viable path for you. If you determine it no longer is at any point, I understand and support you completely. I desperately wish these were not our circumstances. We have to do the best we can, and then the best we can after that. It will be hard.

AltoTheleo

Thank you for not coddling your audience. We need to be ready, and we need to plan, act, and react, but I'm sick and tired of people trying to assure us we'll be ok. We won't be unless we're ready. We won't be ok unless we make sure that we take charge in being ok. We won't be ok just because we say we'll be ok. Stay safe, you, and everyone else here. Prepare. Help each other. Love each other.

Kitty

The best we can hope for is the fact that fascist regimes always implode as the circle of who isn’t the “other” gets smaller and smaller. If you can leave, I won’t blame you or anyone who does. As a disabled queer Enby with no money, that isn’t an option for me. So I am going to stay and fight until they put me into a camp. I will not go quietly, I will do all I can for as long as I am able to. I’ll also be getting a passport as an emergency contingency and hope death camps would wake other countries up enough to allow refugees. I hope it doesn’t come to this. We fought, but we failed. FDR was right and the further the dems got from New Deal policies and actually providing for the working class Americans the easier it was to slip into fascism. It also doesn’t help that the Right has a media apparatus of oligarch and foreign backed channels that drip feed propaganda to the masses. Most of the top podcasts and twitch/youtube channels are some flavour of right wing. The Left doesn’t have that. Legacy media also failed us by focusing on every gaffe of the dems and ignoring the obvious decline of the Mango Mussolini. They did not explain the consequences of a trump presidency nor the benefits of a Harris one. For fucks sake most Americans have no clue what a fucking tariff is. The Mainstream Media has a financial incentive to help trump because he brings eyeballs to screens and clicks to links allowing them to capitalise on ad revenue. The Dems didn’t help that because they SUCK at messaging. Kamala leaned into the Cheney endorsement and didn’t utilise the populist juggernaut they had in Walz. It was all for naught, since they didn’t budge the republicans in any meaningful way. The “Left” is already being blamed. Trans people are being blamed. EVERYONE but the people that did this: the corporate dems running to the right. Going forward all we can do it try to survive and make sure we look out for each other. We are not alone, millions voted on the right side of history. Stay safe Natalie.

Kapelski

For your own sake, move to the EU. You'll get a good fresh start there. Also everyone pray for Ukraine. I'm a finnish reservist myself and I don't think it's too unlikely that I'll have to defend my country and the rest of NATO with my own blood if Trump has his way. Times seem so grim right now.

Goobzilla91

Wishing you all the best from overseas. It's a tough fucking time in the US and now more so. But what fills me with hope for this community is that they can't stop us all. There's too many people liberated to go back into hiding and it won't be the Orwellian nightmare as they'll try to push. You yanks are all strong and you Natalie are a fuckin warrior. You can do this and we have faith in you 🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍⚧️

Bogo

A good post, thanks. Whether you like it or not, people look to you to speak some sense in all this insanity. The world needs you, but for that to happen you gotta take care of numero uno first.

Androgynous Slut

Ty for everything you do Natalie. I started hrt 2 months ago and your content was an important part of my self discovery

ChrissiX

I decided on 7 days of mourning for my country and then I get busy, not sure what yet but that's the plan. I need a breath.

ElenaM

Watching this happen from Europe, I felt a great sense of anxiety and powerlessness. As hard as it is to deny the gravity of the situation and the uncertainty that the future holds, I think it can't be understated how much importance the work produced by people like you hold, for queer people nationally and abroad. Please don't let the situation take that away from you. Take care and stay strong.

ChrissiX

In the DC area (NoVa) if anyone needs a friend.

MokaCola

on the contrary, the past few days have been the first I've spent sober in a long time. I'm trying to be proactive and doing what I can to contribute to my local community so we can set up a community defense network should it be needed (and even in the past few years it has been.) Now more than ever it's time for everyone to get out of their bubbles and reach out, provide their skills and learn new ones, and prepare for things to get as bad as you can imagine them getting. Keep your head on tight, times are going to get tough, and we might need to fight tooth and nail to survive, but for your life and the lives of others, it's worth it.

Seabass

I understand the fear but that shouldn’t mean going into the fear. The next step is making us as loud as possible. Even if Project 2025 gets everything passed, it will still fail because it doesn’t help the people one bit. They were duped into scapegoating once again and we have to teach to break the cycle. Nobody is immune to propaganda but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t educate. I’d say now more then ever, we need to live out of spite to remind them that erasing us is a forever losing battle

Jack Pilate

It’s hard to buy that this is just an education issue when it seems that more than half of Trump voters just don’t think of us as humans…

Flatlander Woman

I remember you were quoting Milton in your video about the 2016 election. The quote started itching in the back of my mind and inspired me to consult how I may henceforth most offend my enemy, which kind of helped

AuxMulder

I have Type I Osteogenesis Imperfecta, which means I’ve broken my bones a lot and also derailed trains looking for Bruce Willis. I am worried about my insurance. I’m worried about my best friend who is gay. I’m worried about all the women I know, and everyone who isn’t white. As a Californian, that’s pretty much everyone. There’s a lot of unknowns in front of us, and there are a lot of knowns that are terrifying to think about. But what we know is we, the left, and decent liberals, libertarians, and SOME Never-Trump Republicans, and maybe best of all, those genuine gun-toting Libertarians. We all have each other. We have time to make contingency plans, organize, and get ready. Ultimately, we’re all team. I’m down to experience new and exciting forms of pain in the streets. I wish there was more we can offer each other in terms of reassurance. This all sucks. For now all we’ve got are words. I am a huge fan. I admire you, Ms. Wynn. I love any and all of ya’ll reading this. Hug your animals and friends and families. Take care.

The Bilderberg Group

I appreciate everything you do for us as a voice for non-idiocy. Since the election I have found the most comfort in returning to taoist ideas and especially the old parable of the farmer and the horse Once upon a time there was a farmer whose horse ran away. That evening, all of his neighbors came around to commiserate. They said, “We are so sorry to hear your horse has run away. This is most unfortunate.” The farmer said, “Maybe.” The next day the horse came back bringing seven wild horses with it, and in the evening everybody came back and said, “Oh, isn’t that lucky. What a great turn of events. You now have eight horses!” The farmer again said, “Maybe.”  The following day his son tried to break one of the horses, and while riding it, he was thrown and broke his leg. The neighbors then said, “Oh dear, that’s too bad,” and the farmer responded, “Maybe.” The next day the conscription officers came around to conscript people into the army, and they rejected his son because he had a broken leg. Again all the neighbors came around and said, “Isn’t that great!” Again, he said, “Maybe.” Stay strong everyone, don't give in to despair.

Agathe Bouquillon

It must be so dreadful, take care of yourself Natalie. In France, the far Right is getting closer and closer to the control of the state, like in others countries around me. The world is a frightening place to live nowadays. I don't know what to say, but I hope that the fascist agenda won't happen in all the USA. Keep safe !

Jack Pilate

same here! I’m in MD and I’m planning on meeting (just for social stuff atm nothing too actionable) with some folks from Progressive Victory, if you’d like to check it out

Brooke Chappell

Word on not being interested in autopsies rn. The media world feels like the part in the second act of “Into the Woods” where everyone is trying to blame everyone else and defend their own choices, and I feel like the Witch hissing “WHO CARES.” I’m battening down my hatches and looking to get involved with mutual aid groups. Don’t know what else I can do right now. Glad you’re in a better-than-some position and have your passport, and I look forward, as always, to hearing what you have to say.

Laura Torlaschi

The idea that your politics and ethics are based on wanting people to think you’re cool is so funny lmaoo

Laura Torlaschi

Joining my local chapter of DSA really helps alleviate the dread, fwiw

Tivvv3

Yeah. Might be time to think about party agnostic organizing as well to at least have some control over preventing the worst outcomes and don't they all have some good and some awful points? No need to tie yourself to some party machine just because it plays to your most important aspirations and fears. Life is vast.

Laura Torlaschi

Guy who sees people having emotional reactions: erm, the left is kind of cringe (unlike me)

Tivvv3

Something like that. I'd prefer people did more party agnostic organizing and Contrapoints' post makes me think she's never thought about this before...

Sunflower Goblin

We are all stronger together. Use this despair to feed the hope that the people, united, can overcome this and reclaim humanity for all. Look up leftist organizations, and join one. Make friends with socialists/communists. Start reading, NOW.

Agron

Trans people are less than 1% of the american population and Trump's campaign spent millions of dollars towards anti trans ads. The 'both sides' shit is so fucking corny and apathetic. I think every queer person, woman, poor person, poc, is well within their right to be massively disappointed in their country and fearful for the social, political and economic future given this outcome. weirdo.

Katherine De Chant

We’re here for you, Natalie. Whatever you decide to do, you’ve already built a steadfast community of people who are all better off for having encountered you. We’ll be behind you, fighting with you or for you, no matter what happens.

Austin F

i think blue states have a bit of a buffer right now, especially considering their recent tendency to specifically codify rights into law, but i can't imagine how catastrophic it might get for people in red states :/ it feels very strange, because i'm from northern virginia (fellow DMV resident lol), and i feel like i can officially call this a blue state now considering it was Democrat in both 2016 and 2024. so the surreal part is that if this happened in 2004 instead of 2024, i would be one of the people in the worst spots. it's just odd to think about. i just realized. virginia is liminal. god damn it.

Cassandra Snyder

Thanks for the message. I think what the left needs to do right now is to solidify our communities. I will support you, and anyone else that needs it.

Kenny Le

Two days after the election, I did that as well. I'm looking forward to doing something, anything, other than watching everything burn to the ground.

Sunflower Goblin

Then join a real leftist organization that ailgns with your views and start making connections with other communists. Don't leave the left because you haven't physically connected with the revolutionary peoples of it.

Rienzi Rico2

In times like these, choosing to keep hope alive seems like a radical and borderline irrational choice. But if the only other option is despair, and if despair can never be an option, then maybe it’s a necessity rather than a choice. I know this probably sounds pretty meaningless given the circumstances, but I’m sending my love from the UK anyway. I’m so sorry for all that’s happened and all that’s likely to come but, as clichéd as it sounds, as long as a sliver of hope remains then hatred and violence can never truly win. Thank you for everything you do.

Fia

love you natalie, as a fellow trans woman i want to say we'll be okay but i have the exact same fears and believe in everything you've outlined. hoping the best for us but i really don't know. 🫂

Maggie

Thanks for articulating all this and sharing your thoughts and feelings. I'm all the way over here in Europe and still feel so heartbroken for you all and terrified for the world, since 'our' shitty right-wingers have already learned all of T's worst lessons and now they have more reason to believe they work. I'm still grieving the future scenario we're not going to get, and reflecting on my next steps to combat what's coming. Stay safe, much love. ❤️

Tivvv3

Agreed. Although there must come a time for reflection or this quickly turns into toxic positivity that is to say a commitment to continue doing things the same way despite the suffering that one must endure today. Maybe with more party agnostic organizing one could rest assured that the worst will be averted and then there's some good things and some bad things with both parties after all... a chance to do more good I always appreciate.

Anna the Smiling Cat

Stay strong and prepare whatever resistance you can. It is possible to at least delay an extremist government.

Laura Torlaschi

I’m an IRL organizer tired of white dudes who can’t stand to be uncomfortable for one second saying stupid shit in comment sections. If that’s cringe to you then I fully embrace that. Have a nice day.

NiniProminente

Hope that the worst case scenario doesn't happen and you get to live how you are doing what you want. Big hugs from Spain.

Sunflower Goblin

We haven't failed. The two-party system is working how it wants to work. It has always been there as a tactic to control the masses. We need to build power outside of it. We aren't in a fascist state YET, but it is coming as capitalism degrades. Join a local leftist organization and start to build actual power. We CAN prevent a fascist state. We do NOT want to just wait for another fascist Germany/Italy to claim millions of lives.

Laura Torlaschi

Yeah! DSA wasn’t my first or only organizing group but they’re strong enough in my city to really mobilize.

Patricia Duffy

Thank you; I'm also in a blue state and have vulnerable family members. I guess I'm vulnerable myself being on SS disability and using medicaid and medicare because of it.

Tancred

so the future lies in darkness; and good forces are weak.

Hannah Katherine

Whatever you have to do to keep yourself safe, do it. You’ve reshaped my thinking in so many ways and if you never made another video it would be enough 🩷

Joshua White

Thank you Natalie. As a library worker Im so scared for what’s coming particularly in regard to public access to queer materials, in the wake that project 2025 seeks to prosecute library workers as distributing pornography to minors. But I know that I must keep going forward serving my community the best I can in the meantime.

Hannah Katherine

Funny because you calling yourself a “white dude turned left by contra” is maybe the cringiest thing I’ve ever heard anyone say

Kitty

Fair points. I’m a little salty today because what was supposed to be a fun day at the county fair with family was tainted by Republicans being racist about my mixed race partner. By failed I meant failed to stop a second trump term. You are correct we have a chance to stop the fascist state from forming. I stand by my statement though. ^.^ Stay safe out there.

Caitlin Tina Jones

Huge hugs from Wales. You are doing great by even doing what you’re doing. Sending all hope and love possible

Mel

Thank you for echoing the severity of the situation. The worst part for me is all of my friends who don't recognize the immediate threat this puts me under. Things are going to happen very fast. We're all weighing similar options. We need allies to organize to help...and right away.

demlet

Just know you're not alone.

Sunflower Goblin

From a Marxist pov, both parties are rotten and behloden to their capitalist masters. Two cheeks of the same butt. They are tools to keep the oppressed from thinking there is another way out. I encourage you to dedicate some time to reading about Marxist class-analysis.

Zhenya Oliinyk

Sending support from Ukraine, there are many people here who love your work

Quizoid

2016 hit me like a ton of bricks but I’ve learned a lot since then. Like in 2016, Trump, and especially JD and Tulsi, went left of the DNC on war, unionizing, the economy, healthy food, even the environment somehow. I’ve remained a leftist, but the DNC has totally dropped concern for the working poor and the middle class. And the populist right are just scooping up these issues, whilst the dems wave rainbow flags in our faces - protecting big business and the military-industrial complex. If your single issue is trans health care I can honestly and sympathetically see why you’d be concerned, but I just don’t know what agenda the dems are supporting since 2008 that addresses most normie’s concerns. I love y’all. Take care of yourself, and digest a balanced news diet so you aren’t so surprised by these results - I wasn’t in 2024 like I was in 2016.

BaFi

Thank you for this post. I was wondering how you were doing in the light of recent events and what would your thoughts and plans be. If you ever had to stop creating content or take down videos, I would be heartbroken. The future of the world looks very grim right now... but it would be much worse without your content in it. I admire your perseverance and will to fight! I wish you all the luck and support you can get, but also that you stay safe, and cared for. And I am looking forward to your new video so much! Sending hugs from Europe 🫂

Sam patera

Thanks for the little writeup! Yeah this sucks ass

Quizoid

And Tulsi mitigates American imperialism. I’ll be cautiously heartened if she becomes the Secretary of State.

Charlotte

Dear Natalie, thank you for this sobering but realistic assessment! I appreciate you saying that there is no point in arguing about Democratic campaign strategy - there are way too many people online, including leftists I like and appreciate - who still want to talk about how Harris needed to be less centrist or whatever and go on about how the Democrats should run next time. Very optimistic to think there's a next time that will be free and fair (or at least as fair as it's ever been). And while Harris being further left would have been nice, I think that's a total red herring - clearly most voters are not operating on rational policy assessments here. This goes much deeper, including how a lot of voters live in a totally different reality and young men have their brain marinated by the Tates of the world all day, and then hear Vance say the same. I hope you are able to go on - you're someone who's known to be able to address the latter group.

Alex Habriga

Thank ya, Natalie. I’m looking forward to your next video. Take care.

Sophia

Natalie you are one of a handful of things that is good about America. My whole family watches your videos, and my boomer parents love you. The world needs you. Take care of yourself <3

mateja gibert

Sending so much love to you, Natalie. I will be here to support you and your work always. You’re a light in the dark. Keep up the good fight and take care of yourself.

Mel

Holy shit dude. Trans people are about to be exterminated and you're sticking with that bullshit? You're blaming the people who are about to lose their lives?

Zindagigi

I prayed (and continue to pray) that Trump experiences a very public bout of incontinence. Just show him shuffling off stage hurredly with a noticeable shadow on his pants--is it shit? is it piss? That would do it.

K Birkenbach

I live in Germany and seeing the US election results always feels like staring down the barrel of a gun. All of theses talking points come out way eventually. The crazy culture war bullshit is here to stay. I know it's high time to take on the real fight, Here and everywhere the American empire touches. Courage and hope is hard to find though. Keep on keeping on. You are a source of courage worldwide.

Melon

💖💖💖💖

Jamie McKelvy

Thank you Natalie, it’s always good to hear your perspective

Sunflower Goblin

The dems agenda is the agenda of big business. The republican agenda is the agenda of big business. They are strategically elected and certain policies put in place for a reason. We are all being oppressed by the same people in power. Time to stop relying on the two-party system! Join a leftist org who wants nothing to do with the Democrats.

Lars Overdale

This is easy for me to say, since I’m not American (but here in Canada there’s always the possibility of having our own version of American political movements coming to the fore), but the best advice is to fight. I agree that an autopsy is pointless right now, because the authoritarians will be single-mindedly doing anything they can to consolidate power and to persecute their chosen scapegoats (though I’m frankly surprised at how women in general have been at least as much of a target as LGBT people). And “fight” doesn’t have to mean “get violent.” Civil disobedience is a great start, and if your videos get deemed “pornographic” because of who you are, then producing content alone is part of this. Insofar as you can, refuse to obey federal diktats, and encourage others to do so as well. At the end of the day, though, you should always have a last line of defense, and so, as I’ve been saying for a while now: arm yourself. If there is no hope left, you can at least take some of the psychos down with you.

BaFi

I definitely agree! (great choice of examples btw)

Grace Stewart

Although this is not a positive thought, I keep reminding myself that queer people have survived through many dark points in history and centuries of persecution. We will need to support each other the best we can through this nightmare.

Tivvv3

Yeah the incentives generated by capitalist ownership accumulation are outright horrifying with how subtle they are and how they work through rewarding delusion. I'm not so optimistic about there being an organizable worker class though and tend to err on the side of what Michael Hudson's on about. Rebuild Capitalism if you want a shot at mass worker organizing. Oh well. The weird part is that people like Vance also get that there's a massive ownership accumulation problem that some class with less buy-in to the system needs to counterbalance think theory of the second best. Of course he's part of a structure himself that in part works against that. Anyway we gotta look for what we can get now and think long term beyond that I guess.

Sunflower Goblin

My advice is to start listening to leftists that want nothing to do with the Democratic party.

ContraPoints

It's much harder to give benefit of the doubt now than it was in 2016. People aren't voting for Trump in 2024 out of a vague sense of "maybe this will shake things up." They know what he stands for, and they voted for that.

Oliwier

My heart goes out to everyone affected by what unfortunately is to come. I don’t live in the US but I don’t understand how so many people here in Europe don’t seem to understand the gravity of the situation. I feel like everyone is just going on with their life as if this isn’t going to affect the life’s of Millions of people. The deep disappointment I feel towards the people around me after seeing how unbothered they are that the lives of so many people are about to be ruined by this lunatic is unmeasurable. Is this normal? How can everyone I know just keep living their lives as if this isn’t possibly the beginning of the end? I always felt like those people were very empathetic so to hear them say things like: „that’s just democracy“ and „they did it to themselves“ makes me wanna throw up. I’m still pretty young so this was the first US election were I felt like I really had a grasp on what was happening. This wave of young male right wing voters is truly terrifying to me. I live in Austria where the nationalist right wing party FPÖ just won elections not long ago. And all over Europe we see the same things happening. I not only do I feel like I failed but I feel like this whole generation is failing. Everyone is always saying we are the future and we decided that the future is the suffering of thousands of people. I will never give up on myself again but this will take time to recover from. Thanks Natalie for making this time more bearable. 🩷

ben stryker

Really not sure there are enough twitter communists to result in minus 15 million votes

Will E.

I recently got out of a pretty miserable depressive spiral (took 6 months off work kinda miserable) and this week has honestly been incredibly productive for me. Wednesday after 2.5 years of having my court ordered name change I finally finished coming out at work, next day I went to SSA and updated my name, the updated my title and registration, next day I called my insurance companies, today I’m finally cleaning my apartment after leaving it abandoned for a few weeks to live with family to help me recover and got bloodwork this morning which I’ve been putting off for the entire year. Now that is not to say I’m glad about the results, if I wasn’t on anti depressants I’m sure I would have cried alot by now but my brain is still adjusting to having serotonin for the first time in it’s life lol, but it has finally given my adhd brain the urgency it needed to get its shit together. Best case safe states stay safe and I as a member of objectively the least targeted demographic of trans people (white, adult, insured, employed, housed, trans man) will have a greater responsibility to help those who are more at risk. I have no real gauge of what the worst caee scenario is but doing what I can now makes me feel better about handling that worst case. Things I was afraid of before seem insignificant now and in some ways for me that’s a net positive at this very moment. It’s not most solace but I don’t believe the country hates trans people, I just believe they do not care about us and that to me is a tiny bit easier to stomach as a trans person in PA who had to sit through so many trans ads during eagles games and watched their state go red.

Melanie Danowski

We need your work now more than ever. Times are uncertain. When times are uncertain we look for mother.

Liam F

As bad as things are, things may not be as bad as we fear, and they will inevitably get better. I know that's little consolation to a lot of people, but to anyone reading this, just take your time to process this, prepare for the worst, but hope for the best because better days absolutely will come. History surprises us, in both the worst and best ways.

evistre

Big big hugs. 💙

Colton Royle

Gonna start listening to "Is That All There Is" by Peggy Lee things are so apocalyptic. We're here for you. Least we're not commiserating alone.

Karen Lowe

Sending lots of love from Australia.

Eleanor Elsinore

I'm always excited to see your posts. Your Kantian ethics line will be quoted by yours personally often. I'm a therapist who runs a publicly queer affirming practice in a very conservative red state. I don't know where to put my feelings, other than to hold space for everyone around me. I don't want to believe you that it's going to be so much worse, but I feel in the pit of my stomach that you're probably right.

Janine

thank you Natalie ❤️ your voice is so important please take care

Jack Edgar

I'm an openly gay school librarian in the deep south, and I'm terrified, too. It's hard to know what to plan for, or where to go...

Ruby Valentine

Looking forward to the video. And fuck that guy and his mates.

Evan Pitkin

Not interested in what went wrong? I wish I was as capable of moving on.

Rachel Spencer

You’re the best, Natalie. I’m a bi PhD candidate in TX, and I teach freshman students every day. I tell them that no matter what they’re feeling right now it’s time to be in community. I’ll be boosting your, Matt’s, and other progressive creators’ videos to them as a reminder that rhetoric, the arguments we surround ourselves with every day whether we like it or not, don’t have to be *his*, don’t have to sound like him

ryan rieffel

Often the earth is a pit of eternal despair

H B

Thank you for this.

Stephanie McAlea

Sending love from the UK. Things aren't great here either but still better than in a Trumpian USA. Get a flight over here everyone. We'll sort something out.

Gasto Hand

Thank you for everything you do, I will keep supporting you on this platform or whatever will arise even if you won't be able to make videos for a while, or whatever the future will hold. ❤️ Now that our German government has broken off, I fear for a similar return to our roots here.. either way, we stand united, and we will keep strong. The fight is never over.

Kendra Hoffman

Very very glad to hear from you today. Thank you.

Deviant Ollam

Your work and who you are is appreciated more than I can say in words. Thank you for offering your thoughts today, and your strength tomorrow.

SG

💚

Tivvv3

She doesn't own me and I'm just curious what she's gonna do in 10 years. Wishing everyone the best with their striving.

Aaron Perez

Natalie, it breaks my heart having to hear this. Our situation looks super bleak right now. As a gay Hispanic man, gay rights may not be on the chopping block on this term. But I am not naive as to not see what future plans they have for it. Just know that I am right here with you. You are not alone. We are not alone. And I will fight to the bone to make sure we as a community, are safe. Take care. Love you 💙✊

Rachel Cohen

In these terrifying times, I’m grateful for all of the work you’ve done and (if you choose) will continue to do. Wishing you love, safety, and self determination.

demlet

While that's true for a lot of voters, it's sounding like a lot of them also just don't follow politics very closely. People were Googling to find out whether Biden was still running on the day of the election. People were Googling to find out who Kamala even was. They may not have even been following news about Trump or Project 2025. Many of those people may have looked at Trump's last term and figured, "nothing that bad happened, the devil I know is better than the one I don't know..." I can't say for sure. We will see how people react to what his administration does, whatever the hell that will be...

Charlotte

Uhhh, I just said it's pointless to endlessly discuss Democrat election strategy? For the record, none of the leftists I know think the Democrats will save us, nor do they (or I) think that voting is the way to make change. But just being against something and wanting nothing to do with it is a bit simplistic, isn't it? Especially when we're talking about the only small-d democratic party in a 2-party system. If leftists had been, like, half as relentlessly engaged with electoral politics as the religious right (a small minority that now dictates the entire Republican platform, and through that the entire US politics) over the past decades, the country would look very different. (Maybe this is not what you meant, but I do not have good experiences with leftist contrarians who do nothing but rant online about how shit the Democrats are. That doesn't get us anywhere.)

demlet

I have to say, no, I really didn't think that would do it.

flwrsevrywhr

you have been and continue to be such a light. ty for all you do, natalie. i hope you are taking care of yourself and finding solace in who and what you love rn.

Aderyn Albarelli

Whatever you choose to do, I'm glad I've heard from you, and hope you stay safe. Maybe we'll hear ya posting from elsewhere, occasionally doing local trivia stuff! I have to ask what supporting each other means In the American context. When I think what each day looks like, it doesn't look like there's an opportunity to engage with anyone outside of work. Maybe I just need to get the fuck out of Oakdale.

eon

Thank you, Natalie! You really are the best. People who read comments here: the strongest form of protection attainable at personal level against unjust and horrible situations is to lean in to your community, be present for the people in your life, give compassion where you can and help each other out. Trump-like awfulness sticks only to places where there is a lack of compassion and care. Sending all of you best wishes from Europe.

TerryEnby

Thinking of you all in the US right now. It’s scary enough to see from the U.K. but I can’t imagine. Please do whatever you need to to take care of yourselves.

Billy Peck

Have been rewatching your stuff on YouTube since The Situation occurred and introducing my partner to your work. Just wanted to share my support and gratitude as a trans person and someone who lost their mother to the opioid crisis. Thank you for always being so open, bold, and thoughtful. ❤️ Love you gorg haha

Joanne Burr

I hope whatever happens you are safe Natalie. You've been such an inspiration to me ❤️

Taryn

You have to do what you need to do, and I hope we can archive and save your work. It's important and it matters. As a non-binary English teacher with an incredibly bannable classroom library who lives in a blue state, I am grateful for the protections I have and yet still afraid. And even more, I'm afraid for educators in much more vulnerable positions. That being said, I work with some of the most vulnerable populations in our state, and going to work every day is an act of resistance that I can and will continue to do.

Lasha Bezhashvili

How I understand all of this. I come from Georgia and we had an election just a week before yours. I had so much hope that we would get rid of a party that, among many other horrible things, decided to make homophobia and authoritarianism their selling point. I signed up as an election observer, quarreled with loads of polling station workers who were doing their best to get rid of us observers, spent the entire spring protesting the government’s attempt to choke civil society organizations, almost got beaten up by riot policemen that very spring had a stranger not hidden me in their apartment, and all this for a big portion of my country to still go and support the final consolidation of autocracy in the country. I had some glimmer of hope that Kamala would win and we still would have US support in our fight for democracy here, but that did not materialize either. We just gotta live this through I guess. And you’re right, reason (alone), unfortunately, will not save us. Yet, there is no alternative to striving, and having people like you fight on the side of liberalism gives me hope ❤️

Marisa

probably no one wants to hear this right now, but as a newly-out trans woman with a lot of trauma, I am trying not to spiral. I think a blanket ban on gender-affirming care is unlikely to go into effect. - We don't know yet if the GOP will have a majority in the House - Even with a majority, they may not be able to get a unanimous vote for the bill - Someone should fact check me on their positions on GAC, but Cassidy, Collins, and Murkowski are still in the Senate, and all of them voted to impeach Trump - If the bill passes, there will be court challenges. I don't think it's correct to assume it will necessarily be an open-and-shut party-line ruling in the Supreme Court, given how Gorsuch ruled in BOSTOCK v. CLAYTON COUNTY, and cases might get handled by lower courts - If the bill passes, it's likely most blue states will choose not to enforce it - There will likely be carve-outs for intersex conditions, and crafty providers may be able to use intersex diagnosis codes for us, to circumvent the letter of the bill That said, a ban for minors seems much more likely. Medicare/Medicaid GAC is likely going away. And obviously if you live in a red state, I highly recommend doing whatever you can to start making arrangements to move, if you have the means to do so. I am doing my best to stockpile HRT. I recommend everyone try to do this, for obvious reasons.

Fruit Basket Case

If some of the worst aspects of Project 2025 are implemented (which I sincerely hope doesn’t happen), there is no shame in leaving the US. You and your work can be more effective when you feel safe and secure, even if that means from afar. If a time comes when you need to prioritize your personal safety and livelihood, keep in mind you can apply for a “digital nomad” visa in countries like Spain, Portugal, or the Czech Republic, which will allow you to stay as long as necessary. Sending strength to you (and to all the other Americans reading this) during these difficult times ❤️

amesville

We love you, Natalie. It’s such a terrifying time to be anything other than a cishet white man with money and at least a nodding acquaintance with some form of Christianity. You do what you need to do to stay safe. I’m looking at my budget to see if I can squeeze out some extra donation dollars, and honestly, keeping my head down for now. Love to all my fellow queers and friends of queers. We’ve got a rough road ahead. January is going to be brutal because he’s not going to wait—he literally has nothing to lose.

amesville

Lots of the “analysis” has been blaming Kamala. I’m not interested in that either. She was a sacrificial lamb, and that fucking sucks.

Jessica Cheeri

I'm not ready to be articulate yet, I'm still reeling, but whatever media production looks like for you in the foreseeable future, I hope I can still be here to support it

amesville

I don’t know you, but I’m awfully proud of you.

elijah

Thank you for being real about the situation without getting too in the weeds about what “went wrong,” or what comes next. It’s important to make sure we know what we are up against, but I’ve seen a lot of hyperbole online the past few days. It’s hard not to despair if that’s all we share with each other. We do have a responsibility to be honest, and that can be depressing a lot of the time, but I think it’s important to make sure we don’t beat others down in the process. It’s a balancing act. Natalie, as always, you walked that tightrope perfectly here. I don’t know how you manage it time and time again, but I will always be thankful that you do ❤️ we support you and we will always support you.

Tivvv3

The impression I got is that RFK Jr. has done more for vaccines than most of us have so it comes off as a bit eclectic to hear you call him out in this context. Maybe it's time to make a vid on his book!

amesville

And even if it did, JD Vance is worse.

Chris Oakley

i'm in my second year of sobriety & these last couple of days have made it really difficult to stay on the wagon. the thing that's been getting me through has been your videos (skipping over the psychedelics tangent for obvious reasons lol)- there's something about hearing your clear-eyed level headed assessments on these issues that feels like such a necessary breath of fresh air these days. i look at our government, our politicians, and our electorate, and i have a really hard time finding any hope for the future of this country. lately i've been finding that hope in your work. thank you for everything you've done & everything you'll continue to do- as bad as things seem, i really think that without your videos, the world would be even more bleak.

Eileen

RFK has done more harm than anyone on the subject of vaccines. He has no business being anywhere near any position on health

Nick

thank you

Tivvv3

Sure about that? I was under the impression he made gains to reduce the use of mercury in vaccines? Since aluminium works as well to boost the immune system response to the active compound. Should we go back to more frequently using mercury in vaccines in your estimation? edit: in general stand on the merits of your case not bravado! I'd like to learn. Thanks.

Timbucktoo2002

As for as I know he’s very vocally anti-vaccine and was spreading Covid misinformation. What has he done for vaccines?

Marisa

respectfully, for estradiol, the DIY community has come a long way and there are multiple manufacturers now who use safe methods. I know people who DIY and they are doing quite well. I just don't think it's accurate to assert that DIY can kill you. It's a good option for folks who don't have access to pharmaceutical preparations.

Joelle Killian

This is such a shitshow. Love you Natalie, let us know how we can help you do your work, because I'm down to help.

Evan Pitkin

Sending Bill Clinton to scold Palestinians in a key swing state doesn't seem like a meaningful sign of Kamala's intentions, and the party's writ large? If you're not here for that discussion then there is no way forward at all. Who would you like to blame instead?

Tivvv3

I'd like to add that despite the serious concerns like a lack of testing against mercury/aluminium free placebo in traditional vaccines and inability to sue companies for damages, he continues to advocate for vaccines which I do as well. Some vaccines are very important! Isn't he trying to salvage the mess that others made? What am I missing?

Tivvv3

I've never heard him be outspoken against vaccines in general. He's always been outspoken for vaccines in general as far as I've heard.

percysowner

This is so horrible. My oldest grandson is trans and we live in a red state, so things can and will get bad. My kids are already looking into passports for their entire family and will start looking for jobs in another country. I wish you safety and peace and that you find a way to keep being who you really are.

Sheaknot

Was just about to start medically transitioning after a decade and a half of wondering if I was trans "enough". Now feeling like I'm "too" trans for where this government is going. Still in shock that so many people threw us and every other marginalized population under the bus like this. Thank you for being honest and validating that there is both real fear and real need. It's such a tightrope walk, weighing one's own (and one's family's) safety against the multitude of others (strangers, friends, found family, and so on) who need this representation, who need to know they are not alone and need someone to fight for them and alongside them.

Monika Galevska

Sending hugs all the way from North Macedonia 🇲🇰 We just had this "red-switch" happen to our country this year, and its not looking good here either 😞 You are such a voice of reason and I'll continue to support your work wherever this road leads. Stay safe Natalie 🫂

Dspaceman20

Please Natalie stay safe. As well as everyone else. Stay safe

Charlotte

Love to you, Natalie, and to everyone else here. Thank you for all you do.

symboi

Palestine and its implications are also worth mentioning. The Democrats concerted normalization of bombing a people out of existence needs mentioning. Democrats sold our future down the river for the sake of the corporate elite. They ignored the glaringly obvious need for working class coalition to beat the fascist transphobe of which you speak. We need to rise up and be better than this

durnsidh `

So judging by your replies you seem to be talking about RFKs claims that thimerisol and similar preservatives are unsafe to use in vaccines, despite all medical research into the area. You should know that his anti-vax views extend far beyond vaccines that use thimerisol, he mostly uses that one chemical as a smoke screen to make it look he has a point to people not in the know. He's also an abelist shitbag who believes autistic people are damaged goods who will never know a fulfilling life.

symboi

Why mention Ukraine and not Gaza?

LetiKärmeniemi

Natalie, you are the greatest. A sure beacon of light when not the sailorwoman of hope, for all us in the dark. You've been kind and enlightening to us all. My best wishes are with you, and I sincerely do hope the situation does not deteriorate any more over there, and that what's able to be saved from such situation manages to be scavenged. If not, either Europe or Canada could be an emergency measure. If there's anything us fans can do in order to support you, please ask right away. Stay strong, you and everybody else reading this currently residing in the US. A light can only dim, never be snuff out.

Aderyn Albarelli

Oh yea, will the queerdoc telehealth service still be an option? I guess it's basically guided DIY

Keenan

I imagine because Gaza was already fucked beyond belief by Biden.

Nic

Maybe because on this matter, it wouldn’t have made a difference who was elected. Which is a new level of bummer in and of itself…

Raeven Rises

Personally, I blame all the people who voted for him. I wasn't aware of anyone else being responsible for this.

symboi

But I don't think we would have gotten this mournful post if Harris would have been elected. Either way, there's still millions of lives in danger that can be saved and both candidates expressed complete disillusionment and/or aggression towards the matter. Trump is terrifying but it's the pit of hell either way

Clare

Thank you Natalie, for this and everything you do. I’ve been thinking of you from London and all the other Americans I love since. This town has been quiet since Wednesday, our hearts all ache for you all. Take care of yourself the very best you can. ❤️

Tivvv3

Got a study to point me to? With 10 year follow-up and typical cumulative doses? And I am aware that there is a body of work that concerns the mRNA platform safety. Opening up the patents is probably the best choice for this so that accusations towards novelty for novelty's (patentability's) sake cannot be made. That alone would go a long way to ensure trust in the safety even as more studies must of course take place given the much accelerated path to market that was offered again without legal liabilities to producers. Given the entirely internally tested alternative production process that produced around 90% of all reports of vaccine damages so maybe the production process that was presented to regulators is really quite safe but so what is it with the alternative production process that uses live bacteria to incubate the mRNA straps? There no shortage of clinical doctors who continue to raise questions here and beyond that. And again to safeguard trust maybe these patents should be revoked.

durnsidh `

It mostly seems to have been suburban white men who simply didn't vote in the presidential race.

JoeO

"It’s possible I’ll have to take down a lot of videos " I wonder if it would be wise to get your content catalog into torrent (Or whatever people use) to distribute copies. It would be terrible for your work to get taken down.

Tivvv3

And I'll forgive the flourish on how he feels about people with autism but do know that you most likely cannot produce a quote that does anything close to justice to the way you put it. Just know that your thinking is colored by the flourishes you allow yourself to make on the regular. Best wishes.

Raeven Rises

For whatever it's worth, Trump's plans for us trans folks do not include rolling back HRT for adults who are currently on it (you can read his plans for changes to transgender policies on his website). I'm as scared as anyone but I do not think that that is on the table. Besides, banning HRT specifically would only be legally possible on the state level. As far as project 2025 goes, they can sperge whatever nonsense they want, but the majority of conservatives and certainly MAGA trumpers aren't looking to ban all porn. Being prepared is good but the heritage foundation's fundamentalist wet dream doesn't automatically happen just because they'd like it to.

Nic

A Harris win for Gaza? Yeah, it’s the pit of hell. For immigrants? Yep, still the pit of hell. Regarding what Natalie talked about in her post? Probably would have been slightly less hellish. That’s what’s being focused on here. No point in wondering what she’d have said had Harris won, that’s just speculation and unless you know her personally I don’t think you have enough information to make a call on that.

Tivvv3

Oh and before I forget I was very much not under the impression that his case for vaccine testing relies on a single ingredient. Again a serious look at his book on the topic should be the least one can do. There's nothing better than having 3-4 points that are rock solid that debunk his broader picture. In your view there must be many such points in his book I take it? Has anyone produce the evidence given it should be all so readily available?

Raeven Rises

"mixed race partner"? Jeeeeezus it's been what, FIFTY YEARS since "guess who's coming to dinner" was released? I'm so sorry, that is absolutely wild to hear that happened.

Raeven Rises

The worst part is the "we have to listen and understand these people" crowd. Like Jesus, I'm not stupid. I get it. I'm just not interested in hearing the brown shirts super nuanced ideas about economics, thanks

Tivvv3

As for the linked article isn't that just a bunch of smear pieces linking to each other? I will have you do your due diligence digging through the sources yourself so then you can point me to key studies and reproduce the arguments presented. edit: Hint there's probably nothing there. Again due diligence matters because I'm metaphorically allergic (and have some very real allergies btw) to throwing crap at the wall and hoping something sticks.

Søren Berthelsen

Thanks for the update, Natalie. I don’t know you but I’ve actually been thinking about how this must feel for you especially in terms of personal safety. I’ll just drop this bit of information in case it might be relevant for you and you decide to leave the US. Denmark has its problems but the conversation on trans people hasn’t exploded like it has in the UK and the US, and trans people are generally more tolerated here - there are still problems like everywhere else but in terms of personal safety and access to health care, I think you would be good. It’s rare that people aren’t good at English as well, but if you need a facilitator for getting you into contact with someone, reaching the correct official websites for government or LGBTQ-organizations, translation, whatever else, I’d be happy to help where I can. It wouldn’t be a lot of work for me to do but I imagine it would take a lot of extra time to get a proper overview for someone who has never engaged with the Danish system. I know I’m not obligated to help you in any sense of course, but I want you to know that the offer is there

Tivvv3

Also side note you do understand that "no good evidence" may as well be code for "there's mechanistic studies but we're not gonna run a 10 year double blind placebo controlled study on things that can harm you by chronic exposure and double blind placebo controlled studies are the gold standard so go away, we don't worry about chronic exposures in that way". Gets people on all kinds of "subscriptions" to ignore causes of chronic conditions of course.

Keenan

Hey folks, I don't want to sound defeatist, but if anyone reading this is making contingency plans to leave the US (just in case) check out the Dutch American Friendship Treaty. There is a financial hurdle that can't be avoided (a few thousand Euros...), but the residency permit itself is basically guaranteed if you can follow the steps required. It involves setting up a "business" as an "entrepreneur" but the definition of both is very broad. Things are very far from perfect here, but if you're exploring your options and have the privilege to afford it, it is one to be aware of. My love to everyone in the US who stands to suffer from this bullshit... I'm sorry :(

Erin DeCew

We love you Natalie! I hope you do whatever you need to do to be safe - the rest of us need to get prepared to shoulder this fight too. My heart goes out to all trans folks this week, especially those in red states who have already been dealing with their state politicians instituting transphobic policies. I wish I was more hopeful that it won't be as bad as we fear. I feel like we're living in the calm before the storm right now.

Lou

1776th like. OMG it's a sign!!!! Be well and like Freddie said "Keep yourself alive", Nat

Tivvv3

Also thanks for your patience whoever read this! Hope this brightened up your day at least a little be it in some weird conflicted way. :)

M. C. Matz

Thank you for posting, Natalie. If you want to stay in the US, Illinois and California have governors who have both stated they are holding the line. Pritzker has spent the few years setting up protections and he is a minted old money billionaire strangely on the populist side. Newsome has convened his legislature strengthen their laws. On the social media side, MediasTouch Network has pivoted to the resistance. They are a bunch of lawyers strategizing lawsuits at the state level and in federal district courts to counter any shenanigans. Mary Trump’s YouTube channel is doing likewise as are many others. Please do what you need to do to stay safe and keep going. Thank you for your work and genius. Much love, Natalie, and everyone here.

susan tiss

I don't know what else to say other than thank you so much for sharing all of this.

SevenTrees

Thank you thank you for posting. I am so grateful for this "little" forum and everyone in it. I'm scared as fuck.

Aderyn Albarelli

If you're accepting cat photos, where do we send them?

Jenavive!

Been rewatching your videos for solace. Thanks, Natalie. <3, Jena

CrystalJade

I have no words that can compensate. It’s easy to obsess or to become hyper vigilant. My own senses are off the chart right now. Although I’m in the UK I have many friends across the US and I feel their pain; these are waves and not ripples. Remember that you aren’t alone. You have agency. And damn if the most googled thing is ‘what is a tariff’ then you know a whole lot of people feel duped right now. There was never a person who could negate the phallic function. Including Trump, Musk or Mr brain worm. Yet they believe they can. That is what hurts so much over and above all the abject insanity. The only therapy I can recommend is to go hang out with the Flaming Lips crowd whenever possible.

Tal

Thank you and see you on the other side. There will be one we need to remember that

Jamie J

I'm not familiar with the DSA - I take it you mean the Democratic Socialists of America? In which case, I'm currently looking into it and will probably join as well

Lauren

Have u considered reaching out to SNL w/ ur ideas??

Sharra Gamez

Part of me feels like a coward for putting together a plan for my husband to find a job in Canada, but how can I let my daughter grow up in this place if there are any other options for us? The vaccine stuff alone...and she's too young to know her sexual orientation. And even if she turns out completely straight, she's pretty but not traditionally feminine. What kind of target will that make her from angry men? I WANT to protect everyone, but I HAVE to protect her to the best of my ability.

Vladlena Costescu

We'll have to see what kind of mess RFK causes at the agency that is my company's client (assuming he gets the expected Cabinet position) but it likely won't be fun and I may be forced to switch jobs.

Baishujinkou

You've given me a lot of hope and determination through these years, Natalie. I promise I'll keep standing through all of this. Please keep taking care of yourself ❤️

Robert Snader

I agree whole hardheartedly that the benefit of the doubt is so much harder to award in the current situation. The best take I can draw from it is that far too many of my country's citizens are feeling terrified of the world ahead, and the orange Nazi provided an emotional shortcut.

Indija-ka Siriwardena

Speaking to the DIY of it all, I've been thinking about it from a safety, qaulity and logistics perspective. I worked as a environmental testing chemist in an production line, apparently I was a stickler for safety and a pedent for analysis. I was wondering if there was group dedicated to organising protocols for those who don't have easy access? Maybe I can improve the safety and quality factor of DIYing for those with limited access.

Robert Snader

I'm just so angry at the reality of what is right now, I don't feel comfortable with assigning blame just yet.

Robert Snader

(sorry few areas left to vent), I'm also angry at myself because I feel like neglected anger and rage in this country is what got us here. I grew up in BFE midwest America. I was surrounded by angry, fundamentalist white people my entire life. That situation sucked. But so many of them were not bad people, just so severely misled by the right, and mostly ignored by the left. It is no excuse for what has happened, just an explanation, and I am so frustrated now as to how to move forward.

ts_babyjane

look into DIYHRT.wiki and their is a subreddit for it. thats the only starting points i can think of.

Robert Snader

In any case Natalie please keep doing what you do. As an avid supporter I'm rooting for you. You are one of a handful of spearheads for the movement we need right now, now more than f ing ever.

Derek

thank you for your service

Robert Snader

Honestly we need to get you, Stephanie Sterling, Jonathan Holmes (not that Jonathan Holmes), Laura Kate Dale, Conrad ZImmerman, and so many others together for a positive rogue gallery of the future.

Paul Ortega

Thank you Natalie for laying out the situation so thoroughly, and for reminding me of the particular, very direct threat to LGBT+ people's livelihoods and LIVES. But also, shame on you for reminding me that I still have Skyrim on my computer.

Naba

Unfortunately Canada is having an election next year and the Canadian version of Trump is leading the polls by ~20 points; sadly the West as a whole is not a safe place :(

Robert Snader

And sorry demlet I rudely ignored you entirely. I think you are right here as well in part. I remember one of the most common google searches in the UK following the brexit vote (alledgedly) being "what is the EU?" I think folks were severely underinformed and just went with the voice that was the loadest.

Jace Walker

I honestly don't know what to say any more but I'm grateful for this community you've built <3

Guilherme Tamaki

Dear Natalie My deepest condolences to you and my fellow Americans. I would offer solace, but the situation in Brazil is dire as well, considering the results of the municipal elections. There is so much at stake, and the silver lining on the horizon is fading. All I can say is this: I will be supporting you. Thank you for all your brightness.

Dylan

Stay strong, Nat!

Dawn Farthing

love & support you & your work, Natalie! thank you for this message & your hope. i will fight to survive & to help others survive & to foil evil at every possible goddamn opportunity.

James Mire

Hi Natalie (and other friends)! I’ve wondered these last few days how you’ve been, so I’m glad to hear from you and from everyone today. One thing that you mentioned stuck out to me in particular, namely that young LGBT people will increasingly need to turn to online content in the coming years for resources on LGBT topics. This makes me all the more thankful for the wealth of information and perspective that you provide through your videos, and for the community that’s grown up around them. I’m happy to continue contributing in whatever ways I can! My best wishes for peace and safety to Natalie and to everyone reading.

Jason F

Thank you always Natalie! You're welcome any time here in Canada, but to be honest it's only been getter worse here too. Stick together, everyone!

Khannea

Amsterdam is wonderful. You know how to reach me if you need help immigrating here. Life is free and safe and paradise here :)

Catanist

Ive been crying my eyes out while listening to Vivaldi's Stabat Mater for extra drama. I wish I was less weepy and more angry but I dont know if I have the energy to fight this time around.

Divad Abelhczejen

I hope you’re doing well 🫂 I’ve been fluctuating between worried and not worried, but hearing that you’re worried definitely makes me worried!

Dave L

It was like this under Reagan, and we never quite recovered. The Dems took their neoliberal heel turn under Clinton, and the wholesale wrecking of the civil rights era successes steamed ahead. Before Project 2025, there was the infamous Powell memo, and it laid down the marching orders for the Heritage Foundation and the neocons. That was 50 years ago, and it'll give you some sense of the size of the work ahead of us, both here in the US, and with our friends abroad. I actually have faith in you all. This is a good time to take up the fight.

Jeffrey Pfeifer

Natalie, hearing from you helps me face the excruciating path forward. Through the gloom we look for beacons of light, people like you who understand, who observe carefully, who speak wisely. Thank you for bolstering our spirits and lighting the way.

S. R.

I think the wost part is the crowd thats happy about this and having a wonderful time celebrating "punishing the Dems" and "dunking" on anyone who's upset for being a "shitlib" - because obviously this means the socialist revolution is closer to reality. Obviously.

KafkaBarbie

Hearing this from you is comforting and also mobilizing. Your work is hugely inspiring to me, thank you for everything you do.

Pierre Brown

Girl. I was so depressed. I ate so much spaghetti, pizza, and spent time I should have been writing either playing the new Pokemon phone game, Marvel Snap, doom scrolling, or taking naps. When I went outside, it was always with a silent sense of fear. Now, I feel angry when walking through the crunchy, Michigan leaves as I walk my dog. It's a feeling I haven't had in a long time. I welcome it this time. I'd rather filled with anger than weighed down by anxiety and sadness. His cult deserves our non-lethal, justified anger this time around. They clearly know exactly what they're signing up for, and are prepared to excuse most of the drastic and unnecessary alteration Trump brings to their lives. I've also been cutting back on the doomscrolling and throwing my energy into a project I've been writing a little before, or perhaps a little after, Kamala was announced as running for president. I realized all of my feelings and the themes inside of my work correlates, on several levels, to this atrocious and disappointing election year. It's been pretty fun to put the anger somewhere out of my head. I hope this same feeling happens as you work on your all of your content. The only other thing keeping me a little bit sane are the blue states already announcing that they are not for any of his bullshit and will be combating everything he can even dream of throwing their way. Also the hope that if they really succeed at coming for LGBTQ rights, specifically gay marriage rights, (which I hope Biden finds some way to codify forever), I know interracial marriage is surely around the corner, and I cannot wait to see Clarence Thomas' foul faced, traitorous ass flip out at Trump for it. But the truth is, if Trump's old, high ass can't even open a goddamn door, I cannot imagine him walking down the stairs of a plane without breaking his puny neck. All of us, even if we need to relocate to a blue/blue-r state or to a different country altogether, must live long enough to see this lying, monstrous, micropenis having ass, rapist loser who bathes in the ugliest shade of orange only found in the cheapest RoseArt box known to man, die in what will likely be one of the most avoidable ways on Earth. :)

Honoria Valemon

Thank you for being such a strong intelligent voice, Natalie. The road ahead looks dark and terrifying and all we can do is throw as many clogs into the machinery as possible. I hope you’ll keep yourself safe and continue to use your voice and make your videos and challenge and delight your fans. Just for levity, for a wild moment I thought you had made a video about Mike “The Situation” from Jersey Shore and his much admired abs. ❤️

frogsmore

Dito here in Australia

Brian Park

Thank you, Natalie. Really needed to read this. Your voice is a much needed solace at a time like this.

frogsmore

I am reminded constantly of David Lynch saying through character in Twin Peaks the Return "Fix [your] hearts or die." I think he is speaking to us as a global population.

fryfry

Well, there's only one thing for it. Stardew Valley Shrimp Stream. Heartalie.

Cerulean

one aspect that i haven’t heard much about: i work in health disparities research, it’s my passion. i’m anticipating cuts due to the administration defunding NIH, in which case i could be potentially unable to find a job after my current grant runs out (they could pull funding of that, apparently, but this particular project is likely to be over by the time that happens). so many jobs potentially lost in the name of christian white nationalism. and, of course, health disparities are going to get so much worse.

Ransom Linder

Prepare for the worst, hope for the best.

Mark keogh

In case you had an irish grandparent you can get an Irish passport.

Eric J

much love 💜 for what it’s worth, i think your videos do make a difference!

Conner Rohwer

We live in a country that rewards Trisha Paytas for merely existing. 😢

Adra

We will get through this together, our greatest form of protest is to live free and thrive despite what is happening rn. This was the first election I voted in and I am glad since they were actually trying to get people to vote for whether my community college system continues to get money from the government or not. Like, are we really relying on 75+ year old voters to decide whether my community college survives or gets shut down? My own family has not reached out to me since I voted blue (and they are fucking cowards, excuse my French) but I have found support in my manager and college friends that have been crying and grieving with me during these times and I have made the decision to spend thanksgiving and christmas with them instead. Though these are traumatic times, I do think we will bond and become closer over it. No matter what the government tries to do, we will have each other. I have found soul family where my birth family was supposed to be. I still hold a lot of hope in my heart for you, for us, and our freedoms in the next 4 years. Very excited for your video. :)

Sam D.

If you want to hop on stream any time, order some take out and play a game with us, we'll chat, drink wine and listen. Just let us know. We're here.I've bought a couple of the games I've watched you play! Good luck working on the video. Sending wind for your sails.

Xina Shimek

I just keep thinking about the Prague Spring and the resulting "normalization".

Valerie

Thanks Natalie. Take care of yourself.

Arben

We are going to be okay. America is too robust. At least we got a 4 year buffer in between terms, the Magaga won’t riot again, and Dump can never run again. The 9 year campaign is finally over. We will coalesce and resist together. Even if the laws do change we can change them back later. Don’t tell yourself your worst fears are going to come true. The right wing is tranquilized from their victory right now which means this is the BEST time to act!!! Dump will not be able to deliver his promises to his base and they will become disillusioned and turn on him.

Nate

You’re the best Natalie! I know I will really appreciate hearing your thoughts as the nightmare unfolds. T_T

John Rovell

I plan on living my little life and doing good to and with those I love and my community up until I have to get my gay ass out of this country or I am thrown into a camp. Whichever happens first. As queer folks, we have fought the Dread our whole lives. They are an old comfy enemy. We have continuously had to adapt to the suboptimal. The same goes for most folks on the margins. The mistake of those that support this regime have made is thinking the Dread will never reach them. But it will. And we will all bear witness to it. Cold comfort that. Folks in worse conditions and situations still dance, make art, sit down to meals with loved ones, have sex, sing, and live. I don't plan on doing any less. What choice do any of us have?

Denny Gee

Funny, I've been playing Skyrim too. Something comforting about it.

Jiyoon

Stay safe Natalie, and everyone else. In these difficult times, it’s knowing that we have people like each other that helps me have hope. Your videos have always had a big role in reminding me that being open to try understanding and having compassion for others has a real impact. Thank you for everything.

Samuel L. Chicken

We love you Natalie and we need you! Take care of yourself and stay safe.

Ty P

I still alternating between numbness and depression. The old "we have to keep fighting" mantra has been recited so often over the last two decades, I don't believe it anymore. In Germany, the government just collapsed and the right wing extremist and openly transphobic AfD is probably on track to become the second strongest party. The came in in first in the last two state elections, and second in another. We had trans acceptance high tide and now it's rolling back. I think of that scene in lotr "We cannot get out. They are coming." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IiiUpdNQwT4

laLuna

I'm moved by your words and want to send my condolences to you and all of you living in America under dumb Trump. I can only Imagine how it is to live as a publicly queer person and knowing that people voted for this to happen. Hope you stay safe and be there for each other. You are allways welcome in Germany. We also have a lot of right wing shitty politicians but ghe situation isnt nearly as bad right now. Sending you Love ✨

Bilyana Borislavova

I was so hoping that we will hear from you. I've heard a lot of people talking about moving and my first thought is "but, wait, who is going to be the resistance?". But of course, I realise how easy it is to say that when I'm not American and I don't live in America.

Tivvv3

Yeah it's not right that politicians proliferate themselves on the backlash produced by Merkel leaving behind a legacy of stagnation that was papered over by cheap energy and cynical politicians delivering vibes to minorities and not much else. Maybe one asks for trouble when the people stay in line with the politicians not the other way around. Regardless of which "team" is winning. Humanity has so much more to build.

Valentine

Watching your old videos for comfort, love you Natalie!!!

Timid and Meek

The country where I'm from also just recently elected an (alleged) war criminal closely linked with the dictatorial regime decades ago; hence the election may have dragged my country back to its dictatorial style of governance. Our struggles may not be the same, but I feel connected to you as well. Everytime I watch you, I feel like I'm connected to this international network of thinkers that is perpetually curious and driven in making sense of a world increasingly dark and mind-numbing. I feel a profound sense of solidarity. Watching your work these past 4-5 years has made my mind monumentally far more patient, curious, empathetic, and resilient in making sense of the world (or in embracing its insanity). It is not material power; but I think it is still power. If you choose to end your work, I am eternally grateful to have been gifted a more prepared and powerful mind to face the world. If you choose to continue, then as the youths would say, let's fucking go.

Tivvv3

Sorry to hear. At least dictatorial style involves bribing whole groups of people (underlings of the suite of right hand men) so in a way it's an upgrade to neolibs. Maybe all we can do is get ahead for ourselves in revitalized economies and in time build a worker movement so we won't have to flip flop between dictatorial and neoliberal leaders. And curiosity is important yeah, glad to hear you're enjoying it!

OvarianTryst

Funny you should mention Oakdale - I don't expect we live in the same Oakdale since there are many of them, but I've recently started going to White Bear Lake Center for the Arts for random activities. On Wednesdays, there's a free queer clay club. It skews a bit younger but everyone is welcome. There's also an art and coffee discussion group on Fridays. An older lady stopped to chat with me after class for nearly two hours, and we commiserated and tried to find hope. To me, this is what supporting each other means. After we were done talking, she gave me the biggest hug. My takeaway is to suggest looking for queer -friendly community groups and just...be present. I myself will also probably be looking into volunteering, though I'm not sure where yet. Maybe art therapy, lol

Balthazar’s Mom

Do whatever you gotta do to stay alive, Natalie! We’ll sort this bullshit one way or another. I hope we can get through it with as little pain and blood as we can

agapi

I've learned so much from you Natalie, you've educated me and you've entertained me. You're the kind of soul this world needs. I'm unfortunately in a country thats affected by american politics and foreign policy but mostly im horrified for the american people. From one useless lesbian to another, stay strong and most of all alive 🩷 ily

Jill Forbes

Watching in horror from Scotland. I’m also sad to note that the right wing “anti woke” propaganda is increasing its influence here. Natalie, you have done so much to educate and entertain us, I hope you have the strength to continue your work in the face of the coming storm. Take care

James

Not to pile on the doom, but when placed in the context of the far right surge across the world this year, it seems clear we’re facing an epochal shift away from the era of human rights, cooperation and peace. A number of EU states have already adopted legislation that breaches various treaty obligations towards refugees and migrants (and have become more authoritarian generally). If/when Trump starts mass deportations, I expect other countries will take that as license to definitely break from the mid 20th century settlement. I fear it will take nothing less than a reinvention of progressive politics over generations to shift back.

Cassady

I am a caring cisgender straight white male who’s 6’4”, 270 lbs and fearless and I will happily put my body on the line to fight off anyone who’s attacking ANY member of the groups the Republican Party is currently persecuting. AND I will continue to vote, and campaign, and march, and shout for a better world. AND I will continue to work to get a better understanding of the world by reading/listening to/watching the voices and faces a brilliant intellectual like yourself AND to spread the word on social media and everywhere I go. Human Nature seems to have two sides: 1. the desire to harm, and 2. the desire to protect everyone so we can all get on with the process of ENJOYING how great it could be to be together and alive in peace. We’ve got to keep SQUELCHING our evil impulses and nurturing our desire to have everyone around us—and around the world—be safe, healthy, happy, and to feel LOVED. I don’t think we have to DIE to go to Heaven. All we have to do is get along with one another. ❤️

Amelia Lisette

I sincerely extend my sympathy, compassion, and sense of loss. I know that sounds a bit pompous and clinically distant, but I can’t say it any other way. I feel particularly for Americans, especially those who don’t reside within the protected class of white, male, cishet straight and wealthy, but I worry also, for the international arena; Ukraine, Gaza, the rupture of the NATO Alliance, but also the looming threat of Putin and his impending violence against the rest of the EU.

Paparazzi

Hey, if you wanna do that already and not doing it currently - foundations that need people to shelter pregnant people to an abortion through the lines of protesters might be near you! Go check them out and use your big body to shelter those who need it :)

Lucie Chalou

Thank you for your letter of support! Although I am not American, I am a citizen of a postsovietian country and this result will affect me greatly, I believe. There will be terrible economical consequences at best, at worst safety of people in my country will be at risk. I feel defeated because when I look around, I do not even really see much possibilieties of where to run. We are living in truly dark times right now.

Tivvv3

Also maybe consider building independent pressure groups so your vote won't be taken for granted. 👍

Tivvv3

As for the part about good and evil... it takes good people to paper over the conflicts of interest that every group has between group reproduction and stated purpose. Our better nature is necessary but insufficient and may in fact leave us not seeing the good causes that others champion for their faults that they look past.

Amanda Palmer

This shit is fucked. My concerns don’t know exactly where to land, but the future of what we make and where we put it is certainly at the forefront of my mind. I love you and will support you wherever this doth lead.

Christina Sotiropoulou

I really hope you won't have to move, or make such radical changes in your channel. I live in Greece, EU, and Trump's election will radically affect my country's economy, which is ruled by yes-men and copy-cats of the US politics. Even though I am a cis woman, well, I face poverty and struggle to improve my skills and to make ends meet, so that I won't suffer from lack of healthcare in an older age. Work and the pursuit of extra studies are the things that keep me happy and socialized. Otherwise, I would be drowned in my own misery. I have also gone through rehab, so gaming and food are my means of escapism. I have returned to playing the Sims 3 lately, which I hadn't played for 10 years. Imagine that! Well, I just wanted to say that I totally sympathise with you and love your work. Can't wait for your next video.

Legal Imbecile

I came from an abusive household where my brother was sent to school Scot free and I was made to work two jobs to get through. Unfortunately I didn’t make it and became addicted to drugs in the midst of the violence and terror my family inflicted upon me. I got out and am now happily married and living on my own. You can maybe see why the “parent rights” movement terrifies me. Not all parents are safe spaces for their children. Finding your videos gave me a sense of learning that I still feel is such a wound for me having not been able to afford to finish school when I had to run away and go out on my own suddenly at 19. Natalie, I can’t thank you enough for everything you have taught me in such an incredible creative way. All your videos are lectures to me, they’re filled with real knowledge and have pointed me towards so many books to develop even further. When I joined your Patreon I knew in an instant it was the least I could pay for education. Thank you for being an educator, for sharing knowledge, for creating. My place in Toronto is open for you if you ever need to run. 💗

Patrick R.

Love ya, Natalie. Stay strong. Everyone in the U.S. . . . thinking of you (and hoping for you) from up north. <3

Tanja

Sending solidarity and good wishes from Switzerland! Thank you for all your videos up until now. They were very helpful for me when my daughter came out as trans. I learned so much from you. So if you ever need a contact in Switzerland, we're here. Stay safe and all the best!

Chantal Sorrentino

Don't act like you haven't seen what's been going on for over a whole year, dude

JoyOfResistance

Not that Europe is going in a great direction, but! If you need someone to marry to get out of the US, let me know, I'm happy to help my oversea queers!

Chantal Sorrentino

Are you a viralogist or epidemiologist? If not, then sit down. The Dunning Kruger effect is so real. My god. We need to listen to the WHO and CDC on these matters, not some "trust me, bro" on the internet

S. R.

I'm feeling edge of blackpill mode about The Situation, but your post made me feel a bit better. Thank you. An easy way for western English speaker with college degree to get a visa out of USA is English teaching in East Asia... And if you come to the birthplace of cat girls, body pillows and yaoi specifically and need help with interpreting/advice, I would be down🫡

Andrea Schreiber

I have often heard it said that it takes 100 days to see the direction a new government is taking. In your case, that probably means how quickly Project 2025 is progressing and whether he can really do everything he has promised. In other words, what he has now promised, because of the Russian offensive initiative, which at the moment seems to be mainly focused on Ukraine, but which would then rule out safe retreat options in Europe for a longer period of time, and it would be safer to first get a foothold in New Zealand or even Canada, because here the signs are pointing to regression, precisely because of the allegedly too progressive policies of the more left-wing parties, but let's wait and see if this 100-day rule also applies in your case. I hope that the promises for which so many of you made this choice will not be fulfilled, because at the end of this legislature, only the strong will remain.

Lina7

The day of not getting out of bed. The day of substance abuse (chocolate) and doomscrolling (yes). The day of gaming for 14 hours. Witchcraft. You described the 3 days after election perfectly. I'm also adding the environment to the list of goodbyes and crimes this administration will be responsible of. Thanks for the world you'll be leaving us.

Chantal Sorrentino

Same here.. Same here.... 😢. Pysy vahvana, kaverini

Sam D.

Sim 4 player here. The Sims has been a haven for queer young (and older!) people for many years across the world. When people can't live out who they want to be irl, it provides a place to be whole, to be free, and to hold on till better times. And they can't pry the game out of our computers!

Marina P

I’ve been thinking a lot about you these past few days. Sending love from Brazil ❤️

Mark Singer

Other creators I follow have studiously avoided saying anything since Tuesday. I'm glad I could count on you. I'm a gay man, widowed from my partner of over three decades last year, who is two years away from a retirement where I will be dependent on Social Security and Medicare. I frankly don't want to live through what is coming. Still, you've made it a little easier today.

Eryn Beatty

Come on over to Portugal! The weather is great! Its where I fled to two years ago. I saw this shitstorm coming and knew the Democrats would fuck it up.

symboi

Sure, the imminent threat to trans rights is worse now than it would have been under Harris and there's much to grieve there. I'm only bringing up Gaza because Ukraine was mentioned in her original post and it seems like a big oversight to gloss it over as we mourn our political situation right now. I'm not speculating on what she would have said, I'm saying she should have mentioned Palestine.

Iris

Pretty sure you have to specifically have at least a Bachelor's. I looked into Japan for instance. You can't do those programs with an Associate's like I have :\ I'll be happy to be corrected if that's not the case though.

33oonum

Hope you'll be safe,I trust you will. Your videos have accompanied me for a long time now (at least since 2019, maybe even before) and I feel relieved to know that intelligent, thoughtful and caring people such as yourself exist everywhere. I'm a gay man, but I don't live in the USA, and in my country menacing political shifts have been happening also. The far-right lurks in every corner. Others have said this too, but I'm of the opinion that maybe a silver ligning exists in all of this: that the USA run by a more empowered Trump will make it become transparenty clear even to common american people's eyes how brutal the United States are, how unjust and criminal capitalism can be to every working class person (not the least minority working class folks). It maybe the case that this will foster change. Stay safe Natalie.

Asche Helling

We're in your corner, Babe. Thanks for staying in ours <3

Tivvv3

I'll make this short okay? I'm a generalist and I have great respect for experts. Now I've been in the generalist game for a long while. Meanwhile Dunning Kruger Effect refers to excitement as one learns the basics of a field while missing that there's a whole world of nuance that must be considered within the field. It's a real worry but it's often wielded to keep serious generalists out of the discussion and I worry more about experts being stuck in their respective silos as a result. I've listened to plenty virologists and practicing MDs to inform my views and only listened to RFK Jr. very little btw and I have a number of disagreements with every expert I have ever heard btw and yet maintain great respect for many of em and experts in general. Now my generist views include an understanding that epidemiology can be gamed easily like any good statistician would tell you, the YTber Veritasium made a video on this before for one, and if there's trillions of dollars at stake then there's enough shaming and internationnal relations tension to keep certain topics off of the agenda. I'd also like to see basic standards of journalism upheld as to the use of sources namely mastery of the arguments presented even if you and I cannot verify the details. But so be able to produce 1-2 key arguments with reference to particular studies, not just a quantified body of studies. These meta analyses and epidemiological findings are almost principally unfit for infering causality. So you need some mechanistic studies too. Tall order I know but so that's what matters if you want to be part of telling people to respect or not respect this or that expert or body of experts. Otherwise people with some life experience will just think you're naive or crazy and avoid you. It's also well established that on average it takes 10 years, emphasis on average, for new scientific insights to make their way into official recommendations and so how does that process work nowadays? By experts writing books with a popular appeal. That's the landscape now that journalism has been sucked dry of cash thanks to the big tech platforms and legacy media loyalty is being bought through advertisements. Journalism was more of a generalist game when there was money and recruitment worked more through local newspapers but now instead you're being groomed by institutions that very much have a common interest in keeping their endowments going up, student tuition is actually not a great deal of most prestigious universities' income. The key point is that people self censor their thinking to rise through the ranks. You'd rather not keep getting told that this isn't a good topic for the news room or a good research area for one. Also because the implication is that your career is at stake. Now you and me as good generalists should feel responsible to question these incentive structure problems even as we mostly go along with what the WHO says, sure. That means we go to the regular doctor, yes I totally agree. Most recommendations are actually pretty good. But when trillions are at stake or well organized professions have a vested interest, well they're not going to get updated in as timely a fashion as we'd like. So I'm not gonna blindly trust a meta analysis that dropped 90% of potentially relevant papers. I'll see if it's a topic where we have medical experts having standpoint diverse discussions as to what may be relevant root causes e.g. chronic exposures of various types. Environmental factors include the food you eat btw I've seen somebody get suprised by this fact before lol. There's a reason the US has a uniquely unhealthy population and it's neither lack of exercise nor lack of willpower to blame and the lack of universal healthcare I'd only blame partially. As much as it would be good to get that sorted out of course. So I've come across plenty bounty for my own benefit by respecting expert scientists and having humility as a generalist. And sure would be cool for some experts to also have more humility before generalists but of course as I pointed out before actually fixing chronic issues just doesn't pay well so why not have everyone work on some hyper specialized, silo'd aspect of e.g. the body and reward the people who are most eager to be arrogant about the their limited but elite competence when it serves the university endowment? Sure take it easy and follow all the current day recommendations if you want. But so it's people who you try to shame that are also important to update those public health(/etc.) recommendations. While you seemingly lacking the skills to make an assessment of what is the Dunning Kruger effect and if it's in play here. No you can not invoke it on RFK Jr. after he spent many months researching to write a book. And sure there are plenty foolish people who may even get signal boosted to create an impression that people just cannot reason with each other. But I'm not gonna let that deter me from encouraging people to strive to be competent generalists at least and doesn't that open up the path for experts to do better as well? No medical doctor becomes an MD to keep people on 5 different medications for an issue that less mold expsure and a change in food choices might fix. We got to have the backs of our experts and that's how that works. Become an excellent generalist with great repsect for experts who knows and sees that all experts have severe limitations when they leave their field of study but that's okay, too. That's where and how we can support em as far as I am concerned. There's only a deterioration of public confidence without that as far as I can tell. And I have plenty criticisms of RFK Jr.. I'd tell people to check out Prof. Steve Keen for a much superior economic understanding for one (MMT adjacent). Anyway wish you the best.

Darren DM

I'm not very articulate, but I'm being truly sincere when I say I feel deeply for yours and your compatriots situation. Sending love and strength.

numb3r5ev3n

"Playing Skyrim for 14 hours" are you in my house? But seriously: thank you. Thank for for just articulating and validating a lot of the things that I have been thinking over the past few days, especially as I have been repeatedly told "if Dems had run on cheaper groceries instead of Wokeness, you guys would have won." I guess we'll see what these folls think after the tariffs kick in.

Fiore

Thank you for the chuckles your phrasing in this gave me. I look forward to your videos so much! And if you need a break again (maybe by streaming a videogame again?) then please do so!

Ellen Wolf

🙏🏻 Dear humanist siblings of North America, 🌎 you have our unconditional support. ✊ Horror and hatred know no borders… For our 2027 presidential elections, we, too, are preparing the resistance here. 🇫🇷 With love, the Froggies. 🐸💚 PS: Could I translate your message into French to share with the Gauls and include a link to your Patreon?

Jeremias B

Come to Canada! Easiest way is enrolling as a student

Vasilii Zubarev

As someone who left Russia the line "waiting for one miserable old man to die" goes crazy

Fr3nchFrii

Tbh, substances are the only way my brain functions. Resistance comes in many forms. It is dim looking into the future, to be sure, but there's revolution brewing, and more people out in both the imperial core, and world at large have been pushing back, seeking truth, and building solidarity. Trump may accelerate destruction, so we have to accelerate preparing in whatever ways we're suited to defend, take care of, and work together with ourselves, each other, and surrounding communities. I don't for a second believe the average person will become a raping murderer the second law and order break down. I believe we evolved because we worked together and I know working together will be the only thing that saves humanity and the planet. Hierarchy has done enough damage to our collective psyches, our habitat, and our furture. All power to all the people.

LEBuwu

Please stay safe as best you can, that’s what’s most important 🩵 Thank you for everything that you do. I don’t know how but we will get through this

Andi Livia

Sorry for going off topic but i was hoping some trans people in here could recommend readings on lgbt and specifically trans rights for me to include in the curriculum for the human rights club im starting at college?

Aderyn Albarelli

That sounds nice, I'm glad you found your peeps! I'm in Oakdale, CT. Red counties in blue states are something else. Where recent elections told me that the electorate's relationship to trans people is one of indifference (in good times and bad) red counties in blue states tend to make Natalie's Ted Bundy comment feel more true

Aderyn Albarelli

And it's mostly liquor stores, unless you can afford a car XD

Christina Sotiropoulou

It's cool for poor people also. You can have a villa and become a simoleon tycoon in no time.

Vivek Patel

Corporate America would've spent so much more money to counter her campaign if she did that

Vivek Patel

I'm in the UK too and I fear that come 2029 there's gonna be a fairly big anti-labour backlash :( They need to do something big otherwise the tories will run on the pretense that labour did nothing

dm

true but she also raised a billion dollars and still lost

Wendy

Thank you for the update. I know this is parasocial, but truly Natalie, you are one of the first people I worried about when the news dropped to my stomach, and to read your paragraph about not pulling back was really inspiring and personally comforting to know that even in the face of grave adversity, your mind still turns to making content that the youth, the future of this country, can use to better understand themselves and society. Take care, love you, and I hope we all lean in during this time.

Evan

I'm definitely doing everything I can to stay positive and pro-active right now, that mainly takes the form of comforting the people in my life who are far more vulnerable and justifiably scared about all of this. That being said, I am 99% certain now that the "average person" will watch you get raped and murdered and believe basically any story that explains that you deserved it. There really isn't a case for relying on the decency of people who will tell you to your face that they'd risk the stability of their civilization for gas to MAYBE be 1 dollar cheaper for a year.

Kay Emm

Thank you for sharing what you are thinking! I love what you do, and I think it’s more important than ever. In fact, I cited your work on anti-trans bills in my US government class the day after the election. The fact that some states have more proposed bills policing trans girls in sports than they do *actual* trans girls in sports got a big laugh…and we really needed it. 💜

Kay Emm

Please take care of yourself! We’re thinking of you.

CharChar Binks

At the risk of being parasocial, love you girl. Stay strong. Stay safe. Stay sane. 💜

fryfry

Maybe not the best place to ask, but what would be some effective ways to support those belonging to the transgender community during tough times, that involve donations, activism, etc. For someone who is not familiar with the community. I mean I know how to hug, but maybe I shouldn't go hugging random strangers.

Fabrizio

Thank you for the update and for sharing your thoughts on the matter. Whatever's coming, I wish for you to survive it and, eventually, thrive. Strong hugs from Europe.

Isto

As someone who’s been starting their journey of discovering myself as a nonbinary person, I’ve found a lot of older art from people who lived in a time when identities like my own could only be underground to be really helpful in this dark time Lou Reed’s ‘Transformer’ was the first thing I put in for myself on Wednesday, and idk if it’s denialism or ignorance but the irreverence of playing on and being unabashedly myself through this is the only way I can see myself through. It’s putting on some eyeliner on a butch fit and getting the coffee shop gays’ attention. It’s expressing myself to the people around me. Hoping you’re all able to find a little piece of that (what was probably an incomprehensible paragraph) still in the face of everything

Ann C

I'm also tired of the blame game and the narrative that our tent is too small (seriously?) or that we failed to connect with Trump voters. It's BS. Trump is a misogynist, racist, transphobic fascist, and they chose to vote for him. We'll all pay the price. Still, we have to get up off the floor and somehow move forward in solidarity. I'm reading Timothy Snyder and Ruth Ben-Ghiat to learn how to resist fascism.

Skibbityboo

There has never been a president more guaranteed to have poop on their grave than DJT.

Jeremy Bell

To all my fellow substance abusers & ED folks, we have to try to not use this as an excuse to spiral into our addictions. I already have & this week it’s been killing me, so I’m trying my best to surface back up for air

highclass_lady

Someone posted about precisely this on r/ContraPoints. I feel it too, how a traumatizing event like this election can bring up past trauma & addictions. As someone who has been there with both but a decade recovered, (anorexia ages 10 to 13 & 1st introduced to opioids at age 13 & had to get clean at 15), if I may, here's part of what I wrote to them: please do your best not to turn to ed's or any other form of harm against yourself as a way to feel a sense of control, to paraphrase what a friend told me, "you deserve to live & thrive more than he [Trump] does, or they [consertives, republicans, the alt right] do! I want to outlive Trump so I can laugh & toast champagne when I've outlasted him." In other words, 1 of the ways you can live your best life is by getting to a place where you can do better than those who hurt you. in accordance with Natalie's "Say Yes to Life" portion at the end of her Envy video, 1 of the best forms of vengeance is to survive & go on to live a fulfilling life, not just for vindication's sake or to spite those who hurt you, & but for your own sake, & maybe also to go on to help make it possible for others to do better as well. i say this as someone more than a decade later, there might be setbacks along the way, but even if your path forward is more relatable than perfect, don't ever give up on becoming the a better version of yourself; even in the midst of extremely difficult times, don't let those who would harm you take that determination from you: every flaw of yours is a learning opportunity to overcome, to grow & become a more healed, evolved, & enriched version of yourself, 1 step at a time, that's how your perspective will bring experience & insight to your voice! You'll get this after watching ContraPoints' Envy: you're both the white & the black swan, a mix of the Apollonian and the Dionysian, you've got this!

Dan McAlister

Thank you always for your work, and take care of yourself. We all need each other.

CrystalJade

Nice to hear from you Vivek. I agree. Conservative movements across the world seem to be interconnected. The problem is that defence mechanisms sell when they connect with people’s fears. It’s a problem of epistemology against psychological heuristics. Those heuristics are derived from the lack of capacity to analyse and frame ‘best interests’, creating the possibility of people voting for simple answers that don’t objectively make sense. It’s the fallacy of populism. The anti establishment narrative from conservatives and those further to the right feels like the manifestation of this fallacy. So riddled with paradox when allied with national pride. I really hope that these forces become fully exposed for what they are. I swear by Gary’s Economics on YouTube as an explainer to my friends. Definitely worthy of a look if you’ve not seen his work.

Jasper Rose

Download videos, save posts, save research papers, print what you can, burn DVDs, Store things. A decentralized archive for the next generation. They need to be able to learn from our experiences, we can't afford to get erased like our predecessors. Write journals, save everything you can, and SURVIVE.

william kirkpatrick

WOW I have never NEEDED to read anything so bad....I would rather watch one of your videos 100x than any other youtuber 2x. I want to say you are David Lynchish or Ken Russellish but thats not it....besides being the only true filmmaker you are just more aggressive and force me to see the world and my personal life both at once.....also I got really fucked up at a surprise Mentors concert and I am lucky I made it home. The first thing you say is that I'm normal to you to black out to block it out....I voted for a bill Dolores Huerta was against accidentally and realized how important her life is "DON'T PUSH ME AROUND!" so I am going to try to join her organization and do whatever they suggest as the mass deportation/concentration begins, and I want to save money. I play the piano and I know a ballet teacher who teaches in Holland every summer. Also I want to be a youtuber but that will take me years. You are my #1!

Delfina

You are so loved, lady. And you're also so right. This feels like one of the only true takes on The Situation I've seen in the past 4 days. Analysis or whatever can happen from the top-down IMO. Our spilled ink won't change big picture stuff like that, and our brainspace should be going to preserving, helping each other, and surviving. And I'm sure I speak for most of your audience when I say that whatever you decide you need to do as a public figure to protect yourself, we understand. And FUCK those small, disgusting, scared little pissbabies. May any of their loved ones with a conscience cut contact and may they eat each other alive from the inside out.

Emily

Tbh, not much progress will ever be made while focusing on the horror of the Republican party without facing the co-conspiratorial horror of the Dems too. All of American politics is a cult of personality and aesthetics, that's not a uniquely Republican vice. The Democrats had plenty of chances since Obama to codify reproductive rights, erase student debt, commit to climate action, pass any sensible gun control, and they never do. Why? It's time to stop thinking of this as a 'lesser of two evils' situation and face the overt reality at this point that the two evils are working together to make sure they always have access to your tax trillions and never have to give any of it back. I understand that many in the core of the empire will now personally experience the fascism that their working dollars have funded abroad. I feel no less horror for the women and trans people who are facing a very real existential threat right now. But if we continue to hide our heads in nostalgia and the comforting illusion that voting Democrat is all we need to do to be a good person fighting oppression... they will pick you off while you wait for any morally bankrupt politician in this system to care. Not even Bernie is calling the extermination of the Palestinian people a 'genocide'; they throw you people like him to water down your moral compass and keep you invested in a system that has never and will never save you. Protecting your rights is not profitable, and the entire North American colonization project is about profit, not people. I know it's hard to face, but the Democrats slashed so many programs and benefits that poor people rely on. Trump got in on a wave not because of misogyny, but because the Democrats abandoned the working class and called them terrorists when they begged for the most basic humanitarian action taken. Instead, billions and billions kept being sent abroad to crush children under bulldozers. And after watching the most nightmarish genocide unfold in real time, I will never be fooled by any candidate that the DNC selects from on high without a primary (does that actually sound democratic to anyone...?) I thought it must be misogyny when Hillary lost. 8 years later, I have read extensively about the history of US imperialism, and you literally just need to learn about the history of your government stealing millions of global donations from Haiti, building 6 houses with it, and calling it a 'gold rush' in leaked documents to wake up about what this system actually exists for. I'm going to make this simple for anyone still in denial about how racist, evil, and indifferent the Democrats are after watching them pretty much all applaud a war criminal that believes the children of Gaza are N@zis that brought this on themselves: If you are not in solidarity with oppressed peoples EVERYWHERE, all around the world, and continue to allow this grifter party to hold your human rights over your head every election, you will play right into their hands. Build global solidarity. Disengage from an evil system. Organize locally, but think globally. We don't have time for liberals acting exactly the way that Malcolm X said they would, and abandoning their concern for the oppressed the moment their already fascist regime comes for them next. Fascism was already here. The Dems kept Jill Stein off the ballot in many states and they ILLEGALLY continue to send money to ac active genocide. And I mean illegal against your own laws. You can google literally anything I've said here if you think I'm pulling it out of my ass. I've read extensively this past year. I used to smoke a mini cigar every American election out of stress, and this year... I knew a fascist piece of shit would get in no matter what.

griff bourne

I’m in the UK, you were one of the first people I thought of after had after heard the news. I really hope you and the people in your life are doing okay. This shouldn’t be the way things are, I hope you do what is best for your safety. I’m so sorry.

Einstein da Silva

Excelent comment! I can totally understand people being terrified by Trump's election and/or choosing to vote and campaign for Harris. But the enthusiasm is something I can't wrap my mind around. The sensation of "we won" that they would for sure feel if she was elected is honestly demoralising.

S. R.

Yes, it seems that's true! Sorry, I didn't know about "Associate's."

Rachel Muir

Natalie, one of the things you can do is to use your platform to encourage folks to have their paperwork in order; SS number, passport, birth certificate -- at least in the states where this is viable.

Rachel Muir

Invisible histories, (https://invisiblehistory.org), is urging LGBTQ+ organizations and individuals to take steps to protect their presence and history on the web. They are looking for web savvy folks to aid in the project. Check out their website.

Pidge

a big one would be to search for local trans-supportive orgs in your city/county/state! if it seems like there’s a lot of well-funded ones, you can search for trans safety US maps by state and donate to trans-supportive orgs in states flagged for aggressive anti-lgbt or anti-trans laws. for search terms, I would use (for example) “atlanta transgender support” or “atlanta lgbt organization,” or (especially in smaller or redder cities/towns) “(town name) trans mutual aid.” I hope that’s a helpful start!! ;_; thank you for asking

Mia Vodanovich

Thank you for all that you have given and all that you have been. In a message to you and everyone in the comments: I cannot fix everything that the Republican party of Trump plans to do, but I am here for all of you and I will fight for all of you. I love you.

Pidge

it’s hard to believe you’re willingly a part of this community when you’ve spent so much time arguing a bad faith point about an alt-right crank. there’s “no good evidence” of harm =/= “vaccines cause autism” or anything else. in fact, even when there is “good evidence” of harm, patients often continue to make the decision to take medications because the benefit outweighs the harm. I take three medications that erode my bone marrow density because, if I don’t take them, I won’t be managing a chronic condition that otherwise lands me in the ER regularly. Everyone in my family who’s had covid has either been extremely sick, hospitalized, or died, and that’s true of tens of millions of people in our country. Before widespread flu vaccine campaigns, millions of people died of influenza each year in the US, and millions more abroad. Even if these medications cause some amount of harm, there’s no viable argument for discontinuing them, just as there’s no viable argument for shutting down the USDA over the recent widespread listeria outbreak. Regulatory agencies need more funds to do the studies you’re asking about, which are extremely expensive, resource-intensive, and logistically difficult to implement, especially with a large enough population size that they’d be viable. If we waited 10 years to distribute a covid vaccine, how many millions of people would die waiting for it? How many millions of people died of the flu and of tuberculosis (in the US) before vaccine campaigns for those diseases? If you’re so impassioned about this topic, doing research from multiple perspectives (rather than asking for citation lists from random people in comments! “prove me wrong!”) is your best bet. goodnight!!!

Pidge

tuberculosis is actually the most deadly infectious disease in the world— if you’ve got so much free time to “research” RFK’s ideas about public health, maybe you can spare some to learn about the global health burden of TB, for which treatment and vaccines have existed for decades, but which many countries have no access to. It would be a great focus point for comparing the health outcomes (including lifespans) of the populations you’ve shown concern about.

Pidge

there’s not (currently) a way to survey voter’s actual history and motivations for their choices (most people don’t understand their internal motives!), and especially not a method for figuring out exactly why members of the democratic party made the decisions they did. If we do find out, it will be through the lens of history, and it will only be an overview. Right now, what’s more helpful (and this isn’t “moving on” at all!) is focusing on how you can contribute to your community and to the people who will most need help in this administration. that’s not “moving on,” it’s addressing a problem with the resources you have available. it’s standing and facing reality with realistic tools for positive change. I’m mourning, too, but there’s plenty of tragedy that can still be prevented.

Evan Pitkin

I'm baffled and annoyed at the implication that you can't help your community and analyse the mistakes that led us here at the same time. As someone who tries to use what time and resources they have to help people in need, it's been heart-rending to donate to the PCRF, go to rallies and raise awareness about the genocide we(Americans) are directly implicated in causing, and then watch the Democratic candidate pledge to continue the slaughter. You're right in saying I cannot quantify what effect this had on turnout for Kamala, but I do continuously find myself reeling at how indifferent people are to this issue, as if the blanket support for mass murder amongst even Democrats isn't an issue that needs to be immediately addressed. You cannot make appeals to voters' morality on the one hand, and cosign the bombing of hospitals, refugee camps and apartments full of sheltering civilians on the other. The mass murder of even more civilians in Gaza is a tragedy every American has an obligation to try and prevent, even if you don't feel it as directly.

UponaWhim

So…where are we moving to? Seriously, what are the best options?

Indija-ka Siriwardena

Good to hear ☺️ I'll see how I can help, but it looks comprehensive, so I'll defer back to working and being good to the people in my real life. Having seen a bit of Tina Friml and putting my own Annansi on. "I hear there is a super secret surprise pre-inauguration party at Lago for all the silent supporters getting Orange actual in to the big leagues, but the MSM isn't allowed talk about it or 🦊" So they have to get their before the end of the month without telling anyone, 😹😹😹 We'll need lots of laughter from some place, may as well be from the ones who secretly wanted it to happen. It's going to be ok -ish.

Austin Luther

Everyone, stay safe and help who you can.

Kritzlof

We all just have to try to stick together and resist in what ways we can. Take care of yourself everyone <3

norah

keep going your voice is more important now!

Kharina Sterner

The majority of UK are in total disbelief. It affects the rest of the world too, with the far right in the UK trying to make their voices louder and more obnoxious. This election win has provided a "be a dickhead" free for all, and we are already seeing proof of racist rhetoric rising. We are on standby and watching carefully - anything remotely hateful will be struck down by us ordinary citizens. I'm sending strength to you, our cousins the other side of the pond. Know we suffer with you, and that we stand with you

Molly Greeves

Sending love from the UK. Your work is invaluable. Take care yourself

Tivvv3

I'd be very surprised if RFK Jr. wasn't on board with fighting Tuberculosis and other chronic conditions. And yes please continue taking your meds until people like RFK Jr. make that progress on addressing root causes, he'd tell you that too. I'm not sure what is wrong about "use all available options". Sure it's hard to give informed consent but calling that out is not a bad thing I'd say?

Tivvv3

Awful ways to frame some topics, even awful takes regarding some topics does not make a universally bad faith or incompetent actor. He comes from his milieu and you come from yours. I'm not gonna be a partisan for some machine one way or another. If there's bounty to share I'll look that way. RFK Jr. has demonstrated competence in many regards and overlapping attention on topics that have garnered the attention of many serious and competent health professionals. That does not have to diminish the awful things he might stand for. And so it's not your job to carry the weight of the world. Keeps you silo'd.

Tivvv3

"Regulatory agencies need more funds to do the studies you’re asking about, which are extremely expensive" I'm all for more money without strings attached to these regulatory bodies. And also get the revolving door between industry and regulatory bodies fixed.

Dorothy Claire Wiesner

Everyone was a co-conspirator this election, from the far right to neoliberals to the left. I saw so many leftists throw away our civil rights because they either refused to vote or voted for Jill Stein out of protest to the situation in Gaza, somehow uninformed that a Trump presidency would be even worse for Palestinians. Knowing that there was little we could do as Americans, leftists could have voted for American democracy and the rights of POCs and queer people. Leftists could have voted against throwing away our environment to Republicans who will do nothing about climate change. But many did not. And then they sit on their high horse and blame equally complicit liberals. Fuck the DNC, but leftists who didn't vote or seriously considered Jill Stein after what happened in 2016 need to realize that they're also part of the problem. We all suck, all of us, and now we're going to live in the little hell of our own makings for at least four more years.

Tivvv3

Side note I'm not into accelerationism nor immiseration theories so for all I know the people in charge will fix issues to do with US public health after most other options have been exhausted while they have a lot more options to exhaust when it comes to TB in the third world. It's a question of power and telling people that their narrow priorities aren't as important as those issues like TB is not a way to build power as far as I understand even if it's true.

Ace

Please please use your platform to promote action and resistance. There’s nothing wrong with taking that time to process, but we need to make this country ungovernable if these policies actually come to pass. We got our rights by organizing, not by voting, and we need to defend them the same way.

hey_boo (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-06 00:00 Thank you Natalie. Your work means a lot. Thank you for your time and energy.
2024-11-11 18:07

Liz Phang

I am always so grateful for your voice, we're about to need it more than ever <3

George Berberian

No, Dems haven't had "plenty of chances" to do these things. Dems don't have the ability to pass lots of legislation as the GOP has controlled the House and/or the Senate, or TFG was President. Same pretty much goes with Biden. All those wonderful things you want need to go through a lot of hurdles which are close to impossible to pass unless a party has a majority in Congress as well as holding the executive branch. The last time for Dems was during Obama's first term from 2009-2011. That's when they passed the ACA. Technically, 2 senators were independents at that time, so something like reproductive rights would have been difficult to pass. Now that the country has pretty much handed the keys over the the Republicans, they could pass pretty much everything if they win the House. And who knows how the Neocons on SCOTUS will rule, but I think we can take a good guess. So, that's what liberals gave up by choosing to vote third party or stay at home. I can only hope the GQP will be relatively dysfunctional for 2 years and then hope people sway back to Dems controlling Congress, which could limit power. We shall see.

Jeremy Bell

Can’t tell you how much this means to me. I started an account on “I am sober” and am going to try it out. It’s a sobriety born out of hopelessness and cold resignation to a period of numb mediocrity & mechanical living. But I hope that it maybe helps my expectations for love and fulfillment feel feasible again ❤️❤️❤️

I identify as a Stuka!

If it's any comfort, fascists have an uncanny knack for snatching defeat from the jaws of victory. Methods include (but are not limited to): Politicizing science, scapegoating useful minorities, taking on too many enemies at once and failing to cooperate effectively with allies. However, they can do considerable damage in the process of losing...

Isaac Mac

Looking at other countries too. Any top contenders for you guys?

Zoë Collis

Dear Natalie, I went to your instagram several times and checked youtube for any sign of you as soon as I ripped myself away from endlessly refreshing the vote counter, once I knew what the result was going to be. Then I found the email copy of this post in my inbox. I'm heartbroken for you. For all of you in the U.S. I'm not from the U.S, and if you need to leave, I think my country would be a safe place for you, well, safer, no where is ideal, leaving your home would be a terrible thing to have to go through, it's all terrible. Whatever happens, please know that you and your work have truly shaped and guided me for the better part of a decade, pretty much all of my twenties. You are my favourite creator, and I am so grateful to you for everything. I apologise for the parasociality of this next statement, but I'm human, so I care. I love you. I do not know you, but you are one of my favourite people ever to exist in human history. Please survive. Your work has been my comfort channel when I've had no one else, you've taught me so much, and helped me more than I can put into words. Again I'm just so grateful for everything you've made. I'm so sorry to you, and to all the Americans who read this. If it is to come to pass that Natalie may have to take down her work for her own safety, does anyone have any ideas on how to respectfully keep them somehow? all I can think of is to save up to buy a hard drive and screen record them, I'm not very good with technology, unfortunately. Natalie, or anyone else if you see this, is that an ethical thing to do? I will miss them and you very much. Please survive.

Eddie

Stay strong Natalie! Can’t wait to see the video. :) thank you for sharing your wisdom ❤️

Zoë Collis

Does anyone know or have any ideas as to what's going to count/ be criminalised if this comes to pass? I feel like I need to start saving everything I love pretty much onto a hard drive. I Think it would amass to thousands of hours of creators work, shows, films with any representation in them, so much music, so many posts and videos. there's so much and I don't even know how to do it and only have one old struggling laptop. This is so horrifying and overwhelming. So much progress and representation and art gone or suppressed, So much might just disappear Could anyone from (thinking of random examples from all over the place) disappear or be in danger of incarceration? like even someone as rich/powerful/comfortable and mainstream as Lady Gaga? or something as center left 2010's wholesome as parks and rec with barely any representation? hell even disney of all companies has gay characters in tiny blink and you'll miss it moments in stuff now. I'm naming things I consider to be so, so tame and trying to gage what might be safe pretty much for one reason or another? But I can also see how they might not be safe depending on how extreme this could become

The Forest Bunch

I think it’s very unlikely that content on privatized, for-profit places like YouTube will be successfully banned. Capitalism is the end all be all in this country for better or worse, Amazon will not stop making money off books if there’s a demand to sell them and Google will not stop making money on leftist and queer content if there’s a demand to watch it. MAGA may try but I think their only success will be in more vulnerable and accessible sources like libraries and schools, those will be something we’ll have to protect as much as possible and rebuild in 4+ years. And if they’re actually stupid enough to ban all porn, their own fanbase will be rioting in the streets. I know MAGA will destroy itself, they aren’t actually united and they’re all trigger-happy, arrogant, and vindictive. It’s not a sustainable paradigm. But the question is how much damage they will cause as they cannibalize each other… that’s what is frightening.

highclass_lady

I've been thinking a lot about hope. Because something I was told that was very helpful to me when I was an adolescent was "live in the present moment, BUT if the moment you're in (is 1 of misery &) is not a moment you want to be living in, while then there's hope." I've been thinking about that advice because this election feels uniquely antithetical to hope, like somehow hope, especially larger scale big picture hope feels to my rational brain like a mix of denial, minimizing, ignorance, naivety, or dismissal. I feel like I'd be acting like an annoying, insensitive privileged a-hole telling people to have hope when I'm not one of the most vulnerable in this situation, because there's something sharply inconsiderate about that. But having & creating hope is not all or nothing. It's not only applicable in one way or universal to every situation, there are versions of hope that can be applied to realistic places, or in realistic ways. Hope is not an excuse or a blanket to throw over something to deny the suffering of others for your own comfort &/or the comfort of those who benefit from a situation or status quo that is or will be worse for those who suffer. We've been let down in disparagingly traumatizing ways, in the realization that the values & protections that help create a safer, kinder, more ethical & less exploitative world were blatantly looked past or audaciously voted against. It's knowing that they want to take away who we are. That feels traumatizingly antithetical to hope. But when talking to a friend I've known since we were children, I was reminded that hope is not the same thing as trying. Not always. And hope is not the only reason to try or to keep going. I told her "it's okay that we had hope, it was better to try. And trying doesn't stop just because things have gone this badly. If anything, a new type of trying starts now. We create our own reasons to keep going, even in the absence of hope." I told my friend what I did because she had reached out to me in a very dark & serious way, & although I also encouraged her to seek professional help, I wanted her to know that I understood the grimness of the situation & that the pieces of optimism we can choose to hold on to in carrying through isn't coming from a place of denial but of resilience. Resilience is a form of resistance that's rooted in survival. In times like these we create our own reasons to keep going, even when the right now & "very soon" future feels bleak & the "someday future" feels so far away, but 1 way we resist is to keep going. I've been near the bottom, trust me, & I promise you that even if it's not realistic to change your situation right now, there may still come a day when you'll be able to build a beautiful life even after all you've been through. So do your best not to burn out, to preserve all the goodness & potential that is still in you, because keeping going is part of resistance, it's part of creating moments in the midst of a storm. Even if you don't feel some grandeur of hope in any given moment, or only feel hope about smaller more temporary bits & pieces rather than the big picture as a whole, sustainably keeping going, trying, is how we create those moments that we make meaningful & beautiful. We create our own meanings, even when, especially when, our feelings & versions of hope at times evolve & transform. And 1 of the many forums of resistance, 1 of the many reasons to fight on & keep going, is all the good they can't stop us from, all the good that we can do. (Even if it's not right at this moment, even if it's not all at once, even though it may often be a little at a time). Hope is wonderful but part of hope is also still a feeling, so sometimes even hope is vulnerable to the same seeming fleetingness as other feelings. And we resist not just because of how we feel but because of what we care about & who we love. So we resist by keeping on going, especially in the midst of hardship, because keeping on going is part of how we can do all the good that we can do. And who you are is worth it all on it's own. This is the anti-capitalist in me so bare with me & listen: you are inherently valuable not just for what you can do, but because you are. In other words, keep going also because you are valuable, regardless of what you can do or if you feel you are in any given moment. So that's 2 more reasons to keep going. And you can only keep counting & keep on creating reasons & moments if you keep going. So keep counting.

Christine Kelly

Looking hard at Costa Rica and of course Canada

Mimi

Thank you, Natalie. I'm trying to figure out whether I'm panicking, depressed, ready to fight, or ready to cut and run. Am pursuing each and all but from a position of complete exhaustion (ie; all the exhaustions: physical, mental, emotional, spiritual). Your voice and point of view are very important to me. I don't see the emails because my email account is a mess right now *shrug*

James Clark

I mean you might be right here because he’s using the technique that made president Hoover flopped.

Tai

I hope you and everyone else is doing okay. It's definitely comforting to hear a creator/thinker I respect and admire tell me things are fucked up and it's not wrong to feel scared and disappointed, but also that we must step up and support each other.

Kieley Evatt

Sending love to a woman I admire. You're such a role model and although I'm sure it's hard to be public and will only get harder for you, I'm so glad you're here helping guide us

jesusluvsyouuu

Thanks for the thoughts, Natalie. ❤️

Paola

💜💜

Demeter Ev

Hey. To quote you back, we can always keep on living, out of spite. You gotta stay safe and the rest of us gotta start contrapointing our way out of madness. if not loudly and publicly, then in quiet spiteful ways. At least neo-liberalism does not mask it self as a friend anymore. It was meant to happen. And now queers gotta provide for queers big time, and i want to believe when the first wave of frustration and disappointment wears off, we will get creative for it.

Lux

Dear Natalie, I feel with you. The news is shocking. Now more than ever - now we will be all the more united and fight for ourselves and others. Things aren't looking much better in Germany at the moment: the rise of the far-right Afd, the progression of inequality, the dissolution of the government and Friedrich Mertz as the potential next Federal Chancellor a.k.a. Mr Blackrock. A man who voted against criminalising marital rape. A man who agitates against the unemployed and migrants. Arrogant, cold and stupid. A Trump comes with many faces. But the core is the same. At least the finance minister has been sacked. Hallelujah. I believe that it is very important to track down our own and collective failings and analyse them, if not now, then later. To learn from them. Which does not absolve Trump voters and the Republicans of their own responsibility. Sending you much strength (which already lies within you), love and equanimity. Feel (consensually) embraced. All the best Lux

Hm

I don’t think it’s shocking at all… I anticipated this and left in September for overseas. It was pretty obvious this was gonna have a good chance of happening probably this year and if not this year than another 4 years from now.

Lux

You are right. I don't feel/think it's that shocking in the sense of unforeseen. I wish you all the best on your future journey

Lauren

Thank you ❤️

Mina Y.

I know this doesn’t mean much and is parasocial as fuck but i do keep you in my thoughts and wish you all the best

livvy94

Some thing worth mentioning is that DIY isn't that hard after you clear the first hurdle of using cryptocurrency and all that crap. Managing hormones is less hectic than managing insulin

Gokce Sencan

Keeping you and everyone else targeted by Trump and his cronies in my thoughts. I've been trying to get a green card for years and spent thousands of dollars in the process. I'm really close to finally getting it, but terrified of my prospects if I can't get it by January 20 (though even if I do, what kind of a country will I find myself in as an immigrant woman with an accent? I escaped one authoritarian regime and found myself in another). I'm trying to come up with a possible exit plan and downsize my life in case I have to leave the US quickly. I'm terrified, paralyzed, distracted, can't sleep and can't concentrate on anything. Can't even imagine what undocumented immigrants must be going through right now.

Citrine The Corgi

Im definitely scared about the future of our country especially as a trans person. But we cant just wollow and go away like they want us to. Now is definitely the time to get as loud and as queer as we possibly can. There are also organizations such as the aclu which will continue to fight for our rights regardless of the situation. The worst thing we can do is disapear. The next 4 years wont be easy, but we gotta strap in.

The Forest Bunch

That comment already makes it clear I don’t care what anyone you like has to say. If you have “no sympathy” you are as bad as the fascists. About 13% of the country voted for this and many of them are uneducated and will be some of the most impacted by this administration.

Themilksnake | Rian Tran (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-14 12:00 Survival as a marginalized group in a country which wants to outlaw your existence is an act of RESISTANCE!!! We stand strong together. If anybody here is based in Upstate NY, I am compiling as many resources from as many areas as possible, in order to form a list before websites go down, info is taken away, etc. We may only have phone numbers and addresses left, who knows. My email is lyhoang@riavanitas.com. Ask me for signal.
2024-11-13 02:21

iamdatname

I'm Australian and I'm freaking out. I'm just thinking about the climate on top of all you mentioned. I'm chronically ill and I just think about all the meds I need to live and the access just being cut off due to environmental conditions. Like America sets the stage for the entire world. Also our election is coming up and it seems our conservative party is going to get in as well. Sick of being trans and disabled in this fucked world.

Leo D

Wait, I’m in Upstate NY too! I’m gonna shoot you an email

gijoes

tried emailing you but it was returned as undeliverable.

gijoes

I am looking to the future with both dread and anticipation. Dread because I don't know how far this will go. Will American institutions be able to protect civil rights? Will community matter if there are literal purges of "the enemy within?" Will our democratic republic, the American experiment, survive this massive upheaval of fear and ignorance? But also anticipation, because I want to know what I can do to help resist hate and tyranny. You have my support, Natalie. How that support is realized remains to be seen, but it will be realized.

Forgiveness333

Unpopular opinion incoming… I think it’s safe to say that we’re in a period of regression when it comes to LGBTQ rights, and I’d like to suggest some ideas for why that may be the case in the year of our lord 2024, and how we can get back towards progress. We’ve spent the last 5-10 years being as “loud and queer as possible” as many in the comments here have put it, and I think it’s no surprise that this period has also seen an increase in resistance to our efforts. As a queer person living in the Deep South, I have a first hand perspective into what conservatives think about LGBTQ rights, and it has RADICALLY shifted in the years that we moved from marriage equality to more progressive ideas. While I wish that “issues” like gender affirming care for minors and trans athletes were NOT hot button issues, the reality is that they are, and that they have fueled a TON of backlash against our movement. Has LGBTQ advocacy has become too progressive too quickly? Have we alienated the general public resulting in backlash, rather than acceptance? It feels like it. While I’d never suggest anyone diminish themselves of their queerness, I do believe we need to get better at understand opposing viewpoints and try to suss out what integration into society looks like. The opposite approach is not working. Whether we like it or not, we are the minority and must convince the majority to vote in ways that’s benefits and protects us and, as of this election, they are simply not convinced. Nay, they are confused and turned-off. Worst case scenario. I’m convinced there is a middle ground we can begin to work from and focus on steady progress rather than huge, immediate leaps. By making our most bi-partisan issues the central focus and pushing our most progressive ideas only to the correct audiences, we can regain some balance with the voting public at large and flip the trajectory back in our favor.

Espresso Afterglo

I read a really good thinkpiece that gave some perspective. In the last 20 years we have had a strong gay rights movement, another wave of feminism, and climate movement. And based on history, after a strong progressive movement, there is often backlash and we enter a time where we have to defend those movements. We have entered (or maybe have been in) a period of backlash for the progress that has been made, and we have to switch to preserving the progress. I'm not happy about it, but that's where we are.

IamBrix

I can't say much to make the fear and anger go away but you've shaped my beliefs so much and you're such a sweet brilliant person

דוד צמיר-גל

Maybe you should make a video specifically about the political system. I know it's not your niche, but it will help a lot. A video attempting to reach Trump supporters; yes, it is possible, and forgetting it's possible means giving up on America; it's a challenge but obviously if anyone can make it, it's Contrapoints

fryfry

Thanks. That gives me a place to start. I guess there are so many, though, and so many ways.

fryfry

Also got pointed to the ACLU for this.

Ted(dy)

don’t set your hopes on Canada it’s not looking great there either

Einstein da Silva

Yeah sure, the lesson to be learned in this election is that the small faction whose votes literally made no difference are shitty people for not voting for Hitler Jr. against Hitler, and not that people who ACTUALLY hold power (aka democrats) did a terrible job at convincing, mobilising american people and standing a real chance in the election and therefore THEY must do and be better.

Einstein da Silva

Last time I checked, Dems had plenty of resource and human material to elect enough members to the House and Senate. But yeah, how could you expect that much from a party that has total autonomy to decide how an on which platforms to run an election under a system they have been adapted to dispute since forever? It's probably just impossible, only a group of political gods could sort it out

Einstein da Silva

It's probably gonna be like the boiling frog. Nothing is going to change from one day to another but your lives will be a lot shittier 4 years from now.

Simon

I dont hate on all forms of liberalsm and certainley not indivduals but its tough for me not to he mad at liberal politcal institutions from my particular situation , looks like liberals unfairley, frauduentley "sand bag" the left and then lose/give power to the right. How can the liberals be so fuckin useless yet manage to beat the left. if the democratic est had got behind the left and a populist, even vulgar left agenda there would have been a fight at least, no? should i feel this kind of dread, I may just be having a slow mild week long heart attack. best wishes

Omega-Tech666

as i sit here in fear of the situation that is approaching in jan.6 of 2025. i fear two things. one is a all out civil war of the people of the right and the people of the left killing each other and mass media will be trying to cover this mayhem of death and gore. two, people just fleeing outta the country. seeking asylum and safety away from america. i don't really know but this is going to get ugly asap once jan.6 happen.

pjkc

The worst is all the three letter agencies, they're all completely fucked. At least there are some checks in congress -- the Republican majorities look like they're gonna be pretty slim, seemingly down-ballot candidates did far worse than the top of the ticket for the GOP. But I don't think people are internalizing how radically and quickly things could change in the executive branch, esp with schedule F. God damn it

livvy94

Also! My friend talked to an endocrinologist and they said that it's impossible to change Estradiol to a controlled substance in just four years. Also, since it's used for so many different purposes and for cis women, pharmaceutical companies would have a fit if he ever tried to pull anything! So at least there's some solace

Bitesize

Afraid I can't offer much except if you choose to escape to Sweden for any length of time, my home is your home. In solidarity/ another Natalie

Cassady

GOOD IDEA!

Millicent Gray

I’m sorry :( stay safe. You’re welcome at my place in Australia, on the other side of the world xxx

May

Love you Natalie

shadow-r

I would just like to add some hearts to the conversation, though they'll never be found <3

Dana Zoutman

thank you for sharing your thoughts, natalie 💛 sending our love and support from the netherlands, where you are very very welcome to come and stay with us if the Situation develops..

Lightningal

It's nice to hear/read from you. I am very concerned about the community in the USA. Sending you all my love. Although here in Germany the chaos also started right after Trump's election victory because our chancellor Olaf Scholz (SPD, our social democrats) fired the finance minister, causing the government coalition to break apart. My suspicion is that Finance Minister Christian Lindner (FDP, Free Democratic Party, our neoliberals) deliberately provoked this after waiting for the US decision by making demands that coalition partners could not keep, blocking necessary investments and ultimately calling for new elections in front of all his coalition partners. New elections will be held in February and the most likely scenario is that the CDU (Christian Democratic Union), which is closest to the AFD (Alternative for Germany, our extreme right), will be re-elected. They plan to cut billions from our social system and introduce tax cuts (but for whom?). I bet the lobbyists of the big corporations are lining up and licking their fingers. Next year will be extremely uncomfortable, to put it nicely.

Kia Nicole Tudor

Why shouldn't I want the Democrats to do more and actually earn my vote? Why doesn't reason work? Don't just write off the entire country as unreasonable people who whine about not getting what they want, when every single person who is saying this are the people who are actually doing that. I'm not going to shut up and color and vote for one of the shitty parties when you know neither of them will do anything good for anyone.

Wesley Loving

You misunderstand. "Reason won't save us" is not the accusation "You, and everyone else, is unreasonable". It's just saying that reason is not a front in the conflict; nor is it an effective weapon. We're not going to help anyone or anything by using reason now. Anyone wishing the Democrats had debated harder is deranged. The Republicans stand a much better chance of "do anything bad" to her, people like her, and people NOT like her, and the fact that you and many others didn't care about that enough to actually do something about it (in aggregate) is extremely alienating and depressing. The Trump Show is back on the air in January, baby, and now we all just tensely tearfully wait for the hurricane to make landfall.

Hayley Books

I also live in the South as a queer person and to be very honest, every progressive social movement in history has been labeled as “going too far” in order to stop that progress. It is a harmful and regressive way of thinking. We cannot abandon our fight for the most marginalized or lose ground to those who want to push us towards complete assimilation in exchange for crumbs. We have to, HAVE to hold our ground and push for more. People smarter than me have talked about this very well. Read the recent NYT article “Enough” by Roxanne Gay, watch the videos “On the Election of a Fascist President” and “Stop blaming trans people for the election (and start blaming Republicans)” (minute 1:50 address this question DIRECTLY) by Citation Needed on YouTube. Heck, while we’re here, I also think Natalie’s video “The Witch Trials of J.K. Rowling” (start at 1:22:07 for her thoughts on this point specifically) does a great job of debunking this way of thinking and giving a ton of context for the way this line of thought has played out in the past. We don’t need to have a public consensus or persuade the masses to get the rights we deserve. We have to demand them, fight for them, and win them. As we always have done. People will not like it. The will say you’re taking it too far and try and steer you off course. You have to have the conviction and perseverance to get it done in order to make the world a more just place for the most marginalized, because is the right thing to do and it has succeeded in the past.

Cristina Madeira

You are an amazing human... And trust me, the world is wachting, we are with all women, trans, black, brown, indigenous, etc. You are stronger than you think <3 Love from Portugal, where you have a place to stay <3

Kylie Prestridge

"I can't get a government which answers all my preferences, so I'm going to allow the worst possible government in US history to gain power and destroy the lives of a large chunk of the people who live in my country" is a hell of a way to announce that you don't care about anyone but yourself. As part of a community, you have a civic duty to try and minimise harm to other people within your community. If this means holding your nose and voting for a party which only vaguely meets some of your criteria but which at least isn't actively threatening to harm half the country in order to prevent a far worse party from gaining control of your country, then that's what a good person must do. Non-voters are every bit as much to blame for the loss of life and destruction of democracy that lies ahead as Trump voters are.

Kia Nicole Tudor

Minimizing harm, to me, looks like not propping up the corrupt class of people who anoint themselves rulers with the vote as a "blessing." You do realize the Democrats fund radical right wing politicians in local races, right? https://www.npr.org/2022/11/11/1135878576/the-democrats-strategy-of-boosting-far-right-candidates-seems-to-have-worked I think you are right, that we have a duty to try to minimize harm. But when the Democrats have a vested interest in keeping minorities poor and dependent, I know they aren't going to help us. They had quite some time to pass legislation protecting abortion rights and transgender rights, and didn't. Because if they can't keep us all on the hook with fear, we might not see them as the only thing between us and certain doom. Wouldn't want people to feel too secure, would they? Don't vote out of fear. Vote from a place of assessing the long term. Neither of those parties is good for this country long term, so I didn't vote for either of them. And I live in a blue state anyway.

Alex

<3

Blank

I agree to an extent. Democrats need to do better. They have a non-trivial amount of power. They aren't using that power competitively in relation to the Republicans. Maybe my head was too much in the sand, I didn't have a sense of what Harris was going to concretely do for the country. Where was our massive book of Democrat policies? I heard some mentions about relief for middle or lower class but that's about it. I still voted for Harris because the alternative is disappointing at best, horrifying at worst. And I'm very depressed about the results across the board. The future looks bleak. I only hope my fears are greater than the reality of it.

Viviane P.L.

I'm sorry for what's happening to all queer, women, people of colour and immigrants in USA. I'm Brazilian, long-time fan of contrapoints and recent suporter on patreon. I was shocked when Trump was first elected but I was sort of less surprised this time. Maybe after surviving Bolsonaro's presidency here (" tropical trump") was somehow a prelude to the damages of far right taking power worldwide. Nonetheless I reckon the fear, anger and hopeless feelings that can overcome us when rights - and life itself- are threatened. Brazil's politics and far right movement is heavily influenced by USA and so many countries can be affected by Trump's administration. I hope we can summon strength and gather with our loved ones to resist such difficult years ahead.

Fr3nchFrii

I know things are unsettling and have been rapidly becoming moreso in the last few years. I understand having the response you did as I would have had a very similar one if I'd read a comment like mine just a few years ago. I hope you're able to find strength, and a pinch of hope throughout the collapsing of American Imperialism. The violence of the State, especially here with our racist military police trained in the art of dehumanizing, has a much higher body count for rape/murder (so does Christianity/the church, just to honorably mention), and have murdered more people every 2-3 years than died during 9/11. They get away with it the majority of the time, with consequences only for the most vile and/or publicly enacted, and with most getting to continue into having a future, unlike their victims, and the countless loved ones left to grief without justice. These are features not bugs and the system can't be reformed, it must be revolutionized.

Archmage

Idk, for a lot of those people (if not all) just the act of listening is the act of submission. They need to learn the value of listening first, i guess? Idk

April Tuesday

Love your show! Raising my sub from $2 to $10. You've really improved my life 💖

McClackClack

Hey I'm sorry because this isn't the best forum but either way I need help with a question: I'm trying to help lgbtqia youth and the best organization seems to be the Trevor project. Is there a better place to donate/possibly volunteer for?

Punk Dinosaur

As a politicized person who comes from the Third World, whose countries and societies get fucked by the U.S. Te*rr0r State, either through bombs, sanctions, vetoes in U.N. "interventions to restore democracy" (which we all know mean invasions), I am extremely DISAPPOINTED in your stance, Contrapoints, and most of these comments about your ignorance and apathy concerning the U.S. T*e*rr0r State actions in Occupied Palestine, in Lebanon, and the rest of the colonized world! To quote Malcolm X: "You cannot solve the Mississipi without solving the Congo," and to quote Aime Cesaire, "Nazism is colonialism come home", you just CANNOT solve your internal far-right problem without trying to solve its external colonial impacts, including genocide of an indigenous people, which is exactly what the country you're living in right now is built on! Genocide of the Native Americans! (Also that the word "American" comes from Amerigo Vespucci an Italian settler/colonizer WOW lol). I am extremely frustrated by Americans' selfishness, to not speak up enough against your state's actions messing up and destroying other peoples' futures, lives, homes, countries, families, identities, completely robbing half the world of our destinies. And you have the audacity to write bullshit like "Democrats are too woke/not woke enough" as they have continued the genocide for the last 14 months. It shows that you value your life more than the life of an oppressed person in Gaza or Beirut. I am UNSUBSCRIBING because there has been enough time you could have spoken up more, now I don't even consider you a leftist / socialist / woke anymore, you're just yet another white 'American' (t)girl who cares more about your white privilege than working towards true collective liberation. Keep on making your pop-culture analysis about Satanism or whatever, the pseudo-left loves to eat this shit up, to make themselves feel smarter or whatever, games and cakes to keep you busy as the colonized worlds burn under your t3rr0r state regime.

Mathilda

Continue doing media Natalie !now more than ever is when it's needed, put your crown back on, as you said, step it up, don't tone it down <3 You have a place in Paris if you want (although changes need to occur here aswell ...)

James

this person is 100% correct, idk why you're bringing this condescension lol

Siba Gasser

So, you're basically frustrated that she didn't mention any of the damage the US is doing to so many other countries and that she's only focusing on inside of the U.S.? I'm trying to understand. Your point seems to make a lot of sense, but as a person living in a country who's not been totally exploited by the U.S. state, I'm most likely somewhat ignorant of this. My wife comes from a country very much negatively affected by the U.S. and she has similar feelings and points towards the U.S., I'm just trying to understand yours, and where your frustration in the context to this post comes from specifically.

SMH

Sophia - couldn't have said it better myself.

Darren DM

I hear you. I had the same issue recently with my pizza delivery man. I was disgusted to learn that he never once raised the issue of American imperialism when delivering pizza. This guy delivers pizza to hundreds of people each week. If he had raised the issue with each customer, he could have tipped the geopolitical baIance in the direction of justice and equity. But instead he chose to grift for tips. What a scumbag. I was so angry I threw the pizza back at him. I don't think I'll ever be able to eat pizza again. And that is a tragedy.

Noah

Ikr, like how dare she forget to dismantle the entire US military industrial complex /s

Mellow Baku

there's a difference between a pizza delivery guy and someone with a large audience discussing things completely relevant to discrimination, and pertaining to world politics, mentioning Ukraine and ignoring horrific genocide in Palestine, and america's legacy of bloodshed slavery and current ignorance etc . . . as you surely know. But it's easy to go for a reductionist cheap joke. all the people (apparently the majority of americans) who don't want to look at these difficult issues will applaud you. long live the state of denial and ignorance.

Darren DM

The irony here is that Natalie has addressed much of this in her recent AMAs, so I shall not recapitulate. Watch them.

João Guilherme Viana

TL; DR: "They should have turned to the camera and specified they’re the exact kind of communist I am."

João Guilherme Viana

Falou tudo! I would love for Natalie Wynn to visit Brazil one day. Such a light in dark times.

Thistle Pass

Wondering how you're feeling now that Trump has announced his plans to seize control of the Gaza Strip and ethnically cleanse it of Palestinians. How's your moral superiority holding up? Hopefully you still feel self-righteous. Wouldn't want real-life conditions to get in the way of your self-congratulatory onanism!

Noah

LMAOO @João Guilherme Viana exactly

Samantha Rhoads

This post has me thinking about all the US citizens that abstained from voting for Kamala because of Palestine. *Sigh*

Avery

Natalie, I’ve followed your work since 2017 because I believed in your stance against racism, fascism, the dangers of reactionary politics, and the ways bigotry festers in online spaces. Your work has even helped me on my own queer journey, giving me language and perspective to understand myself in ways I hadn’t before. But your silence on the genocide in Gaza has been deeply disappointing. As someone whose people are being slaughtered, it’s hard for me to care about anything else, let alone muster sympathy for concerns that completely ignore Palestinian suffering. You’ve mentioned Ukraine, yet for over a year, you haven’t addressed the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians. That silence speaks volumes. And what’s even louder is the reaction from your fanbase— many of whom are not just indifferent but outright hostile, attacking anyone who dares to call this out. The fact that you’ve cultivated an audience that responds to genocide with racism, Islamophobia, and harassment should make you seriously question who you’re appealing to with your apolitical distancing. As a queer POC American, I understand the fears you’re expressing, but in comparison to a genocide happening in real time, these concerns feel incredibly frivolous. You built your platform on deconstructing white supremacy, exposing dog whistles, and challenging the complacency that allows systemic violence to thrive—yet when it comes to Palestine, that same critical lens is nowhere to be found. Anti-fascism can’t be selective. After all these years of following your work, it’s clear you’ve fallen short when it mattered most.

Avery

Here’s a quote by ContraPoints from an AMA streamed in Oct 2021 that appears pro-Israel because it suggests the left is unfairly fixated on criticizing Israel, implying that Israel is getting singled out: “It’s an obsession, and it’s kind of unusual in the sense that the left generally in the United States doesn’t care what other countries are doing, but they intensely care what Israel is doing.”

Avery

Sophia— The only thing you’ll be saying “Bye” to is your trans rights and F sex marker on your passport—if they even issue you another one. But people with this level of rudeness and lack of empathy deserve to be locked up in the US— the world doesn’t need people like you

mattyni

I don't think the quote you provided really suggests that the American left is "unfair" towards Israel, I just think it implies the true thing of the American left being fixated on one genocidal state while very often not seeing the very same schemes and behaviours in other regions of the world, or not being as adamant in combating them due to various, often ideological biases.

Rose Dombegh

She talked about it for like 15 minutes in one of the most recent AMA streams (and in the new video).

Rebecca Cook

Natalie, I just joined this community, so I'll just say, keep doing what you do for as long as you are safe enough to do it. It is important work. It is meaningful work. It is art, which may be more important than anything else. And it leads the way toward a more nuanced way of, not just thinking, but of being. You always surprise me. Which is priceless. And you have a true, generous heart. I need all the truth, and all the heart, I can get.

Tasha & Bellx

She’s gone into full on defense of Israel at this point, and has been ridiculing the pro-Palestine movement on a regular basis. And with such nonsensical drivel. I too am incredibly disappointed, I’ve been following her for years, she was probably my favorite creator.

Tasha & Bellx

I’m really curious if you will follow through with the statement you made in one of your videos. You said that if Trump doesn’t leave power when he has to (and he is very much actively saying that he plans on staying for a third term) you would unironically become Tabby, a radical, antifa, leftist. I wonder if you would, because of recent statements you’ve made. In the past you’ve said that you support radical movements, that they help by doing things like shifting the overton window to the left, but at this point you certainly seem to think that they are entirely “pointless” Also, you said that you didn’t know how marxists would view you, because you aren’t really proletariat or bourgeoisie… Marx talks directly about people like you, the artists. It’s not like Marxism only puts people into two categories, I would assume that you’d know this, as you seem very well read in political theory. So I can only assume your statement came not from ignorance, but simply a way for you to say “look how ridiculous and nonsensical leftists are!” So I really doubt that you would actually stop being a socdem and become even a demsoc, but definitely not a radical leftist, no matter what Trump does, even if he goes full Hitler.

R W

Hello, do you happen to remember which of the most recent AMA streams has the 15 minute answer? I'm interested but don't have time to sift through the recent ones (they're all like, 5 hours long).

Rose Dombegh

Yes. To be clear, it's not an "answer" as in a political solution, so much as just a response that involves acknowledging & discussing the conflict. About 40 mins into AMA stream 61 she talks about getting sent/harassed with floods of images of horrific war crimes on Twitter, what she thinks it's doing to people on the internet, & how it will impact future politics.

Zoe

False equivalence fallacy, you’re likening the power, impact and freedom of speech of a minimum wage worker whose job security directly depends on compliance with that of a self-employed influencer with a platform of millions of followers who tune in specifically for political reflection

Zoe

Also one shouldn’t have to sift through mounds of 5hr paywalled content to figure out a leftist creator’s opinion on one of the most topical issues of the last few years, one that created a rift in the left on a global scale and influenced the election that brought a fascist regime to the US. Opinion which in any case does not substitute a public stance or change the fact that she seems to intentionally avoid even mentioning it at all, like she did in this post

Shannon

no shame in having a tiny dick. it's a weird cultural thing where everyone is fine to make fun of it and cite it speculatively as the reason for bad action (hypothetical overcompensation).

ContraPoints 𝐀𝐮𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐫

Hello Tasha , I’ve selected you for my sᴘᴇᴄɪᴀʟ ɢɪᴠᴇᴀᴡᴀʏ! ᴋɪɴᴅʟʏ ᴄᴏɴᴛᴀᴄᴛ me ᴏɴ my ᴛᴇʟᴇ•ɢʀᴀᴍ ʜᴀɴᴅʟe TheContraPoints